Culture Sandwich

from the so darn wondrous to the so darn weird

Caroline Hagood

Caroline Hagood
Location
New York, New York,
Birthday
November 23
Bio
I'm a poet and writer living in New York City. My articles have appeared in various publications, including The Guardian, Salon, the Huffington Post, and The Economist.

MY RECENT POSTS

Caroline Hagood's Links

My Blog Outside of Open Salon--What You See Here Plus Everything You Don't
Editor’s Pick
OCTOBER 1, 2009 4:19PM

Would You Stop Calling Hillary Clinton a Witch Already

Rate: 20 Flag

 

crca_witch

 

I am so very tired of people trying to cripple potent women by throwing around the “W” word; no, I’m not talking about “Woman” or “Welfare,” I’m talking about “Witchcraft.” What century do we live in? I half expect to see villagers outside my home with torches every time I write a saucy piece.  Excuse me for a moment, I have to get the door.

Sadly, the witch stigma is not merely a relic of the past; it has been used against Hillary Clinton, among others, in so many different ways that it is beginning to border on the creative.  That powerful women in politics continue to be referred to as witches reveals that, far from being an historically localized phenomenon, the witch-hunt is still alive and well today. 

One reason that females have been conflated with evil  is because they engender life, which is, of course, the flip side of death. In the case of midwives and mothers, for example, the reverence for those who can produce life is often confused with the fear that they can take it away. Yet the “W” word is most frequently used to circumscribe the power of a woman who seems to have just a little bit too much of it.

 The witch-hunt is yet another socially sanctioned persecution.  For centuries, societies have resolved their psychosocial dilemmas through the sacrificial female, often in the guise of the witch. Historically, the women accused of witchcraft have been singled out as a result of their powerful or nonconformist natures. They are usually figures, such as healers and spiritual or sociopolitical leaders, on whom the community is deeply dependent.  The sacrifice of the witch serves the dual purpose of eliminating women who threaten carefully regulated, patriarchal societies, and symbolically exorcizing those societies of their psychic demons.

 The crimes that people dream up often reveal more about the accusers than they do about the accused. The hatred and hysteria of those pointing the fingers is often far more sinister than any of their accusations.  I hope that people stop dropping the witch bomb, but until then, give me back my broomstick so that I can hit you with it.

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
*Cackles and waves her broom*

Oh wait...what?

Great post, Caroline.
Halloween is approaching isn't it..

Caroline, I agree with you totally of course. Men in general and especially weak minded limp dicked posers who cling to the illusion of being "in control" are the first to throw the W bomb around. It's much easier than acknowledging the awesomeness of strong and power wielding females. Hillary rocks!
I recently discovered that the W in George W. Bush stands for Warlock.

Great piece. Nice analysis. R
Witches are way cool, except for that really ugly one in "Wizard of Oz"
We still burn witches, only we call them the homeless nowadays.
"Are you a good witch or a bad witch?"

I can't decide...depends on my mood.
AshKW: thanks and snazzy broom, by the way. I'm in the market for a new symbol of my monstrous womanhood.

trig palin: just read your post on increasing your OS karma. As a witch, I can help you with that. Just call my hotline: 1800-W(B)itch.

John: I have known about Warlock Buch for ages, but I took him down; he was my first victim.

littlewillie: hey, that was me.

Harry's ghost: is that what happened to Harry Homeless? I was wondering. Well, welcome to OS. We accept supernatural being here. I hope you feel duly accepted.

spotted_mind: Aren't all us witches a little of both?
Warlock Buch, Warlock Bush, potatoes potatohs. Okay, just sloppy typing.
.." give me back my broomstick so that I can hit you with it."
hahahah.
Thank you. (I'd better behave myself!)
Of all the many people I've met in my lifetime, regardless of politics, Hillary Clinton is one of the most poised, gracious, and personally impressive. The camera does her no favors, and generally, neither does the press.

I hadn't realized anyone had called her that recently, especially after becoming Madam Secretary. Thanks for this post, Caroline.
I'm starting to think i voted the wrong way in the primary
Every time I hear someone called a witch It reminds me of the 'witch versus angry mob of peasants scene' in Monty Python's "Holy Grail". thanks for sharing - rated.

John, I thought the W was for Wrong
Weak and insecure men have always been afraid of assertive women; more's the pity. Witchcraft is just another bete noir to hold over women's heads.

