Cartouche's Blog

Writing My Way Out of Something

cartouche

cartouche
Location
Someplace, somewhere else, USA
Birthday
February 09
Title
nonconfromist (on Twitter)
Company
Mind My Own Business
Bio
Artist, former newspaper columnist and restaurant critic. Author of "In Pursuit of Excellence" (the first cookbook of Two Star Michelin Chef Josiah Citrin). In my spare minute I can be found blogging here, on Huffington Post and other places that don't pay. And writing for some that do. You are NOT in Kansas anymore, Toto. Neither am I.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
APRIL 20, 2010 9:42AM

What Hangs in the Closet of Your Past

Rate: 91 Flag

My not being a big fan of organized religion has less to do with being the daughter of a Holocaust survivor than it does my aversion to organized anything, except perhaps, chaos.  It also has to do with my being a seeker.  I spent the first two decades of my life hearing and believing one version of the truth as it was told/explained/offered and served to me and the next three unraveling, dissecting and uncovering another one.  I am spinning my yarn in reverse. 

When you grow up in a predominantly Jewish neighborhood and your father is the local poster boy for Holocaust survival, you wear a certain badge of honor and earn the guilt by association that comes along with it. As if by extension, family members are defined by this label, without most people having any understanding of the fibers or material from which the cloth is woven.  How much of it is organic or manufactured?  Is it raw or processed?  Does the suit feel as well as it looks or is it over worn?  Whether you like it or not, it’s assigned to you and every day you wake up, take attendance, become that person and dress your part,  even if the bigger part of who you really are is often notably absent.

At the corner of my street lived a family, the matriarch of which was also a Holocaust survivor.  Her daughter Susie was my age and we attended the same school.  We attempted friendship in an awkward way but never actually managed it.  The knowingness we shared about our lives behind closed doors was not enough and we could tell the difference.  We just couldn’t talk about it.

I can remember going over to her house to play on a few occasions and being struck by the fact that as maniacally clean as our home was at all times, hers was downright sterile.  The kitchen on the main floor was, for lack of a better description, simply for “show”.  Absolutely no cooking or food preparation took place in that showroom.  Meals were prepared in a secondary kitchen in the basement.  It too, was spotless.  In fact, the entire house was haunted by disinfectant, cleanliness and ghosts of horrible memories that could not be washed or chased away.  The sheets were changed daily. Even when someone else makes your bed and you lie in it, fresh, clean sheets can’t cover up the truth.

Susie and I shared an unspoken understanding that the single commonality between our parents was the source of our own and included everything from shame, pride, fear and mystery to tension, unanswered questions, confusion and uneasiness.  To walk on eggshells around someone for a few hours is an exercise in restraint.  Being raised walking around and avoiding silent landmines was one of our normal, everyday “rewards”.  In the end, it seemed easier to do it in our own respective houses than inside each other’s.  The choreography in the home of Holocaust survivors is determined by the lead dancer.  Everybody else just follows.  No costume changes are allowed. 

I have turned my wardrobe inside out, restitched sections and seen how its invisible pattern discovered clever ways to repeat itself without any sign of a seamstress' hand.  For so many years, I watched myself be altered by it until I decided to undress myself completely so my skin could finally breathe.  The uniform of being a Holocaust survivor’s daughter is not one I choose to wear to identify myself, even though it is a part of who I am.  It hangs in the closet of reminders.  

I have many others keeping it company.

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Stunningly beautiful and thoughtfully rendered.
As the grandson of a British soldier who helped to liberate Bergen-Belsen, I thoroughly understand the need to be clean. I'd rather not think about what the camps must have been like...
Great Stuff! I don't believe in organized religion either, but putting myself in there shoes, I just don't know!
Brilliantly disturbing!
I'm glad you were able to sweep away the egg shells and start fresh.
I would be curious as to the reasons for all the obsessive cleanliness.
Being the descendant of those who put your family in those camps, I cannot really imagine what it was like. I can say, that I share your desire to strip myself of this "skeleton" though, and live my life for myself.
Beautifully done, Cartouche. The subject matter is so compelling, and the details you describe just completely illustrate a survivor's mindset.
I also have to say - this essay can be a model of how to write powerfully and sparely - every word is chosen and important.
this is the best thing you've written that I've read. there's a great deal of truth and heart here. I know what you're talking about, living in the shadow of a monstrous theatrical event. Yours far more compelling than mine, but theater none the less. my costume is a suit of armor, grossly dented and very thin, it wasn't much in the way of protection, but I got to paint it with a lot of colors so it kept me busy.

