Editor’s Pick
JUNE 28, 2009 12:55PM

Kafka and the Twitterverse

Rate: 59 Flag

Tucked away in a back corner of my morning paper, I found something that caught my eye. 

 

Jean Anleu

 

Jean Anleu may be the first to be Twitarrested by his own government. To be sure, there are paranoid and repressive governments who fear the Twitterverse, and have taken actions. There may be scores of unreported arrests already. We've read reports of Iran arresting thousands, many of them for Internet activity. China and Vietnam are also worried about the effect that Twitter and other social networking sites has on opposition groups—the ability of protesters to use networking sites to gather people quickly for a common cause is a concern to governments that don't trust their own people.

 

But Guatemala is doing something different. They've gone public with Anleu's arrest to send a message to those who might use Twitter as a forum for protesting the government's actions.

 

Anleu's alleged crime? He was so fed up with corruption, especially the government banking system, that he used Twitter to send a message for popular action to counter the corruption. The managers of the government's rural development bank, Banrural, are enmeshed in a political scandal. Anleu sent this message out to the Twitterverse: "First concrete action should be take cash out of Banrural and bankrupt the bank of the corrupt."

 

Prosecutors now seek to charge him for spreading false information which carries a five-year prison sentence and $6,500 in fines (much more than the average Guatemalan makes in a year). 

 

Sympathetic Twitterers raised money for his bail. About half of his $6,200 bail was donated via PayPal from 19 countries.

 

Jean Anleu

 

Prosecutor Genaro Pacheco says that Anleu's words illegally undermined the public trust in Guatemala's banking system. The police were able to prove that Anleu sent the message by searching his home in Guatemala City. He was taken to a prison that houses kidnappers, extortionists and other dangerous criminals for two days before he was able to make bail. 

 

Anleu's lawyer, Jose Toledo, believes the government wants to make an example of him.

 

Twitter co-founder Biz Stone declined to comment on the Anleu case or say whether he knows of any other arrests involving Tweeting.

 

In an irony that only living in a country with a repressive government can produce, Anleu, a geeky computer enthusiast whose passions include playing chess online and reading Czech author Franz Kafka—we see his life has taken on some eerie parallels. Kafka wrote The Trial, whose protagonist struggles to defend himself against the powers of the state.

 

"I fear I'm being watched and scrutinized in everything I say and do," said Anleu, who walks around with an iPhone to constantly tweet and a BlackBerry loaded with e-books. "The fear makes me want to avoid saying what I think, even about the most mundane topics, and saying where I am, where I'm going—like you would normally do on Twitter."

 

Guatemala is only a nominal democracy—emerging, still, from a quarter century of genocidal civil war that has seen the deaths of 250,000 of its own citizens, most of the dead comprised the indigenous Mayan populations in remote villages. Guatemala has never been free from violence in its troubled history—a history our own country has provided examples in the laws of unintended consequences. In the 50s, Eisenhower's State Department and the CIA helped to overthrow the legitimate popularly elected government of Jacobo Arbenz, in part because that newly elected government posed a threat to our own multi-national corporations' profits and interests. 

 

Twitter—not so innocuous or vacuous as some critics like to proclaim—it can be a tool for moving toward freedom, and to hold governments accountable.

 

Anleu's Facebook page is here.

 

 

I have some experience in Guatemala. I've written about one part of that in a previous post here on OS—Chajul and Chalcaté. In my time there, we were never completely safe. On our way up into the remote mountain villages to build homes for widows, we would pass by buses and vehicles, pushed off the dirt highways only enough to allow traffic to pass. They were metaphoric reminders from the government of the dangers of opposition. Slowly rotting and rusting hulks, burned from RPG explosions—stories of untold death and misery—charred and burned bones long since carried away.

 

Our group even had 105mm howitzers fired over our encampment, reportedly as "artillery training exercises," but the message was clear. "You can be here to help widows, orphans, the poor and destitute, but don't make any political statement other than building homes for widows." On one of our trips a uniformed customs agent at the airport in Guatemala City asked us "Why are you taking this dental and medical equipment to the Indians? They're animals—they're not even people."

 

 

 

 

Metanote: I know this is not like my usual postings here on Open Salon, thank you very much for stopping by and for any comment you would like to leave. Regularly scheduled programming will probably return with the next post.  

 

 

Images of Jean Anleu from Flickr poster Surizar and used under Creative Commons license ascribed to the images.

 

 

### 







 








 


...

myspace profile views counter

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
More to come. Twitter like all mediums is a tool. How we use it and how governments try to control it will be interesting. What Twitter and other such tools do, is take away some of the monopolistic tools of communication from government and corporations.
I'm often very blase about new technology and the way it affects people in our very modern society, but this is a great example of how it might be transformative--even if only by responses from governments and organizations who fear openness. I hope for the best for Jean Anleu.
Amazing, Barry - blows my mind.
I think you've nailed it Stellaa, this tool, and others like it, are great equalizers and allow for the common man's dissent where it would not necessarily be heard.

