Booknut

Booknut
Location
Washington, District of Columbia, USA
Birthday
March 08
Bio
I am a social activist (not afraid to call myself LIBERAL in capital letters) who is passionate about peace and loves to read, travel to developing countries, listen to/see provocative lectures and plays -- and drink mojitos!

MY RECENT POSTS

Booknut's Links

MY LINKS
OCTOBER 7, 2012 7:27PM

US will someday reap what it sows through drone attacks

Rate: 5 Flag

“I will never forget what the American soldiers did to my country, my tribe and my family.  They violated our national sovereignty and our Islamic laws. They killed my son and my younger brother.  They destroyed my home. If I see the soldiers who are responsible for this – if I have the opportunity -- I will kill them.” (translated from Pashto)

These are the chilling words of Kareem Khan, a Pakistani journalist from a tribe in Northern Waziristan, whose compound was destroyed by a Hellfire missile from an American drone on Dec. 24, 2009.  They starkly illustrate the concept of “blowback.” What you sow today, you will reap tomorrow -- in this case, hatred and a desire for revenge born from shattering personal loss and a tribal code (called Pashtunwali, or “way of the Pashtuns”) that dictates a simple recipe for justice: eye for an eye.  

To a large extent, this equation explains the intense and ongoing anger over the movie trailer that denigrated the prophet Mohammed. The video by itself would not have produced anger that is so sustained. The Western world’s disrespect of the Islamic culture is perceived to be – often justifiably so – long and broad. In Pakistan, anti-American riots on Fridays after prayers are continuing even now – so much so that the U.S. embassy compound is in almost total lock-down. When CodePink -- a delegation of Americans -- tried to visit the embassy in our van, we were held in virtual captivity a half mile away by the Pakistani police for more than 40 minutes. (After a phone call to the deputy head of mission – a connection most Americans and Pakistanis don’t have – we were miraculously permitted to drive by. We had to argue with the guards, using a show of CodePink “chutzpah,” to be allowed just to take pictures outside.)

The cordon of security that isolates the U.S. embassy into a Green-Zone “bubble” also creates a sense of American impunity among a people who feel that their very survival is under threat. “If they think specific people have done something wrong, arrest them and bring them to court. That is a basic right you give to your own people,” Khan told us. “But (Americans) don’t consider us human beings. I can’t go to your embassy (to register a complaint). This is our sovereign state, but no one can go there without permission.”

Only three persons were in Kahn’s compound when the drone sent six Hellfire missiles crashing into it: a mason who was building a mosque nearby, Kahn's 16-year-old son and his younger brother, who worked as a teacher and believed education was more powerful than the gun. Instead, the drones came and taught his students hatred. As the New York Times has reported, “drones have replaced Guantanamo as the recruiting tool of choice for militants.”  Earlier this year, the Pew Research Center found that 74 percent of Pakistanis now consider the United States to be an enemy. Particularly insidious is the increasingly common belief that the CIA is paying informants to plant tiny, silicon-chip homing devices that attract drones in homes of suspected “militants”; however, says Khan, those chips are frequently used instead to settle old grudges and disputes between tribes. (A note about that word “militant,” so often used by the Western media: Too often all those who are killed by drones are assumed to be terrorists. U.S. officials have confirmed that it now counts all adult males to be militants, absent exonerating evidence. In other words, all men living in Waziristan are guilty until proven otherwise.)

Although the U.S. announced shortly after the strike on Khan’s compound that a “militant target” named Al Juma had been killed, no one by that name was present.  Several months later, yet another strike allegedly killed the same man. “I think actually he is still alive today,” Khan said with graveyard humor.


Each of these Hellfire missiles costs $60,000.

“Twenty-four hours a day, the American drones circle our airspace. Whenever they want to attack any house, no one can (or will even try to) stop them,” Kahn observed. “Everything in our lives is affected – our ability to work, go to school and provide a future for our children. Our boys are leaving for cities elsewhere in Pakistan.”

Another Waziri tribal elder, Malik Jalal, echoed Kahn’s concerns, reporting 17 suicides in the region in the last month alone.

“Family members can’t sit together in large gatherings anymore, for weddings or even funerals; we are too afraid of appearing 'suspicious' to the Americans,” he explained. Consider the story of Sherabaz Khan, who lost both of his brothers on March 17, 2011, when 50 of his tribe members were killed while participating in a jirga, an assembly of Pashtun elders in which tribal decisions are made. Pakistani government authorities had been informed in advance of the planned meeting, yet they clearly did nothing to stop the drone attack. (Despite protestations to the contrary by officials, it is widely acknowledged among the Pakistani people that their government is cooperating at some level with the United States in the drone program.)

