The funny thing, the sad thing, is that I know people who had it far worse than I had it. I didn't live in fear. 364 days of the year (365 on leap years) I was a pretty ordinary kid in a family which, while it was stressful in a lot of ways, was no more abusive than most families. It was that 365th day that was the doozy.
This day happened when I was seven years old. It was Saturday night and I had a friend over to spend the night.
Her name was Leanne and she was my white trash friend - she lived in a two bedroom house with her aging parents. Her dad was on disability and her mom ran an unlicensed daycare out of their house for extra money. They had a pet raccoon which lived in a cage. Her house was the first place I ever ate bologna with little flecks in it - bologna and mayo on white bread for dinner, with a side of canned corn. Her dad gave me a Bible tract which taught me that wishing upon a star was idolatry and would make you go to hell.
My house, two blocks away, might as well have been in another world. My dad was an architect and engineer who often traveled to other countries to supervise the startup of new factories. My mom was a college professor. We never ate white bread or things out of cans. We had two show-quality Siamese cats and a Basset Hound who loved me more than life. My parents were technically Episcopalians - my mom had a copy of the Book of Common Prayer which had belonged to her great-grandmother in 1875 - but we rarely went to church except on holidays.
Leanne and I loved each other. We wanted to be sisters. We made up whole worlds together. I think, looking back, that I probably rode rough-shod over her, not physically but mentally, because she let me. Even though she was older, I was the one who decided what we were going to play next. I wrote plays and she acted in them. And that made her happy, and it made me happy.
Her parents were stricter than my parents. She married young, desperate to get away from them. I have her wedding invitation in my treasure box.
It's really the treasure box which is the subject of this post. Did you have one? Mine was red leather lined with white satin and it had originally held a set of miniature silver goblets with the crests of various cities in Italy. I've had it since forever, and a few years ago I pulled it out and went through it, laughing at myself because even then, the things which were important to me were a writer's things. The play I wrote when I was seven. An impassioned essay on women in love written when I was twelve. I wrote about everything, and I kept the things I thought were important.
I kept this, a sheet of unlined paper with jagged block letters, the pencil almost stabbed through the page:
YOU SAY YOU ARE RIGHT BUT YOU ARE NOT RIGHT AND I WILL NOT FORGET,
I WILL NEVER FORGET.
And it's true, I haven't forgotten. I remember exactly what happened, word for word and moment to moment. I was seven then - the date is on the paper.
My family ate in front of the television set. It wasn't that we liked TV - it was that my dad had a temper, and after one too many dinners that turned into fights, my mother decided we were eating in front of the TV from now on. We ate on red plastic trays in the den, which was a 1970's den, wood panelled and three steps down from the kitchen, opening onto the patio. Those trays could be tricky; glasses tended to slide around on them. When I picked mine up that night, I spilled my milk.
My mother yelled at me and said that I hadn't been paying attention because I was showing off for my friend, and I said, "I didn't do it on purpose!"
And my father said, "Don't talk back to your mother," and cuffed me on the side of the head.
Cuff is a word you don't hear too often today. A cuff is not a slap and it's not a punch; it's a solid strike with cupped hand, upside the ear. It makes your ear ring and it knocks you over. I fell over and my father yelled at me to get up. I didn't get up, so he kicked me. I remember scrambling away from him and falling down the short flight of stairs into the den. I remember holding my arms over my head to protect my head while he kicked me in the head. I thought he might kill me but honestly I wasn't afraid; I was sickened and ashamed, because I could see Leanne's pale face, her mouth open in shock, frozen, trying not to do anything that would make it worse. The dog was barking like his heart was going to explode, but he didn't know who to side with.
And then we ate dinner. Sitting silently in front of the TV. We had barbequed pork chops, white rice, squash with bacon, and a salad of fresh summer tomatoes with Italian dressing.
Leanne came from Circumstances, as they say, and so she knew just the right way to be so as not to make me feel bad. She didn't try to comfort me; she knew I was mad as a swatted hornet. She didn't denounce my parents because she knew that tomorrow morning I would still have to live with them. She was calm and quiet. She sat still while I wrote furiously. And then we talked and talked, long after the lights went out and we were supposed to be asleep.
