A survey conducted post-apocalyptic debt ceiling kerfuffle indicates 82% of Americans have an unfavorable opinion of Congress. Up in Canada, the folks seem to think at least that many Americans are off their rockers.
I've just returned from eleven days on the road, traveling by car with my sister throughout Canada's Maritime province, Nova Scotia. It's a place of breathtaking scenery, moderate climate, pockets of poverty, and general economic malaise. The locals are dependent on tourists who may not show up and crops and catches that may not materialize. On the other hand, lobster is plentiful.
The Nova Scotians--Acadians, Fundians and residents of the Eastern and Southern shores--are friendly and forthcoming, with little of the anxiety that permeates our current culture. Perhaps they've become more adjusted to an unpredictable life, along with the unpredictable weather that produced an unprecedented amount of rain this summer. They seem to like Americans on an individual basis, at least the far fewer number they’ve apparently seen this summer. Blame our economy or our aforementioned anxiety or maybe the lousy weather—or maybe the fact that ferry service from Portland, Maine to Halifax was suspended two years ago—but we state-siders are on the endangered list this year.
My sister, who habitually rises with the dawn, went searching for coffee every morning at Tim Horton's, Canada's ubiquitous version of Dunkin' Donuts, where she sat amongst and eavesdropped on the local fishermen, loggers, long haulers and itinerant workers. I was frequently chatted up by shop clerks and desk clerks eager for conversation during the slow summer. The most common topic, aside from the weather was politics: not politics as practiced in Halifax or Toronto, but further south, in Washington, DC.
There’s plenty to talk about at home, mind you. Toronto, Canada’s largest and presumably most liberal city, just last year overwhelmingly elected a mayor who in both girth and taste for political bullying has it all over our own Chris Christie. Rob Ford is a member of the Progressive Conservative party (is there really such a thing?) and is virulently anti-tax and anti-waste. Among the wasteful programs he’s targeted are anything having to do with the environment or mass transit. He voted to close several prominent bike lanes, calling cyclists "a pain in the ass to motorists" and claims he respects the environment because he turns out the lights.
Nova Scotia has experienced its own political scandals. The province where bribes have for years been a way of life has seen a number of its legislators indicted over the past year. Furthermore, the province has, according to a recent economic report, lost 4,000 jobs over the past year.
Up in Cape Breton, I saw much in the way of single issue signage in support of the unborn and little in the way of diversity—ethnic, political or religious. More than 80% of the residents trace their origins wholly or partly to Great Britain (including Scotland and Ireland), with ancestral ties to France accounting for another 18% of the population. A fair number in this tourist-heavy community take seasonal unemployment in stride by drinking, sleeping and “jumping on the dole” during the winter, according to my Chéticamp guide.
Why are these people so interested in U.S politics, eh?
What struck me about our northern brethren’s questions and observations was that they came with an undercurrent of concern--about the bitterness and pessimism that seems to define our national mood these days. “Does anyone in your country feel hopeful about anything?” one woman queried after asking me to rate Obama’s job performance. “I used to think of Americans as optimistic types,” ventured a traveler from British Columbia, “but no more.”
It’s not surprising to realize we still matter to people outside our country. In fact, those candidates who aren’t suggesting we pull up the moat will insist that America must regain its “super-power status” without, of course, suggesting a viable plan for making that happen.
I don’t know that most of the citizens of the world expect us (or want us) to flex our military, economic or even philanthropic muscles as we once did. They know we’re on the same austerity diet they are. But what I’ve noticed, and others have as well, is that the US is suffering from a character deficit. The mix of optimism, courage, generosity and determination that used to define America has deserted us. True, we have often overstated the argument pertaining to American exceptionalism. On the other hand, the uniquely open-minded, open-hearted, questing American spirit is exceptional. It’s the one resource we can’t afford to lose.
It’s been a long time since we were number one—in education, affordable health care; in several other measures pertaining to well-being and quality of life. We should be focused on making gains in those areas, even as we get used to our slipped position in terms of economic clout. Whether we need to maintain some semblance of superiority in matters of warfare is something we have to reassess. But we shouldn’t, we needn’t surrender our spirit. That’s something Americans have always been able to count on. It may turn out to be something the rest of the world counts on as well.


