Far Above Diamonds

faith, baseball, true love, and a little great literature

Britomart

Britomart
Bio
I teach writing for a living. As I once told a student, "You can find out almost everything you need to know about me if you know that my car is named after both a character from Edmund Spenser's 'The Faerie Queene' and a character from Stephen King." I'm also a baseball fan who's seen more World Series rings in five years than I ever expected in five lifetimes of the Phillies and the Red Sox, a Christian yogi, a failed housekeeper, a mad book collector, and a blogger who's dangerously attached to (over)extended metaphors. Enjoy!

Britomart's Links

New list
JULY 6, 2009 10:51PM

I am a Reaganite* Republican, and I'm proud!

Rate: 7 Flag

I am inspired in content and formatting by Kind of Blue's wonderful post about being a "Bleeding Heart Liberal," here.  As I posted in my comment on Blue's post and have alluded to elsewhere, I'm as Republican as they come, and I'm praying that the 1994 congressional election repeats itself in 2010, and I even dare to hope that a Republican wins the White House in 2012. 

However, I agree with a good chunk of what Blue says when he's talking about reasons for being a "bleeding heart liberal."  My first eleven points directly parallel Blue's, and then I go my own way a bit.

Moreover, I've been irritated as all heck for years with the attitude, unfortunately for me pervasive in my chosen professional field, that Republicans are all greedy and uncaring and want to step on the little people.  Also, most troubling for me as an academic and educator is the attitude encapsulated in the old bumper sticker "Vote Republican: It's Easier Than Thinking."  With one exception, I've voted Republican ever since I've been able to vote, and here are the thoughts that underpin my doing so.  I may have been a Carter baby, but I was a Reagan child (and as an Anglophile, I am also quite a fan of Margaret Thatcher, from the same era), and to this day . . . 

I am a Reaganite Republican because, as the Gipper said, "Government is not the solution to our problems; government is the problem."   As the great Iron Maggie said, ". . . who is society? There is no such thing! There are individual men and women and there are families and no government can do anything except through people and people look to themselves first. It is our duty to look after ourselves and then also to help look after our neighbour . . . "

I want my government small.  I like my government off my back and out of my wallet.  I trust my family and friends, my neighbors and myself, not my government.

I am a Reaganite Republican because I believe in allocating more resources to education, but I never ever want to see another hour or penny spent on assessment, accountability, or administration.  Provide our students, K through grad school, with safe, clean institutions, appropriate resources, and content-expert teachers.  Then leave the teachers alone and let them do their thing.  For colleges, immediately close all the regional accrediting agencies and invest their funds in some kind of account that provides raises for professors in the region or scholarships for students.  Quit spending tax dollars on fiddling around with roads that won't need work for another couple decades and spend the money on raises for professors and tuition cuts for students.

I am a Reaganite Republican because I agree with Blue that "we are all entitled to full and effective health care coverage."  I believe, however, that this is not Europe, and this is not Canada, and that we as Americans need to find a way to provide health coverage for every man, woman, and child that gives no one other than individuals, their doctors, and their families a say in their treatment; that preserves choice of doctor, hospital, medication, et al.; that never generates the stories you hear from Europe and Canada about people being put on 6-month waitlists for tests and surgeries; that pays for it all without raising taxes a penny.

I am a Reaganite Republican because I believe our veterans are heroes and that we should all be on our knees thanking every veteran we know for keeping us free.  Of course they should have whatever the heck they need when they come home (as we all should, see above), but they are also entitled to sustained, public, unjaded respect and gratitude.  In my view, the pendulum hasn't swung far back enough from how people treated/talked about soldiers during the Vietnam War.  We need a little 1945.

I am a Reaganite Republican because I believe that marriage is between one man and one woman, but I think that consenting adults ought to be able to set up whatever households they choose (operative word, in my opinion), name whomever they like as medical decision-maker, beneficiary, and so on, without the need for any government involvement.

I am a Reaganite Republican because I do believe that the Soviet Union was an evil empire, and I believe that Communism/Socialism/fill in the blank were scourges on the soul of humanity, and I believe that there is plenty more evil out there in the world that never sleeps and wants to attack our freedom.  I wasn't always thrilled during the last 8 years, but I slept much easier in my bed with regard to issues of national security then than I do now. 