I had a number of friends who were children of Holocaust survivors and they too had those utterly immaculate kitchens, immaculate homes. How I envied them, because my home was a complete disastrous mess, my mother schizophrenic and barely able to separate her children and her home from her phobias and fantasies. I suppose that controlling cleanliness allow the illusion of control, as if all this working will ensure that you are safe. And we, in the safety of mess and crumbs. All this damage, all this misery.

thanks for sharing this piece of yourself.
This is fascinating. I love the way you've been using clothes as a metaphor, as worn garment, examined and closeted. (r)
Cartouche,
I could actually feel the tense awkwardness of you and Susie trying to establish a friendship. This was well written and it makes one think how horrors like the Holocaust have a lasting and far reaching effect....in ways that are unseen...and I don't know that many people quite grasp that. Thank you for showing this. Much love to you.
Great! You ask me to comment on Really?
I bumped into Clark Kent and Lois Lane.
On the left Feed @ 10:20. I love bumps.
`
MACULAR DEGENERATION - R. Deluty.
`
Rather than try
to discern the world
through haze, blind spots,
distortion, and blur,
she prefers to close her lids
and see trees and flowers,
seashores and canyons,
sunrise and snowfalls,
friends and neighbors,
lightening and rainbows,
her children and grandchildren-
all clear as crystal-
in her mind's eye.
Why, good for you on the acquired attitiude. "silent landmines," eh; show off. That's the catouche I know; deliberate fluent and snazzy. Brilliant, rated.
Strong beautiful metaphors here Cartouche. Clothing like a mask, fabric that you sew over and over until it falls apart, is no longer useful.
Dear C,

Touching story.
To have survival DNA is about as good as it gets !
Your ability to convey emotions and thoughts is unparalleled. No matter how foreign this topic may be to me (growing up as a Holocaust survivor's daughter) you make the feelings very real with your words. I wonder how Suzy made out in this life.
I like that image.. hanging in the closets of our past, we all have these discarded pieces of outwear I think, some made for us, others ill-fitting hand-me-downs..

Skin breathing free, feels good doesn't it?

Rated for awareness.
It is impossible to fully, mentally place myself in the horrific conditions that your mother and others knew. I can imagine that cleanliness and keeping things orderly may be, in part, something survivors cling to because those endeavors show they have some control over their own lives -- control that was stripped away when they were young and the world was especially insane.

Beautiful writing!
Miss C, my response to this is "Cartouche is back." I love it when you write these kinds of essays.
Acknowledgement and then choice, legacies. This is timely for me--last week I was reading "Those Who Save Us", and it was the first time I had read about the compulsion for cleaning among survivors.
This is touching/wonderful/well-written as usual/always/ever.
R
" Being raised walking around and avoiding silent landmines was one of our normal, everyday “rewards”." "... every day you wake up, take attendance, become that person and dress your part, even if the bigger part of who you really are is often notably absent."

Supreme, martyred, patriarchy in a home from a religiously homogenized community, weaves an invisible emotional shroud for a child. In my stridently Catholic neighborhood, we donned sack- cloth and ashes.

This was astounding! Let's go skinny-dipping!!!!

-rated-
Your reflections are quite poignant and illustrate how loss can affect a family. To a far lesser degree, my mother and father and I have mourned the loss of their third child, the sister I waited and longed for who died from SIDS shortly after she was born five years after me. The loss was traumatic for the three of us, but my brother, who was only two years old, fortunately does not remember her or her death. My parents and I rarely spoke of her and my mother can't even tell me what month she was born now that she suffers from early dementia.

That unspokedness you write about is the only way to survive such loss. Thanks for putting it into words. R
We are but jigsaw puzzles of past and present. Sometimes the pieces fit together perfectly and other times the edges grow ragged from being shoved time and again into spaces where, although they look like they fit, they just don't. That's why the future is unknown. There's no room for it as yet.
R
A lovely and insightful look at an attempt to free oneself from the past, to be able to experience life through a new lens. A fascinating trip. Tom Wolfe wrote that our histories are "sewn into the lining of our coats." Unbeknownst. Hiding there as we traveled as far from home as possible, as quick as we could.

