Ben Sen's Blog

Politics, Culture and Religion Without Projections

Ben Sen

Ben Sen
Location
New York, N.Y.,
Birthday
December 31
Bio
I'd rather be judged on the basis of my posts than anything written in my bio. It's put down and gathered as a record of my experience and a response to what I see as the important issues in the world today. I don't pretend it's anything other than subjective. The purpose is to analyse, interpret, express opinions, challenge the status quo, open a few doors, and entertain when the muse permits. I heartily welcome ratings, comments and dialogue as that is what makes this media unique and valuable. It also keeps me honest and encouraged since I'm not getting paid. Take a risk and say something; it feels better. The "conversation" is essential for the growth of the individual and the collective. I have faith it extends beyond the confines of what is said here. "For it is necessary for awake people to be awake, or a breaking line may discourge us back to sleep, the signals we give--yes, no or maybe--should be clear: the darkness around us is deep." From A RITUAL TO READ TO EACH OTHER by William Stafford

MY RECENT POSTS

Ben Sen's Links

New list
No links in this category.
Editor’s Pick
JANUARY 12, 2012 12:09PM

My Love Affair with Michel de Montaigne

Rate: 27 Flag

     It's one of those names the literate recognize but may not go out of their way to learn about.  That was true of me until I read Sarah Blakewell's excellent biography of Michel de Montaigne, "How to Live," which won a National Book Critics Circle Award, hit the bestseller list and gives one hope for the future of literature.

     Montaigne lived from 1533 to 1592 in Central France.  He was an aristocrat, but only gained that status in his father's generation as a result of his military and political career.  The family estate was assembled the generation before that on the banks of the Dordogne River.  The location was crucial, since one side of the river was Perigord, controlled by the Protestants, and the other was Bordeaux, which was primarily Catholic.

      Montaigne's education was unique.  His father insisted he be brought up speaking and communicating in Latin with his tutors.  He became well versed as a boy in the classics, also in Greek, but took a particular interest in the Stoics, the Epicureans, and the Skeptics--always a troublesome lot since they spoke about "how" to live, rather than the abstractions that attracted the eggheads.

     His major work, which occupied him for most of his life was the Essays, in which he re-invented the form so it included the life of the writer himself, a "new" concept that even today confuses readers who prefer a more formal and less intrusive form.  Combining that methodology with his knowledge of the classics led to some notable "rules" for living.  Such as:

      Don't worry about death, Pay attention, Be born, Read a lot, forget most of what you read, and be slow-witted.  Don't forget to use little tricks, Question everything, Keep a little room where nobody can find you, Wake from the sleep of habit, Live temperately, and Do something that nobody has done before. 

     Oh, not to forget: Philosophize only by accident, Give up control, Reflect on everything, and my personal favorites: Guard your humanity, and Be ordinary and imperfect.

    That's for starters.  Some may seem a bit innocuous, but they and his skepticism did succeed in getting Montaigne on the Index of Forbidden Books for almost two hundred years, and you don't come by such honors easily.  His riskiest admonition, depending on your point of view was to invoke moderation in all things, and of course nothing has changed in this regard either.  The hotheads still set the agenda.

     Only part of us is sane: only part of us loves pleasure and the longer day of happiness, wants to live to our nineties and die in peace, in a house that we built, that shall shelter those who come after us.  The other half of us is nearly mad.  It prefers the disagreeable to the agreeable, loves pain and its darker night of despair, and wants to die in a catastrophe that will send life back to its beginnings and leave nothing of our house save its blackened foundations.

     Montaigne's resolve was tested when he was the mayor of Bordeaux during the religious wars that were then racking Europe and would do so for many years.  He was a classic "reluctant" hero who baffled his critics with obfuscation.  He was a politician, not an ideologue who fought for compromise to the satisfaction of no one.  

