BOKO

With existence comes responsibility.

BOKO

BOKO
Birthday
August 04
Bio
Here for now, will leave when I'm done.

MY RECENT POSTS

JANUARY 31, 2011 4:38PM

Cossery in 2011

Rate: 24 Flag

Albert Cossery was not a son of the poor.  Or, to put it in the street vernacular of his characters, the "son of a dog."  That's just one of the many epithets they use for each other, constantly, in Arabic translated into French--its closest meaning in English being not the literal "son of a bitch" so much as the much stronger and earthier "motherfucker."

Cossery was born in 1913 in Cairo, the son of a property owner, which made his family of the same class that became the dreaded targets of his later fiction.  He was also of Greek Orthodox and Lebanese descent--a double bourgeois whammy since many of the ruling order in Egypt at the time were of foreign Middle Eastern background.  Egyptians themselves, like in so many colonial zones, were regarded as little more than dirt by the owners and landlords who ruled directly over them.

The class divisions of the pre-Nasser era in Egypt dominate Cossery's writing.  From his first effort, a loosely stitched together group of stories called Men God Forgot, to the posthumously translated A Splendid Conspiracy, Cossery's output over seventy years was meagre and harsh.  Much like the thieves, prostitutes, and unemployed he chose to write about, Cossery was sullen when it came to the prospects for change in his native Egypt.  He left early in life, like so many writers between the wars, for the relative safety and cultural stimulation of Paris where he settled for the rest of his days.  He died in 2008 at the age of 94.

He wrote all of his fiction in French, although he said that he still "thought in Arabic," and in fact his writing shows the unmistakable mark his homeland made upon him.  The dilemmas of his characters, and the superstitions and personal mythologies they suffer under, are all Egyptian to the core.  Only Egypt, with its millenial history of brutal oppression, first by Egyptians, later by outsiders, and later still by Egyptians once again, could have produced an artist who wrote so intimately and so minutely about misery.  His acidic outlook earned him the title from critics of the "Voltaire of the Nile." 

albertcossery 

Egyptians themselves have a love-hate relationship with Cossery.  He belonged to that generation who saw the fight against the colonial powers as the final test of Egyptian independence.  Few institutions in Egypt recognise him, even though several leading scholars there have translated and celebrated his work.  Cossery was sanguine about the results of the post-independence governments, and remained dedicated to the poorest of the poor.  But some of his work, written in the days leading up to the last revolution in his homeland, echo events today with an eery prescience.

In one of the stories in Men God Forgot, "The Barber has Killed his Wife," a character is thinking about the future of the country and its people.  A resident of one of the poorest quarters in Cairo, Chaktour the tinker, is trying to connect two seemingly unrelated events, the recent murder of a woman by her husband, an otherwise perfectly sane man, and the revolt by a group of street-sweepers against the government authority that keeps them in an abject state of near-starvation (many of them are too poor to afford shoes).  Chaktour is convinced that the man who killed his family, Saadi, was acting out of desperation, from a life that left him no place to go.  While the street sweepers' battle against police over a few lousy pennies--one of them picks up their supervisor and throws him through a plate-glass window in an upscale shopping district--represents another side of the same profound frustration.  Chaktour explains the link between the two events to a man he meets:

"'I should like to know...'

'What?'

'What the semblance is between Saadi's crime and the sweepers' revolt.'

'Do you think there's some connection between the two things?'

'Not a connection but a similar wish.  A very simple wish, that I feel everywhere around me, but that I cannot identify.  We must be several to do that.  All of us, with our wives and children.  Then it will penetrate into our hearts, it will become terrible and it will grow in us.  And when it becomes immense in us and we can no longer support its presence in our hearts, we too will commit deeds that seem senseless to us today, but which at that moment will be simple and just.'" 

As Cossery's fiction matured over the decades, and it became obvious that there would be no release for Egyptians under their new Egyptian rulers, he turned increasingly in his depictions to subtler and even more controversial methods of resistance.  Even laziness, the withdrawal from society and refusal to work, became a potential way out.  This led some critics to regard Cossery as a relic, a dandy, a "misanthropic old sot."  But he never abandoned those on the lowest rung of Arab society--beggars, the disabled, pimps, prostitutes, drug addicts and those who are just too frustrated, and too imbued with some vaguely defined sense of remaining dignity, to submit to the terrors of a state and a society set on breaking them.

It remains to be seen whether the protestors in the streets of Cairo and other cities in North Africa and the Yemen are willing to recognise this group--all those who do not fit into the reigning, U.S.-supported regimes and the deeply divided societies they foster--and do something about their long enduring misery.  As Slavoj Zizek and others pointed out during the uprising in Iran, it is to these people, the despised, the dispossessed, the "left out," that any real revolution must look.  With the global economic depression squeezing all the regimes in the area, skyrocketing food and fuel prices threaten to drive millions more, who barely maintained some standard of living up to this point, into the shadows where Cossery's characters trudge through a sort of living death. 

