Beth Mann's Blog

Beth's Urban Tales of Wonder and Decay

Beth Mann

Beth Mann
Location
Long Beach Island, New Jersey, USA
Birthday
November 11
Title
Presidente
Company
Hot Buttered Media
Bio
I'm a writer and creative consultant. I have years of experimental comedy and strange theater under my belt. I surf. I cook. I love wine, men and song. And oh puppies. I effin' love puppies.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
JULY 28, 2010 6:07PM

The Case Against Placebo Boyfriends

Rate: 66 Flag

 


I don't think I've ever tittered before. I'm not even sure what a titter is. But when the question hit me, that's what I began to do.

"Why don't we just have sex? Right now."

Clint and I don't have sex. He and his brothers live down the street and serve as my surrogate family at the Jersey shore. I realized early on that it was much more important for them to serve that role in my life. Sex changes everything...doesn't it?

We had just finished surfing and a storm was fast approaching so we jumped in my truck and raced back to his house by the bay. While driving, I told him about a sexual dream I had that morning that starred a surfer we knew.

"Everything was so open. It was like there were no...rules around sex. You just saw someone and had sex with them. So when Justin [the surfer] appeared in my dream, I went up to him, unzipped his pants, lifted up my skirt and climbed on top of him. It was all very easy, free."

Clint sat silent and tense in the passenger seat. For a moment, I wondered whether telling a male friend intimate details about a sexual dream is a little different than telling a female friend.

When we got back to his house and out of my truck, the black sky tore open and unleashed. Already wet and in our bathing suits, we stood in the pouring rain for a minute or two, enjoying the feeling. This is a perfect summer moment, I thought. Just this.

We grabbed some towels and dried off under the deck, looking out over the bay as the rain came down harder. Then I noticed a strange sensation; it was if the air had become electrified, bouncing back and forth, through me, through him. Everything felt very alive yet very still at the same moment.

Then zap!

Clint turned to me and said, "Why don't we have sex? Right now. For the next hour. Or two." He didn't sound totally serious...but not totally unserious.

That's when the tittering began - a high-pitched, girly laugh that I don't ever remember emitting in the the entirety of my life.

"Really, that's what people would do in this situation. They'd have sex."

"It's true...they would" I managed to say.

Strangely, "Why Don't We Do It in the Road?" began playing in my head at full volume. I took a wet barefoot step toward him. That easy, sexual dream version of me was in full agreement with his suggestion.

Why wouldn't we have sex? We spend a lot of time together, we know each other very well, we're kinda hot. We're straight. We only live once. Besides, everyone already thinks I sleep with him and his brothers anyway. Let's give them something to really talk about.

Then the head interjected, reminding me of all of the stupid and annoying things Clint has said and done in the past, how careless he's been with my feelings, how terribly...dudelike he can be. If we did have sex, it would suck afterward. He'd potentially tell others how he "tagged" me. Or he'd share with me in detail how much he likes the ass of some chick on the beach, later that very afternoon. And I'd feel disgusted and annoyed. Definite step back.

But what are these stand-in, placebo boyfriend types for anyway? They just kind of hog up time and space that could be dedicated to someone you really like. Why not at least use them to their maximum capacity?

Another step forward.

Filler men can be so frustrating. So much feels right and natural. You have nothing romantically invested in a faux boyfriend, so you relax and truly act yourself. Sure, we all want to believe we're really "ourselves" with our significant other but there's a special lack of concern for a stand-in boyfriend that feels pretty good. I call Clint a moron whenever I damn well please, for instance. He tells me to shut the fuck up when the urge hits him. Easy like Sunday morning.

So why mess up that magic? There's no undoing sex once it's been had.

Step back.

"I need to...iron my clothes."

" You need to what?"

"You heard me, moron. I have ironing. To do."

And with that, I walked left.

Later that day, Clint would introduce me to his friend as his "surfing buddy and neighbor" (which, trust me, he would have done, even if we had sex.) I thanked my lucky stars that I hadn't made a sexually grievous error. Placebos are made up of sugar and have no real medicinal effect whatsoever. But I guess if you don't know any better, placebos can do the trick. Unfortunately, I know better.














 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
haaa....this had me laughing throughout.

and I'm going to use that thing about the ironing.
Damn, and here me and my roboboys were getting along so well . .

My take on this: if you have to discuss having sex, you shouldn't.
Good call, you.
Horrible excuse, Beth. Probably a good decision, though. You possess admirable restraint!
I love your writing, Beth. Just love.

