It's Always Something

spring

Nikki Stern

Nikki Stern
Location
Princeton, New Jersey, USA
Birthday
April 10
Title
whatever sounds good
Company
Sure, come on in
Bio
Author of "Because I Say So: The Dangerous Appeal of Moral Authority" (www.nikkistern.com) and "Hope in Small Doses" to be released June 1, 2010 by Humanist Press.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
DECEMBER 14, 2010 7:27AM

The Holiday Store

Rate: 39 Flag

Once upon a time, people did not race to the malls in order to dash from store to store in search of the perfect gift, or even an acceptable one. They did not face crammed parking lots, overburdened clerks, uninspiring displays, and a lunch of greasy fries or sugary treats that invariably led to a bad case of acid reflux.  Once upon a time, we went to grand department stores and, as we used to say, made a day of it.

These big stores, most of them built between 1870 and 1925, were often baroque-style structures. Most  marshalfields2afeatured high, mosaic ceilings and tile floors, wide aisles, crystal chandeliers, and any number of fine restaurants and tea rooms. Every major city seemed to have at least one of these “grand  dames”: Seattle (Frederick and Nelson), San Francisco (the Emporium), Boston (Jordan Marsh), Dallas (Neiman Marcus), Miami (Burdine’s), New York (Saks, Lord and Taylor, Bloomingdale’s), St. Louis (Famous Barr), Philadelphia (Wannamaker’s) and Chicago (Marshall Field's), to name a few. Many were modeled after their European counterparts, Harrod’s of London or Printemps in Paris, but always with an American twist.  

As a little girl, I eagerly anticipated our yearly holiday department store outing because it involved much more than dropping in on our respectably staid local department store, Gimbel’s. Instead, our day would consist of a trip to Chicago by train, where we’d invariably visit the renowned Chicago Art Museum and then head to Marshall Field’s. 

Marshall-Fields-clockIn the years since, I’ve been in many department stores. But in my six-year-old  Midwestern eyes, Marshall Field’s was the grandest store imaginable. 

The man behind the business, Marshall Field, was an entrepreneur who described his enterprise as an “emporium.” His motto was “give the lady what she wants,” not exactly pc but an accurate assessment of his loyal customer base for many years. In its heyday, Marshall Field’s was a formidable brand that included well-known confectionaries*Marshall-Fields and a popular cookbook. The store itself was a temple to consumer goods with some stunning architecture: the clock at the State Street entrance, the stunning Tiffany Mosaic Dome, and the elegant Walnut Room. Field’s, as  it was sometimes called, featured six well-regarded restaurants, including a Men’s Grill Room and place for afternoon tea. At Christmastime, an area was set off for “Santa-land,” a fantasy concoction of elves and trees, fake snow and twinkly lights and a path that led directly to a real-looking Santa with a real beard (being a department store Santa was once an honorable profession). The entire store looked like a gigantic gift package, from the extravagant window displays to the festooned crystal chandeliers.

The Walnut Room *Marshall Field’s world-famous Frango mints, (chocolate mint truffles) actually originated with Seattle’s Frederick and Nelson but Field’s broadly expanded the market. Marshall Field’s also sold caramel turtle candy in competition with its Chicago rival, Fannie May.

Our trip to Chicago was a dress-up occasion; we wore jumpers or dresses with gloves and hats (my mother kept us in matching outfits until I rebelled shortly after my eighth birthday) and patent-leather shoes unless MomNikDebglovesan early snowstorm necessitated boots. We ate breakfast on the train and went to the museum when we arrived. Then it was time for lunch in the Walnut Room and sometimes a fashion show.  Although I was only mildly interested in clothes and shopping, I loved those lunches; they provided me with a window into what it might mean to be a grownup.  After lunch, we’d walk the store and look—and look and look. We bought candy, of course, and sometimes a gift for my father, if for no other reason than to have it gift-wrapped by people whose magic transformed a gift box into a work of art.   

In truth, there was just as much ostentatiousness on display then as there is now. We weren’t as a people any less acquisitive fifty or even one hundred years ago than we are now; but perhaps we were more inquisitive. I’m sure there were hurried, harried shoppers then as now. But there also was, I’m fairly certain, more wandering, more watching and looking and taking it all in with a sense of wonder. Of course I was very young and many things were wonderous to me.

