Brian B

Brian B
Location
Thunder Bay, Canada
Birthday
November 14
Title
Devil's Advocate
Company
The Sort of Company your mother warned you about
Bio
A Work in Progress. When not doing the devil's work, I'm the single parent of two great young men, living playing and working in beautiful Thunder Bay Ontario. That's at the western end of Lake Superior - the North end of Highway 61. from here, you can just drive all the way to New Orleans, though I have yet to do it.

Brian B's Links

Salon.com
JUNE 1, 2009 8:44AM

Undesirable Alien? Moi?

Rate: 17 Flag

"The World's Longest Undefended Border" is undergoing another fundamental shift today.

 The US-Canada border has never actually been undefended, but recent measures - drone Predator aircraft, increased patrols, infra red cameras, have improved security.

 Today, however,  the United States, for the first time ever, requires Canadians crossing by land into the United states to have a passport, or a rare 'enhanced drivers license'. Americans returning home from Canada will face similar requirements.

 The latter point potentially has a huge negative impact on Canada's cross border economy. Although over 54% of Canadians have a passport , only about 27% of Americans have one.

This applies even in the towns in Quebec and the Maritimes which straddle the border. In one town, the church is bisected by the line, and in Americans park on the wrong side of the lot, they may be unable to return home. Neighbours can no longer run across the street for coffee without reporting to immigration control.

The rationale for this policy is of course, anti-terrorism. The underlying mentality is reflective of the fact that the U.S. Secretary of homeland Security ( a name that invariably reminds me of Hitler Germany, or 1984), in April repeated the totally false statement that 9-11 bombers crossed into the states from Canada.The government feels, apparently, that it must be seen to be doing something, for appearances, no matter what the results. 

As a result of this policy, I won't be crossing the border any time soon, though I live about 40 minutes away, and historically, have visited once or twice a year.Never having travelled anywhere BUT the U. S. (except that day trip to Nogales Mexico in 1965), I never felt the need.

Mid-sized B applied for his passport over two years ago, though he hates to travel, because he was planning to visit a friend in Ohio, by air, and the regulations affected air travel last year.  I filled out the forms too, but, for some reason, never submitted them,. and misplaced them when I moved. When the United states finally said they were persisting with this policy, midsized B downloaded a fresh set of forms for me. They still sit next to my computer, months later. 

 I know that I should get a passport. The last minute May rush to beat the June 1 deadline must be dissipating. I may need to travel for work some day. I love day trips along the shore of Superior.

Yet, I can not help feeling insulted that I am treated like an undesirable alien. After all, my forebearers abandoned Iowa for Ontario, so clearly, I come from a dangerous background. So, I won't get around to applying, I guess, until I get over this feeling.

 I also can not help but wonder whether, in some small way, the terrorists have won.

 

Author tags:

news, politics, travel

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Brian, I know of places in northern New Hampshire where you can be on a walk in the woods and cross the border into Quebec. And I've seen border patrols on the Interstate in Vermont. It's going to be awfully tough to enforce this kind of regulation. Nevertheless, I have my passport at the ready.

And I cannot picture you as an undesirable alien. But as an alien, do you have any special powers?
This is a crap ruling, and yes, the terrorists have won hands-down. I'm sorry Brian - this was done without my agreement or consent.
Very interesting! Great post! It is sad that we have to take such extreme measures and lock up the Canadian borders also. I feel the terrorists have won, they control our country's way of thinking, feeling and even our peace of mind. Not to mention the inconvenience of all changes of security, which has made the thought of traveling almost unbearable.
The bizarro-world of post-9/11/01 has decimated Tijuana, legendary den of sin and now regional champion of brutal drug-trade murders. For the first time in my memory, you need a Passport to get back across the border.

I read "Homeland Security" as "Gestapo Bullshit" myself. So many lies hang on the feeble official tale of 9/11. "Enhanced security" at the borders seems like so much more nonsense. There are no "terrorists." 9/11 was a false-flag operation -- who benefited?

