Ontological art in slow decomposition
We all fight time, the conqueror. Though we strive for stasis, at least when things seem perfect, inexorable linearity prevails. Eventually we lose the illusory battle to halt what seems unnatural and unfair, no second can be reclaimed except what the firing neurons recall. There is some irony that what those cerebral chemicals in the hippocampus display are our best and at times most vivid art.
Still, we fight.
The basalt of time, on the way to Marfa. Larger version is here to see the graffiti.
How can we comprehend our own narrow slices of time when we see something that can't easily be measured by our slices? The volcanoes of ages past produce vertical basaltic dikes, and we try to ignore the immense meaning by marking territory, spraying out of a can as a substitute for ownership peeing. The once liquid solid doesn't care and doesn't know that millions, or tens or hundreds of millions of years have vanished beneath its slow change. The paint will flake and fall as will all the natural constituent parts of the seeming impermeable surface.
Steven Spielberg can make the skies and clouds move with violent alacrity while natural time goes on below in the same scene. Koyaanisqatsi mocks our seeming ownership of time, and brings to focus our lives out of balance. But Spielberg's video trickery and the Hopi concept of time point as metaphors of what ought to be. We ought to enjoy our time even as it screams past us. Create the art that memory will recall even though that art will return to dust in the immeasurable eons to come. Simply—love, live and make beauty. Don't worry that others might not know what that beauty you make means.
Looks like it was a BadYear. (An admittedly bad pun, the tires on the poor yellow John Deere are Goodyears). Larger view.
As I mentioned a couple of posts ago, I was off on another road trip. The destination again was to be Santa Fe—a return to help a friend who owns a lovely tchotchke and gift store near the Plaza. It's only about 650 miles from Dallas to the capital of New Mexico, but I was taking the southern route and more than doubled the miles, racking up a leisurely 1400 miles by the time I arrived.
I take the back roads when I travel, only using an Interstate when there is no other option. (Surprisingly, there are sections of west Texas where an Interstate is the only route, not counting cow trails. Can you imagine that possibility, you east and west coasters? Of course, and not counting Alaska which doesn't really have a comparable highway infrastructure, Texas is the only state in the union where you can drive for 14 hours, much of it on freeways, and still be in the same state.)
The purpose of the southerly route was a different kind of revisiting. I read that one of my favorite pieces of public art was in danger of disappearing—succumbing prematurely to the ravages of time and myopic damage. The Prada Marfa store was once again vandalized and the local artist cum caretaker, Boyd Elder, said that the time may have arrived to stop repairing the quirky iconic art project.
The 15-foot-by-25-foot stucco cube stands alone along highway 90 in the West Texas high desert 40 miles further along from the art mecca of Marfa. The nearest town is Valentine, where with enough foresight, you can send your Valentine cards for the postmaster to mark your cards and letters. It's about the only industry in Valentine, though there is a red roofed church and a red themed Valentine Independent School District that operate amid the stucco and adobe ruins of the town.
Plug the following GPS coordinates into your Google Earth application and you can get a birds-eye view of the lonely outpost of the Italian luxury fashion empire: 30.60331252542824, -104.518436105387.
Of course, it's not really a store you can go into. It does have actual Prada purses and shoes inside (right-footed shoes only, vandals). The glass storefront is not actually glass, but a bullet-proof polycarbonate and the door doesn't operate. There are a couple of security cameras, one inside and one out, but the nearest sheriff station is 40 miles away. Cars are rare intrusions on the highway, rarer still at night. The only activity in the wee hours is an occasional yip of a coyote. However, the stars and clear and bright if you turn away from the store which illuminates the area with fluorescent lights set to a dusk to dawn timer.
Artists Michael Elmgreen from Copenhagen, Denmark, left, and Ingar Dragset from Trondheim, Norway created the Prada Marfa installation in 2005. In the image above they are standing in front of their 2008 work in Tiergarten park in Berlin memorializing the gay victims of the Nazi regime. The image is used by permission as a Creative Commons photo presented by ILGA-Europe.