Salon.com
Comments
The Congress should travel outside of junkets and live with foreigners and get a taste of what the world thinks of us. A (very) few might even learn from it.
On the other hand, I often wonder if it's not mostly a case of the loudmouths getting the most press -- especially in the blogosphere (something to which I pay critical attention because I don't believe most of what I read there), leading to a mere perception that everything is going awry.
You've been around long enough (although not as long as I have) to remember other crises of faith -- the S&L scandal, Vietnam, the Civil Rights conflicts, the dotcom implosion, OPEC, 20-per-cent-plus interest rates, stagflation etc. -- that failed to derail the US.
(Should mention, though, that it's no longer the Retrogressive Preservative party, but rather the Conservative Party of Canada since the merger with the Canadian Alliance a while back.)
I beg to differ with my fellow countryman, Boanerges - I think the unravelling of the U.S. began with all those things he mentioned (except the civil rights movement - and even with that, since segregation was so reluctantly and meanly let go in the face of what was, however peaceable, an uprising) and that unravelling has hit up against globalization of production and stagnant economy beyond its borders. When the American elephant rolls over (and elephant seems to be it, rather than donkey), the whole world shudders...
The United States is not the only country suffering from a "character deficit"; we too are plagued with that affliction.
The Harper federal government has push for election after election to secure a majority during hard economic times without any thought to taxpayers. I believe we’d endured four elections in less than eight years.
To set the record straight progressive conservative is an oxymoron right up there with military intelligence.
Toronto was once known as Toronto the good now it’s a cold indifferent place, showing signs of decay and with rising crime and huge numbers of homeless.
The mayor of Toronto Rob Ford and his brother the side kick are running the city like a side show, flaunting their ignorance like it’s a badge of horour. Perhaps the Fords should be reminded that it’s better at times to be perceived a fool than to open one’s mouth and remove all doubt.
Rob Ford has made it his mission to close neighborhood libraries because they out number Tim Horton’s coffee shops, (I’m sure you’ll attest they serve god awful coffee). I think he’s closing them because he can’t read!
I don’t know about Americans but Canadians sadly don’t vote for something we vote against something…so strange EH?
I’m going to stop before this rant becomes a novel.
Enjoyed your post; I do hope you were well treated and enjoyed your stay with us in the great white north.
Cheers from Toronto,
My friend from the southern U.S. was visiting this weekend and expressed embarrassment about what is happening in America. Funny, then she brought up Rob Ford as an example that "it is happening here too." Rob Ford is a blight on the Toronto landscape. I still can't believe people voted for him.
Now regarding Nova Scotia; in the Maritimes the loss of the fishing industry has left a huge gaping hole both economically and culturally. Being born in Halifax I know some of these regional attitudes which you'll find in any depressed area anywhere in the world. But "regaining super-power status"? I haven't heard any of that talk. Maybe time to go "down home" for a visit ...
"The US is suffering from a character deficit." Unfortunately, that's been the trend for a while. Seems like our society has become obsessed with our differences, to the detriment of any attempts at positive accomplishments
`Hackmatack's Farm. They use local huckleberry's, cherries, and rhubarb's plaant-stalkss for great wine. If you ever get back to Nova Scotias try to pass through the Digby's area, and meet Mr. James E. Outhouse - the Good Lawyer.
He treats You to sea scallops.
Take Con Chapman next trip.
`
As soon as I clean up my shack?
I am headed up to Nova Scotia.
The wild huckleberry wine, ah!
Sip Hackenmatack's Farm Wine!
Please never become inebriated!
No buy 'Keth's' N.S.beer anymore!
'Budweiser' bah brewery bought it!
`
Huckleberries go great with melons.
Politico's get thumped. No ever ripe!
Flop dollops of cream on everything!
Things may get worse before they worst?
I know You will live longer post a N.S. trip.
No blog too much and get as looney as loon.
I am itchhy to head off in my P.U. Truck Asap.
The western winds have begun to send coolness.
I can't wait to walk the sand beaches. Watch clouds.
You see rams, old geezers, and wild\tame naked folk.
The locals cook thee best fish/scallop\lobster soups.
hi Jean and Curt. I haul sheep cheese/and dirty rags.
I'll scrub my jeans in ocean waters/and try to behave.
