My relationship with anti-depressants is complicated, I read widely and I know that they often perform little better than placebo. There may be long term side effects that we just don't know about yet. No one likes BIG PHARM and it is hard not to be suspicious of researchers and physicians that receive funding or other benefits from the industry. However, these pills have simply saved my life. They alllow me to function when nothing else will. (I am only on expert on my own experiences). Mild depression may remit completely with exercise and fresh food, talk therapy or simply by the passage of time. But when you are severely depressed and cannot get out of bed, it is almost impossible to recover with these methods- at least in my case.
My first depression occurred at 19. I was an impoverished student though financial aid made me better off than at home. I had no insurance. I couldn't afford therapy, even on a sliding scale. And to be honest I was too ashamed to go to therapy. I had been brought up to believe only truly crazy people do that. I found a nice physician who gave me free samples of Prozac for a few months and my mom scraped together some funds for a few more. The change was remarkable. I had been unable to get out of bed and would weep for hours on end. That year, I ended up studying abroad (I had never been out of my home state) and had my first boyfriend at the age of 20.
I ran out of the meds around Christmastime and wasn't able to get any over the holidays. I went through a light withdrawal since I hadn't tapered off - I slept for about 2 weeks straight- but after this period I felt ok. I was actually kind of relieved to be off the medication. Now I could be normal.
The pattern continued. I got depressed to the point of not functioning. I sought out the cheapest therapy I could - students on a sliding scale - and when I was working I paid for a Cognitive Behavioral Therapy professional well respected in the field. I didn't drink, I didn't smoke, I ate healthy and exercised. I took my vitamins. I read self help books by the bushel. I would get to the point of no return, of no functioning, not being able to work, to interact with the world at any level and I would have no option left but anti-depressants. I was very conflicted and would discontinue as soon as possible, tapering off and under the care of a doctor. I would also read books on the evils of pharmaceuticals, often as I consumed them.
Eight years ago I started seeing a therapist-in-training who was anti-medication. He was very "new age" and believed in many alternative therapies. I was taking medication at the time at a very low dose and was a bit tired of the see sawing on and off medication. I was deeply in love with a man for the first time. But the therapist insisted I not take medication. I readily complied. I tried many of the therapies and tactics he promoted. After a while I began to get depressed. I got lower and lower. I lost my job. I lost the man I love. I almost lost my mind.
I would ask him, "Should I go on medication?" and he would say "No, not yet. You need to descend into the darkness first and then come through reborn." Yes, he actually said that. Our relationship was more like guru/ disciple. Myths figured quite heavily.
I got to the point where I couldn't go on. I went to see him. He wanted to commit me to a hospital. I did one of the bravest things I have ever done. I fired him. I walked out and made an appointment with a psychiatrist. I started on Lexapro. The therapist called me many times, told me to come back. I never spoke to him again.
There is something called kindling. Basically each depressive episode you have increases the probability that you will have a future episode. At 4-5 prior episodes, my probability is roughly 90%. For people like me, it is better to stay on medication than to keep going on and off. I have accepted that I will probably be on medication for the rest of my life. I am lucky. I have virtually no short term side effects and as for long term effects - well, they look better than a mental hospital or suicide whatever they end up being.
One thing that has been hard to accept is that I have never fully recovered from that last episode. At most I have achieved 50% remission. I've increased doses and switched medications but have never gone above 50%. The most troubling symptom is my fatigue. I can drink espresso and lie there like a log. I am an old woman in my 30s. I exercise regularly, eat well and have seen different therapists. I seem to have plateau'd out. Its been 6 years. I am 34.
Do I accept half a life?


Salon.com
Comments
I don't know enough about meds to give any advice except to say, you sound very smart and that you are very aware of your self and your needs. That's really good.
I bet we would be friends if we met. Maybe in a quiet kind of way, but still, friends.
Take care.
I just listen. I don't really have advice for her. Or for you. But I will listen. (rated)
First I have to say to new blog, and to you, that taking or not taking meds is very much the choice of the individual.
