aging hippie chick

aging hippie chick
Location
Nevada City, California, US
Birthday
June 02
Title
Horticultural Goddess
Bio
Aging, yet immature, hippie chick. Married, musical, compulsively creative and scattered. Still trying to make sense out of life via Buddhism, composting, etc.

MY RECENT POSTS

Aging hippie chick's Links

Salon.com
OCTOBER 26, 2009 1:50PM

Suzanne Somers and magical thinking MIGHT cure your cancer!

Rate: 34 Flag

Omigod.  I saw the aborted-then-rescheduled Larry King Live interview with Suzanne Somers, a woman I'd been only dimly aware of - first through her silly, "aren't I vacuous and cute?" performance on "Three's Company", a show I accidentally and briefly turned on once and quickly turned off because it was painful to watch - and later through glimpses of her promoting her book on facing breast cancer.  I had the feeling, without paying much attention, she was growing as a human being; she seemed fairly intelligent talking about her first book, and I know that facing  mortality often deepens people.

BUT, last Friday I watched her interview on Larry King; initally with interest, thinking "Here's an intelligent, informed woman", but later convinced that she is lying. Convinced for many reasons:

I've NEVER heard the nonsensical term "full body cancer", nor has any other medical professional I know.

It's very unlikely they would have done a CT scan on a patient with dyspnea (shortness of breath) and a rash, a classic allergic reaction treated with IV meds and possibly a breathing treatment. 

It's implausible that a hospital would have 4 "infectious doctors" - in my experience (ER nursing in 8 different hospitals over the years), hospitals have one infectious control specialist.

It's just plain silly that, as she claims, all four would have come to her room and informed her she had: tuberculosis, leprosy, and/or meningitis. It's even sillier that, as she claims, they would have TREATED her for all these diseases without verifying the diagnosis, which is not difficult to do for any of these diseases.

No "leprosy medicine" makes one bleed through the skin, as she claims she was warned could happen.  Some cause clotting problems, which manifest themselves as bruising and maybe blood on your toothbrush, but that makes for SUCH a dull story. . .

Patients are not "wrapped in plastic and taken to a room way up on the top floor" when they are potentially contagious. Hospitals regularly deal with communicable diseases, and have fairly simple procedures for preventing spread: a room with an exhaust fan (of which there are many in hospitals, on regular wards); a cart outside with hand sanitizer, paper gowns, and face masks for various types of infections; and a sign advising visitors what type of protection they need.

There's no reason they would "cut open her throat" to take a lung biopsy (and there is no scar that I could see. . .).

NO doctor would later come to her room and say "What do you know - you DON'T have cancer. Your body is completely free of cancer". This is not something anyone could establish, nor a statement any doctor would make.

Equally suspicious is that Ms. Somers will not name the hospital or doctors she is accusing of such implausible actions. She implies this is high moral ground; my suspicion, however, is that she knows that HIPPA privacy laws preclude anyone's proving or disproving her outrageous story.

The fact is, she could have fabricated the ENTIRE story, or any part of it, and no hospital could contradict her, as she has not named any hospital. No one can prove that she was or was not a patient.

Except Ms. Somers. If she wants any credibility for this outlandish story, she could: produce witnesses who were with her that night - did her husband or her friends she was out with before she was rushed to the emergency room come with her to the hospital? Are they able to corroborate her story?

She could, if she so chose, publish her medical records, with names of the doctors and hospital deleted - not difficult to do. I suspect she will not do these things, because I suspect she fabricated some, maybe all, of this story.

Being in the spotlight is addicting, especially for someone whose self-worth has been largely fed by being pretty and somewhat famous.  Ms. Somers may be free of cancer, but I think she has other issues that bear looking into.  I'm thinking narcissism.  I'm thinking underactive conscience.