 A number of the grand department stores have been bought by Federated, which owns Macy’s. There’s a sameness about them that’s a little dispiriting, not to mention now we've got people, heads bent over cell phones, eyes intent on one destination. But the grand architecture remains, as do some old traditions and perhaps some new ones, such as this event that took place recently at the former Wannamaker’s (now a Macy’s) in Philadelphia. Christmastime may be commerce time but that doesn’t mean we can’t all look up and take in some wonder.

Resources:
Marshall Field's cookbook
History of deparment stores 

Bring Back Marshall Field's

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Gimbel's, B. Altman's, John Wanamaker, Abraham and Straus, Stern's...all gone.
Sadly, we have become a Walmart society.
Shopping as a leisurely and pleasant experience?
I don't think so.
Thanks for bringing us back.
R
FAO Schwartz!

We used to go into St. Louis back when there were street cars. I'm dating myself.
I love the the acquisitive, inquisitive insight. Lovely nostalgic post Nikki.
We don't get a lot of those kinds of stores anymore in big box shopping America. In fact, the last time I was in that kind of a store was recently in South Korea, which is practically every big store. Some friends of mine went to Chicago last week and experienced the same thing, but here in Grand Rapids, I don't think I've seen anything like it in the states for quite some time.
In Canada the geat Eaton Co has gone.. Used to be a grand affair , now everyone seems to sit on their butt and surf for gifts. I am one of the guilty ones.
Rated with hugs
One holiday season, just after I retired from the Air Force, I worked at a Marshall Fields' in San Antonio. It was a lovely experience - and the in-house restaurant and the Frangos mints in our local store were every bit as splendid as you remember.
When I was a child, it was my Granny Jessie who used to take us around to the high-end department stores in Pasadena to do her shopping, and so that JP and Pippy and I could visit the department store Santas. Bullocks, which was VERY high-end at that time, also had a Santa with a real white beard...
There was such an outcry when Macy's ate Field's. That doesn't stop anyone from shopping there, but we're all still a little sad. There's something just not quite right about Macy's (not to mention they phased out a lot of the higher quality items that made Field's worth the trip...)
It was a holiday tradition in the city where I more or less grew up to trek downtown each Christmas season to see the window displays at the Robert Simpson department store. It was amazing for a kid. No idea if it still goes on or even if the store is still there -- haven't been in the old city core for a couple of decades -- but it's nice to remember.
@ Sheepdog: E.J. Korvets!
This was great Nikki. Growing up in NYC Christmas was always magical and those stores like Saks & Lord & Taylor were such a special place to go. I always miss NY at Christmastime.
So many memories here. My father used to take me downtown to The Enchanted Village inside Jordan Marsh every year when I was small. I think they gave up a whole floor to house it. When I was a freshman in college, still in Boston, our women's choral society was joined by Fordham's men and our final piece was the Hallelujah Chorus. I can still feel the sound of it as all our voices came together. Pure magic.
My New York CIty girlfriend just instructed me to add B. Altman's; that was apparently HER place to go.

Lawless: check out the third link I have up there; Chicagoans are seriously up in arms about the demise of Marshall Field's. I feel the same way about MF and about Wannamaker's in Philadelphia.
I loved this piece and had forgotten about the days growing up in Connecticut with trips to New York City and Bloomingdale's. And yes, we would dress up for the occasion. So many I'm running into these days are so stressed out with the shopping and the traffic and the debt and the "it will never be good enough anyway" and it makes you wonder why people persist in doing things that bring them no pleasure. There is a way to approach it with joy. You've described it beautifully.
This really makes me sad, to think how much has changed. I have friends who work at Macy's and lament how corporate powers have zamboni'ed any creativity that once existed in their visual display jobs into the dust. Their ad slogan this year is something about "making the magic." It just ain't happenin', Macy's. You're just like Wal-mart. Thanks for this trip back to a real shopping wonderland.
In my old hometown, we no longer have Leonard's, Monnig's, or Strickland's. Field's as Macy's just ain't the same, even though, to Macy's credit, they have retained much of what people liked, such as the Walnut Room and Santa's Village, but there is something missing, too. As hard as they try, it just falls short.

