When my friend Mary Tom got married, her mama got into it with the caterer over the reception menu. The caterer had sniffed at the proposed menu, which included pimento cheese sandwiches.
Mary Tom’s mama told the caterer that he may have come to Mobile lately by way of New York, but she knew his granny, and she was from Georgianna, so he shouldn’t be pretending he was too good for pimento cheese sandwiches. That she was paying for this whole shebang and there would be no mushrooms wrapped in poof pastry on the buffet line. That when she arrived on the day of the wedding she’d better see pimento cheese on bread or he’d be red-assed from her shoe and on the way back to Georgianna before the sun went down. (Which was an empty threat because Mary Tom’s mama liked to keep a wide mouth Ball jar full of gin in her car, and long before sundown the gin would have dropped below the words "wide mouth" pressed into the glass, down toward the bottom, and she’s a lovely drunk.)
Despite my attire -- a teal taffeta bridesmaid’s dress with a buttbow the size of a treasured carp -- it was a fine wedding and the pimento cheese sandwiches were especially fine.
All across the South, pimento cheese sandwiches are de rigeur for showers (wedding and baby), receptions, dances, teas and other celebrations. Not funerals. Pimento cheese is happy food. Now, there are two kinds of pimento cheese: homemade pimento cheese and inedible pimento cheese. If you are ever called before God and asked to speak the truth, use that one.
Last year I sent my daughter off to college. She called me one day, not long into her exile.
"Mom! Quick question. I bought pimento cheese at the grocery store yesterday..."
"Let me get dressed," I said.
"What? No. I bought pimento cheese at the grocery store and..."
"If I leave now, I’ll be there by five. Splash some water on your face and don’t go to sleep!"
"What are you talking about?" she asked.
"Well, if you bought pimento cheese at the grocery store, you’ve obviously got a head injury. If you’re uninjured, I question your judgement."
"Me too." She sighed so heavily that I wondered about all the other ways her judgement might have recently failed her. "How do you make it? I’ve been telling all my friends how great pimento cheese is, and now I’ve lost credibility."
I talked her through the recipe, and when I hung up I felt a little sad – thinking about my daughter in heathen lands, Mary Tom’s tragic marriage, and all that happened with Mary Tom’s mama. So I made myself a batch of pimento cheese, and before long I was happy again. Pimento cheese on bread can do that.

Bellwether’s Pimento Cheese
8 oz block of extra sharp cheddar cheese, grated (You must grate your own – the pre-grated product will not cream into a spread.)
4 oz jar pimentos, drained very thoroughly and finely diced
3 Tbsp sour cream (or one large dollop)
2 green onions, mostly tops, finely minced
1/4 tsp garlic powder
1/4 tsp ground red pepper
About 2 Tbsp good mayonnaise (Hellman’s please)
Freshly cracked black pepper to taste (You won’t need any salt, and I never say that.)
In a medium-sized bowl, mix together the sour cream, onions, cheese, garlic powder and ground red pepper until the cheese begins to break down into a spread. Stir in the pimentos. Add the mayonnaise a little bit at a time until you reach your desired consistency. It should spread easily, but it shouldn’t be gloppy. Add pepper to taste. Refrigerate for at least two hours.
The daughter likes to use this as a dip for pretzels. I like it as a sandwich, on toasted wheat bread with a bit of dark mustard. It’s also good on a hamburger or veggie burger in place of sliced cheese. We almost always have a bowl of pimento cheese in our fridge.
**Mary Tom’s husband died suddenly of an undiagnosed heart condition, leaving her with two children under the age of four. Mary Tom’s mama has dementia that her doctor swears is unrelated to the gin. My daughter is still in heathen lands, but now that she has the pimento cheese recipe, I don’t worry about her quite as much.**


Salon.com
Comments
Rated with fervent intensity.
Fay - You will eat pimento cheese and you'll LIKE it! ;)
Kathy -- Thanks. It is yum. If maybe an acquired taste.
Lucy -- It's not traditional, but the green onions, the sour cream, garlic powder and red pepper add a lot.
Elisa -- My granny made it too. Memory lane...
Liberal -- Yes, it will get you through a lot. Instant picnic too! Thanks for reading.
Joan -- No, your coffee ice cream with a spoon sounds much better.
Great descriptive phrases used!
R
BTW, a really wonderful thing to do with pimento cheese is to spread it in a casserole dish and bake it 'til it's gooey. It makes a great party dip.
and then a recipe i've been trying to find for years, so thanks for that although if i had some in my frig at all times ... well, i won't say 'cuz that may be the only time pimento cheese didn't make one happy.
One question: I detest mayonnaise of any kind; would it be possible to substitute something else? Extra sour cream, maybe? (Or is it blasphemy to even consider it? :))
my *new* pimento cheese recipe inserts some cream cheese and you KNOW that anything with cream cheese ain/t bad.
Fernsy -- Aw thanks Fernsy! Hugs with fervent intensity!
Buffy -- Store bought yucky yuck. I don't even know what that is. It tastes like greasy-textured plastic.
LCNeal -- I never ate it with baloney as a kid, but I'll bet it tasted dang good.
Jeanette -- That DOES sound good! I've also never heard of that brand. It couldn't be that hard to make a store-bought version that tastes good, I just haven't found one here.
Owl -- Fly away free! (Let me know if you try it.)
Greenheron -- That sounds yummy! I like anything with cream cheese in it. I've made something similar with grated carrots, olives, green onions and sunflower seeds. Now I'm craving that...
Midwest Muse -- I have to admit I've never made my own mayonnaise, but it's something I've wanted to try because I'm sure it's divine and would make every recipe calling for mayo taste ten thousand times better.