I've only had a couple of placebo-yfriends, and in retrospect, they were mistakes. I think you made a good call.

I've lost more than I've ever gained sleeping with boys who are friends. Even when you wish you could, you can't ever quite completely stuff that sex genie back into the bottle. Even worse when you continue to stuff...stuff.

It's complicated, isn' t it.

Well done as always.
yup, you have tremendous restraint. I would have jumped his bones.
Love this post--wise move. And Julie's comment is cracking me up.
Rated for restraint.
Good choice! You definitely would have regretted that one!
Ah, but the thing about the placebo effect is that it can be as real and effective as the "real" thing. Truly. And sometimes the thing that we are searching for is staring us right in the face, but you were probably right in blowing him off (forgive the ah, sexual pun, couldn't resist).

I think I know what I would have done and since I don't even own an iron...
I'd never have the stones to ask like that and ... if you don't ask; you don't get. Sounds you two know one another real well if was not an issue later.
Why not at least use them to their maximum capacity?
Funny, funny...but you know, you lose more friends that way!!
The regret really would have ruined good surfing. I have found the thrill of the electrical charge is best, and enjoy that more than finding out how to dissipate it. And now you know what he'd be fine with, for when your rainy day has no ironing to do.
The most telling line in that particular song is "No one will be watching us." But, as you clearly understand, that only seems to mean "no one will know." Which isn't true: eventually, everyone will know.

But here's a truth: I have never, ever in my life heard a man share intimate details about sex with someone he really cared about. Women share everything, whether the guy's a one-night stand or the love of her life. What's up with that?
I love you Beth, but I was rooting for Clint. Sorry, but I live vicariously through him. Please reconsider. Just for one post.
for a second, i thought you might do the hokey pokey...

wonderful read:)
Excellent case against placebo boyfriends. But now, I think I have a crush on your friend Cliff!

"That's when the tittering began - a high-pitched, girly laugh that I don't ever remember emitting in the the entirety of my life."

Ha! that's when we (us normally non-tittering women) know we're really in a pickle.
"Gay" is not necessarily a deterrent to making a really, really bad choice, says One Who Knows. Good on ya, kiddo. And I feel I can call you that because, mirabile dictu, we both know Kim! Yay! Naturally you are now a favorite, fully rated for sisterliness.
Well, I don't think it would have been a problem if you did not speak about it, arrange it, before, after, during..You could have just "imagined it". It could have been an alternate reality....you know, like an alien took over your body and then returned to the UFO. Ha. Well if you had to talk, you probably did the right thing. What's wrong with this guy anyway??? Just wondering.....R
~~snicker~~ Nothing screws up a friendship faster than sex. Next time the opportunity comes up, run, don't walk, to the nearest exit. Been there, done that. Now I don't have any friends at all. Still, I would have loved to hear you tittering.......
What fun! Great essay.
You are sooooo damn good, even when you're bad. In this case, you are spot on. Having been on both sides of that situation, I'd say your restraint was above and beyond . . . and wise.

Plus, your ability to present a relatable situation so vividly that we could feel the electricity . . . well . . . fuckin' A, Beth . . . you rock. Now if only the rain would start around here . . .
Good points. I haven't had a "placebo" boyfriend (or girlfriend) since my twenties. Haven't wanted one. They don't cure anything, but they can still have unpleasant side-effects.
I want a placebo boyfriend! It has been so long I just might be tempted :)
I think you chose right!
Poor Clint! Beth Mann, you are a cruel wench... but you write fairly well
FINE. You did the right thing. I guess. But damn....It would have been hard for me. (titter titter - she said hard!)
This made me laugh out loud:
Strangely, "Why Don't We Do It in the Road?" began playing in my head at full volume.

You are a fascinating creature, Beth, and I'm having a great time getting to know you. A VERY titillating (but not tittering) post.
I've been in that situation several times. On both sides of the equation.

Having never actually toppled over in such a situation, nor been toppled upon, I've come to regard the near collision as one benefit with friends. You get to breathe a little harder for a while without actually changing anything.
Such restraint and in the rain. Tough call.
Loved this, Beth. Wise and ultra-readable and honest.
men have sex too easily, women have it too uneasily.
ps nothing personal but the way you write it sounds likes its been a long,long time since you last had sex.
good call. and great writing. but i'm practically on the floor with the ironing. ironing is an excuse that flew with this guy? that gets a thousand points just for being so unexpected. sex isn't just sex, even when we think (or try to convince ourselves) that it is.

and i totally love the tags and the song they reference. am going to play it right now, 'knock on wood.' very clever, beth.
sometimes creative folks are so wise...I admire your restraint. but most of all, I admire your ability to visualize the inevitable. To be able to have the types of exchanges you have is supremely important. And you know the ways you have the power to preserve it. I admire that, as I said earlier...while I think about my many blunders over the years....
Great Stuff! But, as usual, I see things differently. There's a case to be made for placebo boyfriends. I've had my share of "placebo" girlfriends, but I never viewed them as placebos. It was more like the relationships were a middle point between nothing and worthwhile relationships. If there weren't good placebo possibilities out there, the gulf between nothing and worthwhile relationship would seem much more daunting.
Hey, all. Thanks for your feedback. It was a fun piece to write.

