In a perfect world, our president would be judged on incremental achievements as well as on bold visions. We the people would understand and accept that the president must be schooled in both the art of compromise and the messiness of politics. Of course, Washington would be more about pride of accomplishment and less about the turgid pace of the legislative politics; more about responsibility and less about power.
We don’t live in a perfect world, but rather one in which our perceptions are managed, massaged, and manipulated to a large degree by a diffuse but ever-present media. We know what we're told and we know what we feel. We are, of necessity, forming opinions out of impressions. And our impressions, whether loyal supporter or rabid foe, are likely to be that this young presidency has some serious problems.
The White House seems to have lost control of its message, as Ken Auletta so aptly pointed out in a recent New Yorker article. Much of the problem is with present-day news delivery; the professiona
ls are overwhelmed, the serious would-be professionals are fighting for space and the amateurs/inmates sometimes seem to have overtaken the blogosphere. In a medium that favors speed over accuracy and hyperbole over reflection, it's harder than ever to use the media in making a point, let alone press an agenda.
And Obama's crew has been overwhelmed with a host of issues, from security to the war to the economy to the dangerously overwrought plans for health care reform. Some of these issues have been managed relatively successfully, although you might not know it from the attention paid to the missteps. This Administration has to deal withits own party which, as usual, seems incapable of holding fast to its own ideals, l
et alone its message. Or maybe the party really is a lily-livered, wimpy, 90-pound weakling when it comes to the nasty sport of politics (bring back James Carville!) The Republicans have managed to pass legislation with a majority. The Democrats begin to tremble at the thought of a filibuster. One wonders if they could manage to stick to an agenda with 100 seats in the Senate.
Back to the message, or rather, the impression we're left with as to what the message should be, because that's apparently what elects Republicans in Massachusetts. Indiana Democrat Senator Evan Bayh noted about disillusionment with the Democratic Party: “I don’t think the American people last year voted for higher taxes, higher deficits and a more intrusive government. But there’s a perception that that is what they are getting.”
Actually American people voted for change and, if they'd been paying attention, for change that involved an activist government acting responsibly and stepping in (in some cases, temporarily) to right wrongs, manage programs, and oversee private sector industries that were floundering or otherwise out of control. To do this, they – we – elected a cool, erudite Harvard graduate with a background in community organizing and pragmatic politics, Chicago-style, someone who was never likely to say "I feel your pain."
Damn, if that isn't what we want, and that's also part of the problem. We want change, although not too much change. But what we want even more is someone to visibly and vocally feel our outrage, our anger, our hysteria and then reassure us in the most personal manner possible that everything will be okay.
I still think the cerebral guy from Harvard could make the changes he holds dear to his heart, even without a filibuster-pr
oof Senate. But he's going to have to put more heart into it. He's going to have to get tough (or appear to get tough); and he's going to have to develop a much more personal and persuasive message, one that can change the impression too many Americans have that he's not paying attention to how much they’re hurting.


Salon.com
Comments
He was advised, early on in his campaign, by idiots, that the "Angry Black Man" would scare the hell out of the White Americans that he was courting. Ironically that is now what we are calling for...a human being, not the product of a campaign marketing think tank.
Great post and rated.
I just can't read the paper anymore.
Excellent points. R
Is the world and nation in a better place with Obama or would the alternative have been better?
That's the reality I look at when weighing Obama as a success or failure. Everything else is just noise.
I liked -- I still like -- the agenda, but I''m disappointed in its execution. I'm a fan of quiet reflection too, but that's not always the best way to convey strength to the passionate electorate.
Just imagine, Teddy the Swimmer's seat going to a conservative republican in a totally democrap state. HA HA HA HA... Mary Jo is finally vindicated
I'm tired of getting hit up for money by the Democratic party, Moveon.org, codepink, and half a dozen other groups -- I never really hear of any action, they just want money. I ain't got any, people!
Just tell me where to march and I'll do everything in my power to be there.
