SEPTEMBER 15, 2009 11:16AM

What lurk beneath? "If this be treason, make the most of it"

Rate: 10 Flag

"Give me liberty, or give me death."

"These are the times that try men's [and Ladies] souls."

"I only regret that I have one life to lose for my country."

"Don't fire [postal clerk] till you see the whites of their eyes."

"I can't tell a lie."

`

What do those words mean? What are the real stories behind them?

"We hold these truths" ....

Patrick Henry may never have said:`If this is treason, make the most of it. 

`

The Stamp Act became law in 1765. This required colonist to pay for postage to affix to legal papers and love letters. The troops, after all, needed to be paid. Troops were to protect colonial land grabbers who loved to rob Native Folk from their well tended Real Estate. Well?

You know that the invading French and Indians wanted territory too. The people were getting inflamed. People everywhere began believing that these taxes were in bad taste. They were violation- taxes. The lightening and thunder roaring was beginning to rumble. The ferment was felt too.

Patrick Henry addressed the Virginia House of Burgesses. Here's how [howling] William Wirt described the scene in his biography, which was first published in 1817:`

Henry exclaimed in a voice of thunder, and with a look of a god:`Cesar had his Brutas - Charles the First, his Cromwell - and George the Third - ('Treason!'

Cried Patrick Henry the speaker - Treason, treason! Echoed from every part of the house .... Henry faltered not for an instant; but rising to a loftier attitude, and fixing on the speaker an eye of the most determined fire, he finished his sentence with the firmest emphasis)--may profit from their example.

"If this be treason, make the most of it." Did Henry say that? I don't know.

*

One eyewitness quoted by Wirt was a young student of law, Thomas Jefferson. "I well remember the cry treason," Jefferson told Wirt, "the pause of Mr. Henry at the name of George 111, and the presence of mind he closed his sentence, and baffled the charge vociferated."

Henry stirred citizens and strongly was condemming  the acts of Parliament. A chasm was deepening. Henry put it in this writ way:`

Light and heat were seen and felt throughout the continent; and  ... everywhere there was talk about colonial liberty ... The spirit of great resistance became bolder and bolder, until the continent was in a flame."

Words get overshadowed. Henry latter commented:`No taxation without representation." There were eyewitnesses and people took sides. People were becoming horrified. The most "sober and virtuous part of these audiences ... some of whom did murmur at the time, 'treason! treason!"

Despite the claim of Henry's 1776 response to the cries of treason, it's by no means clear he ever suggested making the most of it. Biographer and historian Mr. Wirt's recollections were  compiled decades after the event. In 1921 an anonymous Frenchman - whose report was written just one day after the speech in a private journal declares a different story:`

Henry confronted with the accusation of treason, immediately apologized to the entire audience and pledged loyalty to the king. Personally, I (me) find this very interesting.

`

The Frenchman wrote:`

Shortly after I came in, one of the members stood up and said he had read in former times Tarquin and Julus had their Brutus, Charles had his Cromwell, and he did not doubt that  some good Americans would stand up, in favor of his country, but (say he) in a more moderate manner, and was going to continue, when the speaker of the house rose and said, he, the last that stood up had spoken treason, and was sorry to see that not one of the members of the house was loyal enough to stop him, before he had gone too far.

Henry was backpedaling recognizing he has gone too far? Was Wirts account, then, no different from those of Parson Weems, the biographer of George Washington who invented a story of chopping down the pretty cherry tree? 

Patrick Henry gave a speech. It "seized the  pillars of the temple, shook them terribly, and seemed to threaten his opponents with ruin" ...

And it's written "the fainthearted gathered courage ... And cowards became the era's  of the heroes, while they gazed upon their exploits."

My o day, wild.

I just don't know.

I know I gotta behave.

I'll clean cans from farm trucks. 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I gotta get. I feel sullied as a barn cat who sits with baited goat cheese breath at a mouse hole waiting for a comment. Maybe while I'm typing this someone will write something smart-arse.I flea and heehaw like a Jack Daniel's pup crossed with a stinky billy cheshire goat? Goats have good baby sweet smelling breath! I just bantering.
`
This habit of @ Open Salon posting and commenting can get Ya into more predicaments. This blogging can create a bad-climate for lies, lice, fleas, and scandals.

We sure can act the role of scanty polite poster/commenters. Scanty politeness. We scold, quarrel, wear scanty clothes, or, and some folk wear absolutely no clothes.

We can chuckle and snort sounds that seem to imitate toothless hens and rooster chickens.
In the old days in the rural woods the scared cheaters did not dare eat cheese flavored Cheetah.
They ate lizards and leopard.
Ya strolled in a saloon drunk.
Ya anticipated that You'd kiss.
Today Ya's jailed and slapped.
Upon entrance in wild saloon?
Ya sat down to a game of poker.
Ya smelled of sardines in soy oil.
Ya offered to buy the baked bean.
Now we buy vanilla bean ice cream.
That taste great with packed herring.
Cans can will fetch 40- cents a pound.
Times are wild. We best grab hoes too!
Weed beets!
scram. okay!
gotta get go!
Hi Arthur-I love this "I feel sullied as a barn cat who sits with baited goat cheese breath at a mouse hole waiting for a comment." I know just what you mean!
Thanks for a great post...again!
Rated
Hi Arthur-I love this "I feel sullied as a barn cat who sits with baited goat cheese breath at a mouse hole waiting for a comment." I know just what you mean!
Thanks for a great post...again!
Rated
Arthur, leave it to you to teach American history to people in the mist of debate that do not know their history.
Great Post, as per
Hi! Dear junk # one! To say Ya is # one is the highest verbal mumbled utterance. Junk` is # 1!