Sad to relate, we're seeing more women-on-women invective. The campaign of Elizabeth Dole against Kay Hagan in North Carolina was one of the most vicious I've seen, and this is a state known for gutter campaigns (remember Jesse Helms and the "you really needed that job" ad campaign?)

Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely...
littlewillie, the ugly witch in the wizard of the oz is immensely cool. she's an extremely powerful witch. She's ugly as a way to say "eff you, little willie! I don't have to look good for you." She's a real anarchist. A real witch. Witches do NOT have to be pretty.

Don't get me wrong. Glinda is one of my favorite witches. She just so happens to be beautiful.

But don't diss the wicked witch. She represents all of our perfect, mean and powerful ugliness, for which we should never be ashamed.

Sorry for diatribe. Solid piece.

Go witches. Broom in my bedroom corner as I write.

- Sincerely, card-carrying Witch since '66.
Woman have been blamed for a lot over the centuries. It could be as you suggest, a woman's ability to give birth. but in all honesty, after witnessing the birth of daughter, I wouldn't want that ability.

BTW, can you put a hex on Tito from the Bronx? He sold me some bad weed twenty years ago and I'm still pissed.
Okay. No more calling Hillary a witch. Just bitch will do.
Great post Caroline. I drove past her house last week when I was in "the neighborhood". Wished I could have met you too. Maybe next time. What the world needs now...is strong women.
Hey, and congrats on the "Media Bistro" piece. Joan Walsh promoted it and I went and read it.
berrycomposer: that's right, you'd better.

Caracalla's Amanuensis: ah, but what would a witch be without her newt eye boiling and one-eyed trouser snake worship?

Kathy: Alas, they have.

bobbot: not unless you wanted a witch in power--just joshing with you.

DemLiberal: good call on the Monty Python reference.

CarolinaBlue50: It's a sobering thought.

Beth: I loved your diatribe. I think I wrote this piece to lament something, but also with the thought that if we're gonna be called it, we might as well use it to our advantage--reclaim "witch" if you will. I love what you say about "our perfect, mean and powerful ugliness, for which we should never be ashamed." Exactly.
- Sincerely, card-carrying Witch since '82.

Trudge: Consider Tito hexed. I can take a lot, but I draw the line at bad weed.

wind in my wings: be careful, you don't want me to have to post another piece.

Trilogy: Thanks. Strong women are exactly what we need now.
The "Witch Bomb?"
You DO make me smile, Caroline.
I'm still trying to get over Sam on "Bewitched." What a cutie !!!
Just a note that the women accused of witchcraft in Europe's witchburning days, and still today in Africa, India, Eastern Europe, were/are not usually the powerful but, rather, the weak and helpless - archetypical scapegoats. Hence the term 'witchhunt' indicating that nowadays we KNOW we're making empty accusations...
Myriad: thanks for the note. You're absolutely right that not all of the women who have been accused of witchcraft were powerful, and that many of them were "archetypal scapegoats," but a good number of them have been individuals with some kind of threatening potency. In her book, Woman, Church, and State, suffragist Matilda Joslyn Gage wrote that many of the women accused of witchcraft, “had in fact been early scientists, mesmerists and workers with plant extracts, elemental spirits and psychic forces not yet understood." Sorry to get all nerdy on you, but I wrote on this in grad school.
Good one! So true! Either she is a witch or she rhymes with one. Words are so cheap when male power is threatened.
Wish I'd had my broom at the PTA meeting last night.
Jeeze Louise, as if it ain't hard enough to stir a good honest brew.....look at what this poor woman has had to deal with to get where she is? She is a smart fucking PERSON, but because she doesn't have a dick, those with limp ones are deeply threatened by her.

Ask yourself this: Would she ever have received all of these nasty attacks if she were a man? I love love love that there are more women in law schools across the country than men.

Hillary is tough, and that's one of her best qualities. (To this day I love James "Old Snakehead" Carvel's comment about her chances of getting elected in New York: "Well......ya gotta have some pretty sharp damned elbows......and I think she'll do jes' fine.") (I paraphrase, of course, because it's late.....but you've got to love the sentiment.)

