Blue in Texas is

living Blue in a Red state

Laura Deurmyer

Laura Deurmyer
Location
Texas,
Birthday
December 22
Bio
Proud mom to a 3rd grade son, wife of an artist/ artisan, liberal, former urban professional marooned in the sands of West TX

Laura Deurmyer's Links

Salon.com
Editor’s Pick
FEBRUARY 7, 2012 8:01AM

Once Upon A Time, Fostering and Adoption

Rate: 15 Flag

 

Once Upon a Time

 

One of my favorite television shows this season is "Once Upon a Time".  Go ahead, snicker - a forty-five year old woman hooked on what is essentially a fairy tale compendium turned inside out is kind of ridiculous, I give you that.  But it's escapist viewing at its best; clever, well written and well acted.  

Last weekend, my husband and I sat down with Hulu to catch up on a number of back episodes.  Brains firmly set to "off", wine in hand, we disappeared into Storybrooke.

The last episode we watched, "True North" was a riff on the Hansel and Gretel tale. In this version, the kids are little shoplifters, living on their own following the death of their mom, their dad never having been in the picture.  Our heroine, Emma Snow, daughter of Snow White and Prince Charming (stop it:  I hear you snickering), determines to save them from a fate worse than death.

Foster parents.

Yes, foster parents.  After all, she explains bitterly, for foster parents, the kids will just be "a meal ticket".   

Suddenly, my brain kicked on again, like a thermostat sensing heat.  My husband sat up and asked me "What did she say?"   We played back that segment of the scene.  Yep, that's what she said.

In terms of the story, I suppose that statement makes sense to that character.  Having grown up very unhappily in "the system" herself, Emma ties her horror of foster care to her own experiences.  

That tiny segment of one scene made me stop and consider the basic premises of the show in different terms.  What I realized is that this is a show that is profoundly anti-adoption.  

The whole series is built around the Evil Queen adopting Emma's biological son, which doesn't work out so well for him, her being evil and all.  This latest episdode showcased the sentiment - its take-away nugget of "wisdom" being that blood will always find blood, as the kids reunite with their father.

The truth is that blood doesn't always find blood, and blood isn't always best.  

My husband and I have been foster parents;  I am an adoptee.  We have many friends that foster and a number that have adopted. I can honestly say that, while I'm sure "meal ticket" foster parents are out there, I have never known one foster or adoptive parent who was in it for the money. 

As the reluctant father in the show prepared to take his twin twelve year olds home after meeting them for the first time, I wondered if he was ready to be an instant father.  Because sometimes, blood is just not enough.  Ask the hundreds of kidswhose parents cruelly mentally and physically abuse them or just as cruelly neglect them.

If we refuse to change attitudes in our society so that those who seek to care for kids who have no one else are not demonized, we will continue to have a shortage of foster parents.  

Unless we work to continue improving public attitudes about adopting American children and we make adoption easier and more affordable, many wonderful kids will grow to adulthood without a permanent home.  

Until we start paying social workers better, and begin staffing our over-burdened social services agencies appropriately, many children will have a different worker every few months for their entire stay in the system, leading to missed information, broken communication and children falling through the cracks.  (Our foster daughter had at least 4 different state workers during the two years she was with us.) 

Unfortunately, though Storybrooke isn't real, and what fictional Emma thinks doesn't matter, her feelings towards fostering and adoption are all too common.  And that is something that those of us in the adoption/ fostering community need to conciously work on changing.

Or more children like LA County toddler Tori Sandoval will die.

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I am moving my office today, so I won't be able to look in here at all for a while.

And yes, I still want to find out how Snow White and Prince Charming get back together, so I will probably continue to watch Once Upon A Time. (I hear you snickering again!)
No need to snicker.. I am a huge fan!! I had no idea nor even thought about this but you are so right. I was wondering myself if that dad who wanted nothing to do with his kids would make a good Dad.
Hmmm
I will bring these thoughts up with Steve next episode..:)
HUGGGGGGGGGGG
I haven't watched this show, but I loved reading your thoughts on fostering and adoption...we began the adoption through foster care process over two years ago, but they closed our file when my husband's income disappeared a year ago....hopefully there will be a turn around soon.
I parents had to meet the criteria that foster parents meet, we'd have no kids up for adoption!

I KNOW THAT MOST PARENTS LOVE AND CARE FOR THEIR CHILDREN VERY WELL!! (Thought I'd shout that so it's heard)

BUT...... for some, their kids are just an unwanted result of an otherwise good romp in the hay. They don't have any interest in raising kids, they have little love for them, and they couldn't possibly be proper "parents" in a million years.

There are also those who find themselves with a child that they realize they just are not in a position to raise properly even though they love them dearly. They may have emotional or financial or other problems of their own that they have not resolved and, not wishing to put those problems onto an innocent child, make the decision to put their child up for adoption.

I applaud those people who DO have interest, DO have love, and DO take on the responsibilities of child rearing, entirely voluntarily!
I am an adoptee (and before that in a foster home for a short period of time), and I've known many many adoptees and foster parents since. In my last job, we had a lot of foster parents bringing their children in for classes, and all were so very highly invested and committed. One family continued to bring their former foster daughter in -- along with their adopted daughter of the same age -- in for (very expensive) classes even after the birth mother regained custody!

