Cause for Pause

SEPTEMBER 11, 2009 11:26AM

September 11th, 1896

Rate: 10 Flag

 

Twin Towers

 

Every year I asked high school juniors to construct  a traditional and often dreaded Poetry Project. The mere mention of it caused half the class to tremble, as no doubt many of you remember well.

 

Before 9/11, the finished projects were literal, showing the poet's intent through the eyes of the student. Some drew, others cut and pasted from magazines, some even sang or played music to illustrate. Although many were highly creative and artistically gifted, they were without fail typical presentations.

 

The American Literature assignment:

 

  • Select 10 poems from one or more poets presented during the semester.
  • Each poem or line must be  illustrated separately using any medium or facilitator.

 

After 9/11, one 16 year old boy selected only one poem.

As you read it, visualize his hastily sketched pencil-drawing on wrinkled, smudged, torn and tattered brown paper.

 

Instead of clouds, like in the picture above, see billows of smoke and you'll have an idea of his original drawing.

 

His project was voted "Best of Show" and  awarded the highest grade in the class.

 

 

 My life closed twice before its close;

        It yet remains to see

If Immortality unveil

        A third event to me,

So huge, so hopeless to conceive,

       As these that twice befell.

Parting is all we know of heaven,

       And all we need of hell.

 

 

Poems by Emily Dickinson, third series, in 1896.

 

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Thanks for the poem. It's interesting to think about Dickinson and 9/11. What would she have thought? I think your student poet does a good job of giving us a sense of that.
wow.
it's amazing what teenagers have inside of their hearts that we might never have a chance to see.
thank you for sharing that :)
I always loved Emily Dickinson.
Incredibly insightful.

R.
Since he submitted that illustration, I can only see that image through his eyes....
children are natural poets. thoughts and images spring from their pure minds. utterly pure and completely uniquely their own.
incredible. a wise, thoughtful boy.
Insightful... I'm so happy to see Dickinson still maintains a relevancy. rAted!
Every year I learned more from my students than they ever learned from me. Kids have changed, though, since 9/11, especially in the first five years after the towers went down.
Here's hoping for no "third event."
You sound like a good teacher with interesting students.
Thanks, Hawley - I love watching students evolve through exposure of any genre, but poetry in particular seems to make the biggest impact.

@ John Guzlowski - I can't imagine that Emily Dickinson could have handled 9/11. She might have eventually alluded to it, but it would have been veiled, to be sure, as were the few 'political' references she made in her own lifetime.