Whatever.
Jean is Elderly.
She was a movie star.
Jean says` Whatever.
She lifts arms Upward.
I am on my way a`soon.
Ya go to pick a melon. They rots `gin!
Ya never get any fresh great ripe`fruit!
`
The locals celebrate the western winds.
They seem to be calm and healthy there.
I try to go to Nova Scotia once a year too.
The locals share halibut. They live to `100.
I plan to depart any day. I itch for calm days.
I hope we bump in Shelbourne, N.S. some day.
I know some locals who grow pure green beets.
The Farmer Markets on Saturday are so great.
There's many musicians who fiddle and smile.
Although our lib/lefties always try to equate our conservative parties and voters as being similar to American republicans - even to blatantly lying about things like Harper re-naming his government the “Harper Government”, there is more in common between our Canadian Conservative Party and your Democratic Party.
Calling the Conservative government the “Harper” government was done by the mass media. They do it with every federal government, thus one of our Liberal governments was called the “Pearson” government, another the “Trudeau” government.
M.C.S., who bemoans the fact that we had 4 elections in 8 years seems to conveniently forget (a lib/left trait) that it was the lib/left who forced those elections by failing to pass necessary proposed legislation and moving a vote of non-confidence that meant that the government could no longer govern and required that the Prime Minister tender to the Governor General, the resignation of his government and the calling of an election.
Harper fought off numerous challenges by the other parties, who attacked his government both singly and as an unethical coalition. Yet these self-same lefties attack Harper for “calling elections to try to get a majority in parliament.”
The voters weren’t so stupid as the left would have you believe and eventually gave Mr. Harper his majority. Suck it up lefties.
Relax a bit; you’ll get your turn.
.
If anyone is interested in the Canadian use of the terms “Progressive Conservative, Conservative, conservative, Liberal and liberal, as they pertain to our politics, please feel free to PM me.
Rated for curiosities.
I wonder, however, who Jack Taylor was?
Seems to me that the "shining light of the NDP” whom she mentions was Jack Layton. You may judge her political knowledge by this example of her erudition.
Raising his name here, in this context, shows gross disrespect. Those of us who could, and would, like to respond to her glorifying of Layton and his silly-socialist NDP, cannot, in graciousness to his bereaved family, do so this soon after their loss.
I am the only Liberal out of generations.
Tim Hortons swears they do not put MSG in their coffee.. right.. ask the coffee junkies lined up every darn day.
I have heard very little US news here this summer and it has been quite refreshing.
Yes there is poverty in Canada but nothing like the US. Come to my hood and real poverty exists.
Canada is a great country and I have done blogs all summer on it. I never knew a lot about what I wrote and I am Canadian eh?
Glad you had a great time.. HUGGGGGGGGG
RIP Jack Layton
HUGGGGGGGGGG
You are as loveable as anyone could be.
But you know dick-all about Canadian politics. You have forgotten that it was this present Conservative party that kept Canada out of much of the difficulties our American cousins have been suffering.
Tell me one policy of the Conservative party that is the same as that of one that is espoused by the Republicans. Point for point our Conservatives are always much closer - not identical - but closer, to the American Democrats than they are to the Republicans.
The NDP is fully socialist. The Liberals are wandering round somewhere in between the two just trying to figure out what they can say to get elected - as usual. If they think that people want to hear it - they’ll say it! Witness the last two or three elections.
I loves ya, you ol’ Canuck broad, but if you wrote down your knowledge of Canadian politics, I suspect that it would fit on the back of a postage stamp and still leave room for a......
HUUUUUUUUUUGGGS!!!
(ᴼ‿̃)
.