After leaving Dallas well before dawn, I arrived at Fort Davis, a mountain village in the Big Bend highlands and home to the renowned McDonald Observatory. I had rented a cottage that was about 50 miles from my ultimate destination. It was late afternoon. I jettisoned some gear and a duffle and took off to check out the damage.
I was relieved. Though there was more damage than when I last visited, it was not as extensive as I had feared. There were bullet holes in the awning and bullets embedded in the polycarbonate plastic. A new layer of graffiti was on the west wall and on the back of the store and the bronze plaque on a stand was missing, apparently run over by a vehicle. I later learned that Elder was able to retrieve the sign that gave information on the artists and the project and will restore it when some contributing funds are donated.
Bullets embedded
Most boutiques, even inaccessible ones, would have mirrors in them. Here we have me reflected with my cam and tripod inserting myself in a sense into the store.
The Union Pacific rail line parallels Highway 90 from New Orleans to Van Horn, Texas east of El Paso. Much of it is lonely and spare, so it was no surprise that the engineer blew his horn and waved at me as he passed by.
A meta photo
So what will become of a beloved and quirky art installation? There have been a couple of comments on my previous posts about Prada Marfa that the graffiti (and I suppose the vandalism) is part of the art and should be embraced. It's a valid viewpoint, but one I reject and will not embrace for this installation. There is a time and place for graffiti, and an appreciation of a wonderful, at times breathtaking, art form. That doesn't mean it requires anti-contextual ubiquity—that the art itself excuses its presence.
There are exceptions. Take for example, the installation near Amarillo that has evolved to welcome the collaborative contributions of any and all who come by. The Cadillac Ranch has long since welcomed tagging artists, but even that isn't without problems. Even though there is a dumpster near the entrance gate, few, if any participants deposit their spent cans opting to drop them on the surrounding and still working farmland.
Larger view here and note the homage to OS.
A further problem—look at this image taken in August of 2007 and note No. 9 Caddy from the left.
Now look at a similar view taken less than a week ago in April of 2011and note that same No. 9 car.
Collaborative contribution is one thing, destructive vandalism is another. Someone removed the roof for a personal trophy, robbing those who would follow. You're certainly free to disagree, but I don't buy it. I believe wanton destruction is a cancerous narcissism, a selfishness that diminishes the collective experience.
In a Facebook exchange with The Big Bend Sentinel, the artist Elmgreen expressed his dismay and concerns with a representative of the Associated Press.
"If the county and the populations of Marfa and Valentine don’t think it is worth to protect the work and actively take over the responsibility of it in the future it might be necessary for us to reconsider the situation and maybe tear down the little but now rather famous building because it is even worse if it just stands there over sprayed with graffiti and bullet holes in its windows and looks like a ruin.
"It was always our intention to let the Prada Marfa disintegrate over time, but we hoped it would happen in a natural manner," Elmgreen told the AP. "There is not much entertainment along Highway 90 so, of course, the sculpture, which has become something of a landmark in the area, is an obvious target for bored vandals."
Michael Graczyk, reporting for the Associate Press said Elder explained that a recent lightning strike near the site knocked out an online video feed he monitors, making it more difficult to keep tabs on intruders. "We're going to readjust the cameras and spruce the place up," he said. "I'm hoping we're going to catch someone."
Image dedicated to mlh who still wishes upon stars with fervent faith, an endeavor outside of time, the conqueror. Larger view here.
The Prada Marfa store may go the way of the Stardust Motel, on the western edge of Marfa. The motel is now not much more than the high desert grass growing through disintegrating asphalt in a scraped empty lot. The love and pain, the lover's trysts, midnight romances and low-rent rendezvous of the now missing motel have disappeared as quickly as they occurred. Those heated exhaled vapors and desperate breaths, quick promises quickly forgotten have dissolved and disappeared into indifferent evening skies long past and forgotten. The winding stem on our own clocks only work in one direction. Time continues regardless of what we do or choose not to do. It's up to each of us to make of it what we can. Tempus fugit and things tend to decay and vanish. Get busy. Make beauty.