I get really concerned when people tend to get into a rant about their experiences that is repetitive and not giving the listener/reader an opportunity to respond.
Your post, batface , asks some really important questions.
Do you think you might be bi-polar? Cycling in and out of states is common to bi-polar. That you describe it as episodes makes me wonder if you should see a doctor who could take all of the information - because some antidepressants are not great for bi-polar.
No matter what, depressive, bi-polar, ...these are diagnoses, yes, but they are also terms to work with. (And you may have a chemical imbalance, or a thyroid issue - lots of things can lead to depression, both physical and emotional.)
I encourage you to continue to empower yourself, as you have done by writing this post. Keep in mind that it's your body, and your life - and consult as many resources as possible to get what you need.
I hope this comment is not too bossy! I look forward to reading more of your posts.
Depression can be miserable but it is not the same thing as misery.
I had no quality of life before anti-depressants. They enabled me to live.
Is it a full life, a happy life? No. But as someone else said, it's better than none.
This is why I like the NHS - there is no room for hippy shit. They understand clinical depression and they want to take practical steps to help you. And they would never, ever contact you once you had terminated the relationship.
There are too many loose canons in private practice, too many who are sick themselves. Your guys sounds manipulative and needy.
One of my closest friends is a doctor and she has told me many times that depression is one of the few treatable mental illnesses where drugs consistently shows positive results in most people. The thought of going back to the constant anxiety, insomnia and despair that used to be my life is just not an option.
And it is always nice to see you, Aunt Shelle.
new blog, I admire that you always speak up strongly for your beliefs. and I am glad you found a way that works for you.
I really believed in the therapist's approach at first but after THREE YEARS I went from bad to worse. I lost my job and my partner. Next stop, according to the therapist, was the hospital.
Everyone has a limit that they reach in the interest of self-preservation and I reached it. I had to trust myself and my gut at that point, not anyone else. Believe me, nothing was going to "reset" itself.
One thing you need to realize is that there is no one truth in this. You are an expert only on your own depression. Everyone must find their own way. As I said in the tags, YMMV- (your mileage may vary).
I cannot speak to your friend's condition or your own and I am not saying that psychoactive drugs cannot be abused or used unwisely. I no little about antipsychotics.
But I hope you can tell from my writing that I am not a zombified raped ape ;)
I am luckier than your friend. I have a wonderful psychopharmacologist and I have not been cycling on many drugs. I have been on one drug at the same dose for the last couple years and we are considering a change.
Not bossy at all!
Unfortunately/ fortunately I do not have the “highs” of bipolar I/II. The cycles I described were mostly off meds/ depressed, then on meds/ stable.
I have been pretty stable these past 6 years.
Thanks for stopping by.
I hope to incorporate more humor into this blog later. My life is not all gloom and doom, I just wanted to set this up as a place where I can address the "black dog".
Although I described it as half a life, most days I'm glad to be here. Everybody has got there something. This just happens to be my something.
Half a life is indeed better than none, but you must strive for the other 50%. The striving and seeking must also be a bit of a mood lifter.
Carry on, one foot in front of the other.
Cheers
Good post. It's always tempting to give advice, but everyone experiences depression differently, and you seem to have a pretty good handle on what works for you. Good luck with everything.
(Not trying to pimp my post-- just didn't think it would fit here as a comment!)
I have heard of Seligman and Positive Psych.
I am so thrilled you commented. I always like reading your comments on other blogs.
I think if you are doing well on that low dose you should continue if possible. I think if I had stayed on my low dose instead of going off and on, I would be better off. I have found clinical evidence to back this up.
You are right, in some ways depressives are fortunate in their course of treatment. I have read a bit about schizophrenia and other severe mental illness and the options (or lack of) can be heartbreaking.
OTOH, I once had a neurologist prescribe Zoloft to me and I have epilepsy. The literature on Zoloft says it's not to be prescribed to people with seizure disorders in their or their family's history. I was so mad at her, but she never admitted she had made a mistake and I terminated the relationship with her. I hate that doctors can hurt us and then blame us for not fulfilling their wishes.