I'm completely with Blue on the next two--his words are in quotation marks

I am a Reaganite Republican "because I believe that women should be paid the equal amount that a man is paid for the same work and/or job."  Fair is fair; sensible is sensible.

I am a Reaganite Republican "because I don't believe in discrimination in any way, shape or form against another person, regardless of race, color, religion, ethnicity, sex or sexual preference."   

This is not a contradiction with my belief that marriage is between one man and one woman.  Both my religious beliefs and my (layperson's) knowledge of Western history contribute to this opinion, but it is not, I repeat NOT, discrimination.  We on the Right are quite, quite tired of the national debate on these kinds of issues being framed in such a way that we're "hateful" before we even open our mouths.  I believe we're all equal before God and each other--no discrimination there.

I am a Reaganite Republican because I believe in a flat tax.  I believe every person, business, whatever, should pay the same percentage of whatever they earn, and that's all the money the government gets that year.  So called "progressive taxation" is often called "regressive taxation" on my side of the aisle, because too often all it does is punish/discourage achievement.

I am a Reaganite Republican because I, like Blue, believe that dissent is one of the highest forms of patriotism.  Right now, I am horrified that my government is spending all kinds of "stimulus" money instead of cutting taxes, stepping back from industry/market regulation, and letting the American people clean up this mess we've made for ourselves.  I am horrified by how my government is handling international events/threats.  I pray for our safety more fervently than at any point in these last 8 years.

I am a Reaganite Republican because I don't believe animals have rights, but I believe that humans have responsibility.  As a Christian, I believe we have to be responsible with the resources God gave us.  I also place much stock in the saying, "We don't inherit the earth from our parents; we borrow it from our children."  Environmental responsibility, to me, is about the safety and future of other humans, not about the notion that humans are somehow a threat to the Earth.  Earth can flick us off into the cosmos tomorrow, regardless of how much or how little carbon we emit.  Environmental responsibility is about protecting future people.

I am a Reaganite Republican because I believe that there is nothing the government can do better for people than they can do it for themselves.   I believe individuals who actually work for a living can make much better decisions about what to do with their money and other resources than 

I am a Reaganite Republican because I agree with the great Florence King: "The government has three duties: print the money, deliver the mail, and declare war."

I am a Reaganite Republican because 8 years ago, 3,000 members of our American family were murdered, just for going to work on a Tuesday.  I'll be seeing one's memorial while doing some errands this weekend.  Too many people I know (and I'm sure too many my readers know) have been to war since then to keep it from happening again.  Their bravery, and our leaders' hardnosed daring and determination, not diplomacy or international popularity-seeking, are oh so necessary.  Wasn't it Eisenhower who decided to invade Normandy by saying, "Okay, we'll go"?  Like I said above, we need more 1945.

I am a Reaganite Republican because I believe that life begins at conception, and I believe that in the days before Roe v. Wade responsible doctors found ways to provide medically necessary abortions, and I believe they'll do the same if there are ever days after Roe v. Wade, and I believe we as a culture ought to value marriage, children, and family.

I am a Reaganite Republican because I live in a rural area, and I'm devoted to my faith, and though I don't own any weapons I'm all in favor of the 2nd amendment, and I don't believe that any of this constitutes "clinging bitterly" to anything.

I am a Reaganite Republican because, like Blue, I love my country.  I thank God that I was born in this place and time in history, with all the freedoms and advantages this country provides and protects.  I'm sure it sounds cheesy, but I love my fellow Americans, even though various groups of us may not like each other very much from time to time.  I think what Blue pointed out, and what I've tried to extend in my discussion here, is that most ordinary Americans have a pretty similar set of general values and goals for the country; we just disagree about the ways to get to certain goals.

For example, I disagree with a lot of my friends here on OS about gay marriage, but in a larger sense we're all in agreement: we want to be left alone to live our lives as we see fit and to do what we believe is right.  We all want a safe nation, a free nation, individual freedom, equality across races, classes, genders, cultures, a healthy economy, our troops home from Iraq, Afghanistan, and everywhere else with decisive, stable victory concluded.  

