And yet...

Editor’s Pick
JULY 9, 2009 8:42AM

The Opera. I Wish To Go.

Rate: 21 Flag

The opera season here is brief, just a few weeks long. However, it is acclaimed and always exceeds the expectations of critics both local and national. I wish to go. At this moment I have the ticket site open on my computer screen; I could purchase a ticket. One ticket, for a Saturday night performance. I wish to go.

I haven't gone to the opera in years, at least six, and I ache for it. I know little about the genre, but that doesn't prevent me from losing myself in it, romanticizing it, and reveling in every note, every step across the stage. The stories thrill me, offer a true escape, and stretch my mind to accept and sort out an art form that challenges me.

My spouse's illness prevents us from going together and therein sits the rub, the glitch, the chasm, the unending dilemma that I face.  I say "I" because my spouse no longer sees or comprehends this issue like I do. Perhaps this is due to the illness, the medications for the illness, both of those things, or something else. I don't know. I don't think 'why' matters anymore. It just is. Over the last few years this loss of comprehension, the inability to perceive much outside the day-in and day-out, required me to adjust and change my own life in response.

A night at the opera lures me. I think about the details. How I would prepare for the evening: dressing in my new black summer dress, black heels, styling my hair, choosing my favorite jewelry. I’d drink a glass of crisp white wine as I readied myself. At a restaurant downtown, I’d sit outside in the evening sun, order hors d’ oeuvres and watch the crowd as I relaxed and participated, even singularly, in the city’s nightlife. I’d take my seat in the theater, the program in my hands, sharing anticipation with the crowd around me.

But while I was gone, my spouse would be unable to unwind, to relax, to sleep. No matter how many times and the ways we’ve tried for me to be away for the evening, it never seems to be a good idea. My spouse rests more easily when I am here. That is a fact and denying it feels cruel. Whether I am needed to provide physical or emotional care or not, my presence in the house conveys tranquility and brings rest, sleep, and comfort. In many ways that is an honor. I recognize that.

A night at the opera would mean hours away; hours wherein I would enjoy, privately and without my spouse, the intense feeling, the passion, the artistry of the stage. My breath gasping at the fervor, my hands clenching at the high notes, a soft moan from me when the lovers finally touch, all experienced alone. The music would stun me, startle me, and ultimately, soothe me.

Scoring the balance between enjoying such an evening away and reconciling it with the next morning still eludes me. I would come home with the experience fresh in my mind, my senses heightened, and my desire re-awakened. Bringing those feelings into the house is not a good idea. The increased sensitivity, I’ve learned, makes the next days and weeks hurt more than necessary, more than either of us has the capacity with which to respond. Somehow amends must be made to myself, to the construct we have here, and I’ve not yet figured out how. 

The opera. I wish to go. 

 

 I apologize for the self-indulgent tone of this piece when so many here are struggling with much more.  I am very aware that this is a minor issue and that it too shall pass. I just needed to write this and get it out.  

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Thank you for this. This was perfect and beautiful. This was EXACTLY what I needed to read right now, and thank you thank you thank you.

I apologize for the selfish tone of this comment, but you just hit the nail on the head for me, dear.

Get to the opera. I'm going to take a nap. Nobody else has to know what these little triumphs and rebellions mean.
This is beautifully written and clearly conveys the deep struggle you face each day. If you are unable to go maybe you could listen to some opera and imagine being there. If you have a patio you could sit outside and have a glass of wine and listen to the opera.
No matter how it goes please keep writing. You have a great voice.
This does not sound self indulgent to me. It sounds like the thoughts of a woman who aches for the small things that make life complete. You love the opera but deny yourself the pleasure because of your concerns for the well being of another. It's heart breaking, but not self indulgent.
Go, go, go! You must take care of yourself, and sometimes that means putting your needs first. It isn't selfishness, it's survival!
Sorry to hear about your family situation. If it is a matter of evening logistics, The Met has been broadcasting live Saturday matinees into movie theaters all over the country. I've heard that the experience isn't quite as good as the real thing, but still worth it.

If there are emotional reasons to stay at home, bless you. "Peter Grimes" or "Dialogues of the Carmelites" probably wouldn't make you feel very soothed right now.
Thank you, sweet commenters. It feels good to get this out and to read your responses.

Ladyfarmer... maybe I will do that.
And Yet, my friend.

"I would come home with the experience fresh in my mind, my senses heightened, and my desire re-awakened. Bringing those feelings into the house is not a good idea."

Bringing them into your heart IS a good idea. You deserve to feel those things. You KNOW I understand. Please find a way. If I lived there, I would help in a heartbeat.