This sense of immediate necessity, beyond the false sense always offered by a heartless system of wage and land exploitation, has created a window, a chance to break the spell that has hung over millions upon millions of people for centuries.  But when all the smoke has cleared and all the slogans have died down in Cairo and Tunis and Sana'a, the "left out," the dispossessed, those whom God forgot, will remain.  And the real test of any new order will be met.  Or it won't--once again.

 

 

______________________

Quotation from Les hommes oublies de Dieu, translated by Harold Edwards, City Lights Books, 1963

 

  

 

 

 

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Cossery's best known work is probably "The Lazy Ones," but recently "A Splendid Conspiracy" which was published in an excellent English translation by New Directions last year, has received a lot of attention.
Cossery on OS! I have died and gone to some more literate heaven. Now we'll have to give up on the popular stereotype of Americans as stupid and undereducated that's thrown around so freely here. Don't you know we're all supposed to be Homer Simpsons who just care about donuts? A brilliant man, and brilliant choice.

R
I'll have to read his books. It sounds like Beckett to me, and I like that point of view.
Caracalla - There are no solutions other than modern and fully socialized ones. Everything else is a myth of capital, and leads right back into the streets, or someplace worse.

skinny dave - Homer is on vacation. I'm his much older brother. And I like donuts, just not exclusively.

Sam - You make the most interesting comments. Where to begin with a comparison/contrast of the two authors' work? There are similiarities, but Beckett's people seem to me to be even more fragmented than Cossery's. They're literally breaking down into bits and pieces. Cossery's characters maintain a stubborn solidity in the face of the most awful horrors of their poverty. That's a beginning...
I never heard of him, but I am only now getting into literature. Trying to work my way through Crime and Punishment, which I find to be very interesting, although Dosty seems a bit reactionary to me.

I shall have to read Cossery. I rated this and "liked" it on Facebook, and posted it on a few friends FB posts as well.

We often forget that Nasserism, Marxism, Islamicism, they are all appealing to similar groups of people for similar reasons: poverty, hopelessness and constant, unrelenting imperialism.

r
Rw005g - I don't think that's exactly accurate. Islam is not appealing to the same people as the others you mention. Nasserism is mostly an invention of Western critics--there was no sense of any consistent philosophy for those who lived under it, it seemed to change from day to day although the platitudes remained the same. It was an extremely authoritarian regime, and relatively short lived. It's not as transferable as many political commentators make it out to be when discussing other Arab uprisings. It's more of a slogan--local realities and political conditions vary widely in the Arab world. Marxism deals with a global systemic of labor that is common to all of them today. Its appeal in the Middle East has been partly as a secular alternative TO Islam, and so it tends to find support amongst literate people, if not the middle class who are pretty reactionary throughout the region even today. Of course when times get tough, some people who regarded themselves as safe from falling into the most abject poverty begin to realize that their situation wasn't so safe, or so good, all along.
Rw - Of course there is a layer of literate scholars who keep the Islamicist thing going. But most of the followers are not literate, or barely, and rely on the leadership for the endless interpretiveness that comprises the substance of the various movements. For most people Islam is a form of culturalism, a given fact of life--something that comes through clearly in Cossery--and that doesn't exclude other perspectives, incluidng political and even revolutionary ones, from intervening.
There was such a long pause between Cossery's writing about it and the eventual uprising that came, doesn't that tell you something? The capacity for misery is astounding.

He's been accused of fatalism. He seems to suggest that there's no end in sight, that pain is an inevitable part of the human condition and we're all on an endless wheel of suffering, being tortured by existence. Then at other moments, he entertains thoughts of some kind of violent release from the torture. Isn't this the violence of futility? Or does it matter? He doesn't seem to suggest a true social alternative in Men God Forgot. I haven't read his later work.\
Rated
Interacting with you gives focus to my thoughts. Even though we don't often agree, I am better-off for the interaction. Even though OS sucks in numerous ways, I gain from things such as this! 8)
Tracy - He's been accused of political fatalism, and a more serious universal fatalism as you point out. Politically his focus on poverty and suffering and possible forms of resistance all seem to answer the first charge. We'll call that the bourgeois response--the same critics who make that accusation often seem to have trouble stomaching some of the less pretty facts of life he reveals. The second charge is much more difficult.