@skypixieo: It seems that you are the one "forgetting" that it was Harper who broke his own election legislation and called an election for no other reason other than to get a majority (which he failed to do). This is a government that takes credit for the declining crime rate and at the same time pushes an agenda that calls for the same kind of wildly expensive super max prisons that have been a dismal failure in the U.S. Why do we need them if Harper et al are telling the truth? Then there is the matter of untendered fighter jets that the Canadian public (just like the prisons) isn't entitled to know the cost of. Etcetera. I haven't even gotten to the muzzling and utter contempt for scientists and anyone who isn't obsessed with making Harper's true base of rich fundamentalist nutbars even richer -- this is well documented so don't even try to pretend it's a "left/lib" plot -- and the disgusting display of George Bush wannbe foreign "relations" that have left most of the world wondering what in hell is happening to this country. I have no problem with you having an opinion different than mine, but your claim that only Harper is responsible for the economic "recovery" (more like a slow-mo recession in the making) shows that you have drunk the Kool Aid. I can quote you tons of facts to back up my assertions, but ideology of the Harper kind to which you so blindly promote has proven to be uninterested in logic/reality unless it's to suppress it. Harper isn't fit to be mentioned in the same breath as Jack Layton, and no, I didn't agree with all of Layton's policies either. It's called critical thinking.
As with most of our silly socialist crew here in Canada, you misquote me badly and then expect me to “answer to” your misquoted blather.
Do not even imply that I have ever claimed that any Canadian government that I have experienced during my lifetime is a perfect one. They have ALL been far less than they should have been. Were you alive during the previous terms that the liberals formed the government? Were you conscious? Politically, I mean? Any list that you can draw up about the failings of the Conservatives (and I expect it’d be a long one) I can match and more than match with a similar list of such things for when the Liberals were in office.
And let’s not make Layton a saint just yet, eh. He was a politician. That’s all. Just another one of “that bunch”. No better and no worse than any other politician. This is the last comment I will make to you or to anybody who cannot make their points without derogatory remarks about me “drinking the Kool-aid” and before you accuse me of “so blindly promoting” any “agenda” that has to do with the Conservatives, maybe you’d do well to read over the last dozen of my political/economic blogs.
You lib/left types who don’t even need to know what someone thinks or espouses but can try to nail them to the wall for what YOU THINK they believe, make me sick. Find out what the hell you’re talking about before coming out with such trash. But then the style of the lib/left crowd is almost always the dirty personal attack instead of arguing facts.
If your comment is an example of your “critical thinking” then I’ll pass, thanks.
.
r.
There is a root cause, as I see it, for our degeneration. We've always had conservative leadership from time to time, and terrible foreign policy, almost always. When I lived in France they picked on me, but that was just them being French. Mostly they wanted to know things about the far west, and to buy my jeans right off my legs.
But they simply assumed we were optimistic, as you suggest here, and inventive and interesting.
On NPR last week there was a how about how far we have slipped in Math proficiency etc. It wasn't just depressing. We are not "like" a third world country now, educationally speaking, we are, full stop. And it is transforming us, our ability to choose and work and create. And the world is, I think, getting bored. We are no longer the ever-shiny, ever-cool engine for what's next. We are the churning goulash of "what was", spiced with bitter herbs, and dosed with vitriol.
All because we stopped teaching critical thinking, stopped expecting our kids to achieve. The far right -- pardon me, I mean simply the right, now -- campaigns ceaselessly for even more dismantling of education, and teaching non-science nonsense in fixed-morality finishing schools.
Wait, to hell with all that: plenty of lobster, you say?
skypixie: I don't see the need for getting snarky and sarcastic with and anyone who supported Jack Layton. I never set myself up as a political commentator or expert, but I do think Jack's death is a tragic loss for this country. He was a brave and noble man. A man of great integrity. Call his party "silly" if you like, but I still think that hope, optimism and love are stronger than fear, anger and hate. Like Jack Layton wrote in his farewell letter to all Canadians,
"Canada is a great country, one of the hopes of the world. We can be a better one – a country of greater equality, justice, and opportunity … Don't let them tell you it can't be done...
love is better than anger. Hope is better than fear. Optimism is better than despair. So let us be loving, hopeful and optimistic. And we'll change the world."
Every year I get up to Canada and talk with folks I meet about whatever's going on. It is always enlightening and, in general, tar sands aside, Canadians are politically more enlightened than us by a significant factor, a very significant factor.
Will we get it? Will we ever become more like them? Nah, no way!
First the Conservative talking point claim that it was the “lib/left who forced those elections by failing to pass necessary proposed legislation and moving a vote of non-confidence..”
Nonsense. The elections he refers to took place in 2004, 2006, 2008 & 2011. The 2004 was a business as usual election; the previous one having been held in 2000.
The 2006 election was brought on by his hero Steven Harper and sidekick Jack Layton voting down the Liberal government.
