It's Always Something

spring

Nikki Stern

Nikki Stern
Location
Princeton, New Jersey, USA
Birthday
April 10
Title
whatever sounds good
Company
Sure, come on in
Bio
Author of "Because I Say So: The Dangerous Appeal of Moral Authority" (www.nikkistern.com) and "Hope in Small Doses" to be released June 1, 2010 by Humanist Press.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
JULY 28, 2011 5:44PM

Quitting 9/11

Rate: 69 Flag

I’ve been imagining the 10th anniversary as marking a big change, in the manner of the event itself: a cleaver that again sunders my life into before and after. Ten years after the attack that took my husband and left me an involuntary member of a group of grieving relatives, I've quit 9/11.

Not that simple.

In 2005, I began to pull away from the roles that had given me purpose after my husband was killed. Activism is healing, never more so than when a person feels her life to be literally halved (we were two; now I’m one). I felt I might be making a difference, and I drew comfort from people who seemed to understand both my deep pain and my desire to work.

I was spent, though: tired of attempting to express opinions on behalf of others; tired of steering clear of opinions I wanted to express; sick of being treated differently, as if I were a victim or a moral beacon or, god forbid, an opportunist: a symbol of resilience; a receptacle for a nation’s fear, anger, resentment and confusion; someone forever defined by one unexpected, violent, and oh so public event. I didn’t want to represent 9/11 families; I didn’t want to be known as a 9/11 widow.

I stayed professionally connected (the profession being “9/11 family adviser”), advising and consulting on various projects, writing a couple of op-eds and a book based on my experiences as a family member, but with the goal of making a larger point about the danger of moral authority in America. But I found I didn't have anything to say to reporters who still called me for quotes, sent by their editors and producers to find out what "we families" might think about every 9/11-related event  imaginable. 

Last May, Osama bin Laden’s death prompted a new round of calls and requests for interviews. I was invited as part of a group of family members to meet with the President of the United States at ground zero. I jumped at the chance and yes, meeting Barack Obama was thrilling. But that day--the crowds and the checkpoints, the heightened security, the helicopters droning overhead, the microphones and megaphones and construction cranes that hung like vultures over a still-incomplete site where my husband worked and died, even the identification badges bearing my name along with the words “family member” which, when held aloft, granted us access, a wave-through by jack-booted and helmeted police with weapons and walkie-talkies—dumped me unceremoniously back to 2001: a jumble of sights and sounds, exhaustion and exhilaration, highs and lows made up of fear, pride, confusion, and the sense of being different or “special” on account of a loss so severe we hadn’t even had time to process it. I came home  and cried like I hadn't for years.

Maybe that was a turning point or maybe, this time around, there is no precise before and after. 9/11’s hold on me is a little more complicated than I anticipated and I must respect my memory’s tenacity. So I’ve developed a plan: I’m staying away from commemorations, both those in New York and those locally. I won’t be heading into lower Manhattan, not even (for now) to the memorial to try to locate my late husband’s name on the lists of the dead.  No op-eds about 9/11 and how it changed America (did it?) or interviews about what I plan to do or what this milestone means to me.  Have I quit 9/11? Perhaps; perhaps not.  But I know this: for the first time in years, I'm looking forward to autumn.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Nikki, you address this with such painful, maturing clarity and intelligence I can't help but think of you as leading the way for others at this point of departure, as well. I wish you well in this new phase of your journey.
I've been kinda waiting for this. Must be a human tic to want to buttonhole and pigeonhole and categorize one another. Must be convenient to label and then act according to some list of actions for that label.

But you are so much more than a label or button or list. Please be everything you can, and let the ones who want to commemorate do so, as you have already done and done. Much love to you in your journey.
Ah, Nikki. You are something special. ~r
I admire this perspective so much. I can only imagine that a history altering event like this could consume you if you let it. I'll be sharing this one on my FB page.
Yep, sometimes enough is enough. I too look forward to autumn.
I wish you so much healing. Great post.
I wish you nothing but the best wherever life takes you.
I pray that "they" respect your wishes and wish you abundant peace in the next decade
You do what is best for you my friend. People react to things different, and if this is what you need, go for it. I'm glad you're looking forward.
It is just a date. The reality of your husband,
gone now but always here,
in your neural fibers,

in the electricity
in the night,

will only get stronger.
"jumble of sights and sounds,
exhaustion and exhilaration,
highs and lows made up of fear, pride, confusion,
and the sense of being
different
or “special”
on account of a loss so severe we hadn’t even had time to process it. I came home and cried like I hadn't for years. "


Ah, they gotta honor you. It is amazing
how sincere it is,
is it not?
I am so glad you have. You are such a vibrant person, your spark comes through in everything you write. I hate to think of you as anything else but someone who is bursting forth. I hope that is not hurtful. I am not saying anything like move on, I am saying I like the way you live your life from your posts here and I think this decision fits with who you are.
Take care. We will be here either way.
Beautiful in every way. Just like you. Thank you for this.
I know what it is like not looking forward to a time period in the year. Thus, your looking forward to autumn for the first time in years is very significant. I hope it will be a beautiful, peaceful and personally fulfilling one.