Ah, memories...
Macy's on State Street certainly isn't equal to Marshall Field's. The holiday window displays become more generic and less exciting every year. The customer service definitely isn't what it used to be. I used to enjoy Marshall Field's. I didn't live in New Hampshire quite long enough to develop the same level of attachment to Jordan Marsh, which was assimilated into the Macy's Borg world years before Field's, but it was still a loss. I have a lot of friends who feel as I do and will never accept Macy's. Corporate sameness does not cultivate the kind of experience we used to enjoy.
Cleveland had The Higbee Co., and The May Co. Public Square. We actually had and FAO Schwartz in Shaker Hts. in Shaker Square. Now one of the old department stores is a condominium building, and the other is going to be a casino. What will kids today be saying in 2050?
Wonderful post, Nikki. Real nostalgia, and takes most of us back to another time and place.
This was a delightful stroll down memory lane. I remember standing in line for what seemed like hours outside of Frederick and Nelson, staring at their amazing store windows which were chalked full of trains and wooden puppets, waiting to see Santa and then get our Frangos. I had know idea Marhall Fields expanded the market - here I thought it was a west coast thing all along. Thanks for enlightening me, as usual, Nikki! :)
Oh Nikki, I remember those days of my childhood. In Toronto my aunt would take me to Holt Renfew (to look) and Eaton's to buy. Thank you for such a charming post. It brought back really lovely memories.~r
I so remember dressing up and going downtown in Buffalo!
Reading this makes me want to break out the matching heels and purse and go shopping and lunching. I have fond memories of both Marshall Field's in Chicago and the Emporium in San Francisco. Especially loved those elegant gift boxes with the metallic elastic band around it. Those grand department stores were not just places of commerce, but the first public places women could convene, wander, and work.
Love this post! Going to Marshall Fields was an intrinsic part of growing up in Chicago. Next to gazing up at the Tiffany glass ceiling, my favorite thing to do was race to the fancy art noveau water fountains that were at the end of almost every escalator! Then after filling up on free water, head off to the enormous ladies room on the seventh floor! My friends mother was the store nurse! That's right: Fields had nurses working there for employees or customers who needed assistance.......what a place!
What a great story, I loved Fields. I have many memories of it. I worked there summers in the 70's, my mother worked there for years. I met my first boyfriend there, he also worked school breaks. It was a very magical place. This brought up so many, many memories. It had changed so much in the later years, it was no longer quite the grand dame it once was. But the history was still trying to claw its way out of those grand columns, and so many of its unique features. What a place! The basement paths to tunnels, the employee shop, the candy making floor, the restaurant floor, the designer shop, the 28 shop with its private elevator, the antique silver collection, oh my, you have opened a floodgate for me. Thanks for this Nikki!
Marshall Fields was it for Midwesterners. When I was small, my mother took me there one morning and we made it out around dinnertime. We had eaten in the Walnut Room and visited the vast toy department--that went on forever. Later on, the store was much much different. But it stood for something. They used to have the bookstore staff read the bestsellers so that they could sell them better. ?
Great post. Thank you! I couldn't help but think of the Barry Levinson film Avalon while reading this... really a great movie about immigration and assimilation in the 20th century through three generations of a Polish-American family that make it big by opening a successful department store. I won't spoil it and reveal what happens to the building itself, but the movie is worth watching.
I remember about the dressing up when you were going out. That's sure gone out of style. Very nices memories there Nikki.
Great post! I grew up with Frederick & Nelson and Frango Mints (which are now sold by Macy's). I have a Santa pic from 1956 taken at Meier & Frank in Portland (like Frederick and Nelson). I miss those old stores. We were at Target tonight. Yuck!
I have bad memories of department stores. My mother used to take me to Alexander's in Paramus, NJ and buy me pants that were 2 sizes too big to save money, figuring I'd grow into them. I did but, in the meantime, my belt loops were five inches from my chin.
Oh, my, Nikki, this was my childhood. Remember Field's fantastic Christmas windows? They had animated villages, and the escalator to the top floor was magical. Oh, how I miss that ride on the Northwestern to the city for Christmas. Thanks for making me remember this so beautifully.
Thanks for reminding me of Christmas before Walmart. I remember the candy shop near the big department store that was built with blue mirrors as part of the facade reflecting the swirling snowflakes.
Atlanta's grand stores are gone, to make way for parking decks and office cubicles. Shoppers cling to their cell phones as the meander through suburban malls. I love your reminiscence here.
Nikki, it's a dramatic contrast to read your post and think of what has been lost over the years in retail! You paint a lovely portrait of special qualities of these stores. Likewise, I have fond memories of the New York department stores that I saw when I was young. While many are gone there are still some survivors like Lord & Taylor, Saks, and Macy's.

