Aw, For Heaven's Sake...

Cam Battley

Cam Battley
Location
Rural Ontario, Canada
Birthday
April 04
Bio
Canadian owner of small businesses, small children and large dogs. Scuba diver, hard rock fan, business traveler, industrial-strength irritant.

Cam Battley's Links

Salon.com
OCTOBER 21, 2008 3:22PM

Big Dogs Are Best (Small dogs are pests)

Rate: 21 Flag

Angel in clover 

(Angel - proud great pyrenees mountain dog)

I want points for courage, here, as I’m taking on the powerful small-dog lobby, which secretly controls Hollywood, the banks and the United Nations. 

Big dogs are a boon to mankind.  Big dogs are friends.  Big dogs share the load.  They know they’re part of the family, and their job is as sentry.  They’re comfortable with that, and competent.  They know when to be excited, and they know how to just hang out with you, companionably silent.  When they raise their big heads and look you in the eye, they say, “Yeah, I’m glad we’re pals, too.  Can I get an ear scratch or two?”  Then they go back to sleep, their softly resonant snore surely one of nature’s finest toasts to contentment and rightness in the world.

 

Big dogs, in short, are a gift given to us by God, or Darwin, or both, to make our time on Earth better.

 

Small dogs...  Small, yippy dogs.  Small, yippy, anxious, trembly dogs, well, they’re another story.  Do you know where they came from?  No, don’t rush to Wikipedia, I’ll tell you.  They were designed by bad people - biotechnologists in underground lairs – evil-doers with access to real dogs, miniaturization technology, and gene sequences that manufacture endogenous Dexedrine – people who meant the world harm.

 

Small dog 1 

 

Now I’m not advocating anything here, and I respect people who care for tiny canines.  They’re obviously good at dealing with helpless dependents and incessant, high-pitched noise.  Moreover, those small dog owners have been good for the parts of our economy involved in the manufacture of miniature animal clothing, and the treatment of ankle bites (podiatrists?).

 Small dog 2       Wolf 2 

 

Big dogs are proud creatures.  They know the heritage of noble wolves is in their blood.  Small dogs are not proud creatures.  They spend their days trying not to get killed by a squirrel.

 

Big dogs are partners in our lives, loyal, steadfast and true.  Small dogs are accessories in our lives, living “bling”, irritating and not strictly necessary.

 

I say, get a big dog and enrich your life.  If space is a problem, cats are fine, too.  They catch mice and chase away the small dogs.

 

 Note:  “Cam Battley” is a pseudonym, so please send your letters of complaint directly to my main OS blog, under the name “Joan Walsh”. 

Note:  My thanks to DogWoman for reminding me that I hadn’t yet written about dogs – an oversight on my part. 

Update:  I felt bad about not including big Russ, our Black Russian Terrier - fun loving, nosy, as athletic as a Jack Russell (but about 10 times the size).  Here he is.  (Russ is the black one.  Our son Maclain is the taller one.)

Russ and Maclain 

### 

Cam Battley lives quietly in rural Ontario, Canada.

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I want to dodge this bullet. I merely asked Cam for photos of his dogs. My parents and I used to own a Scottish Terrier whom I loved dearly. She was chocked full of personality, sang along when my mother played piano, and bit a neighbor who went through the house to get to the back yard while all of us were out back.

I prefer appreciating the love, devotion, health benefits, and affection of all animals and pets.

I do own a large dog and secretly prefer large dogs, but that's just me. I'm happy for you to own a small dog that looks like a naked rat if that makes you happy! I do appreciate the humor here, but I still would rather build bridges on OS than take sides.

Paws up (with reservations). Love the last tag! Brace yourself.
Your advice is well-taken, DogWoman. I'm wearing a hockey helmet and shin pads. [chuckle]

The devil got into me today, and made me poke a stick into a hornet nest, just to see what would happen.
My husband will sing all day the praises of German Shepherds. I like big dogs fine. Some small dogs do need to get dropkicked. A particularly yippy chihuahua belonging to my high school English teacher comes to mind. But some small dogs, like pugs, act like big dogs. In short, I am a dog agnostic. We will probably end up with a German Shepherd in a few years, although if I had my druthers we could end up with anything from a Newfie to a basenji to a pug, depending on what needed rescuing at the pound that week.