I have stopped watching Once Upon a Time, though not because of the adoption issue. For some reason, the show just didn't click for me, even though I gave it several weeks.
Linda - Right? And no one thought to ask whether or not he had something in his life or background that would make him not suitable. It was just purely based on their blood relationship. Really bothered me.

Just Thinking - Oh no! I hope you still have your little one(s) and will be able to get back on track to adopting soon. It's so very hard when that doesn't work out.

Bell - It doesn't surprise me that the child's former foster parents would be willing to continue the class - it does surprise me that the biological parents will allow them to stay in touch with the child. Whenever we've ended a placement, it's been no contact at all from there on out, sometimes despite our pleas to the contrary. That's a lucky little one- continuity-wise. I didn't know or maybe didn't remember that you were adopted too - thanks for commenting!
Ummm, EVIL FAIRY TALE QUEEN IS ADOPTIVE MOTHER.

Pick your fights, author.

To me, the episode was more about "the system" and one person's personal experience with it, and that's aplot device itself at best, to drive Emma closer to Henry.

Sheesh.

Next up: SPCA attacks Wicked Witch of West for Unfair Treatment of Flying Monkeys. (I was going to say PETA, but those whackadoos probably would attack)
biscuit - That's the great thing about fiction; it makes you think about different things. I saw this and thought about fostering/ adoption because of my experiences. You don't see that - fair enough.

nick - No thanks. I don't think those are people I really would care to hang with.

skypixeo - Thanks for your comment. I agree - natural parents don't really have to do anything other than just be a set of DNA. Which works fine more often than not, but when it doesn't...
Thanks for mentioning Tori. We need to keep her name on people's minds so we never forget what happens when people don't do their jobs.
My wife and I love "Once Upon a Time" especially Carlysle's Rumpelstiltskin character. Thanks for the very interesting and perceptive analysis. Some thought provoking observations!
katrina - Tori's is a truly heart-wrenching story. When I think about what those social workers have to deal with - the sheer amount of cases, and the paperwork required - I can't help but feel that the system sets them up to fail. Plus, the presumption of our system is that blood relations are always, always better. I don't know how I feel about that; as a foster parent who was not chosen to adopt part of my skepticsm is probably bitterness. I never could see how a distant blood relative that had never met her could raise the little girl we'd loved since her early months of life better than we could.

Nick - Thank you. It is a really well -done show. We do enjoy it. I will be interested to see if this theme comes up again, beyond the basic Regina/ Henry conflict.
Hi laura ... I sent you a private message but .... I am Tori's foster mom. Thank you for posting about her. I have set up www.toristorch.com to give our foster children a voice! We have set up a task force to make changes in this system. I WILL not let another child suffer like my girl did... I would love to talk to you ...
I've encountered the same mindset. I am also an adoptee and while on a trip I met a foster family. When I returned I told some people about how wonderful I thought they were and the resposne I got was similar. "They must do it for the money so the mother doesn't have to work" they said. I was appalled. How could a family take on a toddler for the money? The pay isn't all that good, folks.

Rated.
I just finished the process for becoming a foster parent, and I know many people think it's just a way for some folks to get a check. Still, fortunately, many caring people open their homes to children who otherwise would have no one. There are many ways to be a "parent". I don't think any way one is better than the next.
Thank you for providing insight into another community I am not that familiar with.
I love Once Upon a Time. I also watch Grimm on Friday. And I am older than you...

Keep in mind that most of us don't see into the foster care world until it hits the headlines and those are not good news stories. Foster parents do great work and need a better press secretary.
Perhaps OUaT did exactly what the writer/s set out to do.. make viewers think on the foster/adoption systems ;). Television (and movies) make great soap boxes. I too have watched it for most of the season, but it's seemed to have bogged down a bit (for me anyway) lately. A Grimm fan here too :D. Fairy tales are ageless..

As for PR, I think children (and parents) in general need a better agent ; as others have mentioned, good and bad experiences for the little ones have no relation to blood - it's more about 'parenting' genes/skills (or lack of). Like the thing about planting the seed (or producing it) doesn't mean one is a father (mother) :-/.

Rated for just another one of the many shortcomings in society.
Tori's Torch - Thanks for your response and the message. You are and your family are in my thoughts.

Witchy - The pay is really just to cover expenses, and for us, it basically did. Absorbing costs for another child isn't trivial, especially if medical coverage isn't paid for, but with Medicaid and funding for daycare, it was a wash.

Willett - Good for you! I hope you have a good experience, and I look forward to hearing about how it's going.

Ted - Thank you for dropping by!

phyllis' - That is a very good point; only the bad stories get covered. All the hundreds of times when the system works right get no attention at all. And I have to confess: I am also a Grimm fan!

Seer - Thanks. It is good being spurred to think about things when watching television; maybe the writers were intentionally stirring up some of these feelings I had.

Maurene - Thanks for your comment. And huge amen to the reality that shared DNA doesn't always make the best parent!