Beth Mann's Blog

Beth's Urban Tales of Wonder and Decay

Beth Mann

Beth Mann
Location
Long Beach Island, New Jersey, USA
Birthday
November 11
Title
Presidente
Company
Hot Buttered Media
Bio
I'm a writer and creative consultant. I have years of experimental comedy and strange theater under my belt. I surf. I cook. I love wine, men and song. And oh puppies. I effin' love puppies.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
JANUARY 24, 2011 3:03PM

I am not my Blog

Rate: 57 Flag

 



When my mom was dying of cancer years ago, I gave her a journal. I told her to write anything she wanted in it. My mother was a consummate reader and a creative writing teacher, so I knew it wouldn't be a stretch for her. After she died, I read the journal. (I don't think it's ever okay to read someone else's journal, but in this case, I knew my mother was alright with it. And she was dead, afterall, making it harder for her to protest.)

Well, it was scathing. Hateful. Mean-spirited. Destructive. Morose. Mad at the world. Mad as hell at the world. I've never let anyone read that journal because most people would misinterpret it; they would think they knew my mother by reading her scrawl.

But they would be wrong - my mother was dying and had every right in the world to unleash. She was purging, letting go. It was not an indicator of her real personality - it was her expression at that moment. My mother was a bon vivant: rebellious, quirky, fun-loving, very conversational. She could also be depressed, overbearing and narcisstic. She could, like all of us, be many paradoxical things, all at once. But her deathbed journal was not her.

My blog is not me. It contains aspects of me, sure. But it is not the gospel according to Beth. If I wrote truthfully and honestly from the daily-living Beth's point of view, you'd nod off about midway through. I take liberties, because I can. I live out fantasies, because I can. I stretch the truth, because I can. Am I lying? Nah. It's creating.

I heard an interview of Orson Welles many years ago. He said he borrowed stories all the time from people. He then built upon them and acted as if they were his own. His take? A good story is a good story. Why mess it up with the truth?

I find my online life to be a form of wish fulfillment. Practical online magic. When I play out a story of mine, I bring it closer to life. I let my subconscious do the talking. Just like children work out many aspects of themselves through play, I do too. Is it the truly me? Nah, it's more likely an aspect of me that needs to be expressed in order to be purged or transformed. Once it's been born, I've already changed. Morphed and moved on. And the truth police have yet to arrest me!

I'm often surprised how many writers feel the need to stick so religiously to the truth instead of furthering their story in a more creative way. Again, that doesn't mean lying. It simply means letting the director in you (and the editor in you) tell a more exciting, lively story, for your readers' sake and for your own sake.

I've read many online pieces where people will regale every detail of a trip, for instance, only to get to the real story on the last day. Cut out the drive. Cut out the stop you made at the gas station where you asked for directions. Cut out the stomach issue you had that made you pull over and buy Pepto Bismol even though you've had bad experiences with Pepto Bismol in the past. (Of course, if these aspects serve your story, keep it. But most of the time, they don't. I swear.)

The cable guy (an acquaintance of mine) came over a few months ago and gave me a big hug, after he had read a particularly depressing blog entry of mine. He was worried about me. Strangely enough, at that very moment, I had a gorgeous man in my bedroom who had been in the process of kissing and biting every inch of my body. I was in a state of pure ecstasy, hardly depressed, and truly resented having to answer the door. I quickly explained to cable guy that it's just a blog, I'm a creative writer and I have to get back to...writing, now!

I don't like the feeling that people think they know  me so intimately. The whole process can feel voyeuristic and self-exploitative. There are several people who are no longer in my life who read my blog and I wish I could stop them. They think they have some bird's eye view into my life, like some virtual peeping Tom. On a bad day, I won't write for that reason alone. There's this one-sided mirror and I'm being watched. And the funny part? It's not even me they're watching. It's a figment of me, that I've created.

But what do you do? Certainly there is something distasteful about this whole process of writing personal essays and posting them online. I'm actually a fairly private person and I battle with that side of myself every time I post a piece. But I do my best to move past it. Yes, it feels like a peep show at times. But I've deemed it more important to share and express and create. At least that's how I feel right now.

I am not my blog. My blog, to me, is like a super power - it gives me a  chance to exercise (or exorcise) aspects of me I want to develop or  ditch. We should never assume we know someone by their online writing.

The cable guy story? Partially true. I won't tell you which part. It is my fictitious life after all.

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I'm convinced. Bob bob bob bob barbara anne.
sometimes I think there are talkers here and there are writers. I'm a talker, you are definitely a writer. It makes us approach the medium with different intent and expectations.
This so represents how I feel about blogging that I just want to give you a big hug. You are one of the most honest voices here even though you do not reveal everything about yourself, and why should you? I wish I had a bit more of your creativity/freedom to change stories about my life to make them more dramatic. I am too firmly stuck in the journalism mode, which is why I need to take another creative writing class to loosen up. As for the "peep show" mentality, I feel that way every time I write because I know my stalkers are busy assuming everything I write is the gospel and twisting it to their ends. Writing what I want is my way of saying "fuck you" to them. I think you know what I mean by that.
"I don't like the feeling that people think they know me so intimately. The whole process can feel voyeuristic and self-exploitative. There are several people who are no longer in my life who read my blog and I wish I could stop them. They think they have some bird's eye view into my life, like some virtual peeping Tom. On a bad day, I won't write for that reason alone. There's this one-sided mirror and I'm being watched. And the funny part? It's not even me they're watching. It's a figment of me, that I've created."

