Anthropologist Underground

Anthropologist Underground
Birthday
October 13
Bio
I'm Terrie Torgersen Peterson. I hold a BA in Anthropology from the University of Wyoming. I've done archeological field work at Haluzta in Israel, San Juan River cliff dwellings in the American Southwest, and in the Big Horn Canyon in Wyoming. I'm currently a writer and stay-home mom to two gorgeous, laughing children. I enjoy exploring the intersection of science and culture and my own life as ethnography. I also write for Shethought.com. and DoesThisMakeSense.com. You can email me: anthropologistunderground [at] gmail [dot] com.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
DECEMBER 12, 2010 9:46PM

Extinction in Real Time

Rate: 17 Flag
I spent my formative years living in lush, wet coniferous forests.  The ponderosas, fir, spruces, and pines were among my only friends.  They were quiet sentinels who kept me company while I read and anchored the corners of my imaginary houses. They sang moaning songs with the wind and popped and crackled in freezing winter.  Their pyramid tops framed night windows into space.  The few cedars’ peeling bark blazed desert red along dark forest trails.  Summer’s heat released a treasure: their scent.  This is like a drug to me.  It’s a significant element of my love of nature.  Ponderosa is my favorite because it reminds me of vanilla beans.

The moist forests I grew up in fed a healthy (and tasty!) understory filled with thimbleberries, huckleberries, rosehips, wild strawberries, wild raspberries, glacier lilies, mosses and ferns. One of my favorite plants is goat’s beard moss (actually a lichen) . It grows like ornaments in long tendrils which somehow make me feel the weight of the forest’s age.  Beargrass fills the meadows.  I have seen numerous grizzlies, a couple of back bears, and large groups of bald eagles feeding on spawning trout in this forest.  It was here that I have had my only (hopefully) close encounter with mountain lions.

Where I live now it is higher in elevation, drier and much sunnier.  The bright  glades have a lot of lodgepole pines.  The understory is thinner and you can see long distances through the trees. Tridentate sages crowd Indian paintbrushes in the open spaces.
 
Photo 1

My favorite trees here are the krummholz. These are shorter, often bent pines that tend to grow in sparse clusters punctuating the terrain near 10,000 feet.  Krummhotz stands provide sheltered lunch spots, cozy Perseid-watching backrests, and privacy for diaper changes, nursing, and naps. They’re perfect as a tenting windbreak and/or snowfence.

Just southeast of the Lewis Lake trail
 

 
Photo 2 
 
is a cluster we call the Troll Cave.  The Little Anthropologists and I wait every year into July for the snow to melt so we can visit.  My son and his friends named this place when they were two--before they could hike all the way under their own power.  In early July, the pasqueflowers are just emerging and brightening the shade.   If we time our annual trek well, we hike in before the road is open and have the gorgeous alpine valley all to ourselves.  We’ve seen woodpeckers and jays in the trees.  We often see moose and raptors, and occasionally elk.  Marmots watch us pass their rockfall and hurt our ears with their calls.  

Photo 4



Over the last six or seven years we’ve watched mountain pine beetles kill our beloved forests.  
 
 
Photo 5 
 
First a few needles turn red, then whole branches, then  all of the needles blaze red.  
 
Photo 6
 
 
Photo 7
 
 
Photo 8 
 
 
As the trees dry, the needles fall leaving skeletons behind.  These dead trees become unstable and they’re very vulnerable to blow-down and wildfire.  It seems to me that the whole ecosystem in these dying stands declines in health and diversity.  It feels dry and hot even in cool weather. The healthy pine scent is gone, and I see fewer animals.
 
Photo 9
 
 
Photo 10 


Three years ago our favorite campground near three wilderness areas closed to the public.  Hundreds of acres of trees had died and become a hazard.  This area was thick with moose, elk, raptors, cranes, woodpeckers, and blue herons. I’m hearing more and more accounts of forested public lands all over the region closing or restricting access because of the danger.  

