Culture Sandwich

from the so darn wondrous to the so darn weird

Caroline Hagood

Caroline Hagood
Location
New York, New York,
Birthday
November 23
Bio
I'm a poet and writer living in New York City. My articles have appeared in various publications, including The Guardian, Salon, the Huffington Post, and The Economist.

MY RECENT POSTS

Caroline Hagood's Links

My Blog Outside of Open Salon--What You See Here Plus Everything You Don't
Editor’s Pick
MAY 30, 2010 12:24AM

A Summer Reading List for the Socially-Conscious Kid

Rate: 21 Flag

 

If you’re looking for summer reads that will give your child entertainment with a side of social awareness, take a gander at these books that offer nuanced takes on important issues.


Immigration

 

1. Cynthia DeFelice’s Under the Same Sky (for ages 10 and up)

  Under the same sky 
 

While working on his father’s farm, Joe learns about the prejudice and hardship that immigrant Mexican workers face. He discovers that some of the laborers are illegal, but also that many of the immigration laws are flawed. When he sees his deeply principled parents bending the rules for them, he starts to realize that sometimes people have to negotiate their own terms of justice. 

DeFelice teaches her reader that the inequalities in labor and wealth distribution are almost impossible to remedy as long as the societal structures support them; and that, ultimately, when the standard ones fall short, people have to live by their own laws.


Racism and Apartheid

2. Beverley Naidoo’s Chain of Fire (for ages 11 and up)          

Chain of fire

  
In Chain of Fire, Naledi and her friend, Taolo, protest the injustice of Apartheid in their South African community. Taolo perfectly captures the arbitrary nature of racism in the following speech on Apartheid: “They take six pieces of land…Then they say, ‘These pieces aren’t South Africa anymore…Any fool can see how they want to split us up…keeping us apart so they can control us!  Divide and rule!” 

In the end, Taolo and Naledi reveal that a combination of making people aware of prejudice, and showing them that it's their responsibility to do something about it, is the strongest means of effecting social change.


Censorship

3. Nat Hentoff's The Day They Came to Arrest the Book (for ages 13 and up)

The day they came to arrest the book 
 

In The Day They Came to Arrest the Book, Hentoff explores the tension between freedom of expression and the consideration of personal feeling. The debate breaks into two groups—those who want to take The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn off the curriculum because they find it racist and sexist, and those who want to keep it in because they believe that censorship is wrong. 

As a result of Hentoff’s multifaceted treatment of the debate, there is no absolute sense of right or wrong in the book. Although the issue is a complicated one, the novel implies that it is not the role of educators to cut their students off from knowledge, but rather to guide them through all sides of an issue and help them formulate their own opinions.


Multiculturalism

4. Randa Abdel-Fattah's Does My Head Look Big in This? (for ages 13 and up)

Does my head look big in this 
 

In Does My Head Look Big in This?, Abdel-Fattah argues for the acceptance of different cultural/religious practices. Her protagonist, Amal, describes herself as “An Australian-Muslim-Palestinian…whacked with some seriously confusing identity hyphens." A very mature young lady, Amal deals with her mixed cultural heritage with humor and dignity.  She also makes the life-changing decision to wear the hijab (a head-scarf worn by Muslim females) to her predominantly white prep school where it's frowned upon. 

Abdel-Fattah does an excellent job of debunking many of the misconceptions surrounding Muslim women. Contrary to what others might think, for Amal the hijab is not an oppressive symbol, but a liberating one. Abdel-Fattah examines the challenges that arise when a woman doesn’t want to be saved from those who misunderstand her condition. Interestingly, Amal’s quest to get in touch with her religious and cultural roots leads her to feel increasingly comfortable with her hybrid cultural identity.


Feminism

5. L.M. Montgomery’s Anne of Green Gables (for ages 9 and up)

 

Anne of Green Gables 
 
L.M. Montgomery’s Anne embodies an interesting brand of feminism that teaches young women that they don't have to change to fit a world that doesn't accept them, or even just wait for that world to change--they can reconfigure it themselves. Through her powers of imaginative transformation, Anne creates the world in which she has always longed to live. 