Exactly.

And you answered the door while being kissed and bitten. Oh, hell no! Blog reading concerned citizen can come back another time. xox
Absolutely brilliant! Ironically I also was thinking about all of this yesterday and today. I truly enjoyed this. So clear and refreshing.
Thanks
rated
I think you speak for many of us. You just do it so much better! Really well done, Beth and a well-deserved EP.
I think it is imperative we tell the whole truth at all times including using our real name.
Yes, tell the truth for a minute, then make up the rest. Good post and sci-fi poster.
Yes. I could have written this. Not as well, but the sentiment is the same. ~r
Such a joy to read, you are.
While I find myself more in the Dorinda Fox camp - blogging as memoir, for myself and my girls - I love the excursions into a heightened reality some of you manage to pull off.
When you succeed, that's when blogging becomes writing, for me.
Thanks for this, Beth.
Simply reading such pieces is all the instruction I need.
Real or pretend, I'd like to read more about the gorgeous man in your bedroom. Rawr!
i don't think you've ever posted something i didn't envy (for the good writing, not to mention those surf dudes), and this is no exception. i think we each have to be comfortable with whether we're to-the-letter truthful about ourselves in what we post on our blogs, and what works for you may make my skin itch if i tried it. you do mention people who used to be in your life that read -- i know that issue, too. i am changing my view as to whether what i write is in some way dependent on who my readers are. rambling, i know, but it's that kind of day. ;
Wonderful sentiment and great writing advice too.
"Practical online magic" I like that.
Hmmmm. Well, yes, I guess I do know what you mean. I took a couple of my personal experiences, sort of conflated them, and turned it all into one of my most rated posts ever (not that that's saying very much). Would I -- could I -- ever tell the complete truth? Not on your tintype.
I appreciate good writing / blogging when I read it and try not to assume anything about the writer's life or personality because of what s/he has written. This is a very good piece, thank you.
You do speak for many of us. I cringe at the calls to "open up more". Why? If our writing does not say something about our abilities and our characters, then it is not the speaker who is the problem...it is the listener.

Some people want to know the business of other people and they are distressed if they are not handed the intimate and personal details right away.

Others are happy with what they get. I do get many surprises when I have time to read more thoroughly or when someone reveals a personal detail, but it makes me cringe when personal revelation is put ahead of creative expression or storytelling.

Wow. There are posts to gush over today and this is one of them.

Zumapuck.
Creative non-fiction is what blogging is about, no?? Love this piece and how much I and so many others must relate to it. Writers write: sometimes truthfully, sometimes creatively and hopefully always interestingly.

You did so thanks!
P.S .> LOVE the Image....
Wait, we are suppose to write "enhanced" blogs? That explains it, I've been writing about my everyday life as it happens, or as it really happened. Hmmm....I think I'm gonna add a few sexy babes and maybe an insane uncle or something. :)

ps, I like reading about your adventures true or otherwise.
I'm taller and thinner on my blog than I am in real life.
Wait . . . what? What do you mean you aren't your Blog?

I . . . I . . . aw, hell! It takes too much effort to feign disbelief. Dude - you know how you stand in my book - tall and awesome. Even though we're the same age, I want to grow up and surf like you . . . and maybe even write better . . .
I like your perspective. I have known my partner for more than 30 years and lived with her for 18 of 'em and she still constantly surprises me, so how can I possibly expect to know anybody here based on what I read? You made me think. Thank you.
I thank you for this Beth, and no I am not being snide. There are times I read your blog and think in some way I do know you, and I realize that you are endeavoring in something creative, you have taught me something here. On the other end of it, I write a lot of sad poetry, it's the way I process things and I am not always sad, at all. Yet I have to convince people of this and feel bad when they are concerned. This is a learning process for me and I really feel appreciative of what I can learn from the people that have spent time learning their craft. I feel remiss that I have not said it enough before perhaps. Anyway, carry on, and keep making me laugh and I wont' take it personally.
"I don't like the feeling that people think they know me so intimately. The whole process can feel voyeuristic and self-exploitative."

Celebritys have that problem, that people believe they know them intimately through their work. Writers too. I am convinced there are writers out there who would be my best friend if they knew me. But I really know better. That's just a fantasy.

I am many many many things, my blog not the least or the most or anything other than my blog of me today.
I lie, a lot, in my blog, because, well, it's MY blog and I'll lie if I want too!!

Teeheehee!!

But sometimes, I tell the truth, those are my lowest rated posts EVER!!