     Ireland may only have been the most recent outbreak; one hesitates to call it the last in "Christiandom" for fear they'll start again.  The Sunnis and Shites, the Jews and the Muslims, the Hindus and the Pakistanis, and the tribes of Africa have nothing on Christians when matters that nobody can prove then or now are at stake.  Montaigne was well aware of the limits of reason when fanaticism was the will of the majority. 

     He was the guy who despite the mass slaughter all around him left the gates of his estate open, and instead of a private army standing over his bed had only an old man to help him dress--and behold he lived to tell the tale by virtue of his tongue and winning ways.  What a story!  I'm sure you've heard it, but never knew its source: Michel de Montaigne.

      Of course, the parallel with our age is obvious, and the shame that we are still fighting these sad wars.  The Edict of Nantes came in 1598, after Montaigne's death, but his work no doubt influenced it.  It proclaimed the dominence of conscience in the choice of religion yet in this country, formed from the beginning to secure religious freedom there are many faiths who still believe everybody is going to hell who doesn't believe what they believe.

     In the news recently was the story that so-called Christian "leaders" have met to decide on their "alternative" to Mitt Romney, whose Mormon faith is unacceptable to them despite every indication he could well be the only "ordinary" banana in the bunch, aside from Obama, but of course they need him as the "demon" to make themselves the heroes.  It's "what" you believe that matters to them, not how you live.  Ideology outdoes humanity once again.

     What would Montaigne say?  I think he'd counsel to stay detached--but don't run away--otherwise we become one of them and they've won.  There have to be some adults in the room even if the children aren't listening. The rest he would leave to the advancing of literacy and consciousness raising.  He was basically an optimist i.e. they can't all stay dummies all the time.  (I'm not so sure myself.)

    God is still the number one reason for meeting an "unnatural" death and nobody is laughing.  There is no doubt our culture learns little if anything from the past, but for those who do we  can take some hope there will always be Michel de Montaigne to act as our guide.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
As I read your post, I can hear Peter, Paul, and Mary singing in the back ground "Blowin' in the Wind." I am revisiting some of Joseph Campbell's work right now, but I will add Montaigne to my reading list.
Actually, I was listening to Glenn Gould play Bach. Try the biography first. He needs a new translator.
My comment disappeared...grr.

Like you I understand the past is nothing but the repetition of now...sad to say humans don't stop wallowing long enough in "me" to think of the larger picture.

I suppose being imperfect is what allows us to repeat mistakes.
R
Wonderful piece. I've sent it to a few other friends who I know will appreciate its message as much as I did. Those who beat their chests and think they know this country best, know it least.
A beautiful overview of a great man's life. It makes me want to read him all over again. r
Well done, once again. Thank you for giving your writing to us.
I read Donald Frame's translation last spring. It was quite wonderful.
Excellent! I don't remember reading any of Montaigne. I can see why it was banned then and not recommended now. I read Eric Weiner's "Geography of Bliss" recently and much of what Montaigne advocated sounds like Weiner's take on Thai philosophy; live for today and don't think too much. Thinking will make you unhappy. R
Thanks for such an inspiring piece. It means a great deal to me right now and I have forwarded it on to family and a couple of friends. If those in power in our little town could understand it (truly) I would forward it on to them. I might just do that anyway.

