MARCH 1, 2009 1:32AM

Post-mancy: Compliment or OS faux pas?

Rate: 5 Flag

This post is what happens when one drinks one too many Coors Original (the gold can), discovers an OS writer that one had previously overlooked, and reads a New Yorker bio/review of James Baldwin.

 In most internet forums, threadmancy (n. origin: necromancy) is considered rude.  Thread-mancy being the practice of "bumping" a thread from a long time ago. How long "a long time" is seems to be dependent on how active a particular forum is. On a popular forum, threadmancy might be bumping a thread only several days old. On that forum your buddy started in middle school computer class to keep you all entertained, it might be several weeks.

Given the incredibly rapid speed of the hungry feed here at OS, which devours posts in mere minutes even during the slow 4 AM EST time slot, one would assume that OS falls into the category of "popular internet forum."  So does this mean that bumping a post from several months ago by rating or commenting puts one seriously behind the curve? Perhaps even to the point of committing an OS social faux pas?

Of course, OS aspires to be more than 4chan or some other temporary internet thing.  It aspires to RealQualityWriting (TM). And surely no one feels bad discussing Go Tell It On the Mountain instead of Just Above My Head. Or discussing Crime and Punishment instead of The Idiot. In literature, it seems fine to bump the relatively old "post" in light of its superior artistic merit.

"But wait," says the contrarian, "OS is a topical site; full of timely postings on current events, witty movies mocking Republican politicians, and screeds by lost right-wingers." To which I would respond, "true, except for those posters who favor such timeless arts as poetry, personal memoir, or artistic commentary."

And so I put it to you, OS, dare I comment/rate a post from December 2008, or should I return to surfing the feed for only the freshest posts? Those with "born on" dates within the past several days? 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I go back and turn my comments off after a while to advoid postmancy...
i guess my writer's ego wants to enable 'postmancy' if someone is inclined to 'bump' something from my archive...i do think it's a question worth asking, but i'm so new at the blogging thing that i don't know the answer...and now i'm thinking that since i don't have an answer, my comment is sorta pointless...
I'm always last to become aware of these things so I've probably been faux pasing all over the place.
Cat - I suppose that's like driving a stake through the corpse of your posts before they have the chance to rise again.

MC - I wouldn't worry too much about the whole "answer" thing. It doesn't seem important here on the internets. Shoot from your gut!

NB - That's exactly what I'm afraid of...
I leave comments open and am always delighted when someone, often someone who has recently become a friend/favorite is looking at some of my older writings. Nothing is that old, since I came here in only last October. This week I had one new friend read my series "A WWII Romance," which just happens to be my personal favorite. It was fun to have her enjoy it. She left little comments after each post in the series and I thanked her after each.

To me it is fun to have people go back and read my older stuff. As to reposting old pieces, I don't think I could do that. Something seems wrong to me about that, although I know a lot of my friends here do it. I even ran across two of those this week that said that they were reposting it "by request" of someone who wanted to read it. Say what? Anybody could read it anytime already. That was about the lamest excuse I have read.

Good post.

Monte
I'm with Monte. There are so many interesting things to read here, I'm constantly discovering pieces that are both old and new and I appreciate being able to leave a comment. There are many gems hidden here and when one person discovers a jewel they can bring it to the attention of many this way.
I think that commenting on a post from the past is absolutely acceptable. The sites mechanics encourage easy access to posters archives. Discovering old posts and new writers is part of the adventure that is OS.
casus telefon yazılımı, günümzde çok yaygın casus telefon programı, ile dinleyebilirsiniz telefon dinleme dinleme cihazı, ile de dinleme yapabilirsiniz.
çelik kapı