This post is about my experiences of the past year and a half with one man and his family. Thanks for reading.
I met Milt and his daughter in September of 2007. They had advertised for a companion/PCA, I answered the ad, and it was just one of those things. They had already interviewed 12 people, had decided who to hire, but his daughter, Jen, heard my message and decided to fit me in for an interview.I was hired. It was meant to be.
Milt is a retired social worker and scholar with a PhD. from Columbia. He is a careful man - I like to think of him as a typical New Yorker of a certain age. He married and had two daughters, but the marriage failed and he lived alone for many years, intent on his work and his activism in several progressive groups; one that still sends him literature is the Center for Ethical Thought.
I was hired to work two four hour shifts two afternoons a week, for which I would be compensated very generously. Milt was living in an assisted care facility - kind of a retirement home, but with more personal care ; but NOT a nursing home. He had his own small apartment, ate meals in the dining room with other residents.
(If you don't know about these places, you should. The transitional care industry is huge, and you may find yourself considering one of these facilities for your loved ones. Or, y'know, yourself. I think they are great for some people and not right at all for others. Milt was acceptant of being at the Arbors; happiness has never been his middle name, so content was actually a very good thing!)
At first our relationship was strained - getting to know each other can be hard when there's an obvious "I'm paid to be with you." element. But we had a lot in common - one of the first things I did was bring him my New Yorker's after I had finished reading them, which he appreciated. He had kept up his subscription to the Times. The election season was heating up, so we had a lot to talk about.
Also, we live in an incredible place with four colleges and a major university, and cultural offerings are like plucking feathers from a molting chicken. There's literally an abundance of choices. We went to plays and concerts and lectures on the weekends. During the week we went to galleries and museums.And it's a place of natural beauty, which is also very accessable. So we took long walks on the bike paths, or on different campuses.
I was thrilled with my job, and they were thrilled with me. Imagine being praised for seeking out an amazing concert or play, which I was being paid to attend and reimbursed for the ticket, because I was putting so much thought into options for our afternoons! I was sort of like, um....it's not that hard to read the papers! Never mind how much fun we were having!
Naturally, we grew quite close during this time. All three of us. As my relationship with Milt grew and developed, my relationship with Jen also grew. We started talking on the phone regularly about different aspects of her fathers illness, especially as slight signs of deterioration began to occur. There were a few issues of forgetfulness, of course. And he became more frail - dizzy spells, more tiredness. But we were still keeping up a pretty active schedule.
It's hard to remember when things began to change. (HA! It's hard to remember! )When exactly DID the New Yorker become too much? I remember when he told me he didn't need it anymore, but he was still busy with the NY Times. Unless you are with someone every day, those little changes are so subtle. Plus, y'know, was I, or Jen, ready to accept that he might be losing the ability to READ?
And the natural question would be: was HE ready to lose the ability to read? But that's not how it works. Having the newspaper in his hands and figuring out the headlines might have been vital, until just having the familiar newspaper in his hands was vital. At first, I think he did say that the New Yorker's were piling up. Then looked me in the eye and gave me a half smile.
There was a period of being in cahoots against Alzheimer's. Obviously, he knew exactly what was going on. I think he would have committed suicide upon diagnosis (or about when the true dementia set in) except for his love for his daughters.
It's a very precious time, that window of deterioration, if the person is not just pissed off and angry and frustrated. Milt was certainly all of those things, but he also knew that although his future was inevitable, his present was still available. So we managed to do many, many things.
Some stuff is really funny - like taking him to see "Vicky, Christina, Barcelona" which I had advertised to him as a Woody Allen film. Oh, boy. I think he just closed his eyes at some point, and on our way back to the car said, shaking his head;" I don't think that was Woody Allen.". I was, of course, still a little red faced at sitting through the sex scenes while glancing over at him.
It's hard to choose my favorite afternoon with Milt. I guess all the funny ones are most precious, because his smile is so rare. So I love making him laugh. We stormed out of a really bad play once. Well, we carefully managed to negotiate our way out, probably quite slowly, at intermission. But I like to think we stormed out, because it was a really bad play. And once we were out of there he said: "Whew! I didn't like that at all." Me neither! We probably went to have a bagel to recover.