This current infestation is occurring all over the Rocky Mountain region.  In the last year I have personally seen large swaths of dead and dying trees from Alberta, Canada all the way into southern Colorado.  It’s hard to adequately represent the scope of the problem unless you’ve seen it first-hand.  Locally, we’ve watched the red trees’ relentless march from lower elevations up into the high places near the Troll Cave.  

On one hand, evolutionary change in tangible real-time is intellectually interesting.  However, I have a hard time embracing this change because while the beetles are thriving, entire ecosystems and ecological niches are facing local extinctions.

Forestry friends tell me that some forests are beginning to regenerate: aspen are moving in and replacing coniferous trees where there is adequate moisture, and coniferous saplings are beginning to grow in devastated areas.  Unfortunately as long as the infestation continues apace, these young pine trees are unlikely to survive to maturity.  The ancient forests I grew up in are already dying, and my own children may only have vague memories of healthy evergreen forests.  

The scientific consensus is that although multiple factors contribute to the current outbreak, warmer winters are a significant contributor.  Extreme cold over several days to weeks is required to control the beetle populations, and that just hasn’t been happening in the last decade or so.  

From the Coloradan:

A report, "Climate Change and Bark Beetles of the Western United States and Canada: Direct and Indirect Effects," in the September issue of the journal BioScience said the increasing woodland temperatures might allow beetles to survive the winter in ways not often seen before the current outbreak.

Report co-author Jose Negron, an entomologist at the Forest Service's Rocky Mountain Research Station in Fort Collins, said temperatures are no longer dropping to minus 30 or minus 40 in the middle of the winter.

Every winter, mountain pine beetles develop a "cryoprotectant" compound in their bodies to protect them from severe cold. That protection is greatest in the middle of the winter and lowest during autumn and spring when the protection is either building up or wearing off, the report says.

But extremely cold temperatures for a few days or a week or more at a time can break through that barrier and kill the beetles.


Regardless of what you think of climate science, the devastation of the beetle outbreak is undeniable, and in my opinion, incredibly sad. I visit the wild places to escape the bustle of humanity.  The dying landscape is a constant reminder of our appalling stewardship. Regardless of your politics, would it really be so terrible if we begin taking better care of our natural resources?  


Photo 3

 
 
 
 
 
All the photos in this article are mine. AU 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
When those beetles first made their way to this continent they infested about 90 acres. The experts recommended burning an area of about 40,000 acres so as to be sure that they were wiped out. The government refused to do it. Now those beetles extend from the arctic circle to well down in the US and eastward to the province of Quebec, in Canada.

I'm glad Bioscience said warmer winters "might" allow the spread of those insects because the north country is still waaay colder than the south (B.C. on down) and those beetles are spreading like wildfire up there. I doubt that temperatures have much to do with it. Tens of millions of acres are gone, perhaps hundreds of millions will be lost in the end.

There is also some evidence that those beetles are adapting to deciduous trees now too. If they do that few woods will be safe from them.

What a crying shame.
excellent reporting, Terrible news. The sent, i remember the scent , too.
The beetles are coming the beetles are coming and how I wish they were the English group. Canada too has had its entire west coast decimated by the beetles. I just don't know what to do or say except I wish by a miracle they would go away.
A.U., while I have read and seen tree destruction by invasive species in New England and into the Mid-West, I was not aware of this beetle that you mention as ravaging the trees you discuss at higher elevations. That's certainly more bad news and the warming trends associated with climate change clearly are responsible. Thanks for this attractive and informative photo essay!
Drought is a factor too, and I can't help thinking the air quality around them doesn't help. Before the pine beetles and the spruce budworms, we had Ips beetles, which decimated our piñon forests. The weather didn't kill them, and the drought-stressed trees were unable to repel them. Now our aspens are dying, and I wonder what the new succession will look like.