Oh, and P.S.: Ms. Somers and the various doctors in her inner circle claim they're being harassed by the medical establishment because they are coming up with cures that obviate the need for more established, more profitable treatments.  In fact, however, there is NO credible, peer-reviewed evidence for these people, who are, in my opinion, selling false hope for HUGE sums ($60 thousand for the Russian guy's treatment, per Larry King.)  Watch the show - you'll see what I mean.

I'm somewhat surprised at my newfound animosity toward Ms. Somers; I'm usually nicer.  This results, I think, from a couple things:

(To quote Dr. Seuss) Thing One:  I HATE being lied to, and 

Thing Two: by her addiction to celebrity, she is encouraging people to forego traditional treatments for cancer. These are clearly difficult and imperfect, but they are at least based in scientific method and inquiry into effectiveness, vs. anecdotal "I knew someone who did this and got better" evidence, which abounds in her stories.

I agree there are effective alternative treatments that traditional medicine has not embraced or proven, but it's silly to throw out one in favor of the other.

And it's unconscionable to garner money and fame encouraging people to do so.

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
She has been a TV huckster ever since her days of pushing the Thigh-Master. She is probably involved finacianally with some herbal cure she wants to sell on Infomercials. She strikes me as a sort of female Billy Mays only Billy could be intertaining.

Rated.
What, and Larry just sat there like a lox? Maybe he's getting too old for this. I never liked Suzanne Somers either.
R
She lost her credibility years ago. ~R~
Thoughtful and Interesting analysis. Larry King is not known for his skepticism, so distrustful observers are a must. Rated
I watched the show. I heard "full body CHEMO", not full body "CANCER".

We always need to utilize critical thinking when listening to a point of view. Suzanne Somers has some excellent information and points, and other not so good ones. It's still up to us to do our own research. I think her work serves a purpose.

She did say her aim was to inspire people to THINK about alternatives. And I am not aware of any herb she's hocking claiming to fight cancer.
You are right to be angry. She promotes utter nonsense. You have no idea. I suggest not bothering looking further, it will only make you madder. (and you ARE a nice person)

EXCELLENT post.
Sad part about this is that there are people who will swallow this nonsense hook, line and sinker.....The Birthers, Deathers and all those inbetween are clear evidence of just how gullible people can be.....
I WON'T read more about Suzanne Somers. I WON'T.

Starcrest - I have no quarrel with you, and if you find her book helpful go for it. But she did say "full body cancer", many times, actually. I just don't trust her; I think she lacks integrity, which makes me want to run away from someone. Just my take.
Sorry, but any woman who injects faux hormons into her vag every day to "stay young" is a nut.
I didn't see the interview, but I see Thigh-Masters at every garage sale in town.
She's a fame whore.
The lack of scar on her neck really got me too. I kept thinking, I wish I knew the name of that guy for later on in life when I need a face-lift, he does nice work.

I didn't buy it either for some reason, you have pointed out the reasons.
There was a recent story in Newsweek about how Oprah falls for hucksters, Somers being one of them.
http://www.newsweek.com/id/200025
Somers recommends bioidentical hormones as safe, though this is dodgy advice. She even injects hormones directly into her vagina to stay young. She claims to take 60 vitamins/ supplements a day. Anyway, I don't trust her, though I am with you that there are effective alternative therapies to explore. I just think an actual openminded, intelligent, compassionate doctor could help you find them.
I'm shocked, just shocked that someone would go on a cable news program and LIE!
If these doctors really were researching potentially profitable cures, wouldn't any one of the big pharma companies just make them an offer and everyone could make big bucks off the miracle cure? Doesn't that thing happen every day when researchers and universities sell patents to drug companies? Or when they establish their own small companies that get swallowed up by the big ones? Big pharma doesn't squelch potential competitors, it buys them.
Maybe Larry was still in shock about balloon boy to do anything about this. I didn't see it, I can't comment. I do know the thigh master was crap though.
"She has been a TV huckster ever since her days of pushing the Thigh-Master. "

Right. We all know how well the Thigh-Master worked out.

