Alicia PhD

Alicia PhD
Location
New Hampshire, United States
Birthday
September 08
Bio
Alicia has a PhD in Experimental Pathology and, after having worked in a genetics lab for her dissertation, now edits scientific manuscripts full-time from the comfort of the White Mountains. Alicia is also a writer, contributing health commentary and articles on disease and anatomy to many online publishers. She upkeeps a number of blogs devoted to her interests in public health and science.

MY RECENT POSTS

AUGUST 25, 2010 10:18AM

The two faces of stem cell research

Rate: 2 Flag

 

Janus

 

The Roman god Janus is depicted as two faces, one looking right and one looking left. There is an enzyme named after him, JAK, and January is attributed to be his namesake. The god of doorways....

 I think of the images of Janus whenever I read about the legal battle over stem cell research. Federal funding was restricted under Bush, and then it was reopened (to some extent) by Obama. There are advocates and opponents for both adult and embryonic. And then there's the most opposite of all:

A federal judge placed on injunction on federal spending on stem cell research because a current lawsuit is likely to show that Obama's policy violates a law about destroying embryos in research.  Meanwhile, the FDA has greenlighted the first human trials for embryonic stem cell therapy.

So an embryo (a collection of cells with the potential to be human tissues) is destroyed but an already human life may be saved or given better quality. 

The worst part I think is that the lawsuit trying to prevent federal funding of embryonic stem cell research was brought by two researchers interested in adult stem cells - they argue that by funding embryonic stem cells they won't get money for adult stem cells. It's all about the money! 

Adult stem cells have repeatedly been shown to be both beneficial and not as good (potential-wise) as embryonic stem cells. The problem is that they have markers indicating who and where they come from that makes them limited in their applications. Embryonic stem cells, on the other hand, are like clean slates, if we can only figure out how to program them properly. 

Two sides at battle that really should be working together...much like a face that pulls you in two different directions.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Excellent report, as usual Alicia. This is a subject that has very much interested me. Sadly this injunction comes just as a research lab (sorry, I don't recall who) announced positive response in spinal applications. Yes, it's all about the money and if you ask me a perfect example of how to shoot one's self in the foot.
As long as the mighty buck is involved, ALL research will serve that master.

Good information here Alicia
"they argue that by funding embryonic stem cells they won't get money for adult stem cells."

I didn't know that. Man is that depressing. We need to fund science better in this country. My brother's in physics and he's always writing grant proposals it seems. He hates it and I sympathize. People need to know how important research is and not thwart funding.