Adopting an Older Kid Vs. Raising One From Scratch
When I was a 37 year old single woman without kids, I adopted a child who was almost eight years old. In my last post I assessed my mothering abilities because I was feeling the need to sort out my own feelings about our situation. I received encouraging and insightful feedback that really got me wondering what kind of mother I would be if I had given birth or raised my child from infancy.
Here are some of my parenting experiences that have been unique to adopting an older child:
- When my child first came to live with me, I vented to my cousin who said this: "Every new mother worries that she doesn't know what she's doing...that she's doing a terrible job. The difference here is that you are a new mother and your kid regularly says out loud to you, "You don't know what you're doing. You're doing a terrible job."
- Imagine having a 7 yr old in your charge who feels no connection to you and seems to hate you. There were times when we were out in public that she would just take off running and then respond to me as if I was a stranger abducting her. I guess I was. When I picked her up from playdates, she would refuse to go with me. I felt completely powerlessness. Without a mother-child connection, I had to get really creative to maintain any control over her.
- Not having watched my child grow and develop since infancy, I was more prone to being surprised or frustrated at what she couldn't comprehend, articulate or do rather than thrilled at her progress. This really struck me one day when friends were marveling at something clever their toddler said.
- My daughter was born addicted to crack. She is obsessed with sugar, more so, I believe, than the average sweet-toothed child. She molds herself to win the approval of those around her. With these three things in mind, I find it hard to convince myself that she might not one day develop an addiction problem.
- Prior to me, she lived on pop, hot pockets and donuts. I have a lot of food sensitivities, and I eat much differently. I try to compromise, providing her with some comfort foods from her past--but it is never enough.
- By the time she was 6, my daughter had watched every freddy kruger or chainsaw massacre movie you can imagine. She has seen adults, including her mother, have sex right out in the open. This has probably fed my fanaticism about monitoring & discussing her media intake.
- The people she lived with prior to me were racist. In her early days with me there were numerous embarrassing moments, including the first time she saw our mail carrier and yelled, 3 times, while our windows were open, "There's a black man on our porch!" If I had raised her from infancy, I would of course pay attention to teaching her my values. The extra work I had though, was to un-teach her other people's values.
- Speaking of un-teaching her, I remember the first time my 7 yr old & I were playing a pretend game & she was the grown-up. I asked what kind of job she would like, and she replied "I'm going to watch tv and drink beer all day." Oh, and there was the time I gave her a box of little fairy dolls--she took them out & began acting out some kind of jerry springer episode, complete with "you stole my man" and lots of fairy on fairy brawling.
- My daughter was abused and is terrified of angry adults. Her history is written all over her face every time I show anger.
- My daughter was neglected. She lives in fear of not getting enough. This has been expressed in many ways. The good news is that her shoplifting habit was brief and I no longer have to hold my breath when we go through the security door at Target.
- She loves me now. She tells me this often, writes me love notes, likes to be physically close. She has bonded to me and we have been given the therapist's stamp of approval that we are fully "attached." She actually smiles at me now when she sees me arrive to watch one of her games. Although she still calls me her aunt, she will actually tolerate others referring to me as her mother, which is a huge improvement. That said, I know she would leave me to go back to her birth family quicker than I could get her coat. At school, when she has to draw or write about her family, I am nowhere to be found.
- I always have in the back of my mind that my time with her is condensed--I knew I'd get to go trick or treating with her 3 maybe 4 times tops, that there would only be a few times that I could play santa claus...I like to think this has made me more appreciative of our special moments together.


Salon.com
Comments
They gave up when he was not the perfect kid and gave him back.
I applaud you for keeping the faith.
rated with hugs
linda, that just breaks my heart
Thank you Caroline Marie, for stepping up and walking the walk and these bumpy paths with your daughter. Our whole society is grateful for your courage and the size of your heart.
(Yes, i capitalized your name on purpose!)
nicole, there are thousands of beautiful children aging out of the foster care system everyday....it's definitely worth considering
thank you alysa, linda & scj--your words mean a lot to me
Shortly after A moved in, we were at the Rite Aid and I was getting ehr an ice cream cone. They did call us "mom" and "dad" right after moving in, and she had said something out loud with "mom" it in, that the server heard. Then it was time to get the ice cream, I turn to her and say "do you like strawberry?" The *look* from the server as to what kind of horrible mother was I, not knowing whether my 9 year old (who looked even older) liked strawberry!
I love how you write of the changes, the fears all of it so very well.
~R
I began the fostering/adoption process a couple of years ago with hopes of adopting a 4-6 year old. I met my now-fiance, who lived out of state, midstream in the process and was prevented from having him in my home if he hadn't participated in the county's training. (He couldn't be in town every week for several weeks, as required.). I chose to forgo my plans to add to my family.
At any rate, your story makes me sad that I didn't follow through on the adoption, but concerned that I might not have had the ability to manage the many challenges I was likely to face as you so eloquently describe.
Congratulations on making it through to the other side. I wish only the best for you and your daughter in the years to come.
the journey is full of its own rewards for all involved, and I imagine, at a much faster rate.
Plus don't forget--
when your kid does something bad you are absolved of guilt, you have others to blame it on
& when you parent badly you can always tell yourself that at least she has it better now than she did before.
See? There are perks too.....
She is in college now, studing Chinese, and thriving, with all of the normal doubts and thrills that all kids starting college experience. It all comes down to love love love, and more love. Lots of hugging, and setting limits early on.
My story is a successful one, and I bet yours will be as well.
Much love to you .
As difficult a transition as it is for the parents, it is just as difficult for the new siblings and, yes, many bumps in the road. After everyone left home and I was the last one in the nest, we went through a couple of years of temporary foster placements- this time I became the older rather than the younger sibling.
It's worth doing as long as you are realistic in your expectations and understand what you are taking on. These days, most singles and couples already lead very hectic lives so taking on an older, needy child is not easy (my sister adopted 3 girls, aged 6, 5, and 3 at the time from Russia and the road has been mainly potholes and I had custody of the middle child for a year). Kudos to all who open their families and hearts in this manner.