I think that Cossery, especially in his later work, finds possibilities in passivity for resistance. Maybe that's the connection with Beckett, too. Both of them find in a radical passivity a way to answer the sense of frustration experienced by people as they come up against an indifferent system again and again. It's beyond the Bartleby option. Some of Cossery's characters make lethargy into an art form. But from this point of view, the violent passage a l-acte must seem attractive. Like a strange country. This is hardly fatalism, at least not a simple one.
RW- Thanks for stopping. I like your posts, too. The Egyptian and Tunisian situations have been distracting me lately. I'll get over to your blog to comment more sometime soon.
yeah. cossery seems relevant right now. he's always good. the movement in egypt is moving fast, and i see that israel raised the specter of islamic radicals and stuff today. the white house position of allowing mubarak to oversee "reforms" is bizarre. cossery would have supported the protestors and jumped at the chance to get rid of mubarak. yeah.
----Hm, gives one some ideas about what to do with "supervisors" everywhere...hmm....----
Never heard of him, but you make him sound like my type of guy. Anyone who thinks first of the poor and downtrodden has been there. You're a very good writer.
stupot - The position of the White House, to allow Mubarak to stay and oversee the "transition" or "reforms" or whatever, is an absolute obscenity. It's a way of indicating that they want nothing to change. It shows to what extent this administration has lost touch with reality. Obviously Mubarak would take any such opportunity to murder the opposition and then hold "free" elections to his liking. Remember, his son, and his right-hand hatchet man Suleiman still wait in the wings. This is a moment of truth for the Obama administration, and so far they're failing miserably.
Commentary - Supervisors vary from place to place, but the positionality is universal, yes, and so are the possible responses...

Scanner - I would say that Cossery had been there and then back again, several times. He sought out anonymity and obscurity and poverty because he thought that these were the representative conditions of modern life everywhere. Unfortunately he is as right today as ever. Thank you for stopping.
Do not this author or his work at all, but the excerpt you included reminds me a little of Camus.

As for the future in the ever-troubled Mideast, history suggests that true democracy will have a difficult time in places where one strongman or another has ruled for millennia. But one can always hope audaciously.
Cossery is profound in his perspective, almost every word strikes to the heart of things. His take on passivity seems different from Beckett's though. With Cossery it seems more like the calm before the storm, the inevitbability is in the coming violent tide which will cleanse everything. At the same time there's some danger in believing in this sort of thing, as if it will happen all by itself. We have to break through our passivity to make it happen. With Beckett it seems like passivity is all there is, the only halfway digestible option among many ugly ones. When his characters, his "bits and pieces" of people do manage to break through their own paralysis, the results seem more desperate, more pathetic than anything.
Humanity lives in garbage. Cossery knew this, and wouldn't look away. He was crucified for it--and now, look, he was right. The garbage stirs...
It would be very enlightening to read Egyptian (and other M.E.) writing. Our view of the world is shaped by the mind-to-mind experience of reading, and for us in the U.S. & Canada, that comes from our own authors and those of Europe. That contributes to our thinking of people in the rest of the world as The Other, I think - we only have exterior experience of them, and that can be alarming or very strange...
Tom - Cossery knew Camus, but they parted ways as they grew older. After the war, Camus became more conservative and more reactionary. Cossery headed in the opposite direction, or rather, he kept heading in his own direction. The gulf between Camus' deeply humanistic literature, and his pitiless philosophy, has always been a disappointment to me.

Davey - Thanks for clearing that up. The point goes back to Sam's comment. Out of the mouths of youth...

Dr Lee - I love your poem! "A little man" indeed.

Myriad - What's all this "our view of the world" stuff? It's not my view. I've traveled around the world several times over and I've read literature from most of the places I've been. City Lights and New Directions have been sources for a long time. Crack a book, my friend, or book a flight. Or both. Plenty of Americans don't share that more limited "view."
Not someone I know, but I'm interested in that perspective, particularly if it's as good and representative as you say.

Thank you.
kosher - You're welcome. Nothing like sharing good writers. It's a literate crowd here at OS.

For those interested, Citizentube, youtube's free user channel is hosting videos from on-the-ground in Egypt right now. Brilliant, first-hand stuff:

http://www.youtube.com/citizentube?feature=ticker

The internet is all lit up tonight over Egypt. Encouraging to see so many people fostering this. They might just have a shot at getting rid of Mubarak after all. Good night.
so you never did say, boko...what exactly is your point of view on what's happening now in Egypt?
"Orders had gone out a month ago: the city must be liberated from the lowlifes that had taken to swarming like ants at a picnic in even the most respectable streets. This was one of many directives that the new governor — a man bursting with bold initiatives — had issued, and admittedly, it was the most difficult to carry out. The new governor's ambition was to clean up the streets and protect them from any further blots upon their honor; he talked about streets as if they were people. So, after the prostitutes, the street vendors, the cigarette-butt collectors, and other minor scofflaws, he had set his sights on the beggars, a peaceful race with such deep roots in the soil that no presumptive conqueror before him had ever succeeded in exterminating it. It was as if he wanted to disburden the desert of its sand."

