AmyTuteurMD

AmyTuteurMD
Bio
Dr. Amy Tuteur is an obstetrician-gynecologist. She received her undergraduate degree from Harvard College and her medical degree from Boston University School of Medicine. Dr. Tuteur is a former clinical instructor at Harvard Medical School.

JANUARY 22, 2009 8:28PM

Death by sandwich, a medical mystery

Rate: 6 Flag

  sandwich

Over a decade ago, a then 15 year old girl began experiencing unexplained episodes of loss of consciousness. There are many possible causes of such episodes, including simple fainting and seizure disorders. What was most remarkable about these episodes was the trigger: the patient lost consciousness or felt faint every time she ate a sandwich!

As described earlier this month in the medical journal The Lancet, the patient had a very extensive workup over many years:

 She had been subjected to many investigations, many more than once. Blood tests—including a full blood count, a standard biochemistry screen, thyroid function tests, a pituitary hormone profile, an autoantibody screen (including, to screen for coeliac disease, antibodies to the endomysium, and IgA antibodies to reticulin), an ESR, a short synacthen test, an oral glucose tolerance test, and concentrations of glucose (after an overnight fast), C-reactive protein and immunoglobulins; chest radiography; standard and 24 h electrocardiograms (ECGs); and 24 h ambulatory blood pressure recordings had all given unremarkable results. In November, 2007, an electroencephalogram (EEG) had shown no evidence of epilepsy.

In the interim, she was referred for psychiatric evaluation, as often happens when doctors do not understand the cause of a patient’s illness. During the following years, the young woman experienced many similar episodes, some precipitated by drinking carbonated beverages.

Because she was so young, and because a 24 hour electrocardiogram was normal, her doctors thought that her heart was not involved. However, when she was referred to new cardiologists for yet another evaluation, they decided to try monitoring her for a week. She wore a portable ECG device that kept a continuous record of her heart function. At the end of the week, she reported several episodes of lightheadedness when eating. Examination of the monitor strip revealed a surprising finding. Every time she ate a sandwich, her heart stopped! That certainly explained why she fainted. Why, though, did her heart stop whenever she ate a sandwich?

The patient was diagnosed with a very rare syndrome known as swallow syncope (fainting when swallowing). Swallow syncope happens when “wires” get crossed. Both heart rate and swallowing are controlled by the vagus nerve. It’s called the vagus (wandering) nerve because it is the longest nerve of its kind. It exits the brain and extends through the neck, into the chest, and down into the abdomen, throwing off branches along the way.

The vagus nerve carries both signal to control heart rate and sensations that come from the throat and esophagus that are used to regulate swallowing. In people with swallow syncope, the signals sent from the esophagus indicating a large piece of food get “crossed” with  signals to the heart. These errant signals actually cause the heart to stop for several seconds.

Not surprisingly, when no blood is flowing to the brain, the patient faints. In this young woman, the episodes had resolved spontaneously, but there was always the possibility that an episode would last long enough to lead to her death. Therefore, she received a pacemaker.

 

ECG

 

You can see the results in the Lancet illustration shown above. In the top tracing, the patient’s heart stops when she swallows a bite of her sandwich. In the bottom tracing, the patient has a pacemaker, and when her heart stops, her pacemaker kicks in.

The patient was thrilled upon learning the diagnosis. It confirmed what she had insisted all along. Her symptoms were real, and not “all in her head” as some doctors had told her. Now she can eat anything she wants. She promptly gained almost 10 pounds. She jokingly chided her doctor that he hadn’t warned her that she would gain weight as a result, but she is not really concerned. First the first time in more than a decade, she has reached a normal weight, and more importantly, can have a normal life.

counters for myspace

Author tags:

health

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Another reason to want to eat those colored cubes of food that Kirk used to eat on the old Star Trek. Tastes like a sandwich but not shaped like a sandwich.

This might be useful for fashion models. They can get a nerve operation that causes them to faint when they eat thereby making it easier to stay thin.

I guess it is not entirely true that what happens in Vagus, stays in Vagus. There can be consequences.

Oops...sorry for the jokes, I got confused and thought this was one of those Bob Eckstein posts where he picks his favorite punch line.
Is this related to the much more common syncope that some people experience at the sight of a hypodermic needle, for example?

I've seen syncope happen when people have the glaucoma test in which the tonometer is placed directly against the (anesthetized) cornea.

Both of those have an "ick" factor, though.
So I wonder if she would have been consulted by Psychiatrists if she were male? And why would she keep eating sandwiches? I think Iwould switch to soup, chicken, steak. Anything but the offending sandwich!
McGarrett50:

"I guess it is not entirely true that what happens in Vagus, stays in Vagus. There can be consequences."

That's good. I wish I'd thought of that.
Squillo:

"Is this related to the much more common syncope that some people experience at the sight of a hypodermic needle, for example?"

The technical term for common fainting is vasovagal syncope, and as the name suggests, it is also mediated by the vagus nerve. No one is sure exactly why it happens, but it can be triggered by any source of stress. Swallow syncope appears to be triggered by very specific physiologic events.
Pnkyrn:

"And why would she keep eating sandwiches?"

Other foods would also cause her heart to stop, including carbonated beverages. In addition, she had been told that there was nothing wrong with her and that it was likely "all in her head."
A very interesting blog!
Thank heavens they traced it down, and found what was really happening!
Phew!
This reminds me of the teetotalling car! A lady had a car that about half the time wouldn't start up again if she stopped at the grocery store on the way home from work. She told the mechanic, "I know this sounds weird, but if I buy milk, the car starts, but if I buy beer, it doesn't." The problem turned out to be vapor lock - the beer was at the front of the store, and didn't let the engine cool enough to break the lock, whereas the milk was at the back of the store. Moral being sometimes the oddest details turn out to be significant.