My treasure box contains other similar "treasures" about other similar incidents. One is a poem in which I summon forth a magical prince who will carry me to another planet. There's a written summary of the time when I was 15 and I threatened to call the police after my father gave me a black eye and he pulled the phone cable out of the wall and held a gun on me for two hours in the kitchen while my mother pleaded for calm. There's one a little earlier than that, a letter from my first boyfriend, who noticed me because I was putting on purple eyeshadow, not to hide the purple bruise on my eye but to accent it. Oh yes, I told people, I told and told. And I was told: If you think this is bad, you can't imagine what it's like in foster care. A spoiled, upper-class wimp like you would just die. He only hits you one or twice a year, what do you have to complain about? What do you want me to do, get a divorce? And live off what money? You love him, don't you? After all he's done for you, how could you be so selfish as to want to see your father in jail?
I didn't, for the record. Want to see him in jail. I wanted to see him with my boot on his throat. I wanted him to stop, but more than that, I wanted him to understand. I wanted a really big brother (when I was five, I imagined my big brother was Superman and I loved Superman comics more than anything) who would take my side and stand up to him.
Before he was an engineer, my father was a military man. His career was interesting in that he's one of the few people who's been a noncom, a warrant officer, and a commissioned officer. He has three Bronze stars. He walked down from a mountain in Korea when his unit was stranded behind enemy lines; not too long ago I read an essay about his heroism in that incident in a book of classic war correspondence. He holds an unbreakable world record in competitive shooting - the first to shoot a perfect round in a particular type of competition. He's taller than I am, stronger than I am. When I got a little older I used to fight back, and it was always a tactical error on my part. My mother used to tell me that I wouldn't get hurt so badly if I would just submit, but I never submitted.
I was fifteen the last time he hit me. We were both riding horses. I don't completely remember what my offense was - I think I said something snotty about his riding skills. He lashed out with his crop and hit me across the face. And that was a tactical error on his part - because he may outweigh me by twice but I am the better rider. I broke my riding crop across his thigh, his horse reared and dumped him, and he landed hard on his back on a pointed rock.
I dismounted and tied my horse, caught his horse. Then I went back for him. He was sprawling, confused - his hard hat had come off. He asked me to find his glasses and I kicked them further away. My trainer came out to find out what had happened, and he was taken to the hospital. He had six broken ribs and a mild concussion.
And I was thinking, "Praise Jesus, MOTHERFUCKER!"
The broken ribs made it impossible for him to lift his arm high enough to shave. In the weeks while he was healing, he grew a beard. And with the beard, he grew a new personality. More measured, more thoughtful. He never hit me again. But more to the point, he never tried to interfere in arguments between me and my mother again. He never demanded respect from me as his due.
And, in time, he earned my respect.
Now, here's the part where it's critical that you listen, because I'm going to say something that goes against the common, received wisdom. And every word is true. I've told this story before, and I was told, "Of course a sociopath will stop if he stops getting away with it, people don't change."
But people do change. They really do. It may not happen often, it may not be a good bet - and if you're being abused it's not a bet you should take, because it's your life you're betting - but abusers can change. I've seen it. The man I know today is not the man who kicked me when I was seven. If you had told me back then that today I would pray every night for my father's health and well-being, I wouldn't have believed you. But I do.
My husband has never seen my father angry. He says he can't imagine what would make him lose his temper - he's the wisest, steadiest, most patient person he knows. And that wasn't true, before the beard. My father, before the beard, wasn't just bad tempered with me but bad tempered with everyone. He was cold and hot depending and he once slammed a trunk lid on a guy for insulting his first wife's parking skills. Now he's the man everyone brings disputes to when a reasoned voice is needed.
It was decades before my father and I were able to talk about what had happened. He says he had a blinding flash of insight that day - that if he kept acting the way he acted, no one would love him and it would be all his fault. He says he can't offer any excuse for the way he used to treat me, except that he reacted to me when I was seven the same way he would have reacted if a grown man had insulted him in a bar. He says I got it worse than his other children because he respected me more, because he literally forgot that I was a child.