There wasn't much talk of family history in my house. My mother was intent on remaining "white linen" Irish. Not like the rabble that came over after her parents. There was never a word about what was happening in the Auld Sod at the time. Admonitions to scrub behind the ears before Sunday mass had nothing to do with impressing Jesus. I'm quite sure of that.
Closets. We all have them. They are for hiding the things we rarely use or are just as happy to forget about.
Haven't been around much lately, but I can see you haven't lost you touch with the written word.
This was beautiful.
"I spent the first two decades of my life hearing and believing one version of the truth as it was told/explained/offered and served to me and the next three unraveling, dissecting and uncovering another one."

me too...and I think it very important that everyone look to see if there might be a few truths in need of dissecting.
Great writing.
This was so beautifully crafted. You express yourself SO well.
Wow. Such clear & beautiful writing. I've sometimes wondered what it must have been like to grow up in a survivor's home, and now I feel like I had my first real peek.
Beautiful writing, as usual.
As is often the case with your excellent work, I find myself wanting to take a moment of silence to appreciate this over and over again, the nuance and substance of it.
All the applicable adjectives have been taken, Cartouche. I am still peeling off layers of costumes I have worn throughout my life. The naked me is nothing like those roles I was required to play.
Your writing talent is incredible.
Lezlie
I am hearing you breathe in this.
You wrote: "In fact, the entire house was haunted by disinfectant, cleanliness and ghosts of horrible memories that could not be washed or chased away."

Odd in a way, but it is well-established that obsessive-compulsive disorder (often exhibited as an irrational cleanliness) is often the result of molestation as a child. But then again, I suppose it isn't really odd, because both causes are beyond human capacity to fully overcome.
Absolutely superb and profound writing. Thank you.
"Even when someone else makes your bed and you lie in it, fresh, clean sheets can’t cover up the truth."

i can't ignore the myriad of ways the above could be interpreted. upon my completion several of them still sound with measured strokes in my head.

you never disappoint.
Insightful and haunting. Painful memories and fraught with hazards, more like glass than eggshells. Reading this I smelled bleach and felt such sorrow. I'd say, "well done" but that seems silly.
you've written about this before, but never with more eloquence
The choreography in the home of Holocaust survivors is determined by the lead dancer. Your creative and clever ability to use such subtle metaphors in your narratives never ceases to astound me. I also love how you can take on such difficult subjects without any pretention. You just lay all the facts and figures out there- stark naked. Your honest prose is so refreshing. I'm so glad I joined OS and found you.

Oh also... random aside, sort of. I did not know that you were Jewish, but it reminds me of ANOTHER thing we have in common. While I am not Jewish, people always think I am. It may have something to do with my being in Fiddler on the Roof when I was a junior in high school. There were a total of two Jewish kids in that whole show; in fact TEVYE was actually played by a Catholic! (I. Know.) Anyway, most of the cast didn't really take the show seriously and just kind of went through the motions. I really embraced my role and found the culture and story so fascinating that I think a part of me sort of became Jewish. I don't know if that makes any sense... but that's kind of how I feel.

...Aw crap. I highjacked your journal in a comment. I'm sorry! But I did rate you! And I did read and comment in regards to your actual post... so I don't think I'm too much of a jerk. =P

E.
Your metaphor is apt. As the generations change, so too the garments. It is a difficult process -- which to leave on the hanger, which to wear, which to recycle. Very evocative writing.
My closet has some really appalling yet disparate fashion choices such as a purple leather mini-dress and a white eyelet prairie dress. I need to purge that closet.
Loved it. Boy, it would be great if you added some narrative illustrating how this played out in your home.
I so much hope your recollections of your childhood and the aftermath with your father make it into published form one day. you have a deeply moving and unique story to tell. each chapter is riveting...
Incredibly crafted piece!
Unfortunately many who have their own hidden closets, have also locked themselves inside them. Opening yours for a peek from time to time has given you the strength to move forward and open your life to many. Thank you for your honesty and poignant look at reality facing all. My best to you as always my friend....older/exasperated *r
Ah, a clothing and fabric metaphor again. You weave (ooh, no pun intended) such wonderful memories, so different from my own, and so vivid. Love it.
This makes me remember things I've tried to forget, feel emotions I've pushed away, and hurt even more for you. Brilliant metaphor for the outline of your life.

Hells Bells, the narrative of Patricia's life is available in many, many of her posts. Prepare to be blown away. And to cry. And to applaud.
Fine piece of writing.
R
What a brilliant post! I am realizing, partly thanks to Bonnie Russell, that the solution to being a believer but hating organized religion, is to ordain myself a priest and start an unorganized religion. All the priestly toys can be ordered from priest catalogs. My first husband and I have laughed ourselves sick reading those catalogs.