Our cat has been a wonderful member of my family for over 10 years (longer than my husband. He was actually the first boyfriend she liked). So we do not hurt for animal companionship. Although as a mouser, she is hopelessly bad.
I was just saying the same thing to my family this weekend. My boys were very horrified, and brought up all the small dogs that their friends have that they like and think are cute. Bleah to all of them. Nervous, trembly, ready to bite your ankles or scratch your legs at a moment's notice. I know my fear/dislike of small dogs comes from childhood encounters with bad examples of the various small breeds, but I'm sticking with, "thanks, but no thanks". My 90lb Labrador and I are quite happy.
There you go! Thank you, Julie! Love to see an unashamed big dog chauvenist. Love Labs. Now there's a buddy.

Julie, would you do me a favour and send some small dog-lovers over here? I'm up for an argument. (Remember the old Monty Python sketch?)
I should be clear. I meant lovers of small dogs, not dog lovers of small stature.
I love big dogs. I love the way labs and shepherds and Portugese water dogs run, and swim, and lay cozy by the fire. I love dogs that can hold their own on hikes and long walks to the coffee shop.

BUT, I own a small dog. Not a purse-size accessory, mind you, but a 15 pound bichon frisee. He runs, and swims, and curls up with me by the fire. He holds his own on hikes & walks. He barks a mean, deep bark at the mailman and stands sentry at the front window when strangers walk by or up to the door. Of course, he isn't perfect...we're still training him to not jump up on folks to say hello.

Did I mention he doesn't shed? Or that we live on a postage-stamp sized lot in a fairly urban setting? And, that I can't always take him for a 2 mile walk every day and my kids are pretty useless in that regard.

Did I mention that an old ex-boyfriend's Dalmation destroyed his apartment, getting out of his crate and eating the walls or that my aunt's boxer and other big dog mutt ate her leather sofa while left alone?

Hey, I'm just yanking your chain a bit in defending my small dog. Since you're probably disappointed that you didn't cause more of an outcry and tomato-throwing. (Yet - it could still come!)

The real point is that there is a dog out there for every lifestyle and every personality. And too few people really give much thought to whether their family and lifestyle can really handle a dog - big, small or otherwise - and what the dog's needs are.

Because I'm an information-gatherer and book-nerd, I recommend prospective dog owners check out the following book -
The Right Dog for You by Daniel Tortora.

I found it tremendously helpful in narrowing down breeds that were best suited for our family. And yeah, our guy was a shelter dog and doesn't wear clothes (except a T-shirt for Halloween and LSU games.)
lps thanks for commenting, and you were waaay too polite to me. What are you, Canadian or something?

(Maybe if I poke you a bit more...)

I think that's so cute that you have a little tiny fuzzball. Please be sure not to step on him, and don't let the chipmunks bully him.
As a house mate of three 100+ pound bloodhounds and a 40-ish pound mutt, I heartily agree. I want a dog I can hug, that can lie beside me at night and keep me warm, that I don't have to worry about stepping on. Our patriarch, Marshall Dillon, got stung by a scorpion last week. His face swelled up but he was okay within two days. The thing would have killed a small dog or at least cost us untold vet bills.

Yup, I love big dogs. Yours is lovely.
Hi, PF:

A scoripion bite? Ouch! Where do you live? And he's fine? Thank heaven for that.

I love bloodhounds and I love mutts. I agree with you about a dog you can hug. I also like the fact that our dogs are very hard to pick up (though it's a lark to carry them around a bit sometimes & they think it's funny, too). Ours are between 110 & 12o lbs. (Don't know what that is in kilos - though under Canadian law, I've just committed an infraction against metric, I think.)

And thank you for the compliment to Angel. We got her from a rescue society, and she does love to be buttered up. [chuckle]
The Sonoran Desert, and yes I kill about a scorpion a week when the weather's warm. And we had to kill a rattlesnake last week because it decided to hang out at our front door. And move one last night that was in the driveway. Yes, it is very dangerous here.

