.

Alan C. Baird

Alan C. Baird
Location
Mesa, Arizona, USA, Earth
Bio
Alan lives just a stone's throw from Phoenix... which is fine and dandy, until the stones are thrown back.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
AUGUST 20, 2008 1:28PM

Hacking Google: SEO's sneaky spam secret.

Rate: 9 Flag

Search Engine Optimization (SEO) is a service you can buy to boost your website's position on the search engine results page, when Internet surfers try to find certain keywords or phrases, like "Mesa Giant Red Nipple." If you plug that four-word phrase into any of the top web search engines, my site will come out pretty darn near the top. In cyberspace, I am considered to be *the* expert on Mesa Giant Red Nipples, and I've worked very hard to cultivate that reputation.

I've posted at least half a dozen articles on the subject. I've created a couple of blogs that mirror the phrase and link back to my website. I've done some social bookmarking on sites with memorable names like del.icio.us. Or is it deli.cio.us? I can never remember.

If I were really serious about maintaining my Number One ranking, I would hire a squad of Bulgarians and Pakistanis, at ten cents an hour, to find blog comment discussions or other online forums with some "relevancy." For a keyword phrase like "Mesa Giant Red Nipple," they would probably come up with sites showing the difference between a mesa and a butte, or raving about NY Giants football, or offering Simply Red concert photos, or selling breast augmentation and nipple piercing services.

Or they might be less relevant.

Then I would tell the Bulgarians and Pakistanis to write comments and drop links on those blogs or forums, cleverly disguised to blend into the existing conversational threads: "I make plenty big touchdown in my socker game less week. -Rogger, Mesa Giant Red Nipple [link]."

Or maybe I would hire Lithuanians and Vietnamese to do this part of the job. Everyone knows those darn Pakistanis can't blend in anywhere.

But perhaps you're pressed for time and have too much money to worry about small matters like SEO. That's when you go out and hire an SEO firm. They also list themselves under acronyms like SEM (Search Engine Marketing) and SES (Search Engine Strategists). If you don't know anything about hiring an SEO company, here's a list of pointers:

(1) The SEO CEO (Chief Executive Officer) must be able to dazzle you with dialect and baffle you with bullpucky. If he doesn't use jargon like "keyword density" and "backlink boosting," he doesn't know his stuff. On the other hand, if he can rattle off five or six sentences in a slangy SEO-ese lingo, and those sentences make no sense to you at all, he's probably the guy you want.

(2) Most of his staff should be in their early twenties. The younger, the better. In fact, if the CEO is older than 29, he probably hasn't been immersed in cyberspace for more than half his life, so his genetic sequencing hasn't mutated enough to provide the kind of service you need.

(3) Your SEO CEO should assure you that he performs only "ethical" or "organic" or "white hat" SEO. He should also warn you that his competitors engage in "black hat" SEO, and their efforts often result in search engine penalties. He should tell you that if you use those other guys, your site might end up getting banned by Google. He should really scare you. If you're not terrified, he's no freakin' good.

(4) He should offer to research the precise keyword phrases that people customarily use to find your business. Then he should propose "optimizing" your website for those keywords. "Optimizing" is techspeak for "charging exorbitant fees to insert one of your keyword phrases into each paragraph on your site."

(5) By the way, you can discover the same keyword phrases by casually perusing the free server logs provided by your website's hosting company.

(6) At this point, your SEO CEO should offer to sell you custom-written keyword-rich articles that link back to your website. He will tell you he's placing those articles on websites in his inventory that have been carefully selected for their "relevancy." Think nipple piercing.

(7) He should never characterize his inventory websites as "link farms." Even though they are, in truth, link farms.

(8) For the coup de grâce, he will carefully gauge your GQ (Gullibility Quotient), and perhaps offer to sell you "backlink boosting." Make sure to ask whether he uses Pakistanis or Lithuanians.

***

The SEO industry came into being approximately ten seconds after Google announced its PageRank system. Wikipedia, the online encyclopedia, says that "PageRank is a link analysis algorithm that assigns a numerical weighting to each element of a hyperlinked set of documents, such as the World Wide Web, with the purpose of measuring its relative importance within the set."

How much do you wanna bet that some hotshot SEO CEO wrote that sentence?

PageRank (PR) tells me your website's relative importance. If you're PR 1 or 2, I can't even risk being seen with you. But if you're PR 8 or 9, I will anxiously wait by the phone, hoping to be invited to your next party.

SEOers rely on PageRank like the rest of us rely on air. In fact, your average SEOer keeps a wary eye on everything that Google does, because Google created--and can easily destroy--his business. When giant Google takes a crap, every SEOer minutely examines the steaming heap.

But some SEOers want to be ahead of the curve, so they don't wait until the golden turds hit the ground. They jump up, trying to get a view inside Google's butt. They want to know how the digestive system works. The express concern when Google experiences constipation. They offer suppositories for the occasional hemorrhoid. They break out their umbrellas when Google has diarrhea.

Every time Google pitches a puny pebble into the placid pond of SEO, the ensuing ripples can seem like tidal waves to an SEO CEO. If Google makes a tiny adjustment to the way it does business, a complacent SEOer might go bankrupt. To provide an extra security blanket, there's a whole additional layer of SEO practitioners, the SEO Consultants. An SEOcon makes his living by watching Google closely, while analyzing the speeches, blogs, and public pronouncements of Google insiders. The SEOcon then sells his analyses to other SEO geeks via pricey newsletters and books. Some of those books sell for many hundreds of dollars. Good bullpucky ain't cheap.