I loved our walks - in the old days with Milt, we would walk in a stiff breeze on a mild winter day. There was always something to talk about, and there was always the comfort of silence together.
I don't know what's going on in a brain riddled by Alzheimers. I do know that Alzheimers literally eats away at the mind. The only way to truly diagnose it is through an autopsy. So, when we took those walks later into his progression, I was supporting him more. And the sunlight through the trees might be too dazzling. Or the endless path in front of us, with no familiar touchstones, might make him stop. "Where are we going? Where are you taking me?"
Where before he would feel joy and notice a certain knot of bark on a tree, or the lily pads in the pond, now everything was the deep woods.
We still went to concerts, but I was running damage control from the moment we arrived. I would sit him down, explain what I was going to do, go to the box office, explain the situation ie dementia and dizzy spells, need to be near an exit, where are the bathrooms, is there exit lighting...I guess I was pretty demanding. But every minute of music, art, drama, stimulation, community seemed like the most vital drug for me to administer. If even one phrase or note gets to you through your awful disease, I have done my job, I said to myself.
I felt like I was his warrior princess, out to slay any dragon that might prevent us from being out in the community. A radical community activist for one Alzheimers victim. (And former radical community activist!) And he trusted me. He was never much of a talker - a man of careful, chosen words - and now he was not completing sentences. So I was trying to interpret him to me, and us to the world, and all we had, sometimes, was a meaningful look, or a nod. A raised eyebrow - he's still good at that.
Milt fell in early March, was hospitalized for less than a week, and was transferred to a Center for Extended Care. A nursing home. On the Dharma unit. Dementia and Alzheimers. Dharma! What does that mean? What sort of dharma is at play for formerly vibrant people who are slowly losing their minds?
The staff on the Dharma unit are great - and, Milt is different. I tried so hard, at first, not to accept that this might be a progression for him. No way should he be in a nursing home. He was walking around on his own before he fell! He was annoying people because he couldn't find his room at the care facility!
He had just moved to the Alzheimer's/dementia ward there! The Reflections unit! Good god, who comes up with this stuff. Reflections, Dharma ? Nobody's reflecting in Reflections - that's sort of the main symptom of dementia - no reflection!
I have this urge to do battle for him, but it's hard to get him to walk without support. It's been two months, and he is getting better, but we're never going to go for a walk again. I am taking him to a concert this weekend. A van with wheelchair access picks us up and drops us off. I don't know how Milt will feel when we get there. I hope he likes it. I hope he knows there is a world still available to him beyond the belted chair in front of the television on the Dharma unit.
When I see him during the week, I wheel him to a quieter place. We toss a plastic ball that's marked as earth back and forth. I help him do some arm exercises. He can't do it on his own. His hands flutter in front of his chest like agitated birds. I take his hands in mine, and look at him.Sometimes he speaks, but I can't understand. So we just look at each other.
His eyes are so clear, and so open - like he's stunned, like he needs to say something really important. Something he can't quite remember. It's on the tip of his tongue. His hands want to take off in flight. I hold them, crossed against my chest. He squeezes so tight it almost hurts.
There's only so much I can do for him now - and I find it offensive that I can't have him back like he was before he fell. I'm mad about that. I want him back.
I could not have done this job without allowing myself to fully love him. Now I'm learning how to let go, painfully, one step at a time.
(P.S. I took him to the concert this afternoon. It was a youth chorus form here with a visiting chorus from Chicago. Very uplifting - and Milt smiled most of the way through. We won today.)


Salon.com
Comments
The observation about the "Dharma" and "Reflections" units is so apt. I know people are not intentionally patronizing; it's just an example of good intentions falling ironically, painfully short - so true of much of life!
I love the metaphor about the battle, and I am in tears and so grateful that you won today. Beautiful writing, beautiful friendship.
caregivers go through a lot, as you say you can't do the job well without feeling something genuine. But then you, too, experience the loss as they deteriorate. Thank-you for sharing this experience. I'll come back to read more.