BTW, I found the scorpion in three pieces so even though it stung poor Marshall, he exterminated it anyway. Good dog.
Cam, In defense of small dogs;

Many small breeds can be classified as "Working Variety" dogs.
They were bred to do a job. Some smaller breeds are trained to clear areas of rodents, act as sentinels or perform tasks for physically handicapped folks. I saw a small terrier who had learned on it's own to herd cattle. The dog was skilled and absolutely fearless. He accompanied the farmer everywhere he went, serving well the functional and sometimes emotional needs of the Farmer's family. A dear friend of mine was saved from a devastating house fire by a small chiwawa, who woke up residents of an entire building, saving 20+ lives. As I entered college, I adopted a small Terrier who could swim into a fast moving river to retrieve game. He was the most intelligent, loyal companion I had ever met up to that time.

The image of small K-9s had been corrupted and misrepresented by celebrities and irresponsible dog owners. Almost every breed has a place. Many retirement homes welcome the affectionate interaction of small dogs as a way of connecting to elderly folks who are depressed and lonely.

I'm a large dog owner at the moment, finding the Doberman temperament to be most agreeable with our lifestyle, but in later years I would welcome the companionship, antics and loyalty of a small dog.
I am a BIG dog lover. Errr... rather a love of big dogs. The best dog I ever owned was a abandoned female australian sheppard lab mix.
I currnetly own three. Two are hurricane Rita refugees. I wanted to name them Ref & Fugee. No said the kids. One of them chewed through the extension cord we were using for the generator following the hurricane and I wanted to change his name to Sparky. Once again I was over ruled by children (the story of my life). The other dog belonged to my late father-in-law, he asked that I take him upon his death.
But, and this is a large but (did I spell that correctly) During the evacuation for hurricane Gustave the nice woman who owned the B & B I stayed at convinced me to take another refugee pup home. And this is the embarrassing part; he's a Yorkie. He's little and yappy (how I have raled against yappy dogs). But ya know I've had him for a little over two months now and (don't let this get around) I like him.
Oh and BTW so do the other dogs.
Gary and John, your tolerance, politeness and fair points are infuriating.

I don't know what to do with you. I'll think about it and get back to you.
And Cam, I just can't help adding a little more to your fury.......
My dog Blubberstick, http://open.salon.com/content.php?cid=26634
loves little dogs. He has many small pals.............
Gary:

1. Don't you try to charm me with photos of your beautiful Dobermans, when you've decided to defend small dogs.
2. Small terriers can sometimes be honorary members of the big dogs club. Some of them have big-dog hearts.
3. The chihuahua story just tells me your friend should have invested in a smoke detector. They cost $30 bucks and bite less than chihuahuas. And people laugh at you less.
4. There. [chuckle]
John:

1. Aussie shepherds are magnificent creatures.
2. I like your proposed names for the rescued hounds, and I'm sorry your kids nixed the monikers.
3. A Yorkie... [sigh]. In spite of my caveat about some terriers (see above in my reply to Gary), actually liking a Yorkie is problematic. Especially a yappy Yorkie. Don't you know someone you don't like, to whom you could give the Yorkie? If not, for heaven's sake, don't be seen in public with him! [chuckle]
Was it Lucy who said "arghhh - doggy lick!?" You make a grown man cry: "Aaa-ooooooh!"
Stacey, our 2 year-old girl Aila has gotten used to having a wet face half the time, thanks to licks from giant dog tongues. In fact, Angel (pyrenees) has taught Russ (black Russian terrier) that the best way to get kids to leave you alone is to lick them repeatedly until they scamper away, squealing in delight and horror.
I agree that many terriers have big dog hearts and I don't really consider them small dogs. They have their own group after all.

Someday, when we're elderly (knock on wood) and travel a lot, I'd like to get a pair of Corgis. Smaller dog stature, bigger dog body, sort of like our Basset Hound we once had but less slobbery.
Cam - I just wrote, though they write themselves, ten jokes and just let them go.