The 2008 election was called by, once again, Steven Harper. Eight weeks into a summer recess, when Parliament was not even sitting, Harper broke his fixed date own elections law by declaring that Parliament had become dysfunctional (while in recess?) and there needed to be an election.
The 2011 election was due to the opposition parties voting down Harper’s Conservatives. At the time of the vote, the Conservative minority government was on the verge of becoming the longest serving minority government in the country’s history.
So for three of the four elections sited, skypixieo is flat-out wrong. For the other, he apparently feels that it was wrong not to let the Conservative minority serve longer than any minority in history. I’m sure skypixieo knows all the above but the rest of you can be grateful (or not) that you’re getting a close-up view of barely varnished Conservative talking points.
Another Conservative talking point is that “it was this present Conservative party that kept Canada out of much of the difficulties our American cousins have been suffering.”
Considering that in 2006 the Conservatives inherited a large surplus and well-regulated banks from the previous Liberal government, this is yet another baseless claim made by spinners aimed at dupes. It’s not easy to tell which of the two skypixieo is.
Finally, that the Conservatives are most unlike the Republicans? Well they aren’t on climate change which Steven Harper called an international socialist plot in a 2004 fundraising letter. They’ve done dick-all about it in the five years they’ve been in office. And they’re running the same Republican right-wing playbook when it comes to taxation and deficits. They lard the tax system with all sorts of cuts (the GST, deductions for transit passes, kids hockey equipment etc.) and pile up deficits. Next step is to claim that government spending (except on prisons and the military) must be reined in. They’re as small government, pro-military, and anti-science as you can get in Canada. And they’re pushing the envelope on those fronts.
As I see it Canada as a whole is and always have been more open-minded, open-hearted though perhaps less questing (on a mission) than America.
Just getting back around to this blog, so I don't know if you'll see this. My comment was not referring to words that journalists or media use such as the "Trudeau Gov't" or the "Pearson Gov't", Harper actually had the name changed on official federal communications. Check it out ...
http://www.thestar.com/news/canada/article/948436--tories-rebrand-government-of-canada-as-harper-government
We still see the U.S. as the world leader, better at everything when in reality we lead in things we should be embarrassed about like, the most expensive health care system in the world per person with care rated 37th in the world, and our life expectancy is ranked 47th in the world. Don't get me started on the military.
But, I'm preaching to the choir, I imagine.
Nice article. R
We have a vested interest in your politics Nikki, something you'd understand if you weren't as myopic as the rest of your citizens. You are our biggest economic partner and we are unfortunately tied to your economic mess.
"We have a vested interest in your politics Nikki, something you'd understand if you weren't as myopic as the rest of your citizens."
Wow, dan...are you SURE you aren't really an American? Because I don't normally hear that sort of accusatory stereotyping except here in the US.
I thought Nikki's piece--in a NICE way--points out the very real concerns of Canadians regarding our politics here, which are definitely in a shambles. I am probably biased and not afraid to admit it, but it seems that the more Americans allow religion to intrude on government while allowing corporate interests to have such power over everything, the more we continue this pattern of movement.
It's the same pattern feces follows when headed down the toilet.
Anyone who has ever tried to navigate Toronto in a car should fully understand why being so fully against public transportation spending in that city is pure insanity.
I have been saying the same thing for years. So much of our problem in the US is our attitude. Manufacturers are sitting on billions but won't spend because the country has been shaken to its core. They are waiting for a positive sign, any kind of sign before they are willing to reinvest. I think it is particularly sad that Obama's entire campaign rested on the word hope and we have never seen so little of it in this country....
I felt some instant pressure in USA-- to be someone or something to that effect. In Canada all of us felt at ease. The minute we hit American soil, less so. Did you have any of this feeling? And my travels preceeded this decade and were from a better time circa 1999. Still, Canada is so special in part because the people are in general just regular folks whereas once upon a time we were into being 'special.' With that going or gone, what are we here?
Just one analogy, in Finland, I felt almost the same even better than in Canada, since everyone was easy going and not pretentious. I arrived in France at some fancy hotel (had no choice as I am using points from amex) and immediately I felt what I did long ago in SF, that people are stressed and stressing. I know this isn't a direct response to your post, but it is what came to mind. R