Sprezzatura

Because neurotic is the new black....

Ann Nichols

Ann Nichols
Location
East Lansing, Michigan,
Birthday
December 31
Bio
I write, I read, I clean up after people and I worry about things. I have a chronic insufficiency of ironic detachment. My birthday isn't really December 31; it's March 22 but it won't let me change it.

MY RECENT POSTS

Ann Nichols's Links

Salon.com
Editor’s Pick
FEBRUARY 7, 2011 8:40AM

Groupon v. Tibet: I'm Still Not Laughing

Rate: 56 Flag

I think I have a really good sense of humor. I appreciate snark, subtlety and sarcasm, and many of my favorite funny things walk a fine line between humor and blasphemy of various kinds. I love “Family Guy,” “The Simpsons,” Sarah Silverman, “Mr. Show,” “Dogma,” “The Aristocrats,” Hunter S. Thompson and David Sedaris. I love that laugh that comes after a moment of shock, the did he really just say that?!  kind of thing.

I also think Groupon is an incredibly creative business, and I was delighted when they finally decided to make deals available in my small city.  In case you’re not familiar with it, the basic idea is that Groupon makes deals with local businesses, usually for substantial discounts, and then sends the Deal of the Day out to subscribers via Facebook, Twitter and e-mail. The deals are often on things you really want, and the discounts are deep. $10.00 for $20.00 worth of cookies at the best bakery in town is kind of exciting.

Last night during Super Bowl 45, Groupon ran an advertisement that managed to offend me, and motivate me to cancel my subscription and send messages to their corporate headquarters. The Groupon ad appeared near the end of the game, and while it gave me a did they really do that?! moment, I never laughed. Not even a little bit. Here’s the ad:

 

 

So I can see what they were trying to do, and if you go to Groupon’s Facebook page, website, or the YouTube page for the video, you will be reminded countless times that “people are self-righteous” and that “Groupon actually gives money to Tibetan charities” which apparently makes it all okay. I can, apparently, donate money to the Humane Society and then abuse animals with impunity. I also know people who think it was hilarious, one of them is a real, live Buddhist. That, as they say, is what makes baseball.

I don’t know why I don’t think it’s funny, except that maybe the plight of Tibetans is a cause near to my heart, one that I wish more people knew about, cared about and thought about. I was raised by a history professor who taught Chinese humanities and history, and I grew up biased in favor of all things Asian. My father and I engaged in serious conversations about what the Chinese had invented, and I knew my Confucius from my Lao-Tsu from my Buddha. I loved the idea of China, the Chinese, and a culture that had survived for so long.

When I began studying Buddhism and found myself most drawn to the Tibetan variety, I read with horror the accounts of how the Mao launched a full-scale attack on the peaceful race living in the mountains. Monks were slaughtered, monasteries were destroyed and the Dalai Lama was forced to flee from a beloved homeland that he will probably never see again. More than 50 years later, the Chinese government is still attempting to obliterate Tibet. As the ad mockingly notes, Tibet is beautiful, and the people are in trouble, their culture threatened.

Through identification with movie stars like Richard Gere, I worry that, at worst, the average American views Tibet as some kind of lefty, elitist thing to worry about. At best, it’s just one more damned thing happening to other people, far away. Odd thinking, in a country founded on the exercise of religious freedom, to look the other way while our government consistently refuses to offer substantive aid to a people persecuted partly because they are identified with organized religion under a Communist regime. The effect of Groupon’s ad to reduce the importance of China’s genocide and racism and make it seem, well, kind of silly as an issue. I’m still not laughing.

 Much as I have loved my Groupon, I have broken up with them. Call me humorless, self-righteous or knee-jerk; I can take it. For this cause, I can take it. If it turns out that this blaze of insensitivity masquerading as humor creates a buzz about Tibet, that people learn more, care more and act more, I may reconsider, but probably not. In a society in which everything seems to be susceptible to ironic dismissal, and it is more attractive to be hip than passionate, maybe I’m not all that attractive. I can live with that, and I can live without discount cupcakes.