(I will notbe in the doghouse tonight.)

Angel is beautiful.
I do agree on the slobber......it is a little difficult to abide.......well,......I guess most of those big sweetypies make up for it with tasks and love.
Ha! Stacey, if you're around tonight, share the jokes. Like my taste in wine, my taste in jokes is catholic (with a small "c"). I like good ones and bad ones equally. [chuckle]
With three bloodhounds, we get so much slobber. It's everywhere. When they shake their heads, they let go what we call "slingers", the highest of which went about ten feet (we have 14 foot ceilings in the living room so they can try to best that). They "slime" us with love and we just can't wear black at all or it looks like we've had snails crawling all over us. When we do get dressed nice to go out, which for me is rare but more so for my husband, we have to do a little dog avoidance dance whenever they approach. David, in fact, tried to be all poetic about it this morning after walking the four dogs (of the Apocalypse). "They shake their heads in the morning sunlight and the crystalline slingers arc through the air." Ha!

But I love them and only curse them a bit as I scrub slobber off the walls and furniture.
Ahhh. doggone it all, Cam. Our Corgi is a "meduim" sized dog and this category seems to have slipped through the cracks. He is a small dog wanna be, always trying to curl up in any willing lap and he is also a big dog wanna be as he thinks he is a big bad dog and trys to out alpha male the really big digs in the hood.
Gotta just love dogs of all sizes, tho. Truly man's best friend!
I am with Cathy…… I, too, have a Corgi. And Cam don’t you go telling him he is a small dog. He does not take that kind of talk lightly. And when it comes to being a loyal friend, e.c.chpamn is always there to give a loving lick or a nip on the ankle to get me going each day.

And Cam, who do you think runs Britain’s Royal Palaces….. it’s the Royal Corgis!
Oh, all right! The Corgis get a pass because Queen Elizabeth is Canada's official head of state. (Man, I have got to quit making exceptions.)
Cam, we have the perfect golden retriever, Duke. I've never been drawn to small dogs, but my friends have a dog named Meatloaf who is so adorable and cute, he changed my mind. But he's like a cat. He won't have a thing to do with me. Fun post...scary picture of that one small dog. I'll have bad dreams tonight.
I'm no fan of yappy yipsters, but I have to write in on behalf of my little man. He was a toy poodle that we NEVER trimmed to look like a poodle (she rushes to explain) and weighed 6 pounds. But he was NOT a small dog. He never yipped or yapped. He barked like he meant it.

Once a friend, a 6'7" manly type man, watched him for an afternoon, and when I came home, there was Harpo, enthroned on his knee. Not sitting in his lap - Harpo was not a lap dog despite his size - but balancing on the guy's knee, gazing out the window while my friend worked at his computer.

I asked "Hey Olaf, what's up with that? I thought you didn't really like small dogs."

Olaf responded "I do not. I hate them. Harpo is not a small dog. He is a big dog, trapped in a small dog's body."

I miss my little guy. Now I have to go find a dog to pet....
Hi, Sandra: There's an old saying (as far as I know, not properly attributed to anyone) that goes: ‘There's nothing so good for the inside of a man as the outside of a horse.’ It was a favourite aphorim of Ronald Reagan's. I think something similar applies to dogs.

Dogs are good for people.
Umbrella, you'll get no argument from me about cats. I'm a dog person who loves cats, too. I've had them my whole life. 'Nothing like a purring cat giving you a "head bump", to start your day. Plus, they bring you corpses as gifts. When was the last time one of your human friends did that for you, eh?
Hmm. I don't know, Blue Eyes, I've met some pretty nasty dogs with pretty blameless owners. Remember the line from the Simpsons episode with Stampy the elephant? The park ranger opines that, just like people, "some animals are just jerks." [chuckle]
Hi Cam,
I love big dogs.
Have a golden retriever now and he is such a part of our life.
Became "The baby" when our son went to college.
His name is Jake...golden's are so loving.
Before Jake, we had Sammy, a German sheperd...he was wonderful...miss him very much...last week, I called Jake, "Sammy."
Before that we had Lady, an Irish Setter...loved her so much!