But I was a child. And I'm telling you, there is nothing on earth that a seven-year-old is capable of doing that deserves to be punished by being kicked in the head.
I'm sorry that it took six broken ribs to give my father a blinding flash of insight. But I'm not sorry I hit him that day. I keep the handle of my riding crop in my treasure chest.
One more thing in my treasure chest that I'm going to tell you about. It's a report card. I went to a school that was using what was called "IGE" which meant Individually Guided Education. The theory was that we didn't have grades, merely plusses and minuses, and that we were allowed to work at our own pace. IGE was not really the most brilliant idea anyone has come up with - like turning a child loose on a buffet and watching them come back with soft serve ice cream and brownies for an entree - and in short order I was reading at a college level and not touching math at all. But that's not what my report card is concerned about. I have all plusses, in fact, and some double-plusses.
It's in the comments section: Allie doesn't do her homework and nothing we can do seems to motivate her.
The report card has a date on it. Of all the things in my treasure box, it was the date that made me start crying at last. It's dated three days after I wrote the angry letter about being kicked in the head.
See, I remember that report card. I remember being called on the carpet and told that if I didn't shape up, I wouldn't be allowed to attend CLUE, the gifted program which was my favorite thing in school. I loved the CLUE teacher and she was so disappointed in me and I stood with tears streaming down my face, and she asked, "Why? Just tell me why you're not doing your homework."
And I said, "I don't know." And I didn't know. I knew that the homework was easy, cheesy, but I felt as if it were a great moral battle, that if I submitted, it would kill my soul.
But I know now. I have the box, and I can look back at the dates, three days apart. There was a little girl back then - she was seven - and her father kicked her in the head and this was her way of resisting.
That battle, that's still with me. I feel it most often when I feel that someone else is trying to make me do something. Sometimes it's putting the dishes in the dishwasher. Sometimes it's getting my driver's license renewed. Sometimes it's something as small as picking up a piece of kleenex that missed the trash can. Something tiny, something doable, that becomes a mountain that feels like it will crush my soul. I spent a lot of years not doing things and not understanding why, but I'm getting better now. I can recognize that feeling when it starts, and say to myself, "You are not seven anymore. You're not oppressed and no one is kicking you. You don't have to fight anymore and there's no one to sabotage but yourself."
It gets easier. Once I recognized my enemy, I could face it, and when I look straight at it, it melts away like mist. I'm glad I kept my treasure box. I have the usual things in there, love notes, pressed flowers - but the other things are treasures too.



Salon.com
Comments
It's lame (I know) but once I heard Dr. Phil say to someone that they would never get respect from demanding it, that respect is commanded not demanded ... i don't know why I remember that ...
Thank you for sharing this heartfelt and beautifully written story.
But I know a woman whose mother sounds a lot like your father, and who, like your dad, woke up one day and changed her whole life so that she stopped abusing her kids.
I'm grateful to you for sharing this.
at the tender age of seven ....you really did know right from wrong, didn't you?
i can't help but wonder what your dads life was like at that same age
can his constant and horrible anger be explained somehow?
rated with great respect and admiration for the allie past and present
Wow....just wow!
Hopefully all of us can bridge our past with the insight, and the scars that never seem to heal bring about a better, more humane person for our childrrens and those we love sakes.
All my best wishes to you, and thanks for sharing your painful memories they sparked mine, and provided insight. Patrick
There's nothing else I can say.
I can't help but wonder if the concussion didn't jar something into place. (Didn't St. Paul fall off a horse, too, and have a historic change of heart??)
Whatever caused it, I believe it. We all hope that bullies will be tossed off their high horses, and you actually accomplished this. Forgiveness, redemption, courage. You deserve a bronze heart. I loved every word.
You start out almost diminishing the seriousness of the abuse, because it was *only* once a year. And yet as the story goes on it is obvious that the abuse was significant, in that it was not minor and that in all the other days of the year you lived with the stress of your father's anger and the possibility that any moment could be the one that tipped him over.