At some point the Prada Marfa store will disappear. I'm happy to have a personal record of it, an investment of affection and respect for public art that combines whimsy and passion with a searing social commentary even though it doubles my miles.
Your own mileage memories, of course, may vary.
My previous Marfa posts:
Coda
It was an urgent text from a friend saying "where are you?" when I learned that the day after I left the Fort Davis/Valentine/Marfa area that a wildfire consumed 200,000 acres and 40 homes. What became known as the Rockhouse Fire started not far west of Marfa fueled by a years-long drought and 40 to 50 mph winds. Those same conditions prevailed over more than half the state as well, taking more than a million acres, which prompted our secessionist governor, Rick "All Hat and No Cattle" Perry, to proclaim a "day of prayer" to last several days actually, over the Easter weekend for the Lord God and Master of the Universe to send rain and end the misery. Unfortunately, what began as a wet weekend dried up after the call was made which certainly must contain some sort of message, if only we could divine it.
Thanks to dear friend Julie Delio for the text message of concern and who knew where I generally was and didn't want me to perish and for the Texas Monthly link below.
This view is probably gone now, the Rock House Fire that came from the direction of the view burned 200,000 acres and took 40 homes. This is looking southwest from near the top of the road leading to the McDonald Observatory northwest of Fort Davis. Larger view here.
NASA Earth Observatory images of active fires:
Fort Davis and Marfa Rock House and Brewster Fires
Nine arresting images of the Rock House Fire from Texas Monthly
Thanks for visiting friends, and for all your affirmation and support these past three years. April 25 is the third anniversary of my first post on OS, though I was a member in beta long before that post as I attempted to figure out what the hell I was going to do with this site. I can go on and on at times, but it's hard to find the words to express my gratitude and appreciation. Thanks especially to Joan, Kerry, Thomas, Judy and Emily for the opportunity to be a part. Thanks to the friends who have become a part of my world and, as painful as it is, thanks to the friends who have disappeared but who are still held close.
Addendum
The non-profit that supports the site, and many other projects is the BallroomMarfa.org. There's no direct pipeline on the site to support the Prada Marfa installation, but there is a page describing the site, found in this link.
There is a Donate button on that page, but it leads to a request to call Ballroom Marfa to see how you can support. I called and talked to a delightful Nikki. She said that if you go to the main support page and scroll down to the bottom of the page, you'll see a listing for Additional Gift to Programming where you can enter any amount you desire. The drop down menu doesn't list Prada Marfa as a donation destination, but Nikki assured me that if you select General Support and send an email to info@ballroommarfa.org and say you just donated, with your name and amount, those funds will go to support the Prada Marfa store.
Thanks Connie for the suggestion...it's certainly something I should have followed up on without the prompt, so I really appreciate you getting me going on it.
all photos copyright © 2011 by barry b. doyle · all rights reserved
(except as noted otherwise)
# # #
























Salon.com
Comments
in some places the sun has a lot of weight
on other places it is lighter
Kathy, you're so right, it's tangible and weighty.
hugs, not sure what you mean by the rating issue, but thanks so much for the kind words.
diana, I just love the opera comparison, thanks so much for that and for your constant support of what art I try to put up. xo
Jan, we think alike friend. It would be good to sit and contemplate something together in quiet companionship.
http://www.ispyce.com/2010/06/ron-muech-hyper-realist-sculptor.html
to create a crashed flying saucer with dead dessicated inhabitants and place it half buried in one of the remote deserts of the West. Perhaps with a couple of sixpacks aboard and a mummified pizza unconsumed.
I love the Cadillac Ranch - it was one of the few high points about visiting Amarillo every time I go. It looks like I may be there in June - we'll see. Best to you BBD!
♥R
It shows that rural rednecks, if given enough time, would make good Bolsheviks. I, too, would annihilate such a temple to crass consumerism, albeit in a more destructive manner.
WORKERS OF THE WORLD UNITE
MH, thanks for coming by, I agree, it should go slowly and naturally.
Indelible, thanks for sharing those words by Nalick, it fits perfectly.