I know how subtle these losses can be, with many different diseases. It takes great patience and understanding to give so much to those we are entrusted to care for.
I'm more fortunate with my husband, his mind is sharp, his sense of humor intact...it is his body which fails him. But with love, we are able to overcome these obstacles.
I'm glad you won on the day you wrote this, I happen to believe the three of you won by finding each other.
Very beautifully written, and with a sensitivity I admire.
I was really hoping this would resonate with everyone experiencing any debilitating disease with a loved one, and I'm so overjoyed that it has.
Hells bells - Thank you, I take that as a real compliment.
Cartouche -Thanks to you too. Your metaphor of the shoes sums it up so perfectly. And it's an honor to keep putting his shoes on!
Mariana - Thank you for stopping by. I do feel like one of the good guys with Milt!
doloresflores - Thanks! That line was so actual in reality - because the bike path IS a straight line to nowhere - it startled me when I realized what Milt was seeing and experiencing.
Thank you Buffy - again, I'm glad this resonates with people who have debilitating illness as part of their day to day. I would love to read more about what you are experiencing. Keep in touch!
Brenda Gail and Kapwin - thanks, so much.
T&D - I was hoping you would find this post! Milt was at the Arbors before his fall - where we enjoyed many experiences with the doppelgangers of your Mom and her crew! I have more to write about him - some of the funnier moments, and I might even make fun of nasty old Alzheimer's at some point.
Annette 2009 graciously answered my first ever PM to her, begging for a good eye to help me edit/figure out this post. OS is great that way. Special thanks to you - you are a gem.
I really appreciate this, everyone. I worked hard on this post, and cried a lot writing it. So I am beyond happy that it seems to have worked!
I'm so glad Milt has you, and I'm so glad you wrote this. Have you (or will you) share it with Jen?
"I could not have done this job without allowing myself to fully love him. Now I'm learning how to let go, painfully, one step at a time."
We would all be blessed to have someone like you our life.
Reinvented - 16 years is just astounding and heartbreaking. So difficult for everyone.
Redstocking - Thank you! (I've missed you!)
BBE - Thanks, as always.
Marple Frank - Thank you for commenting. Jen is not so big on the internet, but yes I already told her I was writing it (asked permission), and she is very excited. I may print a copy for her, but it would be great for her to read comments too.
mamoore - thank you! It surprised me how protective I became of him! We never embraced at all until this recent stage. Milt is a very reserved, private man - it would have been awful for both of us! Now I'm manhandling him all the time, so I hug him and kiss his cheek before I leave.
Gabby Abbey - Thanks for commenting. Milt's eyes seem more clear now, and he has this steady gaze. He still recognizes me, so I think he's saying: "Get me outta here!", which I try to do. Even if I just wheel him around outside, it's an escape.
KoB - I really appreciate you stopping by. Thanks for caring for your Dad's caregivers. We're a special breed!
Thanks everyone - Milt is lucky to have me as I am lucky to have him. He inspired me to write this, so I thank him as well.
All I can say is, I'm glad I have no daughters.
Thumbed.
d
But did you know that the editors' cover title for this post says "Wilt," not Milt, as in Wilt Chamberlain? OS needs a copy editor!
Thanks for the wonderful, moving post aim.
I appreciate your writing and especially admire the way you ended this on as "up" a note as is possible -- the "P.S.....We won today." It is true, a smile becomes the best sort of triumph.
She had a couple of violent episodes and her condition deteriorated very rapidly, which is a bit atypical. We had to, for our family's safety, relocate her to a really wonderful assisted living facility. Now, both my parents were educators and my mother was an athelete and had a masters degree in math and was just a few credit hours shy of a second masters. She had spent her entire life with a circle of friends who were all accomplished education professionals. The real bitch about this disease is that it robs it's victims of their faculties very slowly and takes an equal toll on their dignity. Seeing a once proud woman reduced to having to have assistance for the most basic tasks is sickening. My mother deserves a much better ending than what she has been given.
(If anyone has a family member who is in the early stages of Alzheimer's and wants some advice on care etc. send me a message and I'll try to give you some good advice.......serious inquiries only please as this is a painful subject for me)
I lighter take ... ? ... okay?