It was surprising that your father changed...really changed. That you set the change in motion is a credit to your not being cowed and submissive. Of course you improved things for yourself by hitting him back, but you also did him a huge favor.
There is something in your defiant resistance...what you demonstrated as a child and in your adult resistance to doing certain things, that resonates with me. I'll have to think about it.
There wasn't a moment of doubt that you would evolve past the brutality and stupidity of a parent who beats a child.
Doesn't mean you did it without being scarred. How you perceived your situation at that age is remarkable. So young, so wise.
p.s. my uncle was one of the Chosin Reseroir survivors. Is that where your dad was? THAT is an amazing story.
Splendid eloquence. All the elements of fine fiction - except for the cruel reality that you suffered it. Irony in the calm civility of your "white trash" friend who witnessed the "refined" life of the upper class. Complexity in your school behavior, finding an outlet for your anger. Climax in the whipping of your father and his injuries; resolution in his redemption.
I circle back around to the point that humans have the choice to change. My Dad saved penny-pinching all his life, as did his father, and most of their generations. Then one day he heard a sermon about letting life pass you by while you save for some rainy day that may not come: and he broke into the fabled college acount. Mind you, I was a year into my bachelor's and my brother ready for his third year and that account was untouched. I'd heard my mother rant about it once. He'd been building a racing trimaran for yeas in the garage that was still a skeleton. He took out enough for 2 years of college, a racing catamaran, a trailer, a heavy duty van to pull it, and a bevy of lavender, pink, and baby blue dress shirts with flamboyantly matching ties and a blue suit. He had always groused about the male of every other species getting to wear the flashy colors while men were doomed to white shirts and grim ties against gray suits.
He changed his life habits in a day. I like to think he was struck by lightning in an existential way. I cling to that possibility in my classroom, hoping that the slacker, the slow learner, the arrogant, the spoiled will one day hear a Sylvia Sermon and walk away changed.
Hope is the thing with wings.
Thanks for a great post.
While I am not physically punitive with my children, I can be extremely unpleasant when I feel they are being willfully disobedient. Like your father I, too, have a tendency to view and speak to my children as if they are adults. That may be good in everyday life as far as fostering independence and growth, but I should know better than to expect that they'll just "get" everything the first time I say it when it comes to disciplinary issues.
So thank you for sharing this story, as painful as it must have been.
Wow, this is me too. A little different story but some similar results. Thank you for sharing yours, it was very well written. I am working up to the day when I can do the same.
Great, heartfelt piece, Allie.
its all there.
you knew
you perservered
you win
I am so happy for you
You saved 2 lives with that riding crop
good work
Rated!!!!
Angus Macflop asked what my dad's life was like at that age and if there was anything that explained his anger. My father spent his childhood with a mother who was bedridden with a chronic illness and died when he was a teenager. His own father was strict and a believer in switches. Yes, I can definitely see where this would come from. And I think there was an element of PTSD involved; some of his military stories are hair-raising.
As for "white trash," I could have prettified my language - which I knew would be offensive to some - but that's how Leanne would describe herself, and how everyone I grew up with would have described her family. And trust me, she would be laughing while she said it. I've lost touch with her recently but we stayed in touch for a long time; subject for another post.
wow.
Gripping from start to finish. I'm happy for your present. Thanks for sharing this.
" trying not to do anything that would make it worse" especially - talk about an ephemeral art form.
I was from a white trash family, though my mother wouldn't have given us such a dinner as that bologna sandwich, she liked to cook. You don't know you're white trash as a kid, you just realize other folks have an opinion about your family. Your portrait of your friend Leanne and her social skills, well it's heartbreaking. No one should have to try so hard, but some of us do. I still have memories of a similar kindness at about the same age.
Congratulations on EP & FP exposure for this well told tale and your wise insight into the human heart.
rated.
You wrote "Something tiny, something doable, that becomes a mountain that feels like it will crush my soul." This explains his stubbornness and inability to make decisions so well. Your entire post is so.......... brilliant and self-aware are the only words to describe it. Thank you for this. I may need to email this to him, as he's in a lot of pain still.
David
Well written and insightful. I don;t what else to say. Beautiful. Rated.