Sparking, let me know if and when you go to the Cadillac Ranch...it'd be worth the 6 hr drive to meet there.
bbyy, Xing jì is exactly what I love doing, and thanks so much for your kind words.
Mumbletypeg, I understand what you're saying, but for me, the Cadillac Ranch is still powerful...that it evolves in that participation is something I enjoy, so much more so since the artists have welcomed it.
Sheba, thanks so much.
Myriad, I think that's how I think of the vandalism at the PM store, a negative experience.
Joah, thanks for the compliments on both sides of this post, it's very much appreciated.
Fusun, thanks for your best wishes, they are odd, which adds to their whimsy and charm.
Ernesto, why not reveal yourself? Your viewpoints are as valid as any, though I disagree, the destruction as a value of which you speak seems an impotent narcissism to me, but I couldn't have said it better than Jan Sand's answer to you. Thanks for stopping by.
FTM, from an artist/foodie chef, your words mean a lot, thanks.
Gary, glad to have you aboard on the travels. Thanks so much for your long and consistent support.
Satori, for texas to be seen, it has to be on the byways, not the highways. I hope you can take a different route next time...thanks too for your kind words.
Steve, thanks...and thanks for your PM suggesting a route north from Marfa/Van Horn. I really enjoyed that and have a panorama I need to share with you.
Jan, your perspicacity is keen, and to my mind, exactly correct. Thank you.
Mary, I'm humbled by your words, that only a true poet could utter. Thank you. xo
I have been on a road trip myself, and hope to do a photo narrative soon. The hard part is choosing the best of 500...yikes.
Thanks you for such a stellar trip, one I no doubt will be making again, and again!
R
suggestion: Post a link for those who might wish to donate to the Save the Marfa Prada Store fund...?
I was thinking of the words "Rust Never Sleeps" after looking at a few of these shots. I'm certainly not surprised - I'm sure you weren't either - at the damage to the "store." I remember recoiling when first seeing spray painting on sacred ancient ruins. I guess the damage and graffiti speaks to the culture at large.
Btw, Congats on your third anniversary. Your photos have made this site easy on the eyes.
Secondly, let me answer Connie re the suggestion for donating to support the Prada Marfa art installation. I'll also put a link at the end of the story so that people can support the site. As you might imagine, the supporting organization relies on gifts and donations to support the arts and specific projects.
The non profit that supports the site, and many other projects is the BallroomMarfa.org. There's no direct pipeline on the site to support the Prada Marfa installation, but there is a page describing the site, found here:
http://ballroommarfa.org/archive/event/prada-marfa/
There's even a Donate button on that page, but it leads to a request to call Ballroom Marfa to see how you can support. I called and talked to a delightful Nikki. She said that if you go to the main support page, found here:
http://ballroommarfa.org/support/
and scroll down to the bottom of the page, you'll see a listing for Additional Gift to Programming where you can enter an amount of your choosing. The drop down menu doesn't list Prada Marfa as a donation destination, but Nikki assured me that if you select General Support and send an email to info@ballroommarfa.org and say you just donated, with your name and amount, those funds will go to support the Prada Marfa store.
Thanks Connie for the suggestion...it's certainly something I should have followed up on without the prompt, so I really appreciate you getting me going on it.
I'll respond to the new comments just after adding the donation information to the end of the piece as a second coda.
Thanks all!
Jan, unfortunately, I'm much the same way.
Annikins, xo
Jeanette, that shot has become a favorite of mine as well...a friend was being wistful about the stars in the sky during a recent conversation, so I dedicated the shot, with only a single star, to that friend. Means a lot to me, as does your appreciation of it and your constant support.
Linnn, delighted that you get it.
Harry, I just have to disagree, a creation that embodies disagreement doesn't have to involve vandalism and destruction...it's just too easy. I think you nail the sentiments concerned though.
Lea, thanks for that lovely thought. Made my day.
Cathy, you are another friend who has been a terrific supporter for the past three years. Thanks so much for your friendship and for your comments here.
Connie, thanks again for the push.
