Cause for Pause

AUGUST 24, 2010 1:53PM

Confederacy of Dunces

Rate: 9 Flag

 

dunces 3

 I was drawn to this book by the title alone and the uniqueness of the cover. The brilliance of the satire did not set in until after the first couple of chapters.

 Ignatius, an unforgettable force, is clearly a genius. Yet, he has no desire to be self-supporting, is slovenly, and writes his gifted essays in a diary on an elementary writing tablet.

 What's amazing to me is after reading 270 reviews on Shelfari, not one alluded to the significance of the title. Haven't checked Goodreads yet.

 It's derived from the epigraph by Jonathan Swift: Thoughts on Various Subjects, Moral and Diverting

 

                  "When a true genius appears in the world,  you may know him by this sign: that the dunces are all in confederacy against him."

 

All of the characters are dunces in Ignatius' mind, not against him, but simply that they exist. He dissects, criticizes and judges their failings, but never his own. That's the flaw in Swift's analogy.

 After devouring every line, I wondered whether or not I was surrounded by the confederacy, or if I was one of the dunces within it?

 The characters believe themselves to be destined for greatness, whether it is the stripper, the general manager of the pants factory, the hot dog vendor or the police officer. 

 They are all self-absorbed to which Ignatius attaches his hyper-critical assessments believing that his genius entitles him to that sovereign and authoritative right. He never quite grasps, except maybe toward the end, that he is the strongest member of the confederacy, giving the title and the theme an ultimate irony.

 It's these parallels that make the book uproariously funny capsulizing them all as dunces serving in a flaccid confederacy, charging onward always groping, doomed to failure.  Collectively, they illustrate the mindset of the '60's, the timeframe in which this book was written. 

 Learning of the author's suicide left me with a profound wondering of "Who will take his literary place?"

 His only other book, also published posthumously, The Neon Bible, cannot compare to Dunces -- but at least it gave me one more day with Toole, a true gift to American Literature. "

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I got about 3/4 the way through that book but never finished it. The boss took it home.
A Confederacy of Dunces is one of my favorite books EVER. Thank you for this! xox
I read this over five years ago and it seems to have surfaced again. Can't believe you never finished it, ocularnervosa -- Guess the boss thought it was a keeper.
I loved the book also, and was inspired by the backstory.
I will get it and read. Thanks, sounds like something I would inhale.
I'll bet Simon and Schuster is still kicking itself for rejecting Toole's submission, commenting that it "isn't really about anything.

You'll love it, Dr. Spud.
i read it so many years ago i hardly remembered the intricacys, but my 20something daughter picked it up and loved it... maybe it deserves a re-read.
sorry, intricacies... we have to be on our best behavior with crazypants out there.
the boss took it home; nice
Apparently, Don, that flew right over my head.
loved this book; read it years ago and now need to reread...
'Dunces' has been on high school reading lists for the past several years. At least, that's where I find them at Barnes and Noble.
Try the Magnificent Dunderheads edited by Rex Stout. Out of print but you can borrow it from the library.
Thanks for the tip, OSE - Can't find it anywhere, you're right. Not even independent sellers on Amazon or through the add-on Invisible Hand which usually finds everything.
Correction: OES....
@OEsheepdog: This is the only one I could find attributed to Rex Stout. Is this the one you're talking about?


Rex Stout
1942 The Illustrious Dunderheads - a collection of isolationist, anti-WWII and pro-Nazi statements and votes by sitting Members of Congress ...
Thanks, Blueroses. I have not read this book, and now I know someone who has recommended it and others who backed her up. It's on my list. ~R
I think the motivation, for me at least, to re-read this book is because of the current political climate given the title....
Addendum:

Collectively, the characters set within the title illustrate the mindset of the 2010 political climate...
Mr. Cruz,

Take your disingenuous comments and shameless spamming some place else.

Best Wishes,

Blue Roses

R- for reported
Tip: Took 'Dunces' with me to read during 'wait time' with a friend at a very serious court case in Galveston this morning.

The satire, especially during a second reading, produces instant guffaws. Had to put it up....
Gosh! Must read this book!
This was a powerful piece. The backstory is unbearably tragic. Had he just kept going...

I know all about Swift, and that quote ,but your analysis felt fresh and poignant.
Thanks, fernsy - Good literature gets better with age.
The funniest book I ever read.
True, Miguela. Couldn't put it down and was crushed to find his demise.