And you are not self-indulgent. Life is full of things to experience and enjoy, and when we cannot, it hurts. xoxoxo
I'm not sure where you live, but Standing tickets at The Met are, I believe, $15 the day of the performance. The Met also has HDTV performances broadcast/simulcast all over the country for very affordable prices.
My mother-in-law was stuck in the house most of the time for over 5 years, following her husband's stroke (he eventually suffered another which proved fatal). However besides relatives and friends who helped out, in the UK there is a charity organization which provides "sitters" for adults to allow their caregivers a night off. They sent over a series of chatty gregarious ladies who all had some personal experience of taking care of the sick and elderly, and allowed her to re-connect with her bridge group and other social contacts. Perhaps there is something similar you could draw upon?
AY, you need these breaks for you to be a better wife and caretaker. I hope you can think of it this way. Get a caretaker or someone to cover your home and please give yourself this much needed respite. Live in the now. Be good to yourself in these small ways. You write so beautifully about the experience --please experience it. Please.
I don't know how you can work yourself into giving yourself the gift of an opera evening, but I hope there is a way you can do it. I discovered it in 1958, a scant 51 years ago, and it's been with me ever since. It survived every abuse I could perpetrate on myself, it survived my marriage, it survived the worst of me. It is my refuge and my island. I don't know where you are, but there simply must be a way for you to fill your soul with this music and drama. Allow yourself to feel the longing and allow yourself to surrender to it for one night. That is the highest form of love you can give yourself because it will enable you to fully love someone else.
This is just brilliant. You've captured everything perfectly. Such a rich and simple thing, a night at the opera. And many who go don't ache for anything. You made a beautiful juxtaposition. Thank you for sharing.
I think you should go too. What is one night? Not even a whole night away? That seems like it should not be too much to ask. You endure so much already. A little selfishness is necessary to both of your survival. If you collapse under the weight of everything, it won't serve him well either. I hope you take this time for yourself.
Ah. I missed a key part. Read slowly for comprehension, children!

"I would come home with the experience fresh in my mind, my senses heightened, and my desire re-awakened. Bringing those feelings into the house is not a good idea"

This is much more problematic than just allowing yourself some guilt-free time away and I struggle with this myself. The fear that if you allow yourself to really feel your feelings they will drown you. Destroy you. It is a real problem. All I can say is you can feel without it killing you. And the death of feeling is not the answer. It's too close to the real thing. I hope you can find a way to experience the opera, which sounds to me like you experiencing some joy. It's important. Joy is important. Not a luxury.
Of course you must go; it will pain your partner somewhat but you will be a better partner for having experienced desire and enjoyment. Confronting (?each of?) you with this truth, that you can take pleasure without him, offers a moment of poignant punctuation. There will be a 'before' and an 'after'. What is it you deny yourself, here, but an approximation of what you desire, in this theatrical representation? You will have left. You will have found pleasure. And you will have returned.... to ‘make amends’. I don’t know your partner’s exact circumstances, but if he loves you then he desires your pleasure. Why do you feel you must make amends (to him) for being desiring?
"Doesn't everyone
need a little yearning,
a dream on which they can build?" (Ute Lemper/ Hollaender)
Thank you so much, each of you, for your comments.
I swear, I get stronger, in some way, every time I post here.

I will try to respond to your individual comments later tonight when I have some free time and privacy.

You are all so good to me.
I found this very moving. It elicits a compassionate response not just for you (or the narrator) but for the sick spouse. This is one of the few pieces I've read on this site that truly deserves all the favorable comments and compliments.
The issue is dealing with the guilt inside once you returned, and there is no magical elixir for that. It can grind you down until the nerves are raw. And yet, the self-denial will leave you shrunken and shriveled inside until it gets to the point of resentment. Either option is poisonous, but only one fatal.
If this is self-indulgent, that's my new favorite genre.

What a lovely, wrenching piece. I so understand that it's not just a night out on the town, but the fear of bringing something back with you... something that might make a bad situation worse, in your view. I would hope that the joy you can experience from a night like that would reflect joy throughout your home; but I know that sometimes, that's not how people work. I wish you the strength you need to find a way to partake in the remaining pleasures of your life whilst remaining true to the obligations you feel. Unfortunately, anyone's saintly behavior is so often thankless until it's much too little, too late. Bless you dearly for giving of your "me" to your "we" so generously. If there is a way that a night out for you can benefit you both, I'm not alone in highly recommending it to you, though.

If you were both dying of thirst, and one could not walk... should the other not leave to seek water? Even if you have to drink a good portion of the water yourself to survive the trip back? Think on how making yourself happy can make you both happier in the long run, and perhaps it will alleviate some of the guilt.
so, to summarize, the two things in life you say make it worth living are
a) sex
b) opera.
ok then!!!
I just want to say again how much I appreciated these messages.

dicea - I'm glad this piece said something unique to you. One never knows when or if that will happen, and I'm so pleased it did. Thank you for telling me.