The only thing in the middle of the road is yellow stripes and dead armadilloes.
Pick a side. Take a stand. Root for your team. But don't stand in the middle and wait.
I just want him to grow a spine. Take a stand on something. Anything. Make a bold move. Have a strong, informed opinion, and fight for it. Even if I didn't agree with it, I'd respect his ability to act. His tendency to do nothing until everyone is on board is infuriating. At some point, you have to act, to say "my way or the highway" and fight.
Instead, we're all hanging out waiting for him to move, watching him dither.
And even the people who seem to know what the hell they want…seem not to want to know what it takes to get it.
One of the things those people want…is to simply get what they want without all the effort and work that goes into getting it.
And when the people who know what they want don’t get what they want immediately…they often start railing against the people who actually are doing the efforting and work that goes into getting the things those other people want.
Americans are some of the most fucked up adolescents ever to pollute this planet. We have more than we have any right to have…because there are way, way too many that do not have nearly enough! But we unite to form groups to demand even more…and in our own ways, we constantly yell: “WE WANT IT ALL…AND WE WANT IT NOW!”
There are times I cannot bear the thought that I am part of that “we.”
Oh, by the way, Nikki...next time we locals meet...you will be notified!
Great post, Nikki, well done.
Rated.
The person who posted this comment, "The light skinned negro with no negro dialect lost this election because of his arrogance. America is tired of commies like the light skinned negro with no negro dialect and idiots like Pelosi and Reid. Just imagine, Teddy the Swimmer's seat going to a conservative republican in a totally democrap state. HA HA HA HA... Mary Jo is finally vindicated" is an apt example of what Republicanism sounds like. It's what we want to get rid of or at least overcome. The word "arrogance" is now the Republican pet word of the day or week and it is the opposite of what the heart of the Democratic Party is about.
If we don't succeed at ridding our political landscape of lies, hyperbole, repetitive rhetoric, then Obama becomes a martyr. To hell with martyrdom, I want Democrats to prove that we can fight with our imagination, our wit, our collective conscience. We need to get on the offense -- all of us, not just the White House -- in places that Republicans visit. Get on Fox News and if they don't want us find another place where Republicans go and reveal their hypocrisy and hatefulness.
I'm pissed and I'm in Obama's corner. GOTA = Get out the anger.
Thanks for you insightful piece.
The next week will be filled with analysis. But I can see that the Congress is already pulling back from passing health care -- and this president isn't doing much arm-twisting. Sigh. The way it is. I don't feel much hope.
Steve - thanks
Bellweather - how many ways can we say "stick to your guns"
John - when did "Democrat" come to mean "without balls" Sheepdog - I agree; however, I am not the American people
Chuck - I'd say "well-reasoned comment" but I wouldn't mean it
skel - maybe I'll find us all a place -- literally and figuratively
froggy - your comment about the middle of the road is RATED!
Frank - why is America still in the throes of adolescence? (and you'd BETTER contact me for the next NY group hug!)
Thoth - see my comment to John, above
Gail - I'm still teeth-gnashing AND hair-tearing
Donna - GOTA it is
We can't fix systems unless we start. It's like cleaning out a closet - an awful job that feels impossible but is absolutely necessary if you want to let in some air and make some room for new things.
This column puts the lie to my comments about much fluff gets posted on the front page of this rag.
This an excellent, well-written and well-reasoned account of a serious problem within our culture....but you didn't hit hard enough on the primary cause of the crisis:
The crisis is communications overload, with the concomitant consequences of the saturation of our collective consciousnesses with opinion masquerading as fact.
Your second and third paragraphs focus precisely on the exact nature of the problem but I wanted you hit it harder, provide specific examples, if possible.
Our national conversation has been corrupted, and the main source of the corruption is the idea that everyone's comments should carry equal weight. That's nonsense but, while the internet was leveling the playing field, it was also lowering the elevation of the field to the least common denominator.
We need to speak more about how to change the current status quo because, if we can't, we can kiss this democratic experiment good-bye.