Noor Behram, a photojournalist from North Waziristan, has been documenting the effects of drone strikes for four years, focusing on the deaths of children and women.  Many women have been killed in drone attacks, since the kitchen is normally adjacent to the large meeting room where jirgas and other gatherings are held. Yet, they frequently go undocumented due to the practice in Waziristan of purda, or the separation of women – to the point that they are not allowed to be photographed, for instance, or even talked about in conversation with outsiders. Women’s deaths are not officially reported.

“So far I have counted more than 670 women who have been killed by drones, most while working in kitchens, and 100 children,” said Behram. To work around the purda restrictions, he begins by collecting the names of the brothers or fathers of women who have been killed, and photos of their clothing. Slowly, as word of his work spreads, tribal members are coming forward to tell them the stories of their women and children, and he often travels up to seven hours to collect the information.

Behram has held an exhibition in Islamabad, and foreign publications like the UK’s Guardian and Germany’s Der Spiegel have printed his pictures. But Pakistani media will not use his images, or even announce the deaths he documents.

“The mainstream narrative in Pakistan has been very pro-drone,” explained Shahzad Akbar, founder of the Foundation for Fundamental Rights (FFR), the organization that is sponsoring the CodePink delegation and sued the CIA for wrongful deaths caused by drones in Pakistan. “If a woman is whipped for violating some norm, those images are shown right away. But drone victims? No. That is slowly changing. “

FFR also is challenging the Pakistani government’s acquiescence with the drone program and – with the UK’s Reprieve – the British government for its own role in providing intelligence.

“Tell your president he must stop using drones to kill innocent people, and tell your fellow Americans they must join you in protesting,” pleaded Kareem Khan. “We are proud of our culture and our way of life, and you are destroying it.”

Author tags:

drones, pakistan

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Thanks for the outstanding article, which should be front page new in the New York Times, but isn't. Obviously. When it comes to American medieval barbarism, this ranks right up there with Guananamo and Abu Ghraib.
A great, informative and insightful piece. THank you.

For what it's worth : "They killed my son and my younger brother. They destroyed my home. If I see the soldiers who are responsible for this – if I have the opportunity -- I will kill them,” works for me, too.
I noted Your return to open sewer with much appreciation. Unfortunately, most of my twenty minutes which I allot myself, is devoted to following the leader of willfully ignorant ones, apisash*t.

Your voice has been missed amongst the din of bullsh*t he and others spew.

Welcome back.

Your friend,

mark

-R-
Thanks Mark! I started my own blog on Tumblr, and have been posting there, as well as on platforms such as Mondoweiss. But...I want to speak to as many people as possible! Thus, my return. I look forward to exchanging comments once again with everyone here...
The ignorant arrogance of the US drone agenda a appalling but drones are, at the moment, relatively new. When they become more universal the USA will feel the anger.
The American disconnect on this issue is staggering. And when this boomerangs back on us we'll act "outraged" and use that as "proof" we need to be bombing the world back to the stone age. The idiots who believe this makes us safer (Hi, Mr. President!) are, in fact, delusional when the reality is it makes us less safe and endangers American lives.

The only thing Obama is safeguarding with these murders is his political career.
I plead with Kareem Khan to fight against the Taliban and the Al Qaida with us and the war will end. Al Qaida attacked the USA from bases in Afghanistan. Now the Taliban are attacking our allies in Afghanistan from Pakistan. They attack India. In fact, every terrorist attack since 9/11 has been launch from Pakistan. Please help us stop that. We are not going to let the bullies intimidate us into ... what ever their diabolical agenda is! We are on the warpath. When Al Qaida and the Taliban and the other terrorist organizations stop fighting, the war will be over. They out number us, we may even lose the immediate battles, however, we will never surrender. We will fight for democracy and human rights for as long as it takes.
Earthling! Do you remember what happened when the Soviets occupied Afghanistan, and we armed the mujahideen? It came back to haunt us later. The same will happen with our drone strikes. We are handing the Taliban factions a recruiting tool. You can bomb to smithereens today and feel good about it, but the people you kill will only be replaced if we don't seek other solutions.