Humdrum Star

being, rather than seeming to be

amittaizero

amittaizero
Location
United States
Birthday
January 22
Bio
Addled spew of a classical liberal pacifist freethinker born and raised in the south. A "never lived up to his potential" student who is now a high school teacher. A limited-in-stature skinny-as-a-rail nerd-o of 25 years. Of English/Welsh?/Cherokee?/African/dubious heritage. Massive sideburns (mutton or otherwise) are a man's best friend. No shaving here. Don't expect Billy Collins. Think of C.D. Wright after Billy Collins donated a smidgeon of his life-force to her. Then, of course, think of a guy. I use dashes and ellipsis...a lot - a lot. Oh, and the name... "Who are we? We find that we live on an insignificant planet of a humdrum star lost in a galaxy tucked away in some forgotten corner of a universe in which there are far more galaxies than people." ~ Carl Sagan

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
NOVEMBER 20, 2009 10:31AM

An Illicit Affair with YHWH, Death & Doubt

Rate: 18 Flag

Two of my students are pregnant.  An acquaintance of mine just had a miscarriage.  A relative has recently attempted suicide – twice.  I just found out that one of my ancestors may have been murdered.

 

Life.  Death. Hmm.

 

I never really believed in Santa Claus.

 

 “Around the world in one night?”  I ask my mother as we sit by a globe. 

“Yes, to all the children in the world,” she smiles. 

That sounds impossible." 

As a child being raised by Christian parents I was horrified at the prospect of death and an eternal life in heaven.  It was meant to be a consolation, but it frightened me.  My parents were bewildered and upset by this bizarre perspective I had somehow developed.  Around age 8, for a period of about 6-months, I could not stop cycling a small voice in my head that repeated, “I hate God.  I hate God.  I hate God.”  My parents told me that it was the devil trying to influence me.  Eventually it stopped.

 

My condition worsened as I grew into a teenager – I was petrified by a fear of death and the ever-after that I was told would be my reward for other types of fear.  I have never been a “fun” person to be around, but in high school I was a pure, undiluted black fog that clung to the walls.  This was not due entirely to religious issues but to various neurological afflictions as well (though I suppose you could label my former faith as such).  My faith was never incredibly deep, but it was there, and no matter how devout someone may be he still has to deal with the dogmas of the faith he professes.  My dogmas involved heaven and hell, but I was equally afraid of both.

 

In 2002 my uncle, a long time drug-addict and mentally ill, finally commits the suicide he's been attempting for so long. 

Someone says, “He’s probably in hell, you know.” 

That was cute. 

I met my wife in college and married her in the spring semester of our senior year.  We are still married.

 

I met someone else in my senior year of college though.  I began to steal away to the library on campus in between classes.  I couldn’t let my girlfriend know what I was doing.  I would jog up to the second floor and wind around to a wooden table that sat by a massive window-wall.  As the snow or rain ran parallel over the outstretched mountains outside I would pull a small piece of paper out of my backpack – it was littered with a series of hastily etched digits:

 

p. 22

p. 45
p. 67

 

The list went on.

 

Why Atheism? by George H. Smith.  I wouldn’t dare check the book out, so I returned everyday to it and pulled it off the shelf, read a few pages and put it back.  I felt like I was having an affair – but I suppose it was only an affair with my own mind.

 

Christian-lite.

 

Deist.

 

Agnostic.

 

Atheist.

 

That was the progression.  It took about a month.  It was beautiful and easy – my brain was alive – buzzing with the possibility that I had nothing to worry about.  The little doubts I’d always carried were finally turning into something that resembled the person they resided in.

 

Fear.  That was it.  The fear of Hell kept me in the faith and the fear of Heaven kept me in a dandy of a theological mess. 

 

My wife didn’t find out that I had abandoned our shared faith until after we were married.  That was wrong of me.  But she’s still here and I’m glad.

 

So now what do I do?

 

 “What do you think it will be like when you die, then?” 

I look at my wife, “Like it was before I was born, I guess.” 

My father believes in the idea that a person “once saved is always saved” - so he thinks he’ll meet me in Heaven despite the fact that I’m a nonbeliever.  If that’s what comforts him, then let him have that.

 

“What would you do if God appeared to you? What would you do if God showed up right in front of you?” 

It’s a sincere question that a relative asks. 

“Which god?” 

After Carl Sagan’s death rumors abounded that he had converted shortly before he passed away.  He realized in the last hour of his life that he was wrong about many things, primarily regarding religion.  These stories of miraculous conversion of a nasty nonbeliever at death run rampant in our society.  The dominant religion gets their “win” without ever having to prove it and the credulously inclined among us carry it with them as a trump card when they encounter the ilk of the “foolish”.  (Sagan's wife Annie Druyan vehemently denies these rumors)

 

 “If a religious official shows up to perform my funeral service I’m going to break some rules of nature and come haunt the bastard,” I tell someone. 

