I just read Ann Nichols’ take on Eat, Pray, Love. Like Ann, I have mixed feelings about the book. Gilbert does appear to suffer from the attractive, well-to-do woman’s burden – ennui – but there isn’t anything about being privileged that protects you from unpleasant feelings even if it seems like there should be, certainly not as a right, but as evidence of emotional upward mobility. Shouldn’t someone be happy? Shouldn’t everyone have a hope of getting there? I don’t begrudge Gilbert her journey or her resulting happiness, and my only problem with her book is the manifesto — eat, pray, love. As revelations, none of those words work for me.
I’ve never needed reminding to eat or to love. I happily consume things others revile, like slimy boiled okra and buttermilk straight from the carton; I love things that are distinctly unlovable, like my daughter’s creepy-pink, hairless rat who has one shrunken eye and one protruding eye and does nothing but run a squeaky wheel spraying urine as she runs. I love that rat.
I also have an uneasy relationship with prayer. When prayer appears to work, I wonder if I would have had the same outcome without praying, and when it doesn’t work, I feel cheated. If it’s true that God has a plan, then what’s the point of groveling? Of course I still pray, for the same reason I revere duct tape. I’m all about the easy fix.
So I started thinking about what my three words might be, words that would succinctly sum up some surprising life lessons, revelations at this turning point in my life – middle age. In the spirit of Gilbert's title, I came up with feet, say, shrug.
Feet — I could write an entire book about my feet. Each heel and toe has a long list of grievances (yes, yes, she got roast beef, and you got none), physical traumas and psychological issues related to finger envy, but to sum it up briefly: in my younger years, I abused my feet terribly. I frequently strapped them into perilous carnival rides, ignoring their throbbing squeals as we painfully teetered along. I have apologized with orthopedic inserts and cork footbeds, yet I remain unforgiven. Who knew feet had such long memories?
Say — When I am very old, inhaling and exhaling in a death rattle, I will remember all the times I didn’t say what I wanted to say. I ate and prayed and loved, but I didn’t say what needed to be said, at the time it needed to be said. My tongue deliberately lagged behind my brain, mistaking subjugation for prudence. There are, however, some good things about getting older. I mean, if you are no longer a girl, then trying to be a good girl is pointless. While I haven’t given my tongue absolute freedom, it’s liberating to imagine that one fine day, I will have my say.
Shrug — As a gesture and a philosophy "shrug" is best illustrated by an anecdote.
In the aftermath of a hurricane, word spreads fast about the first restaurant to get power, the first gas station, the first laundromat. Last hurricane, it was the laundromat owned by Kim, a diminutive Korean despot.
If your family has gone a week without air conditioning and hot water, it is a given that you smell like goat ass and that you have a carload of gamey clothing that needs to be either washed immediately or burned in sacrifice to the weather gods. Choosing the former, I took my turn at the laundromat, and watched as Miss Cotton Blossom Festival came in with her monogrammed canvas tote full of Lily Pulitzer, followed closely by Trouble (her shirt said so) dragging a bulging trash bag of tank tops and booty shorts.
It became clear that although Miss Cotton Blossom Festival might know which fork to use for the chilled asparagus, she was completely unfamiliar with laundromat etiquette. For example, if people are waiting for the machines, it’s unpardonable to let your clothing sit in the machine — even for a second — after the washing or drying is complete. Well, Blossom sat there, drawling into her cell phone for a full three minutes after her washing machine stopped spinning. She did it again with the second machine she had commandeered.
I looked over at Trouble to see if she was fashioning a shiv from a detergent scoop. Catching my gaze, she flattened her mouth into a comic line and gave a dramatic, drawn-out shrug.
Blossom witnessed the shrug, raised a haughty chin and blushed furiously just as Kim strode over to berate her with a wagging finger and rapid clucks of obvious disapproval. After that, Blossom watched her laundry like a dog watches for popsicle drips.
I’ve used that shrug in many times since — to inject a little humor into tense situations, to let others know I’m paying attention but I just don’t care all that much, to remind myself not to care all that much. In that manner, shrug might be the opposite of say: separate the important from the unimportant; know when to speak.
If Gilbert’s book encourages others to name their own three words, then the book has served a valuable purpose and is entirely deserving of its success. Maybe this needs to be an open call — what's your three-word manifesto?


Salon.com
Comments
Love that you love that creepy pink rat!
Loved this. I'll be thinking of my 3 word manifesto - it's just not popping to mind yet. When it does, you'll be the first to know!
(A former prime minister's biography was called "Shrug: Trudeau in Power". No one should ever underestimate what a well-timed shrug can do.)
Hilarious. Finger envy? So true!
I want to make sweet love to that disastrous rat. I disagree that she/he is unlovable. That rat stole my heart with that shrunken eye. Spraying urine be damened. Is he/she single?
Off I go to savor the rest of this succulent post.
