Sprezzatura

Because neurotic is the new black....

Ann Nichols

Ann Nichols
Location
East Lansing, Michigan,
Birthday
December 31
Bio
I write, I read, I clean up after people and I worry about things. I have a chronic insufficiency of ironic detachment. My birthday isn't really December 31; it's March 22 but it won't let me change it.

MY RECENT POSTS

Ann Nichols's Links

Salon.com
Editor’s Pick
APRIL 1, 2011 11:44AM

"Mobbed," About Which: Yuck

Rate: 27 Flag
I have not liked Howie Mandel since “St. Elsewhere.” Based on his newest offering, “Mobbed,” he doesn’t like me  much, either.

In a moment of weakness, in the glow of post ”American Idol” family togetherness, my son and I decided to leave Fox on, and check out “Mobbed.” We thought it would probably be ridiculous, but sometimes a clearly manipulated reality show is just the right kind of funny for a Thursday night. I expected to be faintly amused, and maybe a little moved. I knew it was a wedding (which I always like) and based on the barrage of clips I knew that the bride was beautiful and the groom seemed sincere in his feelings. I expected nothing further, other than the passive surrender of another hour of life and a couple of baskets of clean and folded laundry.

The setup was sweet in that carefully edited reality show way. He loved her, they had been together for three years, and he wanted to go big with his proposal. I am one of those practical types who tends to believe that spending thousands of dollars on an extravaganza removes the focus from the serious commitment and hard work of real marriage as opposed to “Bride” magazine fantasies. “Mobbed” is not, however, a gritty documentary about the realities of married life; it is a confection aimed squarely at YouTube aficionados, Bieber fans and women who own all the Disney princess movies.

I floated along paying minimal attention as I rolled socks and pressed wrinkles out of T-shirts, but I grew alert as Howie and the Experts devised a setup for the proposal. They would send in an actress who would pretend to be a woman from the proposer’s past to accost the couple as they sat at a restaurant table, and, eventually, hurl a drink at him and make a scene. This seemed not to be so much confection as shit sandwich; one Is either in a “Cops” kind of relationship in which there is constant drama and anxiety, or one is not. If one is not, such an occurrence is shocking, painful, and honestly, not very funny. It was not very funny. She cried. I would be terrifically unhappy if, five minutes before my highly public marriage proposal I was sitting alone at a two top, sobbing and believing that I had completely misunderstood the most important relationship in my life.

Of course, they made it right. Sort of. The waiters broke into “Everlasting Love,” there was a parade, there were cloggers, and there was a proposal in the open area of a gigantic California shopping mall. She cried a lot more, she said “yes,” and then there was the Howie Mandel twist - she was asked to have the wedding right then and there. 

I know that no one is meant to analyze reality TV in terms of anyone’s actual life, but I was riveted by that time, worrying about the fact that she was being manipulated into agreement, and that she would be forced by a crowd of  whooping mall shoppers to agree to have her wedding, an act considered sacred by some, surrounded by strangers and TV cameras. Furthermore, she had not had the opportunity to pick out her dress, or her bridesmaids, or even to have her hair done. It was, it seemed to me, a horrific and mutilated Frankenstein of a wedding with the casual spontaneity of flying to Vegas superimposed on the “Bride” magazine fantasy of a Vera Wang dress, designer cupcakes and $500.00 bouquets of hothouse orchids. It was a hot mess.

And so the wedding happened, with the bride wearing a dress pulled on in public over her previous outfit, and unbuttoned up the back. Her face was stained with the tears, and her hair was messy from standing outside and being flash mobbed. It was not what I would have chosen, and probably not what most women would choose; you can say the trappings don’t matter if you’re really meant for each other, but if the trappings don’t matter, there is no justification for spending a small fortune on professional choreographers, formal clothes for a bridal party, or union wages for every unemployed dancer in Los Angeles. I will admit to a tear or two because the bride was beautiful, and I’m a sucker for a wedding, but mostly I was wishing I’d watched a re-run of “Without A Trace,” instead.

Apparently, I just don’t get the whole flash mob thing, although it would be lovely if a crowd in a retail setting burst spontaneously into Christmas carols in mid December and I could stand safely to the side, listening as I picked out ice cube trays. If someone has an important message for me, I prefer a tasteful communiqué on heavy, deckle-edged note paper. I am a reserved person, and I do not even like it when restaurant wait staff is dragged to sing a rushed and unwilling rendition of “Happy Birthday to You.” I will not eat at the Mongolian Barbecue because diners awaiting their spicy tofu stir fries are sometimes forced into a Congo line. 

I would find it amusing if flash mobs were employed to deliver more delicate messages; perhaps a line of Rockettes kicking and a crowd of smiling, everyday types singing “I’ve Got You Under My Skin” to tell one’s past sex partners about a positive test for syphilis. It might also appeal to my dark and twisted nature to see a flash mob announcing that all employees’ paychecks had been lost, perhaps to the strains of Abba’s “Money, Money, Money.”

