Cartouche's Blog

Writing My Way Out of Something

cartouche

cartouche
Location
Someplace, somewhere else, USA
Birthday
February 09
Title
nonconfromist (on Twitter)
Company
Mind My Own Business
Bio
Artist, former newspaper columnist and restaurant critic. Author of "In Pursuit of Excellence" (the first cookbook of Two Star Michelin Chef Josiah Citrin). In my spare minute I can be found blogging here, on Huffington Post and other places that don't pay. And writing for some that do. You are NOT in Kansas anymore, Toto. Neither am I.

MY RECENT POSTS

MARCH 22, 2010 9:50AM

Were You Born to Love or Hate?

Rate: 62 Flag

Close your eyes for a moment and imagine that you had been born blind.   What would be your frame of reference to describe the color red, the concept of beautiful, the shape of a horse, a stunning sunset or the perfect body?   How would you define characteristics like handsome, pretty, pleasing or unsightly?  Your standards would be based on nothing more than what you feel from being in the presence of another.  You might use your hands and your sense of taste and smell to reinforce what you already know to be true based on those feelings.  The validation of your senses emanates from the feelings in your heart.   Throw away your glasses and listen to it. 

The only radar you can really trust is your heart, especially if you are sightless.  Your fingers are the instruments by which it receives the physical message and sends it off to the brain to processes this information.  A blind person won’t judge you for your thinning hair or taste in fashion.  A blind person won’t make a judgment about you before you’ve ever spoken based on the color of your skin or the scars on it.  A blind person won’t deem you unsuitable or incompatible because of your size or girth or physical disability.  A blind person will see you for who and not what you are.  Maybe you’re afraid to get close enough to find out just WHO that might be.  And you still think the person with the cane has the handicap?

                    Your perception can change rather quickly if you have eyes with which to see, but apparently we’ve all been looking at the wrong pictures.   After being accosted all day by images on television, in magazines and on  billboards, we come home with a twisted concept of what we should look like and the revelation that we somehow don’t measure up.   Beauty may be in the eye of the beholder, but I bet you that the scales of justice would balance differently if we saw each other only through our hearts and not our eyes.   There must be a reason that the centers of them are called pupils.  They’re just poor students.  It’s about time we learned a thing or two.

 With your eyes still shut, take your hands and cover your ears.  Imagine that along with being blind, you had also been born deaf.  Not a sound in the world could frighten or destroy your perception of it.  A parent’s voice couldn’t tell you who or what you are, should be, must think, like or do.  No one would tell you to laugh softer or love less.  Words could never provoke, persuade, convince, damage or hurt you.   If you  could no longer communicate with words, what would be your weapons?  To what end and why would you use them?

Imagine every story you were ever told is not filed in your memory or controlling the decisions and actions that you make today.  Imagine no one ever told you that you can’t, shouldn’t, aren’t, will never be.  Think about everything you accept as truth today because long ago someone else forced you to believe it by saying it was so or pierced your heart so deeply that you are still bleeding.  Try to remember where your ideas and beliefs came from and ask yourself if you believe them because they are true or if they are true because someone made you believe them. 

Were you raised in a house that was Godless or full of God?  Do you hate blacks or whites, Jews or gentiles, republicans or democrats, Arabs or Americans, linoleum or hardwood floors, Hellman's or Miracle Whip?  Who is responsible for you believing you should hate a person, a thing or a group of them at all?   You didn’t wake up one morning and decide that something or someone different than yourself was ruining the world and worth discarding, ignoring, destroying or hating.  Someone or something prompted you and taught you to believe it.  As time passed, you sought out the experiences that sustained those ideas and gathered them like soldiers to act as reinforcements.   It doesn’t take a lot of brains to become a valedictorian of ignorance.  All it requires is a controlled classroom and a charismatic teacher.

I can’t expunge what has been written on the blackboard of your life or mine.  But I can ask you to take a look at who was holding the chalk.  And then I’ll ask you to take that chalk away and start thinking for yourself.  You might want to go ahead and invest in an eraser too.  Seek your truth but remember that everybody else’s perception of it comes from their own vast or limited experiences.  It doesn’t make you or anyone else more right or wrong.  It just makes them what they are.  Open your heart to that possibility.

 Nothing is written in stone unless the heart from which words are formed or the recipient for whom they were intended  are made of it

 I ask you again to close your eyes and cover your ears, without sight or sound to influence you.  No vision or hearing imparting or impairing your perspective.  No directors to answer to, no lines to memorize, no script to follow.  Rewind the movie of your life and go back to the point where there was nothing but a fresh roll of film waiting in the camera to start documenting your existence before you were exposed to everything and everyone else.  For nine months inside your mother’s womb you were exactly this being, this soul.  You were you in your purest state, nothing more than a tiny labor of love waiting to happen.