Ric, I think you made an excellent point. It's true. And again, my pieces are not the gospel truth or even my final opinion. Just a point of departure or a moment in time. I'm very happy to have guy friends in my life. It's a good, positive feeling, for the most part. And always a growing experience.

vzn, nothing is more annoying than someone starting off with "don't take this personally" or "no offense." almost bound to be a dose of passive aggressiveness. how simple minded you are, to read a piece like this and jump to conclusions about my sex life. do you believe soap operas are real too? do you yell at the villains if you see them walking down the street? you just like shaming women for having sexual urges. go talk to your mommy about that.

night all! off to the brothel!
You probably anayzled the situation correctly but I can't be sure. I've never had that kind of consensual sex with a friend. The couple of times it's happened, my judgement was considerably impaired and I think they were interested in having more than a friendship.

A work colleague told me she and a male friend decided to have sex just to see what it was like with no romantic overtones. "Fun" and "nice" was the verdict and it was never repeated.

Haven't looked at the comments yet but surely someone has drawn comparisons to Friends With Benefits.
Ain't it fun to be original and iconoclastic? That's definitely how I see you, and it's how I see myself. The road less traveled really appeals to me. If it's unconventional, I'm ready to jump right in; a pedestrian life seems wasted somehow.
a) A good, juicy orgasm is pretty different from a placebo, in my experience.

b) A women telling a single guy friend about her sex dream is like pouring gasoline on a fire. Do you know how hard it is for us poor schmuck male types to keep our hormones in check (even at my age)? Do you have any idea how much effort a guy, who really *does* just want to be your friend, must exert in order to not start thinking about sex in the presence of an attractive woman? And if that woman is wet, and in a wet suit, and is telling you about her sex dream of the previous night, and is about to spend the night at your house? I mean, c'mon!

Yeesh; you women really *don't* understand men, do ya? Thank God for my Sami!
Great name for them, "placebo" boyfriends. I've always thought that friends of the opposite sex are kind of complicated when you're both single. You've touched on some of those issues here. Very enjoyable writing too.
This certainly had me tittering!!! :) Congrats on the Editor's Pick. Well deserved!
Great observations and self-control. Seems like you know the difference and have drawn a line in the sand!
"Placebo boyfriends"... gotta remember that! :-)
R.
"iron my clothes"....is that what the kids are calling it these days?

Funny and wise you are. Clint will thank you later.
Agreed. I have many male friends, if fact my best friend, I am not single however, opportunity is still there, but it would ruin everything. I would miss the fun and banter. That's what bars are for Beth, swirl around in your dress a bit more...
You know, if this were a movie, you'd be played by Sandra Bullock or Jennifer Anniston and he'd be Matthew McConaughey and you'd get together in the end...Ironing - that's awesome!
Perfect. Hard pick. Cosmic lightening or sensible shoes? Been there, chose wisely, looking back not sure I'd miss the sparks for the marks. Guess it depends on how many moments like that come along in you life... and how long it's been since a "real" one has taken the spot. ;) Thanks
Excellent essay on not pooping where you eat.. ..

I wish sex were simple. Never is. ....I come to this conclusion through painful experience.

I have had one pseudo boyfriend (a rather mystical Rabbi, no less!)....who was superb. All the rest? Studies in awkwardness.

GREAT as usual, Beth.
I love those little 'slice of life' posts...well done!
Smart girl. It does seem to suck. Don't quite know why and find it too exhausting to try and explain it to a horny guy whether he's twenty, forty or sixty. Filler sex just ain't what it used to be (which makes me suspect it was never really what it used to be)
Thanks for saving yourself for me...someday...in another lifetime.
heh. Good call on your part. I always liked what Teri Garr's character said in Tootsie about how sex changes things -- after having it with a guy friend she knew, he'd act like he owed her money.
(p.s. I always thought the best excuse was, "I have to go wash my hair.")
I agree that you were probably right not to consummate with your placebo boyfriend. Not because he would brag about it or talk junk about it, but because it sounds like you didn't want to.

