Alice's Looking Glass

(Mad Clatters)
Editor’s Pick
OCTOBER 11, 2008 7:08PM

Opposite of Arab?: "Decent Family Man"

Rate: 24 Flag

 

If you saw the clip of John McCain defending Barack Obama during one of his town hall meetings, you know what I'm talking about. A woman who could not quite put a sentence together (no, not Sarah Palin) said that she "couldn't trust Obama," and then went to say she'd read about him, but mostly stammered until she finally came out with it: "He's an Arab." And what was great was that McCain immediately shook his head, grabbed the microphone back and said, "No. He's a decent family man..." and then noted that they simply disagreed on the issues. But the point is, ladies and gentleman, HE IS NOT AN ARAB!! Phew. Thank God for that. It's one thing to have an African American president -- but an Arab American President? Don't worry -- it'll never happen.  Arab and terrorist have, of course, become synonymous.  Nevermind that the "terrorist" in question in the recent Republican attacks was Bill Ayres, a U.S. citizen (and a waspy one at that).  Arab is now the opposite of American, mom, apple pie, and everything decent in the world. No small wonder that the most successful underground (and not so underground) smear against Obama has been the rumor that he is a secret Muslim. My mother's family immigrated to the U.S. from Syria. They were Christian; they spoke Arabic at home when my mom was growing up, but they assimilated quickly. Now, I notice that many in my extended family do not mention that heritage. And I wonder about friends we have who have come more recently from the Middle East -- those whose accents and last names are recognizably Arab. For myself and other second and third generation Americans with Arabs in their closets, it's easy to pass. But what is it really like to be an Arab in America now, and will it be better under President Obama?

 

Author tags:

mccain, obama, politics, arab

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Wow...it's incredible how many people believe the Muslim/Arab stuff being spread around.
For some reason, most of the "angry people" shown on video, such as that woman in the red t-shirt, are elderly. I don't want to generalize, but if they're anything like my mother and her husband -- both of whom are in their 80s -- I'm not surprised that they're willing to believe the "Arab" and "socialist" stuff.
I didn't see your great post but happened to write about the same subject. I wonder how this "gaffe" on his part will be received by the main stream media?
My daughter just made EXACTLY the same point. We were both pleased to see someone address this.

Thanks.
agree. McCain has gotten himself in a pretty pickle - it would have taken a 10 minute solliquoy to counter all the many ways in which this woman was wrong. A better orator might have been able to turn the opportunity into a demonstration of leadership via character, but McCain isn't that man, no matter how often he says he is.
I wonder how the rest of the world is viewing this and all the negative shout outs? She's just a fluke? Typical Republican? Typical American? Yikes. Just what we freaking need.
I just saw this post...like others here, I commented on the same elsewhere, specifically the "Obama Stomps Out Flames?" post. It's interesting to me that many of the pundits are simply saying that McCain called Obama a decent family man and asked for his supporters to be respectful. Do these pundits actually listen to what people say? Clearly not.
Thanks everyone for all the great comments. (and sorry for the mistakes -- did this one in a hurry!). Stellaa - that's interesting about these people possibly being plants. I'm kind of a conspiracy theorist myself when it comes to Repub smear tactics -- they certainly are doing the good cop -bad cop thing at least.

Sandra - I agree that it's too little too late from McCain. Just repeating that you're a man of character doesn't make it so.

And yes, Chris. I feel like the "anger" is generalized in the media and that more could be done to address what' actually being said, since I think it's revealing.

Roger - I will check out your post -- thanks!
People interested in this issue -- check out roger fallihee's post on same topic. Some really interesting stats there.
One hopes things will get better in this area under Obama. I envision him emptying Gitmo and shutting it down.

It still surprises me how many people will not only openly admit to their prejudice against people from the Middle East, but will actually spend a fair amount of time trying to convince me that they aren't racist, despite their views.
"The Muslim community in America needs to work a lot harder to prove to us they aren't terrorists." One person said to me, "But you don't ever hear them denouncing the attacks of 9/11."
Well, not if you watch Fox "News", jackass.