 

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Me too, Annie. I missed it last night but found it on youtube this morning. I watched it twice to see if indeed, I was just a humorless old crone.
I'm not. It was cruel and tasteless. I cancelled my Groupon subscription and will feel just fine about paying full price at my beloved Georgetown Cupcake. Did Timothy Hutton need the work? I was surprised to see him in the commercial...~r
I can't get the video to work. Bear with me...............
I agree, this was not a message Groupon should have used. Can't understand the ad exec who came up with this idea.
Ann, I sent you video instructions... it is in your Open Salon mail. It is a quick fix.
I suspect there was some very influential CEO fat cat type with Groupon who fancied himself/herself to be a real uber-cool hipster "creative" and they pushed their "edgy" but totally inappropriate insensitive and ill-informed concept through. No one had the b***s to just say no to this person. Happens all the time. Oh, and Hutton just needed a paycheck.
I never saw the ad and still don't really know what it's about. I don't pay attention to ads on the Super Bowl; it's been my personal desire to boycott that event each and every year, so I'll never really know what they did. I'm not one to head to Youtube to watch an ad either.
Buddhadharma, like it or not, has become a hip trend, and thus fodder for the capitalist culture. Images of the Buddha on eighty dollar T shirts, zafus made of organic cotton and temperpedic foam, plastic resin statues of various Buddhas for sale in nearly every museum gift shop. I commented about this a little on Jeanette's post yesterday. What is so remarkable about the Groupon ad? They are only climbing onto the Buddha/Tibet/Dalai Lama wagon to rake in the money along with so many others.

What is ironic about all this is that people in our culture are suffering from a bankruptcy of spirit, a hole where there once was a soul, and all the buy buy Buddha is a reflection of that yearning. There is no understanding behind the yearning though, and so it will not last. In the meantime, those who have a different dog in all this, quietly rise at dawn, sit on our ragged patched pillow and watch the night change into morning.
That was a 2.5 to 2.8 million dollars misspent. Perhaps any publicity is good publicity. Maybe not in this case.
@Duane, I can appreciate you not wanting to head over to youtube to watch something. But how will you understand the significance of Ann's piece and the affect the commercial had on so many of us if you don't?
Tibet is not construed as something lefty or elitist, far from it. It examplifies to me the evils of communism. The Chinese government has convinced most of China that they are helping the Tibetans by educating and modernizing them, integrating them to the rest of China through the destruction of their culture.
Ann~ this is such a succinct, from the heart treatise. I didn't watch the game, and will now watch the clip. That I write this before watching the video is my way if saying I totally trust I will be in complete accordance with you. (r)
I agree, Annie. It was the biggest mistake of the night. My immediate reaction was disgust, though I wondered if I had misunderstood something. I rewound it and replayed it: nope, I had understood it correctly. The Tibetan people are suffering, but that's no reason we bargain-seeking decadent Westerners can't exploit it to save a few dollars on dinner! I love pushing-the-envelope humor too, but this was a horrible idea. Oy.
That is a truly bizarre commercial. Not funny. Uncomfortable.

As an aside, I can't stand to look at Timothy Hutton anymore. It looks like he's had some weird plastic surgery. I think he would have aged naturally very well.
I hadn't joined Groupon so I can't quit, but had the same visceral reaction to the commercial.
I'm not sure of any of it. I applied years ago as a copywriter (wore a Jerry Garcia tie and all) and suspect I did not come close to hire, polite as they were. Let's not kid ourselves. The Himalaya restaurant in Chicago is probably the closest any of will get to the frozen leopard.
Meanwhile, '...susceptible to ironic dismissal...' regrettably paraphrasing Walter Cronkite (it's early): that's the way it is. Assuredly, within a few years our uber-techno-prowess will allow Yak milk dispensers with some type of holistic ap.
They tried to push the line between sacred and profane and that is fine; what is precious to me, may be a joke to another (of course, the mockery of that is the definition of tasteless and cruel:) but I can deal with that. However, my bigger problem with this ad was that it was just not funny! The timing was all wrong and Timothy Hutton charmless. He looked like he was mouthing the lines off a cue card and didn't know what he was doing there. There was no 'did he really just say that?!' moment, just, 'I can't believe that is what they came up with?!' moment.
It was something that the MadMen crew might have come up with in the 50's. Tasteless. Playing on human misery and torture is inexcusable. Hutton and GroupOn should be ashamed and that ad agency should be told that what they did was horrible.
Well said, Ann. My jaw dropped when I saw this. And what was Timothy Hutton thinking?
Besides trivializing Tibet, it just seems like a stupid ad. Why pick on Tibet?
I have the best sense of humor on the planet. Seriously. But that commercial made me uncomfortable, with good reason, and wasn't at all funny. I grimaced at the end of it and thought, "Well, now. That was a mistake."
I'd never even heard of Groupon before now, but they sure have a lot of 'splainin' to do. I had to watch it twice, too, and I still don't see even the slightest possibility of humor in it. Even if I were the least sensitive person on dthe planet, I still wouldn't think it was funny. It is a dud.