You knows commons ay, too!
You are Junk # one me culpa!
I mean:`mensch of real quality!
`
I visited the farm that's bristling with Life's animations. I wish You were at my side. A phobic muchacha? You a young muchacho, huh?
tease. banter.
Cho is a boy.
Cha cha's a gal.
Ya sport a stud?
I mean a nose stud?
Ya companion plant?
Ya wear a 'speedo' suit?
Ya no wear a-matching socks?
Do You smile gently or smirk?
You like buttered bagel and lick?
I mean no wrong. Ya lick butter lips?
You mind lending me a pair of socks?
You may like bagels and lox? butters?
Smiling warmly, giggling gently, a kiss?
okay.
a fantasy.
a pure intent.
imaginations.

I went to far. The feds are watching me!
So- I say:`Eat, drink, sip wine, and toast!
Tell the truth. All people want is the truth!

I love living in the shadow of the executioner?
That's to say:`If You want to be alive:`Be true!
Ya never will see congressman/women Be true?
`
I visited a busy farm. A poppy seed bagel with lox.
Farmers listen to me. They shook their lame heads.
I ask them to pardon my late arrival:`Why I no hoe!
'Um chuckle and snort that they can manage a Farm!
O Yea!
Finally!
No farm?
No beer!
No corny.
No beets!
`
Junk # 1?
I think people may understand our Cultural Crisis? I hope so - the suffering will be a mutual experience. An agrarian voice is rarely heard in cultural debate, even if the politicians pay 'lip service' to care for the poor. baloney! pure textured pink bad meat goulash!

Last night there was a eulogy ref;`Death of a chemical grain Pulitzer Rock-a-Feller grower that advocated a dependence on the WW2- Agra-business model, and the baloney CEO Wall Street stock-holder money-make- greedy ilk-rakes in the dough! Everybody knows these 'Roundup' dependent grain-crops ruin the ecosystem, water, air, and destroy Natures natural biodiversity. To be honest? They cause cancers. Where is social concern and true-well-being conversation?
`
Wow are the topic/discussions skewed!
What cultural malaise! Why no focus?
The problems only mount. Oh a ethos!
Let's aim to be close to policy makers?

Socrates said:`I am amazed at the junk.
Socrates said:`Why buy such junk stuff?
Socrates would compliment Junk # One!
Junk1? Stop over to sip some # One teas?
I read that Socrates loved good libations!
`
Mead is made with honey and luscious fruit.
Sometimes it's nice to lull and be languorous.
Eat tea, raisons, figs, and celebrate ceremony.
Respectfully,
a sipping tea,
water can be?
sip libations.
Ay be merry.
I'll go back to the farm to say:`I've been hearing hiccups and I am biting my lips.
I vow silence.
I vow hiccups.
fondle melons.
eat good fruits.
eat raspberries.
eat good berries.
eat in the shower.
If this is corny, heh
scanner? It's so busy here today.
I heard from the trucker scanner:`
Beautiful Bertha's in town to kiss Ya!
I am in/out and maybe a shammer too?
What did William Carlos Williams say? "It is difficult to get the news from poems/but men die daily for lack of what is found there." I bet I misquoted him, but that's what you are for me, Arthur James. One of the best news sources around. rated.
Dragon Lady?
If you wore a cheap wig I'd snort flames.
I mean:`You make me 'blush' colored today.
You remind me of a May - Beltaine wine brew.
You probably love exotic drinks:`Pomegranates?
That's not a impure imagination:`Blossom honey's!
Maybe I need to go pick:`Chaste Tree monk pepper?
Fresh salads with colorful Nasturtium taste delicious!
Chaste Tree looks like a 5- leaf pot plant. eat. no smoke!
Behaving isn't all it's cracked up to be! I like the history lesson - good to remember what's gone before, as context for current events, in general.
Owl_Says_Who? Owl? Fly `round tonight?
If you see a snarling Doberman or politician?
Please stuff mouths with a moth and katydid?
Please place gently a baby pacifier fake nipple?
Place a bull-tail in the politico's big loud mouth?
Owl_Says_Who can fly around like the loony bat?
Owls see in the dark and can turn the head around!
I like P. Henry. Did they ever collect all his bone so he could be burried in one place. He got around even when dead.
Are you telling me that the American Revolution has been... enveloped in myth?!?

Say it ain't so! ;-D

Personally, I loved it when I discovered the details about the British raid on the weapons cache at Concord. I always thought that would have consisted of muskets and such, but no: The peaceful farmers of Massachusetts had three heavy siege guns (probably of French manifacture) buried in the courtyard of the local jail.

I wonder why...
Norwonk. I don't know nothing for certain.
I remember being at Tivoli Garden in the 70's.
I wonder where that Norwegian women went?
A opera and meal afterwards was a heaven sup.
Then, we walked out to see the black mermaid.
Ya may tell us about Hans Christian Anderson?
That walk along the water canal made me weary.
I still remember loving Norwegian's hospitality.
I thing the pub where Sam Adams said:`Wake up!
The Place where they supped brew was discussion!
A farmers grew grain and barley growers for beers!
The Silversmiths made fine tea kettles. O my Cheer!
The Boston Mass- crew supped at the Green Dragon!
Grow goof-hop? Maybe we can be stewed and behave?