Great post....love your dog!
Thank you.

Margie
Hi, Margie:

You have quite the "resume" of big-dog ownership! I'll bet they are and were splendid. Those are terrific breeds. They sure get under your skin in the best way, don't they. Thanks for complimenting Angel, too. She's definitely a sweetheart. I think I'd better update the post, though to add Russ. I'm starting to feel bad about not showing him, too.
Angel is beautiful! Reminds me of my longtime friend, Ursula. Thanks!
Connie, was Ursula a pyrenees?
There is something about big dogs.....
We share our house with Professor Moriarty, an 11 yr old Irish Wolfhound. When Mori was young we had to buy a new house as he ate the one that we lived in.
Mori had a friend called Dr Watson (RIP) a crossed up Shihtzu/Silky/Foxy - they were inseperable.
So we had both ends of the hound spectrum and it worked out perfectly.
After Watson died we went to the RSPCA Pound and rescued a couple of mutts. Mr Godfrey Norton is the most lovable poodle/maltese cross and Miss Irene Adler is supposed to be wolfhound/? cross - to this day, I can't find any wolfhound in her, only wombat and rat.............. all three are family. They all get and give love by the bucket load.
Size doesn't matter! (except when there is a thunder storm 400 km away) then Himself uploads all 70kg of houndness onto my prone and sleeping body, and he ain't doing that to protect me.
Big is good, medium is good, small is good, tiny is questionable except when it comes to a $0.75 weekly food bill.
Dogs - love'em all.
Cam, you are such a rabble-rouser! What, we weren't entertaining enough for you down here? I mean, c'mon, we gave you Sarah Palin! Well, not *us*, but you know...

I'm a big dog fan myself. Don't tell the cats. (Hmm, if you really want to start a fight, maybe you should advocate a preferred canine birthing method ;)
WOOF WOOF WOOF from a BIG BOXER.

On the other hand, there might be something to be said for the position that pipsqueak chihueyhuey finds itself in next to Paris' right ahem, shoulder.

WOOF
Howard, great comment (exept all that stuff about small dogs being good, of course). And good on you for rescuing those dogs - that's a very good thing to do. We got Angel from a pyrenees rescue society. She'd been abused and was very fearful and skinny. Now she's happy, bossy and (unfortunately) a bit fat. So Moriarty is afraid of thunder is he? With our dogs, it's the vacuum cleaner!
Donna, did I rouse the rabble a little? [evil grin] Actually, I was a bit disappointed I didn't get yelled at more by the pocket-pooch fans. I was feeling feisty yesterday. Today, not at all - wrote something all philosophical and kumbaya. [chuckle]
Oh, look at that incredible dog...big Russ.
Love him!
Thanks for the update.

Margie
Caveat, I always welcome a woof from a Big Boxer. And you may have a point about Paris' little friend. A great hound woundn't have that kind of... celebrity access.
Yep, Cam, judging by the number of comments, I think you roused the rabble pretty good! And no one got nipped...(I read your kumbaya post too and liked it very much. Too awed to comment yet though ;)
Cam, I'm not a big one for drum beating, but you can see a picture of Ursula in my blog, @ Ursula Major. We know from her feet that she was part pyrenees. She also had the disposition, the coloring of the skin under the fur, the two types of fur. We just don't know about the rest.
You are so WRONG! I love big dogs. Ask Sophie the GSD. But Jack the Pomeranian? He's a love.
Pretend_farmer, did you call it slobber? Not to outdo your hub in the poetry department or anything, but you know those are tendrils of love that bind us together. At least that's what us Boxers call 'em, and trust me, we know from drool, what the less poetically inclined might call "that damned dried drool on the black dress."

WOOF
Connie, Ursula was beautiful (definitely pyrenees in the mix - mostly, I'd say from her photo), and she obviously had the heart of a lion. Thanks for sending me over to that post of yours. It's wonderful.