Lezlie
Not the least bit funny, Ann. I didn't see any of the Super Bowl yesterday...thank you for bringing this to my attention. xox
With you 100% Ann,

@Elisa, Tim Robbins had nothing to do with this commercial. I assume you meant Timothy Hutton.
i had a HUGE pit in my stomach when i heard this ad (i was working on my computer when it came on). i have not joined groupon and will NOT join!
I did not watch the Superbowl, but this is really sick. It doesn't even make a bit of sense. What does a Tibetan restaurant in Chicago has anything to do with the plight of the Tibetan people? I thought he had a new TV show, he can't be that desperate.
rated with love
The Tibetan issue was dumbed down as a political issue long before Groupon took a stab at it. It's become a bumper sticker, a hip, human version of Save the Whales (HH the DL is awfully cute, after all--sorry, that probably wasn't funny either).

Lately I've been thinking about how what happened during the "liberation" of Tibet looks a whole lot like the U.S. invasion and annexation of Mexico back when, paired with a continued marginalization and subjugation of the people who originally lived in the conquered territory. I know that Free Tibeters prefer a more romantic analogy with Native Americans, and thus obliquely suggest genocide, but I'm building my Mexico case! Can you imagine a "Free Mexico" movement?
I went to their Facebook page and told them how I felt! I couldn't beleive my eyes when I saw that.
I hadn't seen this commercial on Sunday, but tried to go on Groupon to print something out and the site was down. Now I understand why. Not only is that commercial offensive, it's just not funny. Timothy Hutton almost looks like he's... in yellowface.
Looks as though many were offended, according to a news search I ran, and I am too. Bad advertising; there will be an apology in Groupon's future.
I totally agree with you. The thing was tasteless.
I am a man of low tastes and even I found it offensive. I posted about a Nepalese man today, Bishnu Shrestha, who might like to sit down and have friendly chat with Mr. Hutton.
I'm not buying the spin that GroupOn is trying to put on their FU'ed commercials either (that they were a "spoof").

If that were true I still couldn't over look their disrespect for the tragedy of the Tibetan people. But on top of that, their commercial in which Elizabeth Hurley states "that not all deforestation is bad" is almost as disgusting.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RtH_Zka_o7U


Between the two of them it shows an orchestrated disregard for human life, dignity and world citizenship. In other words, true rightist/elitist corporate arrogance brought to you by the same people that think they have the right to redefine the definition of rape and/or equality.

BTW, if you REALLY want to hurt GroupOn, don't buy any of their pending IPO stock or deal with anyone that does. That will kick the heartless corporate assholes right where it hurts them the most... in the wallet.
@Joan: Ann's article makes it so I don't have to watch the Youtube ad. As I'm used to reading what she has to say and accepting it with the respect it deserves, I can easily see her perspective and know that she gave me some information that I would not normally have received (as someone who never watches the Super Bowl). My point was that I tend to miss a lot of this stuff when it airs, but I'm thankful that people like Ann do report on it so I do grab its significance later.

As such, I still have no desire to watch their ad, but I'm going to pretty much accept Ann's perspective enough to know that what she had to say probably matches with how I would have felt had I watched it in the first place.
Where to draw a line with offensive humor--or whether a line can be drawn--is a subtly difficult question that calls to mind the famous "I know it when I see it" quote from 1964 referring to obscenity (US Supreme Court Justice Stewart). An interesting question to ask is: who might be harmed by this humor, and how? Offensiveness is in the eye of the beholder. Some people are offended by booger jokes. It's a little easier to be critical in this specific example because the expression is an advertisement.

Buddhism and Tibetan freedom are topics near to my heart, but I wasn't so much offended by this ad as puzzled. It's not funny. Almost like I don't "get" it. When the scene shifts and the joke kicks in, it's a non sequitur for me. So I find that this simply fails as a joke due to technical humor issues.

By the way, living and traveling in China, it's been fascinating to visit various temples in Chinese cities and to see that Buddhism is kind of analogous to Catholicism in Europe or the US, with lots of clueless people dutifully going through the knee-jerk motions of bowing to the Buddha (genuflecting). It's hard for us to relate this to Buddhism as we know it from the western spiritual seeker perspective. I'm hoping to post about this, with photos, on Teaching Physics With Chopsticks.
Upon circumspection, my all too flippant counter-point initially but not cogently attempted to illustrate the fact that here we are
*at least* discussing Tibet.

Powerful, those 30 second spots.