♥R
This sounds very positive.
You describe that day so clearly, I have no words.
I see why you might feel ready...
I'm inspired to let go of a couple of my autumn burdens and begin to look forward myself.
Thanks : )
The only thing I can say is ::applause::
Your writing details in a simple and eloquent manner your journey. The realization that there is no real beginning and certainly no end is spot on and means a lot to me....I hope you have a wonderful autumn.
Hooray for you, Nikki. You are the best judge of what you need, and I'm sure that your many friends and acquaintances will support you in whatever way you ask!
I can't even begin to imagine your pain and to be reminded of it continuously must be so hard. I love how you wrote this and that you will finally be able to look forward to autumn once again. I wish you only moving forward..
Nikki, you've been a touchstone for strength, compassion and grace, and you've more than earned your retirement
Thank you for sharing this. It's a fascinating perspective and I think it's important for us to realize that people so closely affected by a tragedy may not want to talk about it all the time. I find, personally, that I can talk about just about anything - but when something truly upsets me, makes me feel deep grief or loss or any other negative emotion - and even some positive ones - I tend to naturally be silent. Whether you've "quit" 9/11 or not, I hope you'll find peace of mind and spirit.
what nick said. i'm thinking after this 10th and the memorial dedication and all, it won't be the media go-to story like it has been for so long, which will be good, i think, for all of us.
This is a wonderful piece that you have written here, from the heart. I am happy that for you, this signals a moving on. I hope the fall is a beautiful time for you this year. My best to you.
This really needs to be on Salon. Well, it's too good for Salon, actually. The most compassionate and hopeful thing I've read in a very long time.
Much love to you, Nikki. Much love.
I've always admired the way you've dealt with what life has dealt to you. I still do.
Nikki,
Thank you for sharing this. It is filled with hope.
Can't blame you one bit for feeling like that Nikki. But be prepared for a massive deluge given that this anniversary is evenly divisible by 10.
Looking forward to Autumn
A life not cleaved into before and after
These are beautiful things.
In my event there were only a handful of us; only 2 still in contact with each other. It took 18 years for my life to not be cleaved in two.
I hope you have a stellar splash of Autumnal colors this year, Nikki. Thanks for this.
Bless you. You have done more than your share. Regaining your sense of peace in the world is the ultimate victory.
Waiting to be heard again. Thank you.
Nikki, your wisdom and eloquence are always admirable.
eloquent, honest, true as an arrow. i think of you this way, always moving forward, even when it may not seem like it. thank you, nikki.
I'm with Verbal. Take a bow.
Subtle, well thought out and beautifully written, but that's Nikki Stern. R
I'll be thinking of you as the leaves change into their vibrant, beautiful colors. Enjoy the beauty around you.
~r
What Mary, Verbal and Jeanette said as well. Anything else I have to say will be shared with you in real time. In autumn, I hope. Brava.
I think of "ten years" as if thirteen days, or seven months, or four & a half years, are not quite as significant. Every moment without the one you love aches. The only thing about "ten" that I get is that it will for it's own reason become a network event, a predictable spectacle.

I wish for you a quiet candle, and peace, Nikki.
You seem to have made the important decision to move on... to become who you are now and not live in the past or what could or should have been. Your healing is working. It's a long journey but you are on the right path. Hugs to you.
Oh, I thought it was QUILTING 9/11. Mibad
No carry QUILTING needles in DC.
The Secret Service may aim guns.
I saw them sit with machine guns.
If Ya bow `say I will weed garden.
`
Nikki Stern. I always recall DC.
That eve with You 9-11 widows.
I fill with tears if I remembers.
I still gotta read your book.
Candace wrote `bout basil?
She do boogie at OS retreat.
You and her sit on Cloud` 9.
I shall wash up with goat sop.
Buy Lavender/Oats milk soap.
Order soap` Cutler Tigh Farm.
I hope real folks sing ballads.
We remember Immortality.
Folk hymnody is to boogie.
If his comment is stuck?
I'll save and email Pope.
I don't know that I have ever read a better description of the inner experience of being a 9/11 family member than your fourth paragraph. It is stunning, as is your description of the vortex of sight and sound and feeling at you May visit. In this post you have made vividly concrete the cliches we so often hear about moving on or moving forward or getting on. I now know what those abstractions mean, what they feel like, how they can be put into action. You have refused to let a milestone become a millstone. Thank you for this exposition of where you understanding and valuing have led you.
Why we hang together on OS, I guess: where else could I sort through this mess, risking inappropriate comments from time to time--not just the ones I receive but also the ones I make? The real "life after" has been greatly enhanced by my time here, hanging with a bunch of disparate writers, commentators, opinionators---go figure.