And then you were born.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
"I can’t expunge what has been written on the blackboard of your life or mine. But I can ask you to take a look at who was holding the chalk. And then I’ll ask you to take that chalk away and start thinking for yourself. You might want to go ahead and invest in an eraser too. Seek your truth but remember that everybody else’s perception of it comes from their own vast or limited experiences. It doesn’t make you or anyone else more right or wrong. It just makes them what they are. Open your heart to that possibility."

Beautiful, Cartouche! True and true...I hope everyone tries it. xox
"It doesn’t take a lot of brains to become a valedictorian of ignorance. All it requires is a controlled classroom and a charismatic teacher." Doesn't this need to be on the wall of every school?
In my mind, this is juxtaposed with images and sounds from the health care debate . . .
I learned from a young girl that what we see and hear is fleeting, that those senses can be taken away without notice, in just one second. What matters is art.
.
To enter every encounter with a clean slate, as if it is the first time, is a Zen premise. So so so darn hard to do. If I can manage it once, one time, one moment of the day, I feel grateful. Thank you for writing about this, expanding on the beauty of it, with your pretty words.
"There must be a reason that the centers of them are called pupils. They’re just poor students."

wow
The eraser is key. Nothing worse than the repeated attempts of those around you to "put you back in that box" as you transform. No crueler words can be uttered than, "You haven't changed a bit" when working you ass off to do exactly that.
Very good post. My mother was a very judgmental woman and when I find myself acting the same way I always end up thinking of her (so I'm probably blaming her). In the end, I was born to love.
Your words, Cartouche, always make me think. You touch on so many truths for me here. "Imagine no one ever told you that you can't, shouldn't, aren't, will never be." Sometimes when I was a child, I would listen in the evenings when we visited friends or relatives, as my mother told those we visited about me. I often wondered who that person was that she was describing to them because it certainly wasn't me. I never uttered a sound. The little child in me didn't really care. I knew who I was. How funny that my mother did not.

What happened to that little girl and her wisdom? I always kept quiet and always kept my own counsel. Then I began to read. As long as I could escape into the world of books and stories and characters, I could be most true to myself. More than anything else then, I learned, not from the books, to be silent. To be fair, someone was always sleeping in my house. In time, I became silent even to myself.

When I began to write, if only in a journal, I found a place to speak, to be myself and to feel safe. I am sure that much of my work with student writers has been deeply influenced by what I learned there.

"Nothing is written in stone unless the heart from which words are formed or the recipient for whom they were intended are made of it." I love these words. "... fresh roll of film...." I expect I will play with this idea today. I know I will come back to these words. Thanks for the gift of them.
If there is one thing I am forever grateful to my parents for teaching me, it is acceptance of all mankind. I never even noticed skin color until I graduated high school and went on to further education in New York City. Then, I didn't understand what the big deal was. Perhaps, because my mother suffered prejudice when she arrived in this country as a little girl, she was determined not to pass that along to my sister and me.
Just beautiful... If only people would listen.
Miss P: your writing this gloomy morning is particularly lovely. As for your original question: despite flashes of anger and some serious tragedies played out across my small bit of landscape, I'm a lover at heart.
We may remark in passing that to be blind and beloved may, in this world where nothing is perfect, be among the most strangely exquisite forms of happiness. The supreme happiness in life is the assurance of being loved; of being loved for oneself, even in spite of oneself; and this assurance the blind man possesses. In his affliction, to be served is to be caressed. Does he lack anything? no. Possessing love he is not deprived of light. A love, moreover, that is wholly pure. There can be no blindness where there is this certainty.

-- Victor Hugo

I'm not sure this quote is on point with your thoughts, but I like it. I can tell that my eraser will have a lot of chalk dust on it.
I think these are lovely thoughts and, as always with your writing, beautifully expressed, but I disagree on a few points.

There is no such thing as tabula rasa even in the womb. Genetic predisposition is a well-documented phenomenon, and while its effects need not rule our lives, we are already biased when we pop out.

I think that the heart, without mediation from a discriminating brain as well as some parentally, societally, or religiously imparted code of conduct and morality, is a terrible guide. Woody Allen once said famously that "the heart wants what it wants," and what the heart sometimes wants is horribly destructive to the individual and society.