Great post. Rated for the work and the great fun comments that it inspired!
Great post...it's so ingrained in our culture that 'witch' means a bad thing. There is however, a religion called Wicca, where people (normal people) are proud to be witches. (I'm not one, but I respect them).
Mrs. Clinton? No mere witch! If she were President (if only!), the Republicans would be holding their butts to recover from the ass-kickings she'd be giving. If she had run, she would have fixed McCain like Medusa and he would have crumbled into dust! You go, Mrs. Clinton! I frankly want the neighborhood kids to think I'm a witch; that way, they leave my yard alone.
Penrose: exactly. words are cheap, but they're also powerful. Call someone a w(b)itch enough and it starts to lodge in people's minds.

mamoore: yes, I would imagine that PTA meetings would be a good place to have your weapon of choice handy.

Ginny Rose: Hillary's had to make a career out of using those sharp elbows on limp dicks:)

madcelt: that's part of why it's such a complex topic in my mind. The word "witch" is used as a put-down and attack, but its associations ( with real Wiccans and even fairy tale caricatures, but not the women persecuted by being called witches, of course) are partially ones of power.

Doris Allen: Medusa plays a similar role in the collective psyche methinks. I'm with you on the lawn thing. Actually, I don't have a lawn, but it works to keep my stoop clear--cackle cackle.
Maybe being accused of witchcraft is the same as being accused of wisdom.
Janelle: you officially win the witch wisdom award for that comment.
Unless Ms. Clinton has left the United Methodist Church to join Wicca, neither she, nor any other non-Wiccan woman, can properly be called a Witch. The word "witch" is just a dodge for someone who doesn't have the eggs (or balls, as the case may be) to come right out and say "bitch". Grow a pair and say what you mean!

I number many Witches among my friends and acquaintances, and most of them are only bitchy sometimes.
XANDER
It could be witches, some evil witches!(Cold stare from Willow and Tara)...
Which is ridiculous 'cause witches they were persecuted,
Wiccan good and love the earth and womyn power and I'll be over here!
No, I won't! So there! I offer on exhibit her most recent "stellar" performance on promoting a "demockery" of democracy in Honduras. Her remonstrations, on behalf of herself and Obama and his Team, against Zelaya trying to regain his democratically elected position as President has been the latest nauseating. But it is just the latest in a not insignificant dossier that Team Obama has built up in only 8 months in power: reversing, reneging upon, and ignoring solemn campaign positions, particularly in national defense, military, government secrecy, and foreign policy/relations
Eric Arthur Blair: well said.

Grima: gotta love the spelling of womyn power.

Sakai Tochari: I see what you're saying, but my point is that even if you feel that way about her, find another way of expressing it than using that word.
trilogy says "What the world needs now...is strong women." I agree.

Furthermore, I say what the world really needs now is good women. Strong is nothing without good, and it's an easy excuse to do as Hillary has often done, become a manipulator, therefore a liar, a female tyrant, not good, and not strong enough to be simply, good. That takes the most strength.
"You go, Mrs. Clinton! I frankly want the neighborhood kids to think I'm a witch; that way, they leave my yard alone.
Doris Allen"
You are, Doris. You are.
"The word "witch" is just a dodge for someone who doesn't have the eggs (or balls, as the case may be) to come right out and say "bitch". Grow a pair and say what you mean! -Eric Arthur Blair"
Some people don't talk that way, and some don't like the word as much as they don't like Hillary. So they change words to a softer one. They still don't like her at the same level, and the rest have to adjust. Is the word is actually harmful? I can't see any harm even if repeated by others (my common test). I mean, is there any harm from calling a male with disagreeable politics what you feel, especially if softened a bit, let's say from a-hole to butthead? That can't be too bad. If people feel Hillary is a witch I can't see any problem with it.

I'm sorry, Caroline, I don't think name calling is beneficial, and it lowers ourselves when we do it, but is there more to the story? Do you want Hillary to succeed just because she's a woman, or to keep America from looking bad?
Alysse: Here's to strong, good women and clear lawns.
Alysse: my feeling is less about Hillary Clinton herself than about the way the word witch is used. If you think her politics are bad, then verbalize that and outline how they could be improved, but don't just throw names around, especially one that has been used as an excuse to put people to death. Nobody was killed in Salem for being accused of bitchery, but they were for witchery.
Which old witch
The wicked witch.
Right on Caroline.

As far as witches, though, I just think people are improving on a modern term with one that no longer relates remotely to death. I'm sure no one wants Hillary to not succeed, regardless of what they think of her. America is on the line.