Culture Sandwich

from the so darn wondrous to the so darn weird

Caroline Hagood

Caroline Hagood
Location
New York, New York,
Birthday
November 23
Bio
I'm a poet, writer, and full-time book, movie, and blog maniac. I'm also a lover of offbeat humor and offbeat everything, really. My poetry and articles have appeared in various publications and I'm currently working on a book about my adventures in the land of writing. http://carolinehagood.typepad.com/ https://twitter.com/Caroline_Hagood If you'd like to get in touch regarding work, please contact caroline_hagood@yahoo.com.

NOVEMBER 6, 2009 12:16PM

Perfume: The Nose Always Knows

Rate: 12 Flag

Perfume- A most Disturbing Flick 

 

 

The impossible happened. Patrick Süskind’s “unfilmable” novel, Perfume: The Story of a Murderer, was adapted for the big screen (2006). This was no easy feat because scent, the book's theme, is difficult to portray cinematically.  

 

Some critics have pointed to the film's political undertones, even interpreting it as an allegory of the Third Reich. The producer, Bernd Eichinger, is no stranger to this subject, having gained international acclaim for The Downfall, a Hitler biopicApparently, Eichinger had been bugging Süskind to let him at Perfumesince its publication in 1985.  His perseverance paid off. 

 

The film does an impressive job with a difficult concept. Tom Tykwer (Run, Lola Run), no stranger to frenetic subject matter, had a tricky job with this tale of a homicidal perfume maker. The result is a charmingly bizarre hybrid that plays like the love child of Chocolat and Silence of the Lambs.

 

In this nightmarish fairytale, Jean-Baptiste Grenouille (Ben Whishaw) is born, despite his mother’s efforts to the contrary, in a filthy fish market.  The scene of his birth is perfectly executed and particularly striking; the pressure mounts as the baby’s heart struggles to pump amidst the many pounding elements of the market, climaxing in Grenouille's only real achievement— his own life.  

 

Years later, on a rare outing, he comes upon his first victim (Karoline Herfurth).  The camera masterfully highlights the pieces of her that obsess him; she is all bosom, shocking red hair, and plums. The search to preserve this experience through scent starts as a troubling fixation and leads to the composition of his master scent, the essences of 25 virgins, finishing with the lovely Laura (Rachel Hurd-Wood). 

 

Perfume is an ode to the nose; it opens with a dark shot of Grenouille’s face, with only his sniffer eerily lit. The film is slow in many places, but the result is a disturbing  examination of the horrors and pleasures of the senses. 

Author tags:

perfume, tom tykwer

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
"The result is a charmingly bizarre hybrid that plays like the love child of Chocolat and Silence of the Lambs"---just right!
The movie really is such a strange bird.
You're probably too young to remember SmelloVision. Not that it really worked, although it was charming to smell cowboy body odor.
Golly Gee!...the Hall of Mirrors World turns full circle...you were one of a select few Caroline who appreciated my essay on The Descent of Woman and Evolution of the Nose...and so a few grains of smello (re the aged J Blue-menthol...now that's a man's after-shave snorter!) planted last August have blossomed into your exquisite bouquet of today! I'm snorting a 'line' of your product off the monitor screen right now 'Caro' ...send a smello-gram to JB an' perk up de ole boy!
You always manage to find the most interesting stuff that is NOT so mainstream--that's what I like about you!
Sounds like a fascinating film!
Read the book when it first came out. Missed the movie. Maybe now I'll Netflix it.
John: every day I mourn the fact that I did not get to experience SmelloVision.

Caracalla: Glad you dig my smello.

Lou: So it does.

Spotted: thanks, bud. It helps to be weird.

Robert: You'd like it.
Let me echo Spotted Mind's comment. Your blog is a treasure trove-- I always walk away enriched, educated, or entertained in some way.

I love Alan Rickman's performances, so I'll have to check this one out. Thanks for the review.

-R-
you got me on "perfume" and"nose" as I would love to know what a nose (in the fragrance industry) knows. This sounds very interesting, I'll have to Netflix it.
rated:)
Caroline,

OK, I'll take your word for it.
Great review.
Rated.
Carolina: thank you so much for your words. I couldn't imagine nicer ones.

Debbs and Thoth: take a look and let me know.
The essence of 25 virgins? WHAT? Caroline I am glad you watched this one so I dont have to. :)
I'm going to have to search your blog for other reviews. This movie intrigues me, and so does your writing.
The book is excellent. The film has its strenghts but I suppose its main weakness is that deals with scents and odours which of course we aren't able to percieve in the cinema or on any other kind of screen. While the book certainly doesn't smell of anything (except perhaps of pulp of coffee stains), I think this technique of invisioning them works more effectively in literature. The whole point of literature after all is to use your faculties of imagination. On the screen on the other hand everything is spelled out for us. But please don't think that saying this makes me one of those snobs who think that this is why books are superior to movies. After all there are also things that movies can acheive which books cannot. It's cool that you also picked up on the Third Reich subtext.
Ariana: yes, it's not for the faint of heart:)

Cindy: that's so nice to hear. You know how I have enjoyed your blog.

Adrian: exactly. that was the great challenge--how to put the pleasures of the nose on screen. Given all the limitations you mention, I think they did quite well. And the Third Reich subtext was quite disturbing, but it certainly added another level.