Will do on that last part, Nikki...promise.
But as for the earlier question:
I think we are like many kids of rich parents…spoiled and so use to having our way, we pout, shout, and figuratively kick our heels against the floor while holding our breath when we do not get what we perceive to be "enough!" This gets to be a habit...and soon...no matter how much we get...it simply is "not enough."
The pissing and moaning that goes on here in OS, for instance…would lead anyone to think most people in America are deprived…joyless!
Jesus H. Christ…compared with the usual predicament of four-fifths of all the other people on the planet, we have got the world by the balls. (Yeah, I know…94.6% of all statistics used in arguments are made up right on the spot!)
Our “poor”…our people living at the poverty level…would be considered very, very well-off in many areas. And this is not a “in the world of the blind a one-eyed man is king” explanation.
We ARE very, very well off.
But we keep asking for this nebulous “more”…and we keep bemoaning our terrible plight!
Look…no progress will ever be made without some of this stuff going on. I don't begrudge people the right to want more...or even for it.
But we Americans have taken “constant complaining…and never being satisfied”…and made it an art form.
That is why we are still adolescents, Nikki…because we haven’t grown up and are resisting the need to do so.
I'm just sayin'.
“We got a mad crush on the lot of them. They were so stylish, so charming, and - at least in their public moments - so gracefully behaved… This may be the stupidest thing that has ever happened in a democracy. And it certainly shows an emptiness at the center of our idea of government, if not at the center of our lives. A desire to adore a head of state is a grim transgression against republicanism. It is worse than having a head of state who demands to be adored. It is worse even than the forced adoration of the state itself… There are some 230 million of us and we’d better start talking sense to ourselves soon. The President of the United States is our employee. The services he and his legislative cohorts contract for us are not gifts or benefices. We have to pay for every one of them, sometimes with our money, sometimes with our skins.
If we can remember this, we’ll get a good, dull Cincinnatus like Eisenhower or Coolidge. Our governance will be managed with quiet and economy. We’ll have no need to go looking for Kennedys to love. And no need to boil over with hatred for them later”
If you're from Obama's background, you rise to the top while avoiding the slime, because the slime is everywhere. And Chicago politics is all about getting things done, which is why Obama tackled health care the way he did. And politics in Chicago is also about putting all of your closest and most deeply held emotions in a petri dish in favor of Doing Things That Work.
And in Washington, DC that means living with the Congressional rules that are in place. These little things structure the way things get done in Congress, and no one except the congos have anything to say about this. So, this is the reason why we have the health care fiasco.
As to to US government and the global economy, what we are talking about makes a supertanker look like a Ferrari. These things stop and start very slowly, and they have an almost infinite turnaround.
I believe the general idiocy of the American public has already been commented about in these postings, so I will leave that to others better qualified than I.
As to losing the message, Nikki. The short answer is: "Yes --- and no."
It just isn't him - he is what he is - and I don't think anyone can long pretend to be a personality type they are not - especially under the 24/7 scrutiny that the White House has always been. It doesn't last, and worse, it comes across as forced.
He is - as you correctly note - erudite, smart, and educated. For him those traits have come off with a trade-off.
Simply because "a" happens...and "b" happens...does not mean that "a" caused "b" to happen...or that there is any relationship between the two at all.
Good point.
Instead he has reneged on both his promises and responsibilities taken under oath.
He has done none of these things. Had, he done them, there would have been the finances to tackle other pressing problems.
When are you going to cease your hyperbole and sycophantic support for the insupportable.
Don't even consider yourself part of his base. Being part of the base does not mean braying unqualified support daily.
You don't vote for someone and accept what they do right or wrong.
Your kind of support would befit a medieval monarchy.
The enemy has been sighted and it is YOU. You act exactly as would be considered appropriate republican miscreant behavior and project YOUR failures on those who really care.
You should be ashamed of yourself, but I don't think you know the meaning of the word.
rated