BikeLizard

BikeLizard
Location
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA
Birthday
April 12
Title
Clerk
Company
Unnamed
Bio
Young. Female. Poor. Right-leaning but confused. Opinionated. Looking to sharpen my writing skills for college.

MY RECENT POSTS

BikeLizard's Links

Salon.com
NOVEMBER 23, 2009 9:26AM

For Some Prisoners, Death is Mercy

Rate: 2 Flag

I don't beleive in the death penalty, or the US's prison system that holds thousands of people for life without the possibility of parole.

This is not a discussion of what is worthy of life in prison, only of what is merciful.  Why cannot a permanent prisoner ask to die?  Life in prison is a shadow life, cut off from family and friends for many, and filled with the dangers inherent to prisons.

 So if you are a prisoner for life without parole, none of your appeals have gone through, why not allow them death?  Have a psychiatric evaluation, determine that the person isn't in the throws of a resolvable crisis, then start the process.  Allow the person one year to make up his mind, repeat evaluation, then allow them to die, with dignity, by the method of their choice.

 Life should never be used as punishment, and for many people arrested in their early 20s and incarcerated for ever, their senses become a prison.  Show some mercy, justice system.

Author tags:

humane, people, prison, death penalty

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
This is such a tricky, touchy issue. On the one hand, I agree, if someone wants to die, they should absolutely retain that right. On the other hand, if we allow prisoners to die arbitrarily as a way to simply avoid the punishment of prison, then we run the risk of losing many potentially really good people, who might learn and grow while in prison, and their growth may influence others who may be released back into society. And with such an imperfect judicial system as we have, I don't know how to best evaluate who could potentially be a positive influence on society in prison if they were to live.
I don't mean prisoners who may someday get out of prison, I mean people who have spent years in prison, have no option, and find life to be agony.

I am an advocate of treating prisoners with mental conditions, and that's why I think there should be a two year waiting list before anyone can die.

Once again, I reccomendd this option only for people who will never leave prison, not those with some hope.

@Neil Paul- So let them speed it up! I never said many people want this option, only that it should be allowed, as I do not presume to understand the mental state of a long term prisoner.
I believe our lives are our own. I believe we should be allowed to control those lives. And I believe that when the situation we find ourselves in becomes completely untenable, we should be allowed to choose whether such a life is worth living.
I know that idea makes many people nervous, if not downright unhappy or even plain old indignant.
So be it.