Okay, enough spleen.
Good post!
Please help with asking Saturday Night Live to refuse to have Sarah Palin as a guest until she publicly decries and denounces those who are doing the "kill him" shouts:

http://open.salon.com/content.php?cid=27262
I agree. I think these folks are plants, and the idea is for McCain to look noble in order to offset the hatemongering going on at rallies where Palin is the chief speaker.

Furthermore, the fact that McCain's use of "decent family man" in opposition to "Arab" does indeed show his true colors.

The 21st century is no time for small-minded bigotry of any kind in the White House.
I was very disappointed to learn that TWO of my friends will probably vote for McCain because they know that “Obama is a Muslim.”

I have always liked Obama, and I was going to vote for him from when he first announced his candidacy. But the more I see these smear tactics and horrid racism - even racism from people who I would have never suspected of being racist - the more I want Obama to win this. Just so these people will be forced to deal with it. (Hopefully most of them will then just get over it.)

It’s time.
I thought the same straight away! Let me get this straight--the new definition of Arab is "antonym to decent family man"? I appreciate what McCain was attempting to say, but this type of gaffe is as telling as a Freudian slip, and will most likely cost him ninety-five percent of the votes in Dearborn, Michigan.
what is it really like to be an Arab in America now, and will it be better under President Obama?

Just guessing here, but I believe it's easier to be an Arab than it is to be a black man in America now, and it will become only marginally easier to be either, if it gets easier at all, under President Obama.
I don't think she was a plant. I watched this clip over and over again last night when I first became aware of it. All my senses tell me McCain is genuine here. I realize that's beside the Arab point, but honestly, one thing at a time. He (and we) knew what she meant, and he had to address that first. Sure, he should have found a way to then say, "And, by the way, so what if he WERE Arab?" But that would have been way too off track. Seriously, I'm not that into defending John McCain; I just think he finally came to his senses a little bit here, finally saw what others had been saying the day or two prior and realized, with a combination of enlightenment and obligation, "I've got to nip this in the bud, like, right now."
I am an Arab-American and was totally offended first by this ignorant woman that is "scared of Obama because he's an Arab" than by McCain because he only tried to reassure he that he's not an Arab. When is being an ARAB such a bad thing. Yes,there are those arabs that are bad but there are also white people that are bad, and those from other races who have chosen the wrong path . Yesterday my daughter cried and asked me "why do they hate us." My family, as many arab families are hard working, tax paying citizens in this country and deserve the same respect given to any american. The hatred that continues to plague this country needs to stop and that needs to begin with our elected officials who seem to be the ones inciting it this time. What happened to freedom of race and religion? For the record the arab men in my life are decent hard working, tax paying Muslims. My grandfather who was a decent arab man was in the U.S. Military. We are Americans who are also Arabs and very proud to be both.
I noticed it immediately. The Arabs have replaced the Russians as the "bad guys" in American culture. Be proud of your heritage. The Arabs gave the world algebra. Anti-Arab feeling has been around for over thirty years. Imagine if the woman had said "He's an Irishman..." or some other nationality, religion, take your pick! Lame McCain missed an opportunity to discuss xenophobia.
There was a "plant" at the rally in Wisconsin -- a nice looking African American man who looked uncomfortable in wrailing against Obama. He did it all the same -- as far as I could see, he was the only person of color in the room.

I do not think the woman in Davenport was a plant. For me, she is no different than the woman that does the facials at my beauty parlor, or one of my co-workers...they are all afraid of an Obama Presidency.