My wife jokes that when we’re buried she’ll have a Celtic cross over her grave and that I’ll have a beaver or some other silly looking animal.  I actually like the notion – perhaps the Oregon State mascot but a little more mellow, eyeing the delicious faux-wood of the crucifix that sits over my wife.


Let me also leave you with this little gem from Annie Druyan, wife of Carl Sagan and genius in her own right:

"I remember that one time Carl was giving a talk, and he spelled out, in a kind of withering succession, these great theories of demotion that science has dealt us, all of the ways in which science is telling us we are not who we would like to believe we are. At the end of it, a young man came up to him and he said: 'What do you give us in return? Now that you've taken everything from us? What meaning is left, if everything that I've been taught since I was a child turns out to be untrue?' Carl looked at him and said, 'Do something meaningful.'"

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Faith as a neurological affliction!

I find my lack of belief to be very freeing. When people ask me, "What, then is the point of life?", I reply that there is no point. They accuse me of being a nihilist. I think life is completely what we make it, and I think that is a far cry from nihilism. Because there is no after-life, I think we have to do our best in the here and now. To those people who say that atheists have no moral compass, I would ask why it takes the threat of hell to get them to behave.

I hadn't heard those stories about Carl Sagan. I don't believe them. (I need to go back and read "The Demon Haunted World"!)
I want to believe, but I don't know what to believe. Science and faith are at war in me. But there are worse things to believe than "do something meaningful."
@ Jeanette DeMain: I think humans are obsessed with there being a "Point" to life - there has to be a predetermined and intelligent reason for our being here. I can see the emotional value of that in some ways but of course it will take more than emotional need and faith to make me believe (much less worship) a deity. Honestly, even if the god of the Abrahamic faiths revealed itself to me I would still refuse to worship it - genocidal maniacs are not appealing leaders.

@ The Good Daughter: I don't think it's so much a question of believing as it is of a new way of approaching ideas. The important thing to remember is that "atheism" is not an organization, social structure or religion - it's an adjective used to describe someone who does not possess a theistic belief. It goes only that far. I don't "believe" in science, I simply prefer the answers that it as a process generates as opposed to those of mysticism. Science is not a thing or a group of people - it's a method of discovery, nothing more. But it's the best chance we have for uncovering the mysteries of the universe, at least in my opinion.
I'm a Roman Catholic who has a pretty good chance of going to hell--no seriously, I believe it--and I don't really feel it's unjust, considering some of the things I've done so far in life. All I'm really concerned about, to be honest, is that, according to most fundamentalists I've heard from (and I'm definitely not one of those), that's where Richard Dawkins is going, too. Eternity with a great evolutionary biologist is one thing; evolution with an ignorant theological bore is quite another. I'm terribly worried that in Hades, the latter is all Professor Dawkins will be.

So that's really the only thing that's keeping me even vaguely on the straight-and-narrow from time to time. Then I think of how good the chances probably are that Terry Eagleton's going to hell, too, and I feel better. I could definitely hang around with him for millenia. He might even manage to shut Dawkins up from time to time.
Oh I dunno, Dewy. If I could watch Eagleton and Dawkins fight it out, hell probably wouldn't be so bad.

Amitaizero, I totally appreciate that atheism is more your neurological style--and increasingly I believe that this is far more a factor in faith than the actual existence or non-existence of God. Myself I'm a fairly happy agnostic.

But I think it's naive in this day and age to say that atheism isn't organized. We live in a secular society--and I'm all for that--but I've seen too many intolerant atheists ganging up in academia these days to think that this continues to be a persecuted minority.

Other than that, I'm happy that you've found peace.
@ Juliet Waters: Terminology is such a funny thing. I look at it this way (which may sound strange): personally, in opinion and in worldview, I am an atheist. I recognize no deities or superstitions and am not holding my breath for evidence. Objectively, and where objective debate and science is concerned, I can be nothing but agnostic. Not in that I think if a deity existed that it would be unknowable but in that I withhold judgment until massive piles of solid evidence pelt us from the heavens.

As for organization, you do have a point. Humans are, as we know, social creatures and like is attracted to like. I can understand the desire to want to be around other people who share the same worldview. I don’t think atheist have been a “persecuted” minority for quite some time, but they are most certainly a heavily mistrusted and maligned minority. Thanks for your comment!
I have struggled with the meaning of life since I was young and though I do believe in God and have faith, I still have angst about the endlessness that life after death presents. After my father died, I felt a connection to him that would not make sense to me if there were no higher being. Seeing the sun rise and set every day proves to me that there must be something that created all of this--after all, everything comes from something. But I appreciate an atheist's struggles and difficulty in believing in a deity and in life after death. It's a topic that will forever be unsettled.
How I loved Carl Sagan! I plant myself firmly in his (and your) camp. Religious faith developed as an explanation for the unexplainable and as a method for controlling the masses. Power/money/religion, that's the true triumvirate.
@ Karin Greenberg: Thanks for your comment. I wouldn't dare pretend that I always felt that what I believed in was bogus - it was certainly a struggle. I think certain people can more easily accomodate religious belief than others and I'm certainly not one of them. I'm much happier with life now that I got rid of all that excess stuff that I didn't need. I'm sorry for the loss of your father but I'm glad that you've found some consolation. I would never dare try to judge you for that.