BTW Scubadiver, your comment is hysterical: "Quilting 9/11"...you have no idea how surreal the outpouring became at one point and quilts were a big part of it. Thanks for your shot of humor.
Ten years seems kind of a magic number for grief. Cancer was like this. It isn't that I'm not invested, and no longer care. I just don't want to wear the pink survivor T shirt anymore. Life goes on, as you so sanely have come to understand.
Hey, Nikki I hope you enjoy the vibrant oranges, reds and yellows this autumn. You can never cross the same river twice. Lovely writing.
You are my go-to gal for grace and dignity under tremendously difficult circumstances in life. You deserve to be able to let it go. I frevently hope this Autumn is the first of many happier ones Nikki.
You share your 10 year old grief with an honesty, openness, and clarity that allow me in, allow me empathy and admiration and connection to the fullness of your humanity and your suffering. Sending you love, Nikkk. Wishing you peace.
Good to read this--looking forward to autumn, yes.
Looking forward to autumn. Those words, "looking forward to..." are the words of hope. Thank you for a beautiful post.
Dianne Lindsey has been booted from SALON for posting on the LIVE STREAMING posts.

She was concerned about the SPORTS ADS being put in front of us in the NEW POSTS and ACTIVITY FEEDS

Never told her why. And now they are probably going to eliminate me.
They never told her. I did. She said she looked in ALL her emails. She said she received nothing.
They even erased my emails from her.
This affects us all.
Even if you did not like her. It still could be you.

What about free speech
I have posted this on my blog. But I am certain I am next
ScubaDiver. Please tell Readers more? I always thought it was courteous to say a few words. Do unto others? How would Salon like to be BOOTED?

I noticed when I have (rarely) commented the entire Spam Post gets BOOTED Off.

Is that in the Salon fine print?
If you comment your banned?
bebop-o
GoodCelery!

(They were my gold star members)

Both were booted @ Salon. Rude.
It's nice to be rude @ Open Salon.

(?)

I have copies of deleted comments.

Salon takes away 'letter' privileges.

If you mention National Guard ads?
or
Crystal Light ad ref Fizz Challenge?
rather
Why doesn't Kerry respond to us?
We are sunbathers on nude beach.
Who knows what the CEO thinks?
cc
We can send to Eric Holder? okay.
Send complaints to Rabbi or Pope.
Father Lipshitz will respond? Greek.

My farm neighbor is Amos Deughud.
He's German Baptist. Call 'Do Good'`
No mispronounce name `Duh Gaud.

Why be nasty? Nasty possums Stink.
Otter who do that? Snarly Doberman.
What is with the Salon & Open Salon?

'goat gouda blueberry' was not the paid
no ads Gold Star Premium membership.

The bebop-o & GoodCelery! were. So?
I could go On and On but it gets tiring.
Let's never cower. That destroys Self.
Good morning. If we get homeless?
No worry. We move in with Joan?
Kerry L. will show hospitality?
Maybe we best wash our socks.
I just watched a praying mantis.
It is one-inch long and light green.
I stopped typing while she strolled.
It's a predatory insect with spiky legs.
Her body is slender and she folds hands.
I hope she isn't a predator who eats blogger.
Maybe she go over to Matt Paust and eat wolf.
huh?
If I get deleted I'll call 9-11 and listen to Mozart.
The 9-11 operator puts possums on hold. Holder?
She calls Eric Holder? Homeless Pope? Knight.
I met a homeless vet on K- Street. He SS? Huh.
I enjoy hearing the diverse opinion of humans.
I have often wondered about how you handle that "label."



To every thing there is a season, and a time to every purpose under the heaven:
A time to be born, and a time to die; a time to plant, and a time to pluck up that which is planted;
A time to kill, and a time to heal; a time to break down, and a time to build up;
A time to weep, and a time to laugh; a time to mourn, and a time to dance;
A time to cast away stones, and a time to gather stones together; a time to embrace, and a time to refrain from embracing;
A time to get, and a time to lose; a time to keep, and a time to cast away;
A time to rend, and a time to sew; a time to keep silence, and a time to speak;
A time to love, and a time to hate; a time of war, and a time of peace. --Ecclesiastes 3. 1-8

Autumn is my favorite season, for so many reasons. We'll both anticipate its comfort.