As Lenny Bruce put it, " The world is what it is, not what we want it to be." I was told when I was very young and enthralled with airplanes that my eyesight would prevent me from ever becoming a pilot. I also have a slight non-specific hand tremor which meant being a surgeon wasn't in the cards either. I'm now grateful to those who made me face those facts although they were painful to hear at the time. People who make you see unpleasant truths about yourself and the world are doing you more of a service than those who tell you anything is possible in life.
cartouche- You have eloquently and succinctly encapsulated months of intensive inpatient therapy with this insightfully stunning prose. "Do unto others..., live and let live..., judge not lest you be judged... contempt before investigation... know thyself... to thine own self be true... ", are often dismissed as platitudes by entrenched skeptics. Most truly healthy people of my acquaintance embrace them as daily, living-principles.
My favorite: "Never think less of yourself, but rather, think of yourself less."
You have earned my admiration, yet again.
-rated-
cartouche,
I was born to love though I had to experience some hate before I found that out; a light to dark kind of thing. Great post ;)
It is posts like this that make me so very glad that I had the good fortune to stumble upon OS.
Many,many thanks.
I do love this. Thank you.
"Nothing is written in stone unless the heart from which words are formed or the recipient for whom they were intended are made of it." This is so full of your wisdom and your golden heart, but then I expected nothing less from you, Cartouche. Thank you, once again.
Rated.
posts like this bring out the humanist in me, the transcendalist, the glass-is-spilling-over it's so full, make love not war mentality. i hope and pray that we are born to love, but i do believe that the two, love and hate go hand in hand. for you to hate something, don't you need emotion, charged and pointed toward something that you once either loved or wanted to love or didn't understand? i think there is this fundamental powerful emotion, like a seed, and once it's planted it can go either way, toward love or hate, but the basic composition is very similiar. it's off by a few molecules, at most. this isn't a bad thing, either. i think the opposite of love is indifference, not hatred. such a wonderful post, and one that left me feeling optimistic and kind of wanting to be born all over again. rated!
Beautiful, Patricia. We always have choices.
Lovely concept. If only those who need it most would listen and learn.
You've got to be taught
To hate and fear,
You've got to be taught
From year to year,
It's got to be drummed
In your dear little ear
You've got to be carefully taught.

You've got to be taught to be afraid
Of people whose eyes are oddly made,
And people whose skin is a diff'rent shade,
You've got to be carefully taught.

You've got to be taught before it's too late,
Before you are six or seven or eight,
To hate all the people your relatives hate,
You've got to be carefully taught!

1949 Rodgers and Hammerstein, SouthPacific
Lovely writing, as usual. You place questions before us which make us wrestle with the realities and want to strive for the ideal.
Our heart is what Life's all about! Thanks for this!!
Your wisdom always amazes me--this is just beautiful and profound.
"Imagine no one ever told you that you can’t, shouldn’t, aren’t, will never be. " That will keep some of us busy for awhile. Thanks for this.
Beautiful thoughts. Might even warm my cynical heart for a moment or two. -r
You stopped me in my tracks!
This is the real you... t Cartouche that first arrived here some time ago, before dust ups made you speak in a tone made cautious by of other people's chalk. Welcome back.
Full of laughter, music, kindness, empathy, loving yet firm rules to live by.
Our house was full of love. Mine too. Empty nest now but the love and positive energy remains.
Loving energy is a sense all it's own.
Couldn't live without it.
"The validation of your senses emanates from the feelings in your heart"
Thank you for these words Cartouche.
Thank you for sharing this. I brought up my children telling them it takes more muscles to frown than to smile, when you forgive you leave the burden of hate behind and when you are open you don't miss all the good things coming your way. You of course have said it very beautifully here. Rated.
so true and well said. i needed this today. i'm sharing with others too. more of us need to start looking at ourselves and our surroundings the way you described.
Very inspiring article!
Great wisdom, Cartouche, and full of challenging questions ... some spoken, others implicit.

I was fortunate, only now learning how much so. I grew up in a house full of love and caring; void of dominating, overwhelming mentalities that tried to control; who proffered perjuduce and jealosies. I've never felt that way toward thsoe who were *different* from me.

Now, 66 years later, I marvel at all the folks who harbor anger and pain and hate and prejudice; who suffer fear and insecurity and self-loathing ... many on this site. I had no idea so many people have been that harmed that years later, they still carry the scars.

I give thanks every day. {{{{R}}}}
Another reason to make the best choices we can is that genetics and environment influence who we are, too, so we're in the tricky position of traveling upstream and going with the current at the same time.
Great line: "There must be a reason that the centers of them are called pupils. They’re just poor students."