Ladyfarmerjed, again, I appreciate your kind note. I think I'll try that patio idea. Soon.

Smithery, thank you for your simple, gentle understanding. You know I mean it.

ElvenDaydream, what a great cheerleader you are! I can hear you chanting this.

Hi, Hoop - hmmmm, I've not heard of that locally, but I'll check into it. Thank you for your comment and for reading.

Outside, wouldn't it be nice if we lived near each other? I think we'd have a lot of fun, and provide much relief to each other. Thank you so much for stopping by with your kindness. It always means much to me.

Hi, Buzz, oh The Met is a long-distance dream, but I will check into your other idea.

GeeBee, I love that idea. The idea of leaving my spouse with a chatty, gregarious lady sounds like a very interesting solution. I love that communities support that program.

Thank you, Lea. I hear you. I promise to really try. I promise.

Kenneth, I love your comment. Love it. I will respond to you by PM with more of a response. Thank you very much.
Stephen, I really appreciate your read of this piece. Thank you for taking the time to read it and comment. I'm so grateful that you 'got it'.

Juli, I love it when you stop by. Thank you. I will not forget these sentences especially: "All I can say is you can feel without it killing you. And the death of feeling is not the answer. It's too close to the real thing." Thank you for saying that.

Psychomama, thanks for reading, again. It's hard to explain the amends. It's mostly internalized feelings and internal coping I have to do. I know it sounds a little silly, but even just an evening away like that, where I will experience all of that, does require me to do some re-entry work the next day. I think I fail at explaining it. If I come up with a better description, I'll PM you.

Mark, such a kind, lovely message. I can't thank you enough... your words feel like a warm hug tonight. I hope that doesn't sound trite. I mean it genuinely.

Mal, well... that's the way to name it, right? Shoot. Damn guilt. You know already how much I appreciate your words.

Raving, thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Your whole comment speaks to me, but especially your last paragraph. I am grateful for your thoughtful read and your time.

vzn - well, umm, ok then.
Beautifully poignant... and heartbreaking as ever (you're killing me! ;-) ).

I was rooting for GeeBee's idea, so I'm glad it appeals. It's hard not to list the 101 options and believe compromise can be found somewhere, but you clearly choose your own path... and in the process write exquisitely about wistfulness.

I like ladyfarmer's idea, too, but I'm also curious if you ever have a night at the opera at home? You say you went to the opera with your spouse, but it's unclear how your spouse relates to it now, meaning, have you had a picnic in bed listening to opera music together?

I find myself wanting to respond to the voice here as a character, so that I can more remotely, workshoply say, I need to know more about her motivations; I want to know why she chooses this path, what tangled her loyalties in this way?

~And yet,~ maybe this moment is escape enough, just writing it here. If so, I wish your favorite opera in your head as you hum bits of it all day, and I would be southern gentleboi-ly remiss if I didn't add, You are looking fine in that black summer dress and heels, no matter what house clothes you happen to be wearing. And, yes, isn't the sunset lovely, and isn't there something as sweet as jasmine in the night air about a balmy summer evening?

I confess (the Hillibillies) Jethro's knowledge of opera, but of the few pieces I know, this came to mind first as fitting for a mid-summer's dream:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Qx2lMaMsl8
ohhhhhhhhh, Butchy, you are so good to me. So very good. Thank you. I was hoping you'd see this piece and come by to visit.

You said, "I find myself wanting to respond to the voice here as a character, so that I can more remotely, workshoply say, I need to know more about her motivations; I want to know why she chooses this path, what tangled her loyalties in this way?"

Those are fair questions, Butchy. Very fair. All I can say is I am trying, slowly, to get there. To figure out the words, and how to say it. More importantly though, I'm pushing myself to decide if I want to say it. Though this community has been kind and helpful to me, I'm still scared to reveal much more.

That video was lovely, and is now bookmarked. Much gratitude to you for that.

And of course, thank you for the sweet compliment about the dress and heels. It is a pretty dress, and I love to wear heels, so... yes, I accept the compliment.
If you can go - as if you can get there - you need to go. Refreshing your spirit is not selfish, nor is it wrong. Your soul cries out for the breath of the music.
Thank, WAH. I know, I do know. But, there's something between knowing and doing, and that is where I am stuck. And, I admit, a little embarrassed at my stuckness.
Well, never let it be said slowly doesn't work for me, too. Lots of my favorite authors take years and years in between books.

I understand revelation, and the energy it takes to confront oneself in one's own words ~and yes~ how one wants to do that ~and yes~ if one even wants to muster the courage. Totally your choice ~and yet~ I hope you're more afraid of that conversation with yourself than with this community (since I haven't heard you mention the DaVinci code once, so I assume your reasons for writing are more subliminal).