Black Man = fear or
Biracial Man = fear >>
Racist fears

Arab = Fear or
Muslim = Fear and
Foreign sounding name = fear >>
Terrorist fears

Racist fears + Terrorist fears and
Economic fears>>>
Overwhelming fear of the future

Overwhelming fear of the future reinforced by the Republicans and Fox News, and not sufficiently debunked by the MSM or perhaps other Democrats beside Obama (there's a thought?) is whippping the misinformed masses into a frenzy.

The fires of the fears of the masses are being fueled and fanned by the Republicans. I think McCain now knows the seriousness of their actions. Since I believe Palin is being paid for her hatchet job, something BIG and unRovian would have to come down to make her stop.

Fearful Republicans => Fearful Democrats >>>
A country in unceasing turmoil that can only come to a head on election day...
i believe the problem lies in a simple confusion. anyone who has understood the history of the "turks" can easily see their threat to any other government or way of life that stands in their way. (ie. or any other group of people that raided to promote their way of life. hmmmm....sounds familiar.....) just read history. it's just business as usual. unfortuanetly, the arab community has been lumped together in such atrocities and are made to pay the price. it blows my mind that racism and fear can prevail in so many minds. when, if ever, will people wake up and blame wrong actions per se, and not an entire people? that's obviously way too much to ask. it's easier for most people to stay in their bubble and point fingers. i believe the solution lies in correcting wrong action, becoming accountable, and quit being afraid of your freakin neighbor for heaven's sake. we are all human.
Eva - thanks for your comments. It is nice to hear from real Arab Americans -- we need more of that in the media. Lonnie - I definitely would not directly compare the experience of Arabs with that of blacks in America. I don't think those comparisons make much sense. Although I remember that Whoopi Goldberg had a sitcom a few years back with an Arab comedian co-starring, and lots of political cracks. It was interesting. I agree, Sue, that it will be nice to see folks with acknowledged or unacknowledged racist "fears" about Obama have to get used to President Obama. I've heard people I know say they are "afraid" of Obama -- and they won't hear the notion that this might have something to do with race. As for McCain's good intentions - I don't doubt that he is uncomfortable with these outbursts, but let's face it, he's running the campaign he's running. Can't shake hands with the devil and say you're only kidding...but I think these outbursts are important because they give voice to a lot of the things people are thinking out there. Is the result to reinforce those fears? Or maybe to act as therapy and get them out of the (our) system?
I'm a white guy of Christian faith tradition who has spent a bit of time with Arabs and Moslems. I have been accepted as an honored guest at a local Islamic center. So, I can share, albeit in a small way, your concern. As a man who listens for White People Code, I also strongly suspect that the Arab-Moslem thing is contrived as a substitute for calling Obama a n-----. It's become an accepted bigotry.

I blame Bush for stoking the Arab hate by deliberately failing to discern between the secular Saddam and the religious fanatics who attacked the USA on Sept. 11 "Strike back at the Arabs. They attacked us." It's sick, wrong and sinful, and I pray with my Moslem cousins for a reckonning and correction in this country.
I am a colored Judeo-Christian and proud of my roots. If a christian does horrible things to our religion, I speak against them. The problem with the Arab americans is that they don't get up and speak out against the islamic radicals that have infested this world. Instead, they sit in mosques and sidewalks in our country and talk badly against the american people. I am from Florida and we have a very large muslim community, and many are my friends. But, we don't talk politics or religion because they hate americans and defend the radicals. This is rooted in from their family. It is a racism that needs to be rooted out if we are to see them in a different light. I admire american muslims who moderate themselves into our WAYS, our customs. If I am to go to Iran, Iraq or other islamic countries, I must apply and respect their customs. Such as bowing down my head in Japan instead of shaking their hands. So if the muslim in american would moderate themselves into our ways and our customs, I believe we can live in harmony instead of hate. Obama is not a muslim. Obama is a radical thug and is giving the Muslim and the Christian a bad name. Period! And if I was Mccain- I would have taken the microphone and said- There is nothing wrong being an Arab. Not the garbage that he stated concerning how great of a family man Obama is- because most of us really know what he was doing a few years ago and families don't do vile things.
So much of the anti-Arab narrative seems to me to be related to the adoption of Israel and its agenda and values by the U.S.