PFFFFT! :D
ps I still cannot stop harboring this dream of ditching everything and living in LBI and surfing with these cool young guys who have crushes on me.. please let me hold on to this, I promise never to bring it up again.
You said it so well. Thank you. (Besides you write so well who would care if it is true?) To the ones who think they know a blogger I say, "Get your own life."
Beth, I find this interesting. Perhaps, it is because I am the opposite. What you see in my Open Salon space is probably me. I say "probably" because I would not be a good judge. However, my family and real life friends read what I post on Open Salon and they give me feedback. Therefore, I tend to stick very much to "me".
I like what you said here and it is all truth.
your so cute beth but please don't take my comment as condescending.
I don't think a forced evacuation by the National Guard could have made me leave my bedroom if a gorgeous man was in there biting and kissing every inch of my body.
I have to say I learn a lot reading your stuff -- and once again you are the teacher...thank you.
An entertaining and informative post. Made me think of an old mantra... "I have a body but am not my body, I have a mind but am not my mind etc., ..."

I think I'll add, "I have a blog but I am not my blog." ;0

I have written stuff that was fiction, even tagged it as such still some comprehended it as the gospel truth of my life. May have been my delivery but also people blur fact and fiction even when not intended so. Anyways, creative non-fiction is a ton of fun. I love it.
I am convinced that my interior fantasy life is much more interesting...the blogging lets me get it out.
Beth, I think this is a really fine rationale, laid out so clearly, on the importance of creative emphasis within a story. Is any of it all true..ever? Certainly not. Memory is always incongruent with events. Ask anyone who has witnessed the same thing. Different stories all around.

The most difficult part is trying to witness one's own life, in all its complexities and contradictions. Literature is there to help us make sense of it all. Good one...
Your writing is "to die for" Beth. You've given me something to think about. I find it very difficult to embellish the truth when I'm writing a personal essay. It could be because of my hatred of lying or it could be because of my innate fear of "being found out," one of my pervasive personality quirks. Maybe I could lighten up on myself a bit, especially since the only one who knows my truth is me.

Lezlie
You nailed this topic, as usual, in your unique, singular style. I open my personal, professional and emotional doors in my blog memoirs, a whole different animal. I tell the truth *as I see and remember it* but you got me to thinking about all those gas stations I didn't kick to the curb in the interest of total truthiness. Thanks, pal. Editing!
I liked the story about your mother's journal Beth. it must have been a shock to you at first. And I don't really care how much is true or not in a post. Being convincing is more important.
Right on target.
Great post. It is, in the end, all about the story, and the story is all about the writing.
Here! Here! I wrote a story a while back ( a long while back) and another writer e-mailed me about it, very upset. I explained that, hello! It's writing, like a book.... not all true, relax. He went off and then told me I had lost a friend, then promptly took me off his favorites list. Aren't we here to create? Hell yes!
My blogging does not define me.

I enjoy reading yours.
Even your tags are amusing. What a gal! R
Perfectly put. I have never been one to let the truth stand in the way of a great story.

Good for you.
Oh yeah - True Grit is NOT a bore. Sheesh.
I nod in agreement on both counts. I lost my mother some years ago and I watched that fun loving, mild mannered little lady just become downright mean. She even cussed. This felt so familiar.
Regarding blogging, I'm always a little bit shocked at how people actually assume they know who you are. You called this one!
Rated.
This is great, Beth (or whoever you are). I think that when we skim past the mundane details of our lives, and maybe stretch something and tint something else... that actually reveals our true selves.
I am not my blog either.

I am my twitter account.
As for me, every word I write is completely true so yes, I actually am a real life pirate.

Oh, and thanks Riordan, now I have Jan and Dean stuck in my head.
PS Should I have put a comma before and after yes?
I don't even know who I am. I'd hate someone to assume that who I am in a moment is who I am always. But who is that really?...washed away by the next ripple, the next wave. Lovely writing!
Hey, cable guy. You read this blog. You can tell us all what really happened that day... hee hee hee
I like to create myself as a character, but with only about a quarter of your brio. I'm a certain character at dinner parties. I shine at dinner parties. I'm not all that amusing the rest of the time. I'm someone else when I write. I've experimented recently with writing the filthiest, kinkiest porn I had in me. I'm uncomfortably aware that it was the closest to me that I've come.
For some reason I was lucky enough to see this in the feed this morning. I love the way you write. And I have to say, that even when I am telling the truth, (and I usually am) it is still only a slice of what is going on. I could not, would not tell the whole truth to the thousands of people who read my blog. Okay, the hundreds. Dozens? ~r
Sirenita:

I could have guessed you'd write some fantastic porn and how close it would be to the essential you. Perhaps that's why we should all try out hand at erotic writing at some point - to get that much closer to the real deal. You'd have to go there, though (I know you would) - you'd have to reach deep and not "put on."

Joan:

Yes a slice of me. And even then, a slice of me that's ever changing and often quite distant from me. Sometimes its just about creating a good story with a kernel of truth, that's all. Why not? Why must we stick to some gospel truth? Just write it into existence.
Lies tend to be aspirational.

Which also tend to be highly revealing.

If you lie about it, you care about it.

And, I am more interested in who someone wants to be rather than who they are at that exact moment.

And since we are talking about dreams -- then the entire notion of lying is close to nonsense.

Of course you can lie about whether you ate the plums, but what does it mean to lie about a dream?