Femme -- Thanks a bunch for the compliment. It is dangerous to have a big bowl in the fridge all the time! I tell myself its better than having to eat fast food for lunch...but, really, I'm not sure that's true.
Ame i -- Mary Tom's mama did say it that way, because she was from a very good family. In my far less pedigreed family it's puh-me-un-toe cha-ay-z. The accents here aren't nearly as genteel and refined as some!
Not yet born -- No recipe is sacred in my book. You could certainly substitute more sour cream (or like Dianaani says -- cream cheese) or even plain yogurt. Why not? Those who don't like pimentos can even substitute finely diced roasted red peppers. The taste and texture are similar.
Zul -- I'm glad you popped in and found the recipe you've been looking for (or one like it).
Sophieh -- You're welcome, Sophie -- and it's always good to see you.
Dianaani -- Mary Tom is still struggling in some ways. I do worry for her. Cream cheese would be an excellent addition or substitution!
Cindy -- Thank you! Mary Tom's mama was (is) a handful. She wears caftans.
Saturn -- I hope you do. Thanks for reading and commenting. :)
Love your writing too.
I don't know where in the south you are from, honey, but come on over anytime. A girl who knows her pimento cheese is a girl worth knowing.
Gordon -- I've used pimentos for years without really knowing what they are. Apparently, a little mild pepper (a bit like a red bell pepper), quite sweet with no heat.
Luck o' the Griswolds -- Yes Jeanette's suggestion has lured me, taunted me...I will TRY! Even though I'm a cold sandwich person and in fact I craved COLD Ruben sandwiches when I was pregnant.
Diary -- With all of the food choices available there is no reason to revisit reviled foods of your childhood...unless you want to! Sometimes food is all about memory. If it brings up bad memories, give it a pass, and move onto something safer (and healthier anyway)!
Nora -- is Cheerwine anything like Scuppernong wine? It's really really sweet and variably potent? If so, I'm with you. I don't want to be with you. But I'm with you!
BlackBart --- Ah. Yes! You know.
Gratefuldan -- I was going to say you could sub low fat this for low fat that, but no...It would mess with your diet. The only consolation is that if you have a pimento cheese sandwich for lunch you won't be snacking or heading out for fast food. You should, however, pick some beans or cotton to work it off.
Lulu -- I'll make the tea to whatever sweetness you want it. Just come...
Librarienne -- Yes, not too smooth or it feels greasy. :)
Gracielou -- I have no problem with roasted red peppers being subbed for pimentos. I almost think if they had been available way back when it would be called "roasted red pepper cheese." (Glad to know ya!)
Scupper -- That's so sweet! I hope one day you'll write about that. (Not that pimento cheese lends itself to poetry. But if anyone could tackle it, you could.)
Clark -- Well, I have arrived! Thanks for visiting and for your acknowledgement. You are a scholar and a mumbleman.
Kim -- It's a pretty straightforward recipe. Nuttin fancy, but it's symbolic, somehow, here. I love to read about similar regional favorites from faraway places. I think that if I try them, I might be transported, and maybe that's true!
Eileen -- DO NOT eat something called "pimento cheese" that someone bought at Walmart. Seriously, I'm not a snob. Or a neat freak. Or any other words you'd use to describe people who are fastidious/elitist.....although I kinda admire expensive shoes (but, shhh!). If you make it yourself, following some common sense guidelines (provided within the recipe), you'll be fine even if you veer off course and add other ingredients. Grated sharp cheddar...some type of roasted pepper...a binder (sour cream, mayo, cream cheese)...have fun!
but no Dukes? what kind of upbringing did you have? next thing you'll be telling us to put dark meat in the chicken salad. Girl, you better get right.
Emma -- It is good and dead simple. (Happy to see you!)
Your recipe sounds wonderful and I would make it but someone else would have to chop the pimientos. Please. I'll bait my own hook, but I will not chop pimientos.
"Despite my attire -- a teal taffeta bridesmaid’s dress with a buttbow the size of a treasured carp"...please let me draw that! (r)
Your story is so funny and heartwarming... thanks for sharing it.
Rated.
Dirndl -- If anyone could do justice to that dress you could! It was truly horrid as was (in retrospect) Mary Tom's dress. She says we let her down when we didn't tell her it was not a flattering dress.
Pilgrim -- It is addictive. :)
consonantsandvowels - I love books where there are recipes intertwined with the story. Like Water for Chocolate is a favorite!
k b -- That IS friendship! I'll bet it's a marvelous recipe and when you share it with a friend it's even tastier.
GirlyBoyMama -- She never had a problem telling anyone what for. In the sweetest drawl. I hope you do try the recipe!
Jason -- Excellent!!!
Mumbletypeg -- I've had some versions that made me want to wipe my tougue off with a Lysol wipe, so I can imagine the taste of what you have endured. Extra sharp cheddar cheese is the key, and almost any recipe you use that has the extra sharp cheddar will turn out tasty.
Thoth -- Now that's a sight I'd love to see. Thoth grating cheese and making sandwiches!
Paige -- Nice to meet ya! I look forward to getting to know you. This is a great place to meet alter-egos and lost twins. And I wish Gilmore would write another book. I'm sure I'd love it.
Jonathan -- I hope you try it and report back.
2mchwork -- I'm glad you enjoyed the piece and I know what you mean. About "South" and Weight Watchers!
Outrider -- Yayay! I'm so happy that you tried it and enjoyed it.
(BTW, Dukes can be found in the Winn Dixie - don't say I sent you but I love the stuff)
My favorite sandwich is this: hearty wheat bread, smeared with spicy mustard and browned in a butter-drenched skillet. When the bread is butter-fried, spread one slice with tuna salad and the other side with pimento cheese. Smack those two slices together.