benjamin_the_donkey

benjamin_the_donkey
Location
Middle East
Birthday
September 23
Bio
"Donkeys live a long time. None of you has ever seen a dead donkey."

MY RECENT POSTS

Benjamin_the_donkey's Links

Salon.com
NOVEMBER 16, 2009 11:18PM

One Day, All this Will be Nothing but Memory

Rate: 14 Flag

My sons sitting in a sunlit window, a few days before I write these words, the first really cool day of the year. A half-eaten banana in the older boy's hand, the little one looking up at his brother with--what? A new expression, maybe a new feeling?  One not quite like any I'd seen before. Both boys wonderfully themselves, wonderfully unaware of their father and his camera.

One day, all this will be nothing but memory. This is the sadness of photography, that it reminds us of this fact, even before moment is over. The click of the shutter is the snick of a lock, a door closed forever.

What else is there? Outside the window, a blurred mass of trees, a high-rise construction project. Inside, was there music? A stray fly buzzing? A lingering smell of eggs from breakfast? I can't say; it's gone already.

Very soon, all this will be nothing but memory. And later, not even memory. My wife was out that day, in class. My sons won't remember. They're too young, and, even if they were older, there's no reason. It's not a birthday, a wedding, a funeral, a tragedy or a celebration. Just a day like any other, a banana like any other, a typical morning in early autumn in Taipei. When I and my memory are gone at last, there will be only this image, this surface, indecipherable even to the boys it pictures.

It's not that I will die--everyone dies-- but that this particular moment, this exact sunlight, this unexpected cool air, this moment in the life of these boys, that all this  should die with me-- that's what is unbearable. And so I go on shooting photos. What else can I do?

   

bananaboys.med

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Information is never lost in this universe. Time, unfurled from the perspective of our limited brains reveals the ulitmate glory of the nature of information itself.
It is never lost. Though we, from our eyes and those of the others ends, nothing ever really ends in the grand scheme.
And even if I'm wrong, there's nothing like now for enjoying the moment.

Rated.
This is gorgeous. We are all but transient moments in search of the next one or the one we (think we) left behind.
beautiful children, beautiful words.

The Buddha says not just to talk about impermanence, but to use it as an instrument to help us penetrate deeply into reality. wise advice... this reminded me.
These are the times I remember most. Not the special events. The small jewel moments. R for beautiful children and appreciation.
Lovely piece. That's what always gets me about old photos. You know the images of you, but you just can't seem to grasp who you were when they were taken.
R
Andy--Yes. But there's that pesky thing called "ego"....

O'Really--Thank you!

lorriane--Thanks. I try.

rita--Thanks. I thinks they're beautiful too (surprise!).

neilpaul--I've never see Madmen. Hasn't come to Taiwan, as far as I know.

John-- Thanks. And imagining new photos becoming old photos... even more so.
That picture is beautiful.

"For me the noise of Time is not sad: I love bells, clocks, watches — and I recall that at first photographic implements were related to techniques of cabinetmaking and the machinery of precision: cameras, in short, were clocks for seeing, and perhaps in me someone very old still hears in the photographic mechanism the living sound of the wood."
— Roland Barthes (Camera Lucida: Reflections on Photography)

If you haven't read Camera Lucida, do so. I think you'd like it.

-e
The photo is beautiful. I found myself thinking: "That's going to be an illustration in one of those boys' biography some day."
Lovely. I look at pictures of my kids from fifteen or twenty years ago and see not only something that has passed, but hopefully something essential that still resides in each of them. I look at childhood pictures of myself and hope for the same thing.
a virtual hug to the father in you ((Benjamin))
gazoo73-- Thanks. I haven't read Barthes at all, just commentaries by others. I should.

Eva-- Thank you. I hope I come off well in that biography.

C.K.-- I'm anticipating that. Of what I see in this image, how much will be unchanged when they are 10, 15, 20?

Rolling-- Thank you!
Beautiful children. I took a lot of photos when my nephew was your younger son's age. It's just been a couple of years, but already the memory of what he was like then is fading, and has been replaced by how he is now.
Well put...I know the feeling. And beautiful photo, too...