Buns of Steel, on the other hand. And the whole 'steel' series, for that matter. Anyone who has ever slept with a total woman of steel knows those work. I should write an entire post on the steel infomercials. And just not to keep everyone hanging.... the steel woman is great until you run into the inevitable problems which need no explanation.

Veg-A-Matic, The Pocket Fisherman, and even, 'Set it and Forget It' -- civilization as we know it is dependent on infomercials.

But, medical treatment, not so much.
The picture were okay. As long as she didn't say anything. I'm no ER nurse, but a Dr. will NEVER give you an absolute answer.
Hear, hear! Somers is a self-important monster. They're not unusual in celebrityville, but she's in a class by herself. Thanks for a reasoned argument. After listening to her once for 5 minutes, I seriously considered killing either her or myself.
Don't do it, Emma! Well, maybe her, but not yourself. You add something to the world. . . AHC
THANK YOU. Gah. Just GAH.

I love quackwatch.org.
Now I've got this bizarre mental image of a leprosy-ridden Somers, encased in Saran wrap, being held up to the sun on the hospital roof by some muscular orderly, a la Kunta Kinte and his firstborn in "Roots." It's stuck in my old head, and I just can't get it out!
Love the Saran Wrap/Kunta Kinte thing. And I'll check out quackwatch - THAT's what I'm looking for.
Yes, yes, and yes! I can't improve on this.
herion; crack, fame
all the same
I steer clear of celebrities selling books (at least until I become one), and have long steered clear of Larry King (until he wants to help me sell MY book), and his practiced look of concern. But if you write one, I think I'll buy it.
Oh, THANK you, jimmymac. I'll get on it - I have my arsenal of "how to write fiction" books and I'm already slogging through them. And thanks, all you fellow writers - high praise, from the likes o' you. . .
She's been selling herself on TV for years, Suzanne Sommers has. Forgive me, but she is just a ditzy broad, and played the part well -- so well, in fact, that I began to realize it wasn't acting.

I have to hand it to her, though. Over a number of years she has sold books, machines, and a bunch of other junk to a lot of people, who just lapped it up.

Maybe it's just her feeble way of contributing to society...
Never heard of her, and to hear tell, that's likely just as well. As the old adage goes, "If something or someone sounds too good to be true, then they probably are...".'Lucksters' are the new 'stars' of prime time, talk show host Tee-Vee. Another reason to tape down the red round OFF button on the remote.

Rated.
Although Strawberry just made me feel a hundred years old, this was excellent. Thank you for your rational, and reasoned criticism of this whackadoo.
Oh no! Not the "off" button. I know I should, but I'm just gonna watch one more episode of Rachel Maddow. I can quit any time. No, really. AHC
"And at least Billy finally shut up.

Okay, that was harsh."
Good, though. . . (In the words of U. Utah Phillips. Ever hear "Moose Turd Pie"? If not, you haven't lived. . .
The intelligence of this critique is matched only be the absence of same in Ms. Sommer's approach to dispensing health care advice.
She is the poster child for making valuable alternative health treatments look bad. I can't stand her. I heard the term, "all over body cancer" and I nearly laughed myself out of my chair, too.

Great post - thanks for sparing me any further subjection to her out of curiosity.
I loved when the cancer specialist pointed out her fabricated numbers for immune function were not medical or scientific measures - at least a couple good science/medical professionals were on the panel. Great post. Rated.
Thanks, kids. And yeah, John, Larry King sat there like a lox. . . He has interesting people on, but I'm finding him increasingly disappointing. Plus, he constantly interrupts people's train of thought to fire off his next questions - more robotic than conversational.

Hope you're still in your chair, Kate. . . AHC
"Damn! That's Moose Turd Pie.
It's good though."
Yes, Doug! Oh YES! So glad SOMEONE understands me. . .
AHC, if you haven't listened to Mojo Nixon's "Where the Hell's My Money?", you should. ("Elvis is Everywhere" is also good: "You know what's happenin' in that Bermuda Triangle? Elvis needs boats!")
Pay no attention to that little woman behind the curtain...