Lezlie
Peace be with you.
now if only americans could forget about the whole thing too. OOPS!! too late!! we doubled our warmachine spending in only a decade, and now we're arguing over which poor and senior groups to slash in the throat. and still nobody's talking about the warmachine. including you!
You'll always be one of the people I most admire Nikki. It's funny, but your book is not on the bookshelf in the den, it's still on my bedside table, though I've long since read it. I guess I just don't want to remove it, I want it there to remember, which I know is an odd thing, especially after what you've just written here. But then, your book transcends 9/11, so I still feel good about doing that little homage to truth and honesty.
I did not lose any close, or any distant family member in 911. but, I will never forget, and I will not relent in my efforts to uncover the truth, and bring the truth to light. and no, I still dont think the real truth has come to light. one cannot be a fanatic, and fanatics repulse me as much as anyone, but neither can one be an apathic.
1+1 =/= 3
"All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing."
Edmund Burke (1729 - 1797)

"he who does not stand for something will fall for anything" --MLK
"those who do not learn from the past are condemnded to repeat it" --santayana
I am just saying `
So Be it. I agree.
bbd and vzn etc.,
`
If in a courtroom
no sulk with pickles
I mean?
No stick pickles up nose.
No visit ER with big toes.
No stub toes on fart mule.
That's just a mule's noise.
Never say to judge that Ya`
`
Honorable horrible baloney.
Ask the judge to be more honest.
Judge Walker charges` $250.00.
That's just for my court transcript.
No call Judge `Your Evil Majesty.
Gaud.
behave
tell truth.
I follows.
I get peeved.
Call PA's FBI.
Sonny? Wait?
We suffer still.
You care or no?
glad I trickled in. This is a great read.
written as though we were sitting and having coffee together - a very good place to be after all has been said, and all that has been done. It was good to read this Nikki.
Such a lucid, honest account of what you have been through and your feelings surrounding 9/11. I am so sorry for your loss.
May autumn signal the beginning of years of nothing but peace, renewal, love, and every other good thing you desire. Thank you for sharing your story.
Nikki: I have no doubt you've contributed untold comfort and insight to people in need. My wish for you is for well-earned relief, an immediate and long-lasting return to normalcy and privacy, a permanent refuge from all things symbolic, "newsworthy" and invasive.
Oh, Nikki. Such a lucid account of a public drama that must have left you alone with your private grief. My whole being is trembling at your courage to embrace the fear and tears that await you. That is so brave , ennobling, and bold.

I believe that grief is not measured in miles but moments.

(I look forward to Wednesday night.)
I've quit 9/11. Not that simple.

This is poignant. I hope autumn comes quickly.
I don't have the words... but you capture the confusion and ambivalence between memory and healing. My guess is that as the years go by from autumn to autumn, you will find your way as witness and chronicler. Seems to me there's another book here. . .
I admire your decision, I find it sensible and wish you the warmth and love.
Oh, Nikki. You make my eyes leak, with your stoic courage and insistence on following your instincts, wherever they may lead. Your heart is True North, and that is so rare. Carry on!
I cOnfess thAT I FOLLOWED BELLWEATHER VANCE.
`
Keys stick.
I wish that`
`
I asked for`
`
one more dance.
in Catholic school`
`
the oddest priest`
gaVE SEX ED class.
he no ever get any`
`
standing ovation.
he buy condoms?
He buy Trojans`
at BP gas rest`
`
stop. Rest up.
I'm in pajamas.
Is that one sin?
It's a two piece.
It's two sinful.
forgive me...
Your sweet.
I's off to bed.
`
No fall from`
`
a bed, grace,
and you be`
calm and so`
happy. Peace.
What a difference between this version of Salon and its big brother. Over there, the same post inspires anger and resentment. Not even worth responding to; just proves my point.

Last night I met more OS writers, this time in Manhattan...and they're even more terrific in person. Which perhaps proves that you can take the Salon out of Open, but you should never take the Open out of Salon.
You have a great head on your shoulders and may the universe open it's heart to you...
Nikki: It's great to hear your voice again, full of thoughtful insights and truth. Hope you continue to be well.
You write beautifully. I am glad that you have reached this place in your life, but I do hope you will keep writing, because I, for one, would like to keep reading your work. Fall is my favorite season too. May you enjoy the pumpkins and mums and sweaters and air that is easy to breathe.
Fairly new to OS - I don't know whether you started writing here BEFORE or AFTER. All I know is your writing is eloquant. Rated