Hitherto, how much of the audience, frankly, had thought about Tibet since Richard Gere accepted for 'An Officer and a Gentleman'?
I've used a Groupon deal, just once, and came to understand it's a desperate marketing effort used by a business that was previously good by reputation, but is now failing because they got lazy in the worst possible economy and forgot about what good service and great product was all about. Now they are flailing and using Groupon as a last desperate measure to save the business. They'll be under within the first quarter of 2011, and I learned a very good lesson. You get what you pay for in almost every case. So no more deep discount Groupon coupons for me.

I watched the ad above... twice, and still don't get it. It was a very poor effort to link two completely unlike ideas, and failed in extremis. I'd have asked for my money back if I had been Groupon, but then again... maybe in this case, they got way more/less than what they paid for. I love it when I get to see a good kharmic slap to the back of the head.

Now, see if you can spot the link between my first graph and my second.
Forgot to mention, I loved 'Seven Years in Tibet' and thought it brought a great deal of awareness of the Tibetan history to the world through media, but was disappointed in the long term effects of that awareness. Kind of like Darfur.... an 'isn't it awful' response, but little taking up of arms (literally or figuratively) for the freedom of these people. Guess it's too bad they aren't sitting on oil fields, huh.
I saw the commercial last night but didn't really hear it, as I was watching the game at a bar and generally tuning out the commercials anyway. Re-watching it, however, I was struck by three things: 1) Is Timothy Hutton really that desperate for work or does he just need to pay for his botox?; 2) It is not funny, and judging by what you find funny, Annie, we have a very similar sense of humor; 3) Aside from its offensiveness, it's a really REALLY bad commercial!
Okay, Annie...
I'm about to carry your outrage one step further. There was a time when I watched the Super Bowl for the commercials -- knowing that the best and brightest in the business would be out there, outshining one another. Last night, I watched with jaw dropped... one humorless, tasteless, stupid attempt to get attention after another. The Groupon spot was right in the pocket with the rest, wayward, trivial and offensive as ever. I wish I had taken a count of the of the pepsi cans flying, the bashes on the head and in the balls, and number of the crashes and thrashings, incidents of road rage, and scenes of wreckage and mayhem in general.
In the ad world I grew up in (and in which I worked for decades), the best commercials had a heartbeat, and the key to their success was their humanity. Seems we've lost it somewhere.
... I'm with you, howling and not laughing.
Nothing is sacred in capitalism. In capitalism, everything -- EVERYTHING -- is only a commodity.

And Timothy Hutton: WTF? It's bad enough that he's doing TV commercials, but to do cruel commercials lacking compassion and respect?

Next time Groupon should get Rush Limbaugh to do its ads disrespecting the Asian culture.
I lost the horizon on this one and smacked a mountainside. I thought groupon was a fish and though they travel in schools wouldn't they be smart enough to know their agent sold them a tasteless product. Scrape the curry off this stinker and let the stray cats play patsy with it. Talk about your turd in the punchbowl.
i completely fail to see any humor in this, even offensive humor. it makes groupon look opportunistic in a predatory way, and aligns them with the inhumanity inflicted upon the tibetans, by trying to cash in on it. thank you for posting this ann nichols. i don't have tv and wouldn't have known about it otherwise.
Oh fer Chrissake. Get over yerself.
@Duane,
I just hope you know my question to you wasn't a reprimand or a judgement. I am often curious and interested to hear why people think the way they do. Thank you for explaining.
This was not funny, and like you, I found it offensive. I'm not understanding how an intelligent ad exec could allow this. In the arts many believe the best minds are in advertising......Huh?
Love this, Ann. And I respect your background knowledge, of which I have none.

Have you seen this? I like this author a lot--he's an ethics professor in Canada somewhere.
Groupon Super Bowl Ad: Unethical
Yeah, I was more than a little taken aback by this commercial wondering about the "humor" intended that just didn't quite work.
those Madmen at it again.....
This won my "Worst Commercial of the Year," award.
Groupon and Timothy Hutton should be ashamed.
It was tacky and crushingly insensitive.
You dissected it quite well.
I hate to shout, but ....

WHAT IDIOT THOT THAT WAS CLEVER?