I have no problem with my feet, but knowing when to say or shrug is valuable knowledge.
The sentence about the rat is classic.
what three words? hmmm. 'sing' is one.
oh, and i love "If it’s true that God has a plan, then what’s the point of groveling?" hysterically funny.
Come to my world bellwether..
Loved this and rated it with hugs
Rated for Miss Cotton Blossom Festival and Trouble with the tank tops and booty shorts. Fantastic image that will stick in my brain a long, long time.
Loved this, Bell...you always paint the most colorful images with your words. By the way, I'm still trying to kiss up to my feet for years of misdeeds.
I know I could do better, but not nearly as well as you, Ms. Vance. I hope Reese Witherspoon plays you in the movie "Feet. Say. Shrug."
I'm going to have to give this some thought as to my three weords because a certain three come to mind too easily. I'll keep them to myself for now. Another, Ha!
I thought Gilbert's book was blasphemy and reeked of white middle-class privileged not to mention cultural appropriation but hey, that's just me. Under the circumstance, I like your three words way better.
I have so much to learn about say and shrug, and when to do each. And then there is this:
I’ve never needed reminding to eat or to love. I happily consume things others revile, like slimy boiled okra and buttermilk straight from the carton; I love things that are distinctly unlovable, like my daughter’s creepy-pink, hairless rat who has one shrunken eye and one protruding eye and does nothing but run a squeaky wheel spraying urine as she runs. I love that rat.
Hmmm, goat ass.
BTW, I learned the art of the shrug this summer. It pretty much summed up the entire summer and will quite possibly prove even more useful when school starts next week. _r
Bonnie -- I severely underestimated the feet. I wish I had known.
Sparking -- Your three words will be profoundly moving. Courage is one.
Mypsyche -- Wow! I want your three words. Play.The.Lottery. That's the only way I'll see millions.
Boanerges -- I'm going to look for that bio. Until that moment, I never thought about the shrug, but it is powerful.
Owl -- I was just suprised that Trouble knew the shrug and I didn't. A lesson I wasn't expecting.
Gabby -- I'm in that cycle too. I walk my laps and shower. Write. Sleep. Walk my laps and shower. Cook. Hose off...On a positive note, when I'm walking I've been seeing the squirrels shred pinecones, which is supposed to mean that we'll have a cold winter.
Fernsy -- Oh yea, that rat is single. Well, she was attached, but her former cagemate was the one that scratched out her left eye. Being a rat sucks far more than being Elizabeth Gilbert.
Cranky -- No problem with feet? Well, you must be a man.
Densie -- The power of duct tape must equal the power of a higher being. I'm sure of it.
Hugs -- I can't wait to know what yours would be. I don't think "love" is a problem for you either.
Linda -- I'm kind of sad that the trend toward statement t-shirts has passed. It made things a lot simpler.
Bluestocking -- I know you have AT LEAST three words!
Femme -- Oooh..."sing" would be my fourth word. Maybe my first, but it didn't fit in with Gilbert's title.
Fusuna -- I could get behind those words.
Katy B. -- Report back!
Ann -- If gave my feet access to a pencil, we'd be off to the races. 400 pages before the week was out.
Linda -- Who knew? Right? Foot care needs to be taught along with sex ed in middle school.
Lea -- I haven't seen that post, but I'm headed that way. Knowing your travels, I'm sure your post beats Gilbert's book, hands down.
Scanner -- Your three words would certainly be a relevation. We could all learn a lot from you and your experiences.
Froggy -- There were others at the laundromat, wearing all sorts of ill-advised clothing. At least I wasn't reduced to wearing my "You should see this wet" t-shirt.
Jonathan -- Yep. Your wife and I -- we know about de-feet.
Lisa -- Tired is one of my words. Not an inspirational word, however, so we aren't supposed to write about those.
Lucy -- Reese would certainly fire her agent were that suggested. But now you have me thinking -- who would play me? Nathan Lane or Jeffery Tambor?
Libmomrn -- Well, I checked it out of the library so maybe my tolerance was higher than if I had paid for it.
Surly -- I haven't seen any interviews. I just keep seeing the Julia Roberts promos. As a writer myself, I keep thinking -- Damn! Just, Damn!
Scarlett -- When you unleash your tongue, (you mean you haven't already???) we'll all need to stand waaaay back! Yeah, I get the insufferable qualities you describe -- but I like to think that in person we'd like her. Maybe?
Noah -- I'm ten, so any post with "poo" in the title is a winner in my book.
Kimberly -- It would be hard to screw that prayer up. I'm going to use that one from now on.
Caroline -- No no no...don't listen to me. Except, you are younger than me, so take care of your feet. I'm pretty sure you have the say and shrug already.
Lemon -- Thanks. If it feet, say, shrug needed a score, you'd find the perfect song.
Bea -- She's a sweet rat, but they pee everywhere. I'm trying to post more often. The real world keeps intruding.