If Clint is your friend, would he ever be as unkind toward you as this post imagines?
I like my ex-boyfriend much better as neighbor and friend. He's so much less trouble now he's been demoted. And I really CAN say anything to him.
brilliantly funny, Beth! r.
Clint sounds like an old fashioned idiot. Dumb enough to think the question was the way to get there, insensitive enough to think you wouldn't mind, dumb enough to not know you won't forget he asked.
Did you see it the time his surfboard hit him in the head ?
hey beth, I see you do not specifically deny my accusation.

I guess you're in a category all by yourself. faux sex positive, wink =)

something for you to ponder.. why did your experience directly/perfectly contradict your dream? what the heck do you think was in your subconscious to create such a dream? what is the meaning of it? for you? or do you think the dream was meaningless?
Im sorta wondering how someone can write a comment that is "passive aggressive". still trying to figure that one out.
in psychology I guess nowhere is it more true that a "little knowledge is a dangerous thing" =)
by the way I have long had the same dream, in the sense of a utopia/fantasy to consciously ponder =)
and Im scratching my head on this one-- how can what I wrote be interpreted as attempting to "shaming women for sexual impulses".... wow, you're really off the wall on that one. not that I any need to defend against such a baseless and derogatory accusation, but I have many blog posts that attest to quite the opposite.
and maybe this could be retitled "the case against conflicted females" :p
Interesting....

Less than a year ago, you were willing to have sex with a man you know is confirmed narcissist and world-class jerk.

http://open.salon.com/blog/beth_mann/2009/10/27/kissing_my_devil_goodbye_one_last_time

Yet you were unwilling to have sex with a man you clearly value enough to hang out with regularly (this current post) because he might brag to his friends about it afterward.

In the "Devil" case, you completely bought in to the Rescue-the-Bad-Boy fantasy. In your surfer friend's case, you completely rejected the possibility of making your dream real.

The two most reasonable explanations for this I can come up with are:

A) You matured a lot in the past 9 months . That's seems unlikely.

B) In both cases, your subconscious mind made the decision ("I want Mr. Devil. I don't want Mr. Surfer") and your conscious mind attempted to build a quasi-rational framework for your decision.

Perhaps, to paraphrase Malcolm Gladwell, you shouldn't be so quick to come up with explanations for things you do not have explanations for.
I have ironing to do is right up there with I have to wash my hair. Another great piece, Beth.
Yours is such a wise, funny, well-written post. I have had plenty of guy friends, but no placebo boyfriends, and I've never looked back and regretted it.
You said "Then the head interjected" and "Filler men."

Rated and enjoyed.
You know what a dude is and are too wise for that. Dudeness wears thin for a sensible woman. And you can treasure the fact that all the sorry gossips are still wrong.
I was thinking last night about my mistakes. And the night before. And just this morning. Oh, where is The One?
Well written, as always. I had been wondering how Clint was.
As for the dude, you probably did the best thing. But my favorite moment here was the downpour. Standing under a summer deluge in your bathing suit when you're already damp from the ocean is positively luscious. It makes even the filthy asphalt feel good under the soles of your feet, the rain swirling around your ankles and rushing between your toes. Right? WAY better than a quick screw.
"Wise choice" is what comes immediately to mind.
I like the idea that you are going with your instinct. Which tells you to not bang Clint. That seems like quite a solid idea, and go with it.

The rest, I'm sorry, sounds very ex post facto rationalization of something not very rational.

Some guys are friends with benefits, others friends. No reason to get all weird about either. Clint sounds like the later.

Next time tell him you would only have sex with him if you were married.

Then see what happens.
A friend sent me this comment:

Whether or not you fucked Clint seems incidental. What is striking about your story is witnessing a guy riding in the car with his “neighbor and surfing buddy” while she shares a very personal dream with him in what might just have been one of the truly intimate moments of his short witted life and his response is: make the moment be about him.

Had you dreamed of drowning would he have taken you back down to the beach and held you under a wave?

Had you dreamt of flying would he have offered to push you off a cliff?

In another moment of the perpetual embarrassment that is maleness, our hero sacrifices an opportunity to know you more intimately for the chance pleasure of exploring the structure of the skin that you occupy, in absentia.

Had he been present in the cab of your truck, the conversation, if any, would have been much less contrived after that beautiful moment in the rain.

Sex is easy. Intimacy is something that merits reconsidering the urgency of ironing.