I've been planning to write about my childhood for a while, but it was a post by idahospud that gave me the insight that helped me tie everything together. He wrote about self-sabotage, and the reasons for it.
I should probably confess that the tragic look on my face is because my mom got my hair cut so short. I had very long hair and I was proud of it, and she talked me into a shorter cut because "It will be cute." It will be cute is mom-speak for "I'm sick of shampooing all that hair!" if you didn't know. I thought I looked like a boy!
It's really scary if you think about it how many children go through something similar. Just read through the comments... Now look at your kid's school class. Statistically, 1 in 4 children will be physically abused at some point badly enough to require an emergency room visit. And you've got to figure there are a lot of kids getting beaten but not taken to the ER. Which of the kids your kid plays with are going home to this? It's too common and we need to find some answers.
Patrick Daniels, alsoknownas, I'm so glad you won your battles. Sorry you had to fight them in the first place though.
SeattleK8, yeah, I guess you could say that was my dad's Road to Damascus moment. But although I had a hand in his falling off the horse, I can't claim credit for his decision to become a better person afterward.
Kitehlips, yep, Chosin Reservoir. Most of the troops at Chosin were Marines (and they withdrew in an organized fashion) but my dad was Army, which did not.
Bunglermoose, you absolutely made my day - thinking that I might have helped someone to be a better parent is more than I could have hoped for. It's all too easy for parents to get caught up in a battle of wills with their children - forgetting how one sided the power is in such a struggle. Someone's got to be the grown-up and calm down first, and it's not reasonable to expect it to be the kid! Thank you for commenting and I wish your family all the best.
Susanne - Leanne was one in a million. She went through hell of her own, but her story has a happy ending too! Maybe I'll write about her next.
About forgiveness: I think all people long to forgive. Forgiving feels good. But it's much easier to forgive when the person who wronged you really understands and has changed. I was talking to my husband about this, and he said, "It's as though the person your dad was then doesn't exist anymore." And in a sense that's true. My father is not religious, but in a real sense he has been born again. He remade himself. And it doesn't make sense to me to be angry at this person for what that other person did.
Conversely, I think I would have a really tough time forgiving him if he hadn't changed. I know I have a hard time forgiving my mother, who still doesn't understand that her complicity in his abuse was wrong. And I can't find it in myself to tell any other person what they should or should not forgive.
Thank you all again.
What a sad story. Sociopaths are very clever and abusers in general and sexual abusers in particular very rarely change (at least, I've never encountered one who did.) I hope my post doesn't mislead anyone into thinking that's not true.
-Holy crap, I think I dated that girl!
I actually found the ending the most compelling part - your ability to understand (and try to deal with) your need to resist doing something that someone else wants you to do. When you were a child, it was actually a well-chosen coping mechanism, one of the few available to you. You may have saved yourself by opting to resist this way. And you have helped me understand some of the behaviors of someone in my life who had a highly controlling father, and I thank you for that, very much.
Judging by your picture, you are about my age, and I had a dress just like that and a haircut to match.
Rated for incredible insight and self-awareness.
That battle, that's still with me. I feel it most often when I feel that someone else is trying to make me do something. Sometimes it's putting the dishes in the dishwasher. Sometimes it's getting my driver's license renewed. Sometimes it's something as small as picking up a piece of kleenex that missed the trash can. Something tiny, something doable, that becomes a mountain that feels like it will crush my soul. I spent a lot of years not doing things and not understanding why, but I'm getting better now. I can recognize that feeling when it starts, and say to myself, "You are not seven anymore. You're not oppressed and no one is kicking you. You don't have to fight anymore and there's no one to sabotage but yourself."
it was a real "a-ha" moment for me. I can't do things. Lots of things. I know I'm only sabataging myself. I grew up in a similarily fucked up home. I've made the connection to how I grew up in general, but how you were able to make the connection so clearly because of the dated contents of your treasure box is wonderful. Because you were able to connect the dots, you're now healing and moving past this . . . this incompacity . . . paralyzation . . . And because you wrote about it, maybe I will start to do the same.
Thank you. A million thank yous. Rated.