All those involved in this travesty better hope there's no such thing as bad karma.
I bet the target for that ad was under 30 which probably was right on for their sense of humor.
Ann, I saw this last night and didn't think it was funny in the least. I didn't even know what it was about, but I sure won't be joining in now. Thanks for the info! R
This is the guy who starred in Falcon and the Snowman?- this is Sean's bro? Turns out Hutton is a complete A+ Kook now. A sell-out and a hater with metro hair. On first glance Sunday it was obvious: the whole spot was going to offend. These Ad Agency wunderkinds need to get out more.
I've thought about it a little more while reading the thoughtful comments here, trying now to figure out just what in hell they were trying to do. Perhaps it's an attempt to exploit the same sense of absurdity as the ads where lawyer says to jail inmate how happy is because "I've saved a bunch on my insurance" or, doctor to football player whose busted knee will keep him out for the season, "Don't worry, I have unlimited email, blah blah. Might even be the same ad agency, Non Sequiturs Assoc.? Time for them to send their top execs to run the next Republican presidential campaign.
That was a completely leaden commercial. I imagine there is a way to make Tibet funny -- this ain't it. It doesn't even make sense. By that reasoning ....Why not go down to Louisiana and eat in one of their BP-ruined seafood restaurants, to present a friggin' Groupon! Does that make it any clearer for people who think it's funny?
Laughing? No, not at all. It backfired, it was not cool, it was tasteless and those pundits and professional marketers who have tried to defend it today just sound specious.
I caught the Elizabeth Hurley one - starts off talking about destruction of the rain forest and then segues to the thrill of getting a deal on Brazilian bikini wax. I was genuinely disgusted, and also cancelled my groupon subscription.
Just truly dumb. The deforestation one with Liz Hurley was much better.
I didn't see this yesterday and several of the commenters have already summed up my reaction. Can you imagine if they'd tried, say:

"Egyptians have taken to the streets to protest decades of dictatorship, a lack of political freedoms and widespread poverty. But they sure know their hummus and no one does it better than Farouk's! Please lend a thought to valiant Egyptians and BUY OUR PRODUCT!"

And poor Timothy Hutton. I loved him in The Falcon and the Snowman and I'm sure he never thought he'd see the day where tripe like this was his best offer.
I was certain that I had misunderstood; that perhaps I'd simply not processed it correctly because I couldn't believe what I thought I had heard. This was one of those times I'd hoped I gotten it all wrong.
I think the Hurley ad illustrates what they're trying to do with this ad series better than the Tibet one and if I was in a cynical mood and drinking it might be a little funny. Not the Tibet one, though.

This gives me a picture of Groupon as a bunch of those oily young guys with slicked back hair and expensive suits who thought they came up with a hot idea that would make their big fortunes. The only thing they really give a shit about is looking like they make a lot of money. If they actually make some, so much the better but they will always spend more than they make. I dropped them a long time ago because they never had deals I wanted when I wanted them and I didn't need them deciding what I would buy when. I'm funny like that and resigned to a life of poverty, too.

Not to be a bitch but on the subject of Tibet, how many other small cultures do you think the Chinese revolution has obliterated over the last 60 years?
I agree that the ads are tasteless and bot even remotely funny. But I just discovered there is an altruistic element to this campaign:

http://savethemoney.groupon.com/

Too bad it wasn't more obvious in the commercials.
The worst part is that Ann's description of Groupon makes it sound like something I would have liked. Too bad - not only did they lose existing customers, they lost potential customers like me...I totally don't get the mean ads; the Pepsi Max ad with the abusive wife was terrible also.
Oh, and the ad agency, too. Not one of the good, creative ones.
I didn't see the ad, but I'll view your clip next. Thanks for publicizing this.

Mocking people in distress may provide a cheap laugh, but it cheapens the joker in the process.

I haven't read all your comments so it's possible someone has already mentioned this, but there is an excellent documentary available called Tibet: Cry of the Snow Lion that tells the story of China's grim takeover of Tibet. The link is to the documentary's website. It is available at Netflix as an instant download and is well worth seeing.
Can't say I was offended, exactly, but it sure was stupid. Glad I don't watch TV....
The back story behind this company and the way they operate would fill volumes.
Great piece. I am similarly unamused by the ad. Humor? NOT at all. What drunken clueless frat boy thought this would be funny? Thanks Ann...terrific spot on reaction and writing. Love you for this and more. rrr
I love anyone who loves The Aristocrats.
I think SouthP.'s usually brilliant in spite of itself.
I didn't see the advert (til now) and I'm w you. r.
Adjectives that come to mind to describe this year's crop of Superbowl ads: unoriginal, witless, sophomoric, tasteless, pointless, confusing, or dull. Even the much-hailed Darth Vader commercial was weak--but since it wasn't tasteless, pointless, confusing, etc., it's being hailed as the advertisement of the year. Oh please! You've never seen a better commercial featuring a kid? Yes you have--dozens, actually.

It's kind of fashionably elitist to complain about how lowbrow culture has become but if these ads are any indication, we are sliding downhill fast.