Also, thanks to Rodney Roe for recommending this wonderful writing.
Great writing and super-interesting. I am one of those who of course knows the name Montaigne without--until now--knowing anything about him. A gift to read something like this before my pedestrian workday. So literary!
Yes. I hear. . .Peter, Paul, and Mary singing:
`
Inch by inch, row by row, someone pick up
a pick and a hoe. All it takes is a piece of rich:
`
Fertile Earth Ground (Plat-Plot) and a hoe.
Please help me with this garden ground`
`
Help this garden grow. Crows steal seeds`
`
Greedy hubris ill/ilk make Ruin-hamartia.
Translated in Greek to Tragic Failed Life.
A compost dung flop that wobbles `bout.
`
I use to glean Michel de' Montaigne` lots.
Congrats on a well deserved EP. Thanks.
He read the classics and added footnotes.
`
P.S.
Bob Skye has a powerful letter/post.
He closed the comments. Respect/pain.
`
off topic?
`
refusing to touch
her fiance's father
a mortician
`
Yes. Joseph Cambell.
`
Hero with One-Thousand faces -
`
He wrote:
`
Last eve watching the news I witnessed
Vietnam Veterans expressing Compassion
It was of the highest-level of Compassion
Soldiers in battle were disregarding the
Fear of death - They were willing to
Display the surrender of their life
and placing their own Life at risk
willing to die to save another
comrade. I cried when I read.
He was anti-media/hate and
Hollywood portrayed vets as
maniacs, snipers, leprous and
Obvious symbols of a war that
America was losing. (weep) ay.
`
I need a beer? I go to DC.
I'll wear blue flip-flops
and goggles to rant`
`
Good reading, posted to FB for others to enjoy.
I think I like this guy Montaigne. In this age of the superhero and the billionaire stock traders and the worship by the hapless of the 1%, he seems to think it's fine to be ordinary, as long as you think a bit, though you don't need to be a genius. Thanks for this synopsis of his worldview.
Why would an ideologue fight for compromise?
ElegantMistake:

Exactamundo! The trick is "debriefing" those who start to see it. The mob runs on ideology.
Sir, you, like Montaigne are a bon vivant and much respected. As to any fundies -- may they eternally rot in the hell of someone else's true religion.
My candidate for the Montaigne award in our time is the late Vaclav Havel, the courageous playwright and prisoner of conscience who became the president of post-totalitarian Czechoslovakia, and calmly guided a country in turmoil through the perils of divorce during a time that's come to be called the Velvet Revolution.
"God is still the number one reason for meeting an "unnatural" death"

Amen... this was really interesting- really
I just started reading Bakewell's book yesterday, so this is very timely. I haven't read any Montaigne and have been wondering if I shouldn't do that before or in conjuction with Bakewell's bio of him.

Interesting post, relating it to the current crazy politicians. So true!

R.
Another book to add to the "read before I die" list. Thanks for a well-written and informative post Ben.
The father of the modern essay, still fascinating and surprisingly contemporary. This was so enjoyable to read. And thanks for the book recommendation.
♥╔═══╦╗╔╗╔╦═══╦═══╦════╗♥
♥║╔═╗║║║║║║╔══╣╔══╣╔╗╔╗║♥
♥║╚══╣║║║║║╚══╣╚══╬╝║║╚╝♥
♥╚══╗║╚╝╚╝║╔══╣╔══╝─║║
♥║╚═╝╠╗╔╗╔╣╚══╣╚══╗─║║
♥╚═══╝╚╝╚╝╚═══╩═══╝─╚ for the fine thoughts on Montaigne...
Such a fine read. Thank you for something of substance. A little room is essential...I have one in NH. The older I get, the less I need.


LACE CURTAINS

Through tattered panels
Swirls and embroidered zinnia
Overlay pine bows

Sunlight filtered through
Linen mesh
Swipes my desk

From my window

A cloudless sky appears etched
Lawn mottled, shadows altered.
Light softened.

Brilliant colors of fall
Now dappled by
Veils of sun bleached ochre.

From my window

Through intricate ornamental webs,
The world is dreamy and pliable

In my dotage I will live in one room
With a hardy fern in a wicker stand

Bone china teacups, friendly old books
A crystal wine decanter on simple shelf
Are all that I require.

There too, I shall demand tattered panels
For my windows

I wish to see patterns
Of billowing lace
Dance upon my floor
When my old feet cannot.
The culture of faith makes numerous mistakes, is fragile and breaks - and there aren't enough to clean up the terrible mess. Amen to your post!
Holy cow, this is a wonderful post about a remarkable individual. Moderation in all things...and we must embrace our shadow. Befriended you back.