Culture Sandwich

from the so darn wondrous to the so darn weird

Caroline Hagood

Caroline Hagood
Location
New York, New York,
Birthday
November 23
Bio
I'm a poet and writer living in New York City. My articles have appeared in various publications, including The Guardian, Salon, the Huffington Post, and The Economist.

MY RECENT POSTS

Caroline Hagood's Links

My Blog Outside of Open Salon--What You See Here Plus Everything You Don't
Editor’s Pick
OCTOBER 18, 2010 11:18AM

The Live Version of "30 Rock" Reminds Us of Our Own Humanity

Rate: 11 Flag

Liz-lemon-picture 

If you think about it, what "30 Rock" did by going live last Thursday is more mind-bending than it first appears. It's a real recorded, but now live, NBC show written by Tina Fey (Liz Lemon) about a fictional live NBC show written by Liz Lemon (Tina Fey), based on Fey's work on "Saturday Night Live."

Thus, Liz Lemon, the harried, gauche yet immensely charming head writer is also Tina Fey the harried, gauche yet immensely charming head writer, and her show has suddenly shifted into exactly what it used to pretend to be—the transformation is complete. 

The live episodes (they did an East Coast and a West Coast version) gesture towards the awkwardness of their own undertaking. They are peppered with purposeful mistakes to ensure that, in the case that the show doesn't quite pull it off, at least it will be in on its own joke. When there is a quick scene change and Fey can't make it, Julia Louis Dreyfus (Elaine from “Seinfeld”) stands in for her. The only thing that could make the episode even more reference-heavy and too clever for its own good would be having Sarah Palin as the Fey stand-in.

Presumably, people find the arts so satisfying because they read, listen to music, and watch movies and television (and especially reality television, as misguided as that might be) in order to escape their own reality, yes, but also to see it reflected back to them in more palatable and comprehensible terms. In going live, "30 Rock" accomplishes both of these mental positions at once because it portrays another reality for the viewer to escape into, yet also breaks down the fourth wall by referring to its own constructedness and, even more poignantly, reminding the viewer of the other thing that waits beyond that wall--their own life.

Thus, the live show allows for a simultaneous experience of fiction and reality, but the reality is dressed in a helpful layer of fiction that allows it to go down more easily. It's psychological or philosophical depending on how you look at it--a cheaper form of therapy or just another attempt to answer the question that sounds continuously at the margins of our minds: “what does it all mean?". In its recorded form, "30 Rock" can be slick and perfectly executed, but in its live form, heavy with self-reflexivity and an awareness of its own vulnerability, like leaked un-photoshopped images of celebrities, it reminds us of our own humanity.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I've only seen a little of "30 Rock" and haven't really gotten into it. I did love Tina as SP.

Your commentary, too, was a very nice mindf*ck - reminding me of endlessly regressing images in two facing mirrors, or the "Land O Lakes" package the kids talk about in a recent episode of "Mad Men."
Or Escher's art. Rated for fun.
Cleverly crafted and insightful piece, Caroline.
Thanks for the interesting analysis, Caroline. Haven't seen those episodes yet, but thank God for On Demand!
You've convinced me to see it. R.
Sharp and insightful. Just like you.
Very very intriguing! I like how your mind works. I haven't seen the episode yet -- it's on our DVR. Which...wait a minute. Seems to (maybe?) have killed the immediacy? I mean, it's still live to ME whenever I watch it, but it's no longer "live." I wonder if something is lost in that delay? Or does watching via TV provide a theoretical delay/disconnect anyway?
Fantastic stuff Caroline. You never cease to entertain and inform.
I saw both the East Coast and West Coast versions, thanks to Hulu, and loved watching them back to back - 30 Rock is one of my favorite shows.
LuminousMuse: oh good, I'm glad it was a mindf*ck

Matt: Thanks very much

John; totally

bluestocking babe: Thanks a lot

Jonathan: oh I'm glad

Cartouche: that's so nice to hear. thank you

Bellwether: Oh I think it will still be live to you:)

tomreedtoon: this is the first time for 30 rock

Jack: thanks, bud

owl: totally the way to do it
Caracalla: I loved 'Godel, Escher, Bach!' I'm sure some of the math went over my head, but I loved the concepts! The whole droste effect and all that.
Great article. Thanks for posting the Hulu video.

Best,
@LaLicenciada
Great article. Thanks for posting the Hulu video.

Best,
@LaLicenciada
Oh I can't wait to watch this now. I was just watching reruns last night. Such a great show. Such a great post. Good work!
LaLicenciada and Anna: Thanks so much!
This sounds like an exception to the rule that TV is the most mind-numbing of mediums that turns it audience life into a living hell by coercing them into purchasing meaningless brand objects. The inevitable consequence is that they must engage in greweling meanial labor to be able to accommodate for this kind of life style. Thank your drawing my attention to this show.
Adrian: It's an exception to me, at least.