 Two 1990s films really strike a chord for me.  Neither won any Oscars, but both Speechless and My Fellow Americans ended with hardcore Democrat characters and hardcore Republican characters coming together around the realization that, whatever their political differences, their larger civic values were in agreement.  I hope there's some of that left now.  That, and a little 1945.

To all--Happy Belated Independence Day.

*Please don't anyone throw specific policy decisions of the Reagan years at me.  I was 9 when he left office, I don't remember the specifics, and it's not a fair fight.  I'm using the term "Reaganite Republican" here in a broad sense for three reasons: 1) Like Blue whose post inspired me, I'm using a common label stuck on people in my party and saying what I mean by it; 2) I like the alliterative quality of "Reaganite Republican; 3) on my side of the political aisle, Reagan is our JFK.  We recognize he wasn't perfect, but he represents a golden age we want back.

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Okay--got it--now let's all discuss how we're going to start a party that takes the good from both, and get together every 4th of July for the Party Convention, at which we will watch My Fellow Americans and drink red, white, and blue margaritas.
I wanted to lend my support since OS can get pretty one (liberal) sided. I think McCain was the better candidate than Obama and I think the Republicans would have been better at handling this banking crisis but unfortunately the war, Katrina, and the crazy Christian fundamentalist side of the Republican Party made the Democrats promise of change more attractive at this election even though Obama really didn't have the experience or the relationships to make that happen. But I don't think he cares, I think he is going to make a lot of money writing and speaking as the former President of the US just as he used being President of the Harvard Law Review to catapult his career and he didn't make any changes there either (see Frontline documentary if you would like more details).
You like everyone else in this country are entitled to believe as you wish -- at least until the Christian Republicans gain control. But believing doesn't make it so, and it certainly doesn't mean God believes what you believe.

Rather than go down your complete list, let me choose one that I've had personal experience with as an INDIVIDUAL faced with a personal decision, not as a simpleton president making a political decision about things he knew little or nothing about, and certainly had no stake in as an INDIVIDUAL: Stem-cell research.

I am the father of an in vitro child, and your belief that an eight-celled zygote is a human being makes me a murderer. Sorry, you're wrong, and before you reply, please extend me the courtesy of reading my post :

Stem Cells and Sophie's Choice

One more thing: "Government is not the solution to our problems; government is the problem." Great sloganeering, but really bad logic. This is perhaps one of the most ignorant and self-contradictory slogans ever uttered by an American presidential candidate.

If government truly is the problem, why would anyone want to be part of it? If you don't want to govern, don't run for public office. That slogan led directly to 30 years of abdication by those whose sworn constitutional duty it was to "provide for the common defense AND promote the general welfare. Reaganomics, what George HW Bush correctly labeled Voodoo Economics was the "rising tide that lifts all yachts", and our children's children's children will pay dearly for the folly that lowering taxes increases revenues.

That's another logical absurdity -- by that reasoning, eliminating taxes completely should create infinite revenue. Furthermore, if you're really bent on "drowning government in a bathtub", why would you want to increase revenues?

I could go on, but I suspect this is another situation where logic does not move and reason does not hold much sway.
And as for your statement: "2) I like the alliterative quality of "Reaganite Republican", well, that certainly seems a sound basis for forming one's political philosophy. Now we know how the "compassionate conservative" who was neither got elected twice -- well, once actually.
aofedotcom--thanks for the kind words.

Tom and ironman--you've completely missed my larger points and this spirit of my post, and been rude in the process. Was that really worth your time? To be rude to someone you don't even know?
Sorry, if you found my comments rude, but if you want to see rude, try posting a liberal viewpoint on a conservative blog (see Rush Limbaugh for details).

If you're truly serious about finding common ground with people who understand the necessary role of government in protecting a civilized society from the excesses of corporate criminality, I would suggest you begin by dropping the "govt is the problem" shtick -- it automatically identifies you as someone who drank the Kool-Aid.
I have to agree with Brit in that our government is killing our ability to compete internationally. Now if we can just get rid of those damn child labor laws, the minimum wage and all forms of pollution control we'd be back on top. Get government off our backs!
You survived. Brave. careful Britomart.
Comments are now closed.