Rosy -- With your rich history, your words will be wise indeed.
Stim -- I'd never dis the ennui. It's my favorite state of being behind "manic." Goat ass. You mean you've never smelled it?
LC -- I figured yours would be Write. Write. Write. Talk about a squeaky wheel -- you're an energizer rat!
Fernsy -- Let's you and I see the movie together. It would be insufferable if I had to watch it with anyone else.
Diananni -- Your three words would terrify me with their depth and zen.
Sophieh -- You should have been there at the laundromat. There were several stories going on at once. Hurricanes are good for something.
Susan -- I should probably post a picture of the rat.
Sue -- Those are good ones. I've always avoided "move" but I'm realizing the benefit, and I do need a reminder to do so.
Make. Made. Contemplate.
Slug, Heal, Blow!
I think I'll have to do a post to explain mine. :)
Wish I could rate this again and again!
Or maybe it would be: "Drink, Don't, Fall."
Can't decide.........
be in mine too.:)
Rated
~s
I can say that I wished I'd learned the art of the shrug. Throughout the years, I've been more prone to shoot from the hip. I'm usually quick to tell it like it is. I have no problem pointing out the elephant in the living room or letting it be known that the emperor has no clothes. Needless to say, this hasn't always worked for me. So many times, a well-executed shrug would have been a much better alternative to whatever came out of my yapping trap.
Still thinking about my three word manifesto. Maybe "shrug" should be part of it.
Anyway, I didn't relate to the book at all and was disappointed. I had thought the book was about a woman re-discovering herself and redefining herself on her own terms, without a man. Given my state at the time, that's what I was interested in reading about. I didn't get that sense at all. I couldn't identify with this well-off woman who was free to roam the world. (Um, with enough money and the opportunity of world travel, any woman could find herself.) That the book ended with her simply entering into another relationship, I felt slightly short-changed. It didn't seem to me like she'd really traveled very far at all.
Again, my reaction was probably colored by my own difficult situation.
I can just see Miss Cotton Blossom now, a little armpit stinky and horrified...
Rita -- Hurricanes bring together all sorts of people who wouldn't normally interact. Laundromats are an interesting place. I have other stories...
Alice -- Those are great, out-of-the-box choices. Contemplate is something I need to do more of.
Sparking -- Heal, I get. Slug and blow...yeah...you need to do a post!
Peggy -- I could find my mojo eating pasta in Italy too, especially as compared to trying to find it eating Spaghetti-O's at an Arkansas trailer park.
Steve -- You own those words.
Ladyslipper -- I enjoyed reading your three words as well.
Lulu -- Now I'm blushing and feeling undeservedly wonderful. As you know, I always love reading your posts too -- they are delicious in every way. Even the political ones.
Grace -- I think you hit upon one of the main reasons people are annoyed with her. Her revelations could have come from a "more deserving" person, with some widom and knowledge street cred (not me!), but someone who has lived the life for longer than a year.
Ginny -- Drink. Don't. Fall should be stenciled in every bar's bathroom!
Fay -- Thanks! I'm glad you did one, or two, or three all together!
Dear Reader -- I can't actually kick ass, so a shrug is my only weapon!
Mumble -- Somehow, I think you have communication skills far and above the shrug!
Anna -- My throbbing feet agree. I sure wish I had known how important their happiness would be.
Dirndl -- That rat sounds delightful! Oddly, a lot of domesticated rats seem to get tumors. I wonder why?? Enjoy your rat play time!
Mime -- I'm glad you liked it! (I'd be interested in knowing how you'd silently act-out your three words.)
Stephanie -- Thanks so much for reading and taking the time to comment. I really loved your post about your dad's photos.
Katy B -- Yeah, as a heroine, she was disappointing. I guess that makes her human, though. In reading your posts, I've always admired your ability to SAY!
Matt -- You have a rat too?? Since they can't really hold their urine, if they are running the wheel, they're peeing at the same time! I just make sure I clean the cage mesh and table regularly. It is a pain, though, and I wonder why I'm doing it since it's my daughter's rat!
Just Thinking -- She was out of her element, but maybe less so after the laundromat experience. Next time she'll be a pro! Thanks for reading and commenting.
Mine would be 3 phrases:
calm down, shut up, keep going (for the days I find life to be just a tiny bit freaky!)
Thanks for your great writing always!
One of my main food gripes is how hard it is to get anything besides lowfat buttermilk nowadays.
And then you mention "hurricane." Gotta be Mississippi or Louisiana coast. I do like Southerners who write on Salon.
Clay -- Those three phrases resonate with me, especially keep going. That's the one I'm always forgetting.
Pilgrim -- I enjoyed your three words in poem form -- even if it was rat-free.
Felicia -- I'm sure your three words are delicious.
Honto -- Florida Gulf Coast. I'm able to get whole buttermilk in any grocery store. It's the trade-off for the hurricanes!