I'm merely responding to the tension building since these separate pieces work very much for me as a whole, and the question of motivation is slowly swelling, and I'm all for a tantric tale. But, yes, I suppose I am admitting my bias that I hope ~and yet~ doesn't turn out to mean ~yes, but.~ ;-)

You're very welcome, Mam/Miz-san. The pace of your posts makes me natsukashii/nostalgic for snail mail and perfumed stationery and exotic stamps. I haven't been wooed like this in a long time.
Butchy,

This is some serious pressure: 'But, yes, I suppose I am admitting my bias that I hope ~and yet~ doesn't turn out to mean ~yes, but.~ ;-)'

All I can promise you is that I am trying. I am really trying. I struggle with what is worthy of posting, and what can possibly be sorted through in my mind in a way that is relevant, at all, to others.

I will try. That's all I can promise.


You are a wonderful reader, truly. Thank you.
The trick--it is a trick you see, more difficult than any other--is to refuse to compartmentalize at all. Delete the boundaries. Long for your own story. The comic-tragedy of your life is the opera. Take it with you. Bring the staged opera back home into the opera of your life. Write about your desire, fan your desire, worship your desire, and contain it as if your survival depends on it, as of course it does. It all belongs to you. You can't choose to ignore any of it. It is who you are, the wonder of you.
Oh, don't feel pressue, hon. Not my intention at all. I fully own it is my own tension (and my own struggles with revelation), as Risa so beautifully says differently.

I just stopped by for a respite from the puddin'-wrestling on my way home. I do so love the quiet meditation here, and I trust it's all relevant, whether you feel it's your best writing or not. I feel for your struggle and appreciate your sharing it with us in whatever form and time you choose.

No, no, thank YOU, darlin', and the time and space cosmic confluence of nanoparticles that led me to read you first here and make me think, I rather like this Open Salon.
Please, please stop being a martyr, it's not selfishness to need some beauty in one's life, it's a necessity. Go to the opera!
The opera. I wish for you to go, too.

I actually think it would be good for you to go out and feel those feelings, and yes, even to bring them into the house. You are alive. You are vibrant. Your love for your husband is true and deep. If his is for you as well, or ever was, he would also tell you: The opera. I wish for you to go. Take care of yourself, you will be renewed and refreshed and be a better caregiver as a result. You can relay the evening to him in detail and he will have a chance to experience it through you. Maybe you can play him a recording of the opera you go to and enjoy it together. But you, you should go in person.
A caregiver's role is very complicated. Especially for persons whose loved one endures a serious, long-term illness. During the height of the AIDS crisis, I knew several individuals who attended a support group for caregivers. It seemed to help them enormously. I recommend you investigate such a group, because the emotional toll of caregiving is very intense. It can warp one's perspective, leading to serious codependency disorders. The key to caregiving is deciding for oneself the degree to which self-care is - and is not - allowed. As difficult as it may seem, it is critical to distinguish one's identity outside of the illness, to define a life outside of the caregiver role.
Monsieur, You are very right. Sadness comes with that very idea. Once one accepts the role as caregiver, it is very difficult to maintain a role as spouse. A 'separateness' is forced to be created whether we want to believe it or not.

Thank you for your wisdom. I always appreciate your comments.
Risa, I may have to read your comment a million times, or close to it. I love what you wrote here.

BB - I know. I trust your patience. I think this writing stuff may be a little good for me, too. As is your friendship.

Joyspring, you are right, I am sure. Thanks for the support.

And thanks, Susan. I missed the season here, but I will try hard to catch the opera when I travel later this summer. I travel to large cities for business, so I should be able to. That will at least give me a taste again.

Thanks all. You are kind people.
So beautifully written. I love the way you express your struggle. I don't think you are being a "martyr" -- I suspect finding the balance between what you want and what you need is tricky.

Your desire to facilitate your husband's ability to "rest more easily" is so sensitive and generous -- traits that are what I have come to understand are at the core of you. But in denying yourself the same comfort you are denying your Self. Please, if you can go away for business, you can (dare I say must?) go away for your own sweet self! And only for an evening. It is not selfish to love yourself. Seems like a good time to apply the Golden Rule.

Take care of you, too, please. You have many friends and much love out here wanting Life for you.
Tears for your comment tonight, nowledge. How very kind of you, thank you.

You know... the word 'martyr' wasn't sitting well with me either, but I couldn't name the reason. I suspect it's because I don't think of myself in that way, at all. Your words feel just right to me - I truly struggle to find the balance between sustaining me and between hurting us anymore than we've been hurt. I ache to be respectful and fair, and yet... I know I need to sustain and maintain so that I can remain here.

The bottom line is, something always has to give, from one side or the other for me to find the balance. Figuring out from which side I should draw upon is my ongoing struggle, and clearly you saw that.

So grateful, on this quiet night, for your message of kindness and support.

All my thanks to you.
Comments are now closed.