Pretty much, I prefer all flash mobs to take place in the train stations of foreign countries where I can observe them from a safe distance,  on YouTube. I think Howie Mandel and his crack team of reality TV manipulados should stay far, far away from any serious, personal and sensitive moments in life. I think I should stick to the BBC.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Joanie will read this on her lunch break.
It's her lunch break right now. :)
Gah, I am glad I did not see this. Yuck. Nay to conga lines too...forced or otherwise.
OMG, it *is* my lunch break. I just got here. Annie, I did not see this and I have no idea what you are talking about, but yes, you are still very funny. xo ~r
I was horrified/fascinated and I felt so damned sorry for the bride, whose name I cannot remember, with the obviously too-small, unbuttoned dress hanging off her.

I hope she demands a second wedding--one for which she has at least a modicum of input.

But mostly it was the drink-throwing thing that made me want to vomit. That was meanspirited and utterly unnecessary.
I didn't see it either but you've left me wondering what choice I would have made. Like Denise, I hope she demands a second wedding...with a smaller guest list.
I find I'm always reminding myself that it's 'not-reality' TV, and that people get paid, etc. Anyone who'd agree to an actual on-the-spot real wedding would need to go down to City Hall for a marriage license and do it all over again later. Glad I missed this, these shows make me itch.
This sounds like they put people through an emotional roller coaster ride. What a night mare, but if you tuned in for the whole thing, then they got their ratings. The trick is bringing the viewer back.....
rated
Congrats on the EP!
It was indeed a horrible "non-reality" show. But what gets me is that, after all these weeks of writing awesomeness, Ann gets an EP with... although well written...fluff.
i'm glad you watched it and wrote this up so i know for sure i will see it. ick ick.

oh, and denise, too.
Oh my gosh, that sounds absolutely awful. Why do people do this sort of thing to themselves? I caught portions of two Trump shows this year and shook my head at the willingness of B list celebrities to completely ruin that B reputation.

But Ann, this post was perfection. Funny, smart, pitch perfect. I'm glad I didn't watch the show but I'm glad I read your piece about it.
Oh. By the show's title, I was hoping it would be about going through a mafia initiation. If Howie and his crack staff think that "tasteless and cruel" make good TV, the staff should tie Howie down and have everyone in the mall shake hands with him. What an asshole.

"perhaps a line of Rockettes ... about a positive test for syphilis." That mental picture made me laugh.
And for setting up the woman he loves to go through this shit, the groom's a dick, too.
I watched Without a Trace. Thanks for the validation. That said, I am grateful that you watched this, because I am more than certain this post was far more entertaining and "reality" than its subject could possibly have been!
What is a flash mob? This scenario sounds like one the woman will regret for the rest of her married life, which given your description, might be until next fall.
Bad reality TV is taking over the airwaves. I won't support a reality show even if I think I might like it because I don't want to support the genre. But then again, many people get a charge out of this kind of thing so...who am I to say it's not cool.
Sounds a lot like my first marriage!
Very enjoyable.
I watched, drawn into post-Idol inertia, while painting the living room. My thoughts mirrored yours - I felt terrible for the bride. All I could imagine is how she'd feel when she saw it and realized what a mess she was in during her big moment.
Some flash mobs are amazing..but they should be spectator only. Greenheron..try googling flash mobs You Tube..my favorite was the Christmas Hallelujah
I don't even turn on reality shows ever. I tried watching them when they first appeared, but I found them tiresome, boring and extremely fake. I also discovered I almost always hated every character that was on one of those shows, so it was better for me to just avoid them completely. That's a behavior that's never going to change for me. If one comes on while I'm watching tv, I switch the channel or turn off the television.
A flash mob singing “I’ve Got You Under My Skin” to tell one’s past sex partners about a positive test for syphilis--priceless!
How horrible for that poor woman! What an awful idea for a show. Loved the writing, though.
I liked the first flash mob I saw on Youtube before it was named "flash mob". As I've seen more and more I wondered how long it would be before they took this quirky fun idea and murdered it. I think the finale of the season should be a flash mob to arrest Howie and the producers.
A wedding like that would have all the fascination of a bad road accident, for me.

And no, I don't want video cameras OR complete strangers present at any wedding of my choosing.

rated.
Ann, I have never watched this program, nor do I expect I ever will. But this is some of the best writing I have ever seen on OS. Obviously Emily agrees. Congratulations on making the cover!
Tsk, tsk. After all your beautiful personal essays of the last two weeks, you finally get an EP for saying a crappy TV show is crappy? Typical OS, unfortunately. This why I get upset when I read Entertainment Weekly and read a talented writer like Ken Tucker wasting his skills trying to get 1,000 words out of the latest season of The Bachelor.
I couldn't stand the idea of 1 hour of Howie, so went elsewhere, apparently that was a wise decision.