In the meantime, I need a Passport to get back from a day trip to Tijuana or Ensenada? Since when? Bureaucracy makes budgets fat, it does not "enhance" security.
COS: besides the resemblance to a sunflower?
Ardee: wasn't thinking you would.
fireeyes: well said
GW: I've always said that once Santa Monica's domestic help gets turned back at the border, the rules will be relaxed...
You are so right, Brian. I have heard so many Canadians, and other non USA people complain about the tone of the reception they get when they come to the States. Almost -- guilty until proven innocent. I guess it's the new normal. But please don't let it keep you from coming here!
What makes me mad is that it is based on the false premise that Canada is "soft" on terrorists and that terrorists have come from Canada to the U.S. Of course, Homeland Security boss Janet Napalinato repeats that allegation, even though she knows it is false.

It has nothing to do with terrorism, and everything to do with politics, which always trumps common sense.
oh brian, thank you for shedding light on this subject about which i knew absolutely nothing. what a piece of shit thing to happen!!! oh yes, having to have passport will totally cut down on those pesky terrorists!! way to go, homeland security. shit, man. to have to go through immigration to get some fucking coffee!!

on another note, you do have to get a passport so you and/or medium B can come visit the wonderpups and me in lovely portland, oregon. i know im' not much of a draw, being fat and mud brown and all, but the girls are outstanding in every way. love love lvoe and gratitude for this much needed piece!!! you need a title that is more on the nose, love. people need to read this sucker!!!
And now we've armed our border guards. Such fine progress wraught by the Bush/Cheney fear mongering. One crossing is actually closed for fear of violence. I guess they succeeded in destroying the peaceful, long-standing relationship between our two countries. And to boot, it will impede trade and traffic.

Good day all around.
I've only been to Canada once, when I was six, to Niagra Falls. Are they going to put immigration officers on the Maid of the Mist now? If I remember correctly, we got on the boat in Canada, went over to the base of the American Falls, then back to the base of the Canadian Falls. We stayed in an Econolodge on the Canadian side, but crossed back and forth on foot or on tour buses several times during our time there.

Other than a quick check of my Dad's ordinary Indiana driver's license when we entered Canada for the first time in the car, no one hassled us for our paperwork.

This is nutty. Western European countries have problems with terrorism too, and even though almost everyone has a passport there, crossing borders isn't this bureaucratic nightmare.
Alien? Maybe. Undesireable? Aw, come on now, don't be so hard on yourself!

Somehow I don't think this is going to be like the Berlin Wall, where those caught on the wrong side were out of luck. Don't be irritated, it's just a passport. Although I'm glad this didn't happen when I was in high school, otherwise how would I have gone up to Vancouver to get drunk every weekend?
PF: more proof sobriety is overrated?
Lee: there are spots along the river south of here that you can still walk across...shhh
janie: and Obama too chicken to reverse it.
emma: fear of terror, but also part of this whole racist illegal immigrant fear mongering too...
lea: I have the form here, somewhere...
I had no idea this was a "thing". I've always needed my passport when going to Canada. But then, I've only gotten there by plane.

An empathetic "grrrrrrf!" for you!

And a rate, of course!
Another ridiculous political move based on fear and plain ole George Bush dumbness. But the terrorists only win if you let them. Get the passport. My daughter is driving up into Ontario today (with passport in hand).
Well, I've had a passport since I was born...so to me, having a valid passport enables me to be somewhat spontaneous and go where I want to.

It may be an inconvenience, but I wouldn't let something like a little paperwork hold me down.

Rated
Please visit the US knowing that it welcomes you with open arms.

I enjoy having a passport and I think you will too. It is a ticket to a very large theater indeed. However, I hope your passport photo turns out better than mine did. lol

We can't let the terrorists win. Trust.
BT: passports were not required until 2008...
maryt: knew I could count on you for the push
Buffy: you adventurer you!
tai: back in '06 when this was first announced, I even got the picture taken, but got distracted planning on selling my house....
Any society that would give up a little liberty to gain a little security will deserve neither and lose both.
Benjamin Franklin
well quoted, cin