I would take slight issue with your wombinology, in that evidence strongly suggests the fetus is affected by external stimuli. But your point is well-taken -- we do judge far too much with our eyes rather than our hearts.

I'm often accused of being a "Chinese Menu" Christian, and that's supposed to be an insult that ranks right up there with "secular humanist" -- as tho there was something inherently evil about being secular or a humanist or picking and choosing among the doctrines, myths and evils that are handed to you in the name of religion.

My answer to accusers is simple: How can you believe something your own heart tells you is wrong? How, for example, can you hate someone simple because they're black or white? Gay or straight? And how can you see two people more or less indistinguishable from each other and hate one because they are Catholic and you are Protestant? Or they are Muslim and you are Hindu? Or they are Arab and you are Jew?

Any God worthy of the name and of adoration would despise all this regardless of what is writ in someone's holy book.
A very thoughtful post! I've been reading the Dyer translation of the Tao Te Ching, and was reminded of the 10th verse:

I suspend my belief in opposites by seeing myself in all.

Giving birth and nourishing;
having, yet not possessing;
working, yet not taking credit;
leading without controlling or dominating.

One who heeds this power
brings the Tao to this very earth.
This is the primal virtue.
I don't think it is realistically possible for most people, unless they have reached a continual state of Divine Essence, to go back to the time they were born and wipe the slate clean, but it is certainly possible for most of us to open our minds and our hearts. Thank you for sharing that essential truth.
"And then you were born."
Definitely downhill from there: the first eviction from the first full service luxury condo. No wonder newborns scream ...
What a gorgeous post. What that would feel like to me is Heaven on Earth. Thank you for saying it so beautifully.
Great post. Thank you.
I think it's a bad idea to tell people to close their eyes at the beginning of a post. I didn't get past the first sentence because I couldn't see the rest. In fact, my eyes are still closed. Can I open them now?
Kidding aside, great post, very well written, as always.
R
I loved this post and I think it is one of the best things of yours I have read. The imagery of a blind person is an amazing metaphor. I have a visual problem that may cause me to go blind someday, so I can fully relate. Of course as my eye dr once said to me, "Anyone can go blind on any given day, you are not special."
Touche. Let's appreciate the love from our heart. R.
Beautiful post, cartouche; so true.
Rated.
Cartouche:
Darn girl, you always make me think!
Yours has been a voice of reason many times over in OS. Keep writing. We need to be reminded.
Much love.
c: I come to this late as I've taken a little vacation from all things OS. This is a wonderful post. I've printed it out so that I can read it again at another time and another place: soon and near. My own blackboard is so filled and cluttered that an eraser just smears it around. I need to take a bucket of soapy water and just throw it on my board and use a little elbow grease... but I won't. But thanks for reminding me how lazy I am. R.
I'm definitely going to have to rad this more than once. Beautiful.
Sometimes I think I was born to dither.

Other times no.

Another well-composed post Cartouche.
Lovely and wonderful. Hate seems to swirl about...I can't control that, but today I can choose to love. I will absorb this and radiate love.

Rated,
Stephanie
I keep following twostinkybabies.
But, I don't do diaper. I loved this.
Tao.
You'd think the USA would try truth.
There was a era when Tao was practiced.
Wars, lies, plunder and greed makes miserable.
There's a old book`The Sword and the Chalice.
There was the BC days when folk got deathly ill.
War had plundered the Plutocrats inner beings.
Thugs became effete, weak, panicky, piss-pants,
gibber-bellow-bah bah boo, a phew bad leeches.
People became grass roots irate at a 'sick fat cat?
Truth.
Try Truth.
Tao. Try it.
I was real sad.
A old KKK geezer picked up a young child while he wore a white cape and KKK hat.
Hoods in fancy rags.
DC clothes stink bah.
I never saw such such silly.
Those silly clothes are silk.
Ties cost more than wine jug.
Shoes look like woods ladyslippers.
But, a natural lady slipper is pretty.
K-Street shoes have diamonds on sole.
Karma.
Pay dues.
One day.
Wake up.
practices.
kindness.

Then, somebody ask`Try Truth! It will amaze folk!
No one will steal beets, turnips, and white KKK capes!
I remember a photo of a old KKK hater holding a toddler!
I love your posts. Original and airy, but also succinct and tightly written so nary an extra word remains without a purpose. So glad you're here.
Beautifully written ...Touché! (I only wish I could write half as well.)
The latest research shows there is no scientific basis for the concept of race. All people share 99.9% the same DNA. What we currently call "race" is simply superficial differences in appearance. We are essentially the same.

And we're all born loving, and wanting to be loved.

Everthing after that is learned.