***

So the primary objective in SEO today is to figure out what Google is thinking and how it operates. Some companies try to discover how a competitor's widget works through reverse engineering. They take apart the widget and analyze its technological principles, attempting to duplicate its function without infringing any copyrights. Some companies turn computer hackers loose on a competitor's system, to discover vulnerabilities they can exploit.

And some companies try to hack Google.

Most reputable firms want to avoid, as much as possible, paying for ads on search engine results pages. They want their websites to appear near the top of those results pages in a natural way... "organically." But good "organic" search results are not as chock-full of healthy goodness as the word might imply. To get a high organic ranking, companies usually try to spam the search engines. They pay an SEOer to put their spammy "keyword-rich" pages on inventory websites. They pay the SEOer to hire spam-generating Pakistanis. They pay the SEOer for "backlink boosting."

By the way, doesn't "Backlink Boosting" sound like a great title for gay porn?

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Alan,
Great, informative article with hilarious commentary.
Julie
If you already know my name, it's easy to find me.

Which was pretty much true before the Internet.

It is immensely annoying to me that if you only know my not-very-common last name, my Uncle Art is above me in page rank. My Uncle Art probably doesn't even have an email address.

But he played for the Yankees in the '50s.
Good information!

How does one find out what their site's Page Rank is? I need to know who I can invite to parties or whether I'll be shunned.
It is immensely annoying to me that if you only know my not-very-common last name, my Uncle Art is above me in page rank.

Huh. I'm outranked by a California vineyard (owned by relatives on my father's side) and a Louisiana high school marching band.

Though entertainingly enough I'm not the only person with my name, as unusual as the last name is. (My wife is unique in that regard, as it happens.) I've gotten email congratulating me on being the most famous Rob St. Amant on the Internet.
Well I don't normally do this but I had to sign up because everything you said is more or less wrong. I will start from the beginning. Real SEOs do not use comment spam or forum spam for link development. First of all it is annoying and secondly it is worthless. If the blogs or forums do not use nofollow the links from those sources is totally devalued and worthless to all of the major search engines. Sure you can hire outsourced spammers but they are not SEOs (even if they call themselves SEOs).

Now on to your description of an SEO firm.

(1) If you talk to an SEO CEO who actually uses phrases like "keyword density" and considers it important you should run the other way. You should look for an SEO firm who will explain their methodology in a way that you can understand. If they try to dazzle you with obscure nomenclature and buzz words they are masking what they do and are probably not trustworthy.

(2) I am over 30 and have been doing SEO for around 10 years now. While it is true that SEO is a youthful industry their are plenty of practicioners in their 30's, 40's, and 50's.

(3) You are correct that you should look for SEOs who practice white hat SEO. Unless of course you are in a churn and burn industry like porn, poker, or pills where instant results can yield enourmous profits. If you are establishing a long term business you should work with ethical SEOs and they should not try to scare you. They should explain their methods and how they comply with the major search engine guidelines.

(4 & 5) Keyword research is extremely important. Sure, you can see what terms people are using to find your site through log files but that only tells half of the story. You could be targeting keywords with very low search volume and missing out on traffic from keywords on which the majority of your target audience is searching. Not conducting keyword research could be the difference between a few hundred visitors and thousands of paying customers.

(6) Article sites are worthless anymore. Sure they used to work but they are totally devalued now. Qualified SEOs will look at your analytics, log files, keyword research, and competition to provide advice on new content ideas for your own website.

(7) Qualified SEOs do not use link farms or a network of sites to drive links to your site. Sure, shady SEOs may do this but the majority of professional SEOs help you develop natural and editorial links through the development of quality content, publicity, and generally making your site more link worthy.

(8) I have been doing SEO for nearly 10 years and have never heard of "backlink boosting". If you hear that phrase run the other way.

Oh, and to your next point, SEO was around a long time before Google. When the first search engine came online SEO was born. Google changed the game with their Page Rank (BackRub) algorithm but SEO had been around long before that. And real SEOs know that the green pixels that show "Page Rank" in your Google toolbar are a worthless metric. Real Page Rank is only seen inside the Googleplex. It is updated daily and is much more complex calculation than the simplified, outdated, and meaningless Page Rank everyone else sees.

The primary objective of an SEO is to create useful sites for search engines and users. That means developing relevant content and making sure the site is easily crawlable so the content is accessible for search engines. Spammers try to game search engines to get their low quality pages to the top while SEOs work to get high quality sites ranked above these low quality spammers.
NB: author tags include "humor," "satire" and "comedy." I guess it wasn't clear. But the article *is* based on my experiences with a particular SEO firm. Sleazy bastards. And here's a site for determining one's PageRank: www.prchecker.info Enjoy! (According to them, salon.com is PR8.)
Yeah, that's why I hesitate to make comments like that. Believe me, I hate sleazy SEO firms more than anyone else. It just gives us all a bad name. Sorry for being so serious but it gets me riled up.
That was a good read, and is reflective of all that is Bad in the SEO industry! Like Mark Pilatowski I couldn't help but sign-up to respond.

Agree with all his points, how I like to differ myself is by educating the clients. By holding their hands through the process, educating them on how search engines work, the importance of identifying keywords their server logs DON'T contain, and then tracking how their site performs through analytics.

Once customers can understand what is involved, and the benefits to their business, especially from an advertising cost perspective then they are normally happy to go ahead.

Great article though, and helps give me peace of mind knowing that I am trying to be very White Hat :)