Rob, it's an important point. We are blase about the things that are easily at hand here, viewed from someone else's eyes and experience in some of these marginally democratic governments and in repressive regimes, it is an empowering tool and experience.
Really amazing post, Barry! Your experience never ceases to amaze me and that you have such integrity and versatility in your management of the information you impart to us. A very intereting topic which will undoubtedly be scrutinized more closely by most governments and organizations shrouded in secrecy. I foresee a James Bondesque movie on this very subject to be released in the not too distant future. Rated and EP quality!
Barry I seem to find everything out through twitter - from important news to silly gossip and which friends know the same songs as I do. Like Rob I take my technology for granted - thanks for reminding me that everyone isn't as privileged.
Was it less than a month ago that every story/post about Twitter essentially mocked the twits? Now it's the essential tool for popular uprising.
thank you for telling this story. I agree with Stellaa and Rob on this but I am worried, too, about the stories I hear that lets technology (given recently to Iran by Siemans and another company) that allows governments to interfer with and change tweets.
What's the difference between Jean Anleu and Thomas Paine? The medium. Thanks, Barry.
And Lord! I wish the Celebrity Death Match would get off the cover so we could see some other stuff without having to search it out!
Thank you for sharing this. Most of us here in the U.S. don't realize the struggles going on in our own hemisphere. (I certainly didn't know about this story.) Your post also reminds me how sad the situation is when this is relegated to a back page corner blip in the newspaper.
I haven't been a big fan of Twitter so far, because so much of the content has been vacuous. This is a good example of how Twitter, and other communication media, continue to evolve.

Free speech is a very real dividing line between fully democratic countries and those that are only marginally so. We do tend to take it for granted, and we shouldn't. Too many people didn't notice (or chose to ignore) how much Shrub's regime nibbled away at its edges.

BTW, the only way I've used Twitter so far has been checking out someone's feed with local transit delay info, which provides very useful information that our transit services do not offer.
bbd,
good for you to do all this fine work.
You are all over the cover, you know.
It figures. The first guy ever followed on Twitter gets himself arrested. Great reporting.
Can you imagine the scene in the corporate offices of Twitter when somebody saus, "The CIA or The State Department is on th phone?"

Great piece Barry.
Stephanie, I saw that...it was some special Kafka irony I guess: screen cap of me and large breasts on the cover of OS can be seen here.
I just read your post on your experiences in Guatemala. It is one of the most beautiful countries, yet so very torn up by war and death. Most in the US have no idea . . .

That Twitter may put otherwise obscure news into world view is fascinating. And in spite of the oppressive governments, people seems to be very creative in accessing these emerging technologies. Hopefully, that trend will continue. Thanks for posting this, bbd - excellent post on many levels.
Thank you, Barry. It may not be your usual fare but it is am important post and we likely would have known nothing about it if you had not posted. Very well done report.

Monte
Like so many things/tools, original usage is not always the thing that evolves into the most important aspect. Twitter may turn out to be a major tool for both good and evil. To be continued ...
Governments, especially corrupt, repressive ones, will have an uphill battle on their hands --an ultimately unwinable battle-- against community interaction and activism online. Unless they go the way of North Korea. But I doubt the toothpaste can be put back in the tube once people have tasted the freedom of the Internet.

Great reporting Barry, especially appreciated hearing your personal knowledge. We don't tend to have the South American countries on our radar unless something big happens. Only thing lately was a cheating governor...
Thanks for this well constructed post. I am glad to know that someone will write about other places (Than Iran) and situations where Twitter is changing the games that corrupt governments and people will play.

Two weeks ago, we were bemoaning the shallow and useless nature of "twittering". Now we see the usefulness and power of that technology.
I can't help but think this is just the beginning. I see more to come. That we will be able to witness it but be unable to reverse the injustice saddens me the most. Well done, Barry.
Strong stuff. By so adroitly chronicling the problem, you're also becoming part of the solution.
thank you so much for covering this. i have been reading the blog rconversation for years now, and it's hard to find people who can write eloquently, yet concisely about the ways the internet can be used to ensnare activists and control speech. thank you.
http://rconversation.blogs.com/
Bananas seem so innocent don't they? And yet, they corrupted so many Central American countries back in the day. The only question I have is I wonder how long it will be before the first tweeter gets arrested in this country?
Corporations and governments read these blogs in order to stay ahead of any potential trend or any individual that could cause potential trouble for them. We are all under watch whether we like it or not!
This is a great piece, BBD. Thank you for the information and your personal experiences. First rate journalism. xox
I had no idea twitter could be so powerful (else the powers that be would not fear it). I am not as plugged in as you. I drew the line at texting for years before finally beginning to use this tool. Twitter seems beyond my comprehension at the moment.
Excellent update from the land of Twitter and freedom of speech. Many thanks. I was one of many who wrote about Twitter's growing up when it came to this kind of use (by dissenters). Stay tuned...
What's really ironic is that Barry discovered this via a dead tree.
Thanks for giving this to us in such a useable package. Twitter seemed so, oh, Ahston Kutcher-Kitschey-esq at the beginning, I ignored it. Give me Kafka-esque and I can see the true potential.