Which implies that Jewish Arabs would be seen as a separate category. Are they?

And Alice, thanks for this post. The divide-by-identity strategy is as pernicious in its U.S. Republican usage as it has been in any other country, and its extreme forms have led to the 194 million people who died by genocide in the 20th century (this figure appeared in a book by Avraham Burg, former speaker of the Israeli parliament. I have neither sought nor found corroboration for it.)
Two thumbs up, and thanks to Easy Wind for linking me. I noticed this too. And to some of my fellow Jews, who may be enjoying this general atmosphere - remember your history, brothers and sister. Arabs may be the scapegoat flavor of the month in America right now, but we yids got market share that'll always keep on giving, and the mob needs some variety from time to time...

So I wouldn't be at all happy.
Insanity reigns and Senator McCain says "he's a good family man" but not "he's a Christian." So while there is a supposed "keeping the crowds in check" thing happening, there isn't at all. There is no decency there, only a calculated amount of words so as to appear half decent. And when this particular woman kept saying "I don't trust him" he nodded as though he understood completely, and when she came out with the "Arab" thing he quickly said something - because he has to. And one can say to me "some will never be pleased" but seriously... this is becoming more absurd every day. He is shocked at the Wallace thing. Please!!!!!!!!!! Where do these people come from? Maybe Obama will say something about it because he has to but it's true!!!! Oy vey. Strange times these are.
You might be interested in a interview conducted with the woman in the film above after the event in Minnesota. She, like Jeb, does not believe McCain and instead believes a letter being circulated by McCain volunteers slandering Obama. She received this letter from another volunteer and claims to have sent 400 more out to "people in the phone book". She is obviously very fearful of an Obama win and her conclusions are completely based on these unsubstantiated claims in this letter backed up by the red meat throw out at rallies, especially by Palin and by the distorted TV ads which constitute 100% of McCains campaign advertising . Rumor and distortion incorporated!
Jeb, there are ways to fact check the claims in these emails and letters. Try Google and read a history of Bill Ayres. I did and found he was a terrorist when Obama was 8 and today his associates include the republican governor of S Carolina, Mayor Dailey of Chicago, and one of McCain's biggest donors, staunch republican William Annenberg on whose board both Ayers and Obama and another 170 or so prominent Chicagoans from both the left and right sit and work to make education better. How come only Obama is being called a terrorist here? I think fact checking will calm your fears. Or you can vote based on what amounts to gossip, distortion, innuendo and out right lies.

Here is a link to the interview and its transcript:
http://the-uptake.groups.theuptake.org/en/videogalleryView/id/933/
I am thankful to have found this piece. I have been upset about the implications of McCain's statement. My heart aches for my fellow Americans (as he so loves to say, pretending he knows who we are) who happen to be Arab.
Samantha
Apparently, the only African American at the Wisconsin rally(mentioned in my first comment here) went on CNN to complain that he was being harrassed by other blacks for his statements. He is a radio talk show host on the local station. Who knows?
I remember my German immigrant grandparents, aunts, uncles in the 40's whispering and feeling they needed to stay low as "Americans" made disparaging remarks and worse about our heritage.

Hummmm.
I'm glad you posted this, and wish more of the news anchors would address the same. Just because McCain kind of defended a racist statement with a racist compromise is no reason to hail him like the "Straight Talk Express" is back.

Then again, it isn't exactly surprising. To John McCain, Arab = terrorist. Arab people are just one of the "they's" that want to kill Americans. I think it would have surprised me more if McCain had said something like, "No ma'am, he's not an Arab, nor do you need to distrust Arab people." In fact, I might change my mind a little about how I think McCain views the world.

But then, the politics of fear wouldn't work quite so well if there wasn't an entire racial group we could point the "they" finger at.