Any dog lovers reading this - go read "Ursula Major", at Connie's place.
Leigh, you are a delightful, thoughtful and articulate person. In every way, a fabulous individual. How, then, did you succumb to the delusion that small dogs are at all acceptable? [tsk, tsk]

Who did this to you? The Russians? The Scientologists? Dr. Phil? Procter & Gamble?
Cam, yours is a question that is easily addressed.

Jack. Jack did this to me. With his tiny, stupid, adorable happy-to-see-me, hail met long lost adored one thing that he does, whether I've been out of the country or merely shut the bathroom door uncharacteristically.

Jack, who can rouse even Sophie from slumber, to wrestle for a bone he can't even lift. Jack, the brave bug hunter, the stander-upper to cats twice his size (though all he wants to do is sniff sniff sniff them and perhaps bark, once or twice. Just for effect. Doesn't really mean anything by it.)

It's Jack, who fit in the palm of my hand when we got him, who dances when he walks, who dreams of pulling a 200 ton truck with just his teeth one day, who thinks, "Tiny poo? Why put it outside? It's so small and delicate, really. A work of tiny poo art, really. Let's put it right here in the dining room where it can be admired. Or stepped on. Or both."

Blame Jack.
Oh, for heaven's sake, Leigh, you're impossible! All right. Jack gets a pass... Here's his honorary "big-dog" badge.
The problem with small dogs isn't necessarily size; it's personality. It's the yappy-treat-me-like-a-neurotic-baby thing that makes a small dog objectionable. It's the way people carry them in baby carriers and strollers. I would much rather go goo-goo over a Wolfhound in a stroller (they are sooooo cute, those Wolfhounds). It's the way people over-feed them and think it's cute that their dogs are fat. No, wait, people do that to large dogs, too.

It's the cutsie factor as opposed to genuine adorability. Cutsie is bad, it's overdone, it has no gravitas.
There you go, lemuridae - gravitas. Big dogs have gravitas! Small dogs have... I'm thinking "neuroses".
aw, Leigh, now I really miss my little man, he of the tiny poo
Sandra, stop that! I did not write a post extolling big dogs, just to have it reduced to a discussion of "tiny poo"!

Sheesh. (If you must discuss poo here, please make it big, too.)
Well, Cam, you get no argument from me. Your Angel looks lovely and Russ looks like a lot of fun. I am especially partial to the Northern breeds. Samoyeds are my all-time favourite, but I also love Siberian huskies and Keeshonds. Former housemate had a Samoyed, and his personality was so ideal: playful, affectionate, never ever growled at any other person or any other dog in all of the many dog walks I took him on. Very intelligent. I could hug him without worrying that I would squish him or strangulate his neck.

Years ago (after I moved out on my own), my Mom got a shih tzu. It was so embarrassing taking it for a walk... it was smaller than most cats! (and looked like an overgrown furry rat). But what I really hated was that, despite visiting my folks regularly once a week, this darn excuse for a dog would still yap every time I came to the front door. I was so annoyed, I started yapping back at it! And it would go hide under the love seat for most of my visit.
WOOF from a big dog!
Cynarra and OE: right-thinking Americans! And let it be said that during this time of economic turmoil, the country itself must be like the big dog: stolid and resolved; committed to its tasks and steadfast in protecting all that is good and fine about America. (I think I just strained my nobility muscle.)
I call 'em spit 'em & roast 'ems. (As a joke, just a joke, no hate mail please!)
Oooooh! Your Angel is so pretty. I just rescued a year ago, our lovely Pyr Jeffrey. He's mixed with something a few gens back, so is only 85lbs (small for a Pyr). He is so wonderful. I got to your post by putting Pyrenees in the search box. I just needed a fix - not too many folks have 'em.

Re Canada, we just had some friends drive from Whitehorse, Yukon down to central VA to visit us on their way to a graduation. Canadians rock!
I love big dogs. My Siberian Huskies are so wolf-like in looks and behavior.

But, I love little dogs too. I had a Cairn Terrier who was the biggest small dog I've ever know. She was totally alpha to the German Shepard she shared a yard with.
That's "ever known" ...I wish we could edit.