A Lady takes a `Nam Vet partner to a VA health clinic. She wonders?She says:`Check this Nam Vet out? A VA doc says:`We'll give a Vet a free physical. Drop the `Nam Vet off, and pick him up in about eight hours.
She comes back to the VA. What's wrong with the old timer? The VA doc says:`I forgot. It was a busy Vet day. Doc request:`On the way home, take a Vet one block down the street from home. Drop him off. If the `Nam (Gulf War Etc.,Afghan) Vet finds his way home ... ? .... Your partner has either terminal AIDS or Old-Timers-Illnesses. She ask:`How will I know the diagnosis?
The VA doc says this:`
If Ya partner finds his way home,
Please don't dare kiss him. Kiss?
Mary? No. Cathy?
No. Kiss Aim tho?
I go jog in woods?
Be merry in spite?
I feel like so many of the comments enrich my initial essay, and I feel a sort of solidarity with all of you!
Milt's daughter, Jen, is going to read this online sometime today. I'm excited for her to see all the comments, too. Thanks again, everyone. OS is a terrific place filled with terrific people.
You can never let go. He'll always be a part of you.
From one caregiver to another, a hearty, heartfelt salute. I'll be reading more.
Carry on.
http://risaden.blogspot.com/2009/08/palliative-care-grand-rounds-august.html
Risa - That is an honor and I'm excited to follow that link. I'm SO glad you shared this. If it makes an iota of difference for anyone suffering with/within this disease than my job is being done.
Psychomama: Thank you. I'm so glad this touched so many people because I feel connected - and Alzheimer's is so much about the lonely and disconnected parts of life, for everyone. It's a virtual support group, in a way, when i return to these comments.
I need to write an update - Alzheimer's is so, so weird. Milt has started coming back to us! Full sentences, he's walking (with assistance) - it's like he finally came back from that bad, three month acid trip. He's never leaving the Dharma unit, but it looks like he might be able to get in my car to go for a drive, which will get him away for a few hours every week. Fingers crossed.
I am caring for my Dad and there are some days that I watch him and want my Dad back. Wish I had someone like you to give me a hand some days. The "we won today" sentiment is beautiful.
I know it well. We've had a few of those, too. They make me smile and cry all at the same time.
It was really painful, but there's a simple explanation. Whatever part of his brain that was dealing with associations associated me with companionship from the outside - nothing complex. Or that's how I interpret it.
His daughter was, and is, worried, he became incontinent, he wasn't standing up on his own so "toileting" was difficult (the staff do all of that at the care facility), and maybe the part of his brain that was still recognizing Jen was also rejecting her seeing him in those really vulnerable moments, or rejecting his daughter being his caregiver.
I WAS his companion and caregiver, so it was easier for me to slither through the gap between assisted living and "nursing home".
That's my theory.
I would love to know more about your experiences with your Dad, and I truly hope you can access outside help - it's amazing what a relief a stranger can be for everyone! That unfettered relationship can be, I think, a vital part of support for certain stages of dementia and Alzheimers. Plus, you probably need, and deserve, a break. I hope you are well.
As long as I'm with him, he's okay, happy and amiable. If I'm out of site, his anxiety is heartbreaking to watch. He's so afraid that someone is going to "put him away" somewhere, or take him away and not bring him back, or that I'll leave him behind and not come back that he can't enjoy anything unless I'm there.
For me, it's exhausting. I'm trying to juggle his care with working. Thankfully, I work from home, but the hours I'm keeping seriously kill.
He's blind (macular degeneration) - which makes it harder for him because he can't see much of anything going on around him.
I'm hoping to eventually wean him into external care. I took him to a day facility a few times.... a few minutes the first time, then an hour, then 2 hours. Hoping against fact that he'll get used to it and realize I'm coming back. So far, no luck -- he sits there just afraid out of his mind until I get back and he hears my voice.
Thanks for asking. Sometimes the simplest of human communications makes all the difference in the world. It helps me feel like I'm not *really* alone in this and that there's caring voices out there somewhere. :)