"So the policeman, this zealous servant of a mighty state, threw himself at the beggar (whose very serenity was a kind of provocation), roundly berating him according to rules of a time-tested art. But the beggar failed to react to these insults, murderous though they were. He was an old man, hideously wrinkled, with a gray beard that swallowed up the whole of his face and a head that vanished under an enormous turban. His eyes were closed, and the thick black circles under them gave him an epicene appearance altogether unusual for a bum. What's more, he was dressed in a fanciful multi-colored outfit better suited to a street acrobat than to a man in his condition. This eccentric old man, the ancestor of his eternally persecuted race, seemed sunk in a deep sleep that even the deafening roar of the countless cars fighting through the intersection could not disturb. At last, realizing the futility of his insults and orders, the cop gave the bum a kick, and then another kick, to knock him out of his infuriating inertia. He was just about to kick him again when he saw the beggar abandon his initial position and slump to the ground, where he assumed the proud and thoroughly disdainful attitude of the dead. For a moment, the policeman thought he'd killed him and was seized with panic at the thought of having lost his prey. A dead beggar was worth less than nothing; it might even get him fired. He needed this bum to be alive. Bending over the old man, he grabbed him by his turban, shaking him with savage fury in an attempt to bring him back to life. This action was both rash and irreparable: as if by magic, the beggar's head became detached from his neck and remained stuck to the turban, which the policeman continued to brandish in the air like a bloody trophy."

From The Jokers, Albert Cossery, 1964.
Mr Mubarak says that he won't be running in the elections planned for September, but as long as he stays we all know, and the Egyptian people all know, exactly what that mens: a crackdown and repression, with some limp excuses from the White House. The Obama administration's vacillating, weak position on this is no longer tenable. When they're discussing your "strategy" on every network, Mr President, it's no longer a strategy. It's ridiculous. Mr Mubarak, get out of Egypt.
I read a short story from him online last night. Great. I'm going to buy a couple of his novels from Amazon. It doesn't look like a lot of his work was translated. Unfortunately, I don't read French! All the comments that I found say how beautifully he writes in that language. C'est la vie! *(: >)
Most of the translations of Cossery are several decades old. Last year two new ones came out: "A Splendid Conspiracy," translated by Alyson Waters, and "Violence and Derision" by New York Review of Books Classics. They're both well done, although I'm partial to the City Lights translations.
I am so happy to see you mention a writer that I thought was read by no one else at all Boko. I read a translation of his years ago and remember him well.
OS has some good posts sometimes. This one is a treasure to read.
I am stunned for some reason. I guess I am not the only one who reads here and need to remember that.

Egypt is going down to the dogs. Our prez is looking more than slightly sad from trying to straddle too many fences lately. It is not good right now for the people who want what Americans peddle the most: ideas. Never mind the war materials.
Mission - Some of the best writers are hardly read by anyone.
@stu,
In answer to your question...
All I see is a series of ruptures.
typical Deleuzian. yeah.
We don't have many good writers today in America. Cossery sounds like a bohemian and I love writers like that. We got off on the wrong track when we started paying too much attention to big publishing companies and the tripe they put out. It's also good to point out that the protests in Egypt aren't the end of things. They'll have to figure out some way to keep the economic troubles that really caused this from toppling the next government, and the next one...since I think the "recession" is going to be with us all for some time. Global food prices have risen sharply, and there's talk of hyperinflation in Europe!

Rated.
Glad to see all this discussion about Cossery. I translated, with great passion and care, A Splendid Conspiracy. His last novel, Les couleurs de l'infamie, I also translated and it will be coming out with ND later this year as The Colors of Infamy. NYRB published his Violence et Derision as The Jokers last year (translated by Anna Moschovakis). Cossery's moment seems to have finally come. Thank you for spreading the word.
--Alyson
Alyson - Je vous en prie. Feel free to message me here when the translation of Les couleurs de l'infamie comes out. I'll write something up about it.
I enjoy the Cossery wit. He has an incomparable way of comparing wealth to poverty and the powerful to the powerless. Thanks for reminding me that someone gifted me with his latest book.
Alaa Al Aswany is another fine contemporary writer who takes a direct approach against the current regime. "The Yacoubian Building" was a bestseller across the Middle East, and although she has a very different view from Cossery, she's skilled at drawing out the conflicts between local societies and U.S. influences in the area. She's on my to-read list.
Mr Mubarak is no longer in power tonight in Egypt. Somewhere a camel smiles. Bon soir, Albert.