@ Ablonde: I can't help but be in awe of Carl Sagan's amazing clarity and compassion. There are so many different motivations behind religious belief - and I certainly don't discount that the ones you listed. I think someday we may all outgrow it - but it won't and can't happen overnight.
This is wonderfully engaging, entertaining, and (damn, I need another e here . . . ) ergonomic? No, I'll go with educational . . . in the sense that your description of your process, including influences, is inspiring. (ok, I'd better stop before the alliteration kills us all)

Bottom line, I like the way you write, and the way you think.
When I freed my mind of the Heaven & Hell question, it felt like such a relief -- I've always known that it was right for me based on that lightness. "undiluted black fog that clung to the walls" is brilliant.
@ Owl_Says_Who: You are too kind. I suppose I wouldn't mind being ergonomic though I'm not sure what that would look like. As a person who lives for thinking and writing there is no higher compliment than when you wrote that you like my approach to both. Thank you.

@ skeletnwmn: I'm a melancholy person by nature so adding notions of Heaven and Hell turned me into a morbid little monster. Don't get me wrong though - every now and then I did find comfort in the thought of a "higher being" but it wasn't enough - I am much happier now that I've abandoned the long train of mysticism that has covered the face of humanity. My happy thoughts now are sharp, concrete and delightfully grounded in the real.
Well, if God appeared to me, I 'd start believing in him. Until then, I find the concept dubious, at best.

I don't know how the world began. But if there was a Creator, where did he come from? But the idea that a benevolent God is looking out for the human race (or just the faithful) and cares what we do? It just doesn't make sense, given the way the world is.
Do something meaningful! duh, as if we need to be told this. But we do. Oh yes, we do, over and over and over again. In temples we hear it best, so there's where we hear it, be they rounded or square, open or closed, online or in print or oral or F2F, decorated with crucifixes or beavers, linga or yoni, monkeys or elephants, buddha or christ or calligraphy.

Do something meaningful -- thanks for reminding me!
I find comfort in the biosphere. Finding meaning? The myriad connections between non-living cycles of water and stone and innumerable living creatures, who in turn are all connected to each other...that's more than enough for me. I get awe, peace, connection and meaning all at once...if anything is worthy of worship, the biosphere is.
The idea of living my whole life under the eyes of some god who was going to either punish me by sending me to hell or pat me on the head and take me to heaven for being good was simply exhausting.

I was rigid, terrified and convinced I was going to hell all through middle school and junior high. In high school I accepted my fate, and by college I decided religion had killed god.

Now, I feel extremely peaceful. I am accountable to myself, and frankly, I have to live in my own head and that's far more terrifying than a fiery pit.
An interfaith or multiple faith marriage is a civilized marriage- Bravo for you and your wife-Best to you both.

We came from the trees. Period. We developed from a common ape ancestor, some hominids became humans, our cousins became the great apes and the Neandertal stuck it out as long as they could.

Does a great spirit re-incarnate every time a monkey dies? If so, there's a heaven, if not, we die just like dogs. Monotheism used to be wisdom, ashes to ashes ...

My (GOD) its nothing to get a fright over! Unless you didn't study science and math in school, then you are pretty much useless now. Bummer. Metaphysics had a beginning and an end, god was dead, then came the big bang and the bubble- and actual religious conundrum based on observational FACTS!

hahahahahahahaha when we die we dont go to heaven oh crap.
Christmas..Oh boy..... let's see - I told my kids that St. Nicholas is a saint and exists for believers of our ilk of Christianity and is present with all believers of all time (the communion of saints) - so of course he's real. The rest of the junk is pagan nonsense - but a lot of fun and an opportunity to remember people who need that.

Fraud in Marriage - Some christian groups take the New Testament seriously that if a Christian marries a non-Christian, the Christian is not free to leave as to do so might harm the non-Christian's receptiveness to God. So lucky you if she's that type of Christian.

Suicide - Hard to believe that a loving God would punish a mentally ill person for ending his/her life. Here on earth, we even excuse the mentally ill from responsibility for murder

What if everything I believe is untrue? - CS Lewis said that he'd rather life a life guided by the same beliefs even if and maybe even especially if they are untrue- so he'd live his life the same way. I agree, but I might stop giving money to the Church and blush a little when I praised myself (God).