Lord & Taylor was the Manhattan clothing store I saw the most of in my youth and received lots of clothing over the years as gifts from that particular store courtesy of my grandparents and parents. On the bright side, the surviving stores I mentioned are still in the same locations these many years later.
Rothschildes in KC, remembering elevator attendants, those stupid gloves and the matching dresses and shoes. Thanks for the resurrection of memories lost and found again this morning.
I loved being taken to the old Wannamaker ldg in downtown Philadelphia as a kid. Gimbel's, too. r.
What a beautifully nostalgic post this is!

I have very fond memories of shopping at Higbee's in downtown Cleveland. Of course, it is now gone, like so many others, but at least it has been memorialized on film. Higbees was where the department store scenes from "A Christmas Story" were filmed.

And my grandmother worked for many years at The May Company, also in downtown Cleveland. Gone as well. So sad.
SO much better than the box stores.

This is a lovely reminiscence. My Nan used to take us four kids to downtown Kansas City, to Macy's and other big stores, for our annual Christmas shopping. Two buses, transfers clutched and the downtown streets through the glass, seeing Santa, hot cocoa on the mezzanine, all the windows...

Sigh. A wonderful reminder, Nikki.
At the risk of sounding ever so sappy, I hope you all take a look at the YouTube video. At the very least, it'll put a smile on your face.

No, things aren't the same as they were, true, but there are those rare grace notes to be captured and I love this one--and the thoroughly modern convenience of being able to experience it although I wasn't there.
Macys in Philly still has the Wannamakers organ which is incredible. This was a wonderful walk down memory lane, great piece, Nikki. RRRRR
Beautiful and so touching this time of year! There was a building in my hometown of Cleveland, I believe it housed a department store called "Higgins" if memory serves. It was one of those gorgeous old buildings with lots of history you described. Years back, they turned it into a mega mall, and though it's more attractive than many other malls, it definitely lost its character.

Wish I could visit it now!
a terrific post, nikki, that blends all the facts of the grande days of department store retail with the nostalgia of those shopping day trips. even in little san diego there were two local department stores -- Marston's and Walker Scott -- that were wonderlands to me, big ornate downtown buildings, beautifully decorated. getting dressed to go shopping there and have lunch was an event i looked forward to every year. thanks for taking me back.
I love that picture of you and your mom and your sister. I think I was an in-between generation -- I vaguely remember some of the grand department stores, butI came of (shopping) age at a time of malls. Now that I'm so very very weary of malls and avoid them most of the time, I can't help but feel nostalgic for a time that I never got to be a part of.
Oh, you so took me back. Sheepdog named many of Philly's late Grande Dames, but missed a few: Strawbridge & Clothier, Bonwit Teller and especially the very tony Nan Duskin (I got my wedding dress there). Wonderful piece stirring wonderful personal memories.
Thanks for rekindling all those same thoughts about the old department stores.
Reminds me of Bamberger's inNewark. They had a photo studio where we were ... induced ... to pose every year. They were bought by Macy's.
Shoppin was fun fifty years ago. But yes, it was -- more civilized fun. Thanks for those memories

Happy department store Santa days!!
Bamberger's! Omg, I forgot about that one (my mother was from Newark). Boy the list goes on and on. Any town and stores we've failed to acknowledge?
In Atlanta, it was Rich's. ::sigh::

Santaland had a railroad that you climbed into sans parents, and you rode over the mountains and down into the station, where you were taken, with your fistful of dollars in hand, into the Christmas Shop where you found yourself independently buying something wonderfully surprising for your family or friends. I truly felt it was Christmas when I came back out to my parents with my little bag held up, proudly announcing "No peeking!"

I miss that sort of ostentation. It's one of the reasons I love Miracle on 34th. Those stores were originals, so beautiful.
My Aunt Franny and my mom, brother and I would hop the train to Chicago and wind up on State Street at Fields...checking out all the amazing store windows and having dinner under the massive tree! This brought it all back! Thanks Nikki! Such great memories! r