Yet the book’s characters are not the only ones whose outlook Anne changes. Anne’s attitude is so infectious that it reaches even her readers--reminding them that they, too, can change the world around them.

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Forget kids, let's get adults to read these books!

Hell, many adults may *just* be educated enough these days to comprehend tween lit ~snerk~
Exactly, PSM, I am reading the last three for sure. Excellent review, Caroline, and thank you. R
These are wonderful choices. And yes, as Placebo says, Let's get adults to read them too!_r
And a little child shall lead them!
Placebo, Thoth, and Joan: I always wonder about where the line is between adult and children's books. Very interesting.

Lou: well said.
This is great. there a number of books by Avi that are not new, but if kids missed them, have great underlying messages along these lines: Something Upstairs, The Christmas Rat, for example...and others...
they all sound good to me! thanks for making this list.
Patrick: great additions

dianaani: Thanks for reading.
Sharing this... a million thank yous, Caroline.
Excellent list! Thank you Caroline.
Anne of Green Gables -- one of my favorite books! The others are new to me, but I read YA a lot and I'll have to look for these at our library.
Amanda, Caroline, and Karin: Thanks! I'm glad you like the recommendations.

Bellwether: You'll have to tell me what you think if you get around to any of them
Kids' books just get better and better. We read Under the Same Sky here just a few weeks ago. One of many wonderful new releases. Thanks Caroline.
Thanks, Laura. Yeah, I would imagine that Under the Same Sky is a good way to bring up the topic of immigration with your kid.
These all look good, I think my daughter may enjoy the first one, as she recently wrote a paper about fruits and vegetables from a migrant workers point of view. I would also add to the list:

"Good Fortune" by Noni Carter--
From School Library Journal
Grade 9 Up—Sarah, Anna, and Ayanna are the names used by one person over the course of her life. First she is Sarah, a slave on a plantation in Tennessee. Her days are full of endless labor, humiliation, and the threat of rape. She struggles to understand the meaning of freedom and to educate herself despite the danger. After witnessing a brutal whipping, she flees north to freedom. Barely surviving the harrowing journey, Sarah and her adopted brother arrive in Ohio, only to find that freedom is not as sweet as she had hoped. She changes her name to Anna and begins a new life, but she worries about loved ones left behind and is embittered by the severe restrictions and discrimination faced by free blacks. One of the more effective literary devices is how Anna's narration gradually shifts from slave patois to more refined speech as her education progresses. Ayanna was her name as a child in Africa, remembered in nightmares, where the memories of the murder of her mother, the horrifying ocean passage in the belly of a slave ship, and being separated from her brother on the auction block haunt her. The transitions between the dreams and waking life are occasionally jarring, but on the whole the narrative flows smoothly and is well paced. An author's note about fact and fiction in the book adds weight to the historical information included.—Caroline Tesauro, Radford Public Library, VA

This a debut novel from a student at Harvard.

My daughter(almost 12) is reading it now and says it is a page turner.
WHAT A TERRIFIC BOOK-LIST! Excellent descriptions.
Rated.
So glad to see Anne here. I would add any of Tamora Pierce's books to the list.
Anne: Ooh, thanks so much for the tip!

Jonathan: Thank you. So glad you enjoyed it.

ttfn: I couldn't leave Anne out! Thanks for the recommendation.
Taking this list with me when we go to the mountains this summer...Although I think we may have read a couple already. Which is good. In the immortal words of Caroline Hagood: "Me likey."
Love the list, and I'll be adding some of these titles to my own library. I've practically memorized the Anne of GG series, and it only struck me a few years ago that Anne's desire--and ability--to get an advanced education was indeed highly progressive in the early 20th century. Montgomery had to bend over backwards to show that an educated woman would still want to be a mother.
I've added Anne of Green Gables to our list! We're still a little to young for the rest (or at least Sunshine is), but I definitely have written them down! Thanks my friend.
debg and sparking: glad you liked the list. I was seriously affected by Anne as a child. And, for her time, she was quite revolutionary.