Scarlett, thanks so much for your lovely words.
congruous with all positions
And I have been wondering for awhile now, if this need to leave a mark on things isn't innate. A few years back, I was visiting a friend in Segovia, Spain. Every day, I would climb the steps along the wall of the old city, where the Aqueduct of Segovia ended in a fountain. And every day, I'd tsk over the graffiti painted on its stones. I'd think, who are these fools? Do they really think their words can compare? Who the hell thinks it is a good idea to deface World Heritage Sites? It wasn't tourists - this was winter and they don't pack cans of spray paint. tsk-tsk, that was me, for five days. And then my friend and I were walking under a different part of the Aqueduct and she pointed out some stones in the arches where Romans, nearly 2000 years ago, had carved initials. And instead of tsking, I marveled. And the very next morning I didn't know what to think about the graffiti.
We were in Dallas while you were in New Mexico. My husband had a conference, so we drove down to the Bosque del Apache for a day, spent another day near Roswell and then a night in Abilene. We drove up around Possum Kingdom Lake, because who can resist a name like that and also because we wanted to photograph scissortail flycatchers. After the conference, we drove all the way to northern Kansas. All of that totaled a lot of miles through empty country, and it was a wonderful trip.
When I was a little girl (back when Kansas schools taught geology, among other sciences), I marveled at the way the Grand Canyon had been cut one grain of sand at a time. As I've grown older, I've realized that's not the case. The grains of sand slip by at the bottom of the canyon until a million tons of undermined rock come crashed down. Time conquers in fits and starts, not all of them particularly dignified. Between Rico and Cortez, a small cabin has stood on a hillside for as long as I can remember and probably 130 years before that. This year, it collapsed under the weight of the snow. The abandoned house across the street from the church falls apart piece by piece. I hear a piece of roofing tin flapping in the wind for months on end, and then one night the sound is gone, the tin blown away, another part of the house exposed to the elements. I'll have a better view when it's gone, but it's part of the world as I know it and I'll mourn when it falls in on itself.
We want the world to keep pace with us, I think, and it doesn't even notice us. That's a good thing, I'm convinced, and we should strive to remain unnoticed by the environment, but it's a hard lesson to learn.
Thank you for this and all your wonderful photo essays. Once again, I'm awed.
http://www.npr.org/2011/04/25/135705721/crochet-vandals-do-graffiti-like-your-grandma
ume, I'm very pleased with your meaningful comment, thanks very much.
Suresh, thank you for your kind words as well, and thanks so much for looking at both sides of the post, both the words and the images.
Marcelle, it does mean a lot coming from you...and not in any way being dismissive of any other comment, but it has more to do with what I know of you, your own artistic abilities which are broad, and the amazing art in how you write. I feel much the same way, that I love the stunning beauty in graffiti, and especially it's transformative nature in certain settings. It's interesting how we see things in context when history is involved. My own experience mirrors yours when at Newgrange in Ireland, and going into the bowels of the massive burial mound through a narrow passage and discovering the ancient graffiti there...curious juxtapositions that made me think through it as well.
Also, thanks Marcelle, for your very consistent support in our time together here on OS. I know you don't post here as you did at the beginning, and I understand even though that is a loss for me personally and for the members and beyond at large. Whatever goes forward, you've been and will remain a treasured friend. That you enjoy, appreciate and understand what I do means the world to me. I can't thank you enough. xo
HL, after having met you, and know you as a person who walks the talk, you words have an intrinsic and beautiful weight for me. You say "unnoticed by the environment" but I know you know that's not the same as trying to make a difference. The forces are inexorable, but we can be stewards of our own section of time as a gift to ourselves and ours and others progeny.
You were at Possum Kingdom Lake soon before it exploded into a fiery furnace...they're saying now it will take generations, perhaps 80 years or so to recover from the devastation...of course complicated by climate change, which some deny.
Karin, thanks so much for stopping by, it's much appreciated as is your encouraging words.
Connie, I saw that on the NPR website and thought it just fascinating. Thanks for the link, it's a terrific story.
/R+
I've always had a fundamental problem with vandalism and destruction. To me, it represents a basic lack of respect for the artist and for anyone who might want to enjoy the work in its intended condition.