Driving to Denver last week, I did see lots of little green trees among the red ones, and so far our ponderosas are fine.
We have been going to the North Carolina parts of the Blue Ridge Mountains now for the last 6-7 years. Lots of hiking, some (but not nearly enough) fishing. When we first started oging there, I was amzed at the grand Eastern Hemlocks along some of the trails we hiked. Some really big-ass trees that might have been 150-200 years old. I remember hearing a park ranger say soemthing baout the Hemlock wooly adelgid, an Asian import, that was doing some damage to the Hemlocks. Seven years later, you can see the grey skeletons of most of the big-ass Hemlocks on the mountainsides of the Blue Ridge down into the Smokies. There are smaller Hemlocks peaking up in the understory but they don't seem to get very big before the bug gets them; the big-ass trees are no more.
I first saw the evidence of the beetles while visiting the Park City area of Utah and was shocked. A terrible shame.

One thing people can do, is to burn your firewood where you get it. In other words, don't bring firewood from one camping area to another. You can be the unwitting transporter of all sorts of creatures and things that don't belong. Same is true for anglers, make sure your gear and/or boat is thoroughly washed/rinsed before entering a new body of water.
When are we going to be able to get the US government to take climate change seriously! Do we have to kidnap, tie-up and transport the climate change deniers out to the Rockies to see this devastation for themselves? Or will that only fail because they will make up some other reason for the pine beetle infestation?
I don't disagree that climate change (especially drought) is a factor in the beetle situation, but it is also a cycle. In Colorado, there are areas (Poudre Canyon is one) that were devasted by similar outbreaks years ago and have since recovered. I do see glimmers of hope too - one of my favorite camping areas between Silverthorne & Fraser is starting to come back. From afar, all you see are the red & brown trees, but up close it really is rather lush. There are small pines, many aspens and quite a bit of undergrowth that is thriving now that the canopy has opened up. There is a cmapground up there that all the affected trees removed from a few eyars ago. It was quite ugly then - everything was exposed and there was no privacy or shade to be had anywhere, but now the aspens have taken over and it is once again a nice place to camp. My biggest worry is that a fire will un do it all before it has a chance to fully recover.
One of my favorite sensory experiences is the scent of evergreen. I would hate to lose it. An excellent post.
Love your photos. Yep, and we are on the verge of seeing the death of all of our ash trees due to the ash borer, which will devastate the Northeast.
Thanks for the comments everyone! And many thanks for the Editor's Pick!

I'm sorry to hear how widespread this and similar infestations are.

skypixie: Bummer about adapting to deciduous trees! I was surprised to learn how many other types of trees are dying from similar infestations.

I'm told that each management agency is taking a different approach to mitigation. Hopefully their efforts will yield some viable solutions in the near future.

High Lonesome and Wandering: One of the beloved places I have watched slowly die over the years is the west side of RMNP around Granby. I'm glad to hear that there's some regeneration. Agreed about the fire. The vast amounts of extremely dry tinder is scary.
Beautiful pictures, and wonderfully written. It's depressing, but the more information that's released on these phenomena, the more minds might (hopefully) change. Keep it up.

By the way, I am learning a tremendous amount from Greenman's videos on YouTube; are you familiar with them?

http://www.youtube.com/user/greenman3610
I've read a little on this and it's one more shark in the water on teh global warming front. I'm a boomer and this is the biggest issue of my lifetime. Sad to say we're losing badly. Many people refuse to believe it's even happening.
stellaa, daniel, and abrawang: thanks for stopping by and commenting! I'll check out Greenman.
What a marvelous place to live and raise your little anthropologists. Beautiful photos, even with the harsh reality you report.
Thanks Linda! We feel lucky to live near mountains and forests.
I can see many people comment on this post. It is very evident that you are very concern with our environment and that you want to save all these trees and natural resources from extinction. Let your voices be heard at http://ithinkrevolution.com.