We all should "friend" anleu; and twitter away!
Wow, that's a story I hadn't heard, but it's also one that is not surprising. I suspect he would have been arrested if he had been handing out printed leaflets with the same comments. I can foresee an incident in our own country where someone's immoderate tweets could be construed as inciting terrorism. Freedom of speech is a precarious thing in most of the world.
well yay, finally something decent on the cover. congrats.
Excellent reporting, Barry. I'd not heard of this, but I'm not surprised that certain governments would fear this technology. Allowing common people to have a voice, and then finding that they share that voice with others, might chip away at their government's stranglehold. I have a lot more respect for Twitter's potential now. Thanks.
Thank you so much for bringing this to our attention. I spent three weeks in Guatemala. It can be scary, even in Antigua. And the current regime--bad. I am glad for Twitter and Facebook. This, and the cell phone access to instant photo transmission is our best protection against torture and repression. We HAVE to do everything possible to keep the internet free from governmental tampering.
“I fear I'm being watched and scrutinized in everything I say and do.” . . . “The fear makes me want to avoid saying what I think, even about the most mundane topics.”

This is precisely why Anleu was arrested—to put the fear into the people so they would remain silent. And that’s why it’s even more important for voices like yours to sing out about the injustices you’ve witnessed—and for all of us to join in this hallelujah outcry for freedom of speech and justice worldwide.

( m&m )
BBD, I thought this was a literate and fascinating post about a story and place I'd never have heard about otherwise. Now I'm curious to hear what group/mission led you to Guatemala and about your experiences there. All the best to Jean Anleu - sounds like both Kafka and Orwell, especially the detail about him fearing to say what he thinks.
Ordinary people are actually able to steal some of the thunder of dictators and repressive governments. .......I can't help but think of the scores of poor oppressors, dictators, political murderers, and general thugs who will have less control over their subjects, and mre work to do chasing down the truth.......
Glad you posted this, Barry. Fascinating and frightening.
Just another way for the man to oppress the people. Monkey fingered and reddit.
I think it is inevitable that social networking tools will be co-opted to spy on citizens, and not just by totalitarian regimes. Guatemala and Iran are cases in point.
If it can happen there, it can happen here.
It's sad. I've travelled a lot in Central America, and it's been a crappy week. This in Guatemala. Now the coup in Honduras, and inevitable crackdown on protestors.

On the up side, when I was there, in the mid late 90s, cell phone technology was just starting. There wasn't enough infrastructure for phone lines in many of the mountainous, rural parts. They may not be able to tweet their protests, but they can at least call for medical help.
This is a powerful post. Thank you for it! Rated and shared with my friends on twitter and facebook.
Funny how people keep finding ways to get around repressive governments. Not so funny how it seems like our OWN government almost always has a hand in the rise to power of these regimes.

Excellent post, Barry.
Great find Barry and I'm glad you did such an excellent post about it. Twitter is a powerful tool, despite many people's general misunderstanding of it.
Top right on the cover. Where it belongs.
Rated
Fascinating -- an excellent report. The conflict between repressive governments and the information age is just beginning. We shall see how it evolves. Thank you for bringing this to our attention.
Nicely done. My daughter works in neighboring Nicaragua and while there are vast governmental differences, there are also similarities. What she is most amazed by is the sheer corruption in government at all levels, and particularly at the federal level. She says the uneducated villagers thoughout the consuntryside are under the impression that thier government leaders are helping them to a better life, when in fact they are holding them in ignorance and ripping them off. They 9villagers) do the work, produce the products (e.g., coffee) and government officials get rich. Hmmmmmm....sounds eerily familiar doesn't it?
Great job on an interesting story.
People always say we take our freedoms for granted. What does that mean, exactly... that we should give them up and cry all day long, because others in the world don't have the same freedoms?

Rather than sitting around and crying that we take our freedoms for granted, why don't we HELP others gain freedom... somehow... in whatever way we can?

I'm sick and tired of "being told" that I have to feel bad and guilty for having freedoms that others may not have.

I don't use Twitter, because I tend not to flock to things that the general populous flocks toward, but in cases like these, they are a good thing.
Bill S... of course! The more our government can keep others' governments controlling their people, the more "WE" can stay on top of the power pile. Agreed.
Thank you for bringing this intriguing story to our attention.
A beginning, this. Of what? Well-covered.
Rated. I like how internet communities connect people and give them a voice. But it's very scary that aggressive governments are watching these communities so closely. Makes me a little nervous.