There could be women Catholic priests if women were sufficiently disobedient. Mass and all the sacraments can easily be performed in homes. Why could the hierarchy do without making utter idiots of themselves? Arrest them? Excommunicate them?
What a post, cartouche. Great writing.
The children of parents who have endured traumatic, historic events are frequently swept up by feelings, ideas and beliefs they do not have the capacity to understand or digest. It can take a lifetime to make sense of, to incorporate into our being, some of the things we inherit.
Others have spoken so eloquently. For now I will just say thank-you.
Poignant and powerful. I loved what Algis said... survival DNA ...
This reminds me of that R.E.M. song or CD, I forget, that has the phrase "life's rich tapestry." Some memories deserve to put into mothballs.
Simply beautiful.

Rated,
Stephanie
I love the metaphor here. It helps me to comprehend the incomprehensible.
This feels very negative, yet searching, like a mouse trying to get out of a trap. Memories of our own and of others sometimes overtake ourselves and then our lives. I liked how you put this cloak into a closet. Sometimes, though things continuously touch our lives, we need to put them aside to live it. This was very well written and I can almost feel the pain. Rated.
"The choreography in the home of Holocaust survivors is determined by the lead dancer. Everybody else just follows. No costume changes are allowed." That is a great description, whether the dancer chooses the solitary dance your dad chose, or decides to be a social creature, always surrounded by people, like my high school pal's grandpa, who always wanted us to hang out over there, the more of us, the louder the laughter, the better.
Flawless writing. Such a pleasure to read, even when the subject matter tugs at all the feeling places, or especially then.
Enough resides in the closet of my past to make a psychotherapist rich.
Just beautiful. I would have thought there was nowhere new to take the topic, but I would have been wrong.
So sorry I couldn't get here until just now.
Your experience is extremely far removed from mine. It doesn't take away any of the heartache, all these miles and years between us. And you are able to describe this pain in a sublimely beautiful way.
It's almost startling how clear your vision is, both within and without, then you speak it in a way I can see it too. I don't know how to put it any better. Thank you.
When John B. doesn't make a joke you know you've written out of the ballpark.

P, I'm going to PM you about this subject awfully close to my heart/mind/soul.
Your piece feels like the beginning of a spiritually enriching discussion. How I wish we were neighbors so that I could invite you over to have that discussion.
i'm so last-in-line that i can't say anything original. just know that i get this, the wearing of costumes, some we have chosen and some gifted. beautiful, succinct writing, cartouche. 500, right?
Your writing reminds me what a treasure trove OS really is. Thank you for this piece of fine writing.
Ever read Elizabeth Rosner's Speed of Light? It's a great novel about the children of a Holocaust survivor. The author is also the daughter of Holocaust survivors. Powerful post. Thank you. r
Cartouche, your writing here is much like the homes of you and your friend. It is concise. It is clear and clean. Skillfully swept and kept to the point. It is not until we enter the closet, are we given prompts for the emotional heartache you've endured through these years. I'm wondering if this was a beautifully, deliberately construed writing element, consciously applied by you, the daughter of the Holocaust survivor?
R
Interesting to see this facet of life through your eyes.
The term, "organized religion," is vastly broad. Oddly, I wouldn't have connected the Holocaust to organized religion, simply due to the association I have with that term.
Now that you have purged your closet, you can go to church, synagogue, temple, or what have you on your own terms, and use if for other needs: fellowship, meditation, spiritual exploration, ritual, conviviality, etc.
What you describe--and I feel like you still are not in it, just looking down at it--is what survivors of growing up in a family that includes a member with mental illness or addiction also describe. The problem and the pain it causes is screaming, SCREAMING to be recognized, but is met with silence and denial. We spend an equally inordinate amount of time and energy, for the rest of our lives, giving it a voice.
Well rendered metaphors in this piece Patricia. I never thought of that part of your very identity being so difficult to contain in your day-to-day life. Walking on eggshells and walking on hidden land mines are similar dilemmas. The only difference is that one is lethal...
your essay to some degree suggests that OCD [in this case, wrt housecleaning] is a kind of mental mechanism tightly tied up with PTSD.....
"Whether you like it or not, it’s assigned to you and every day you wake up, take attendance, become that person and dress your part" is only one extraordinary fragment in an astonishing piece. Kudos.
Beautifully woven.
I've always thought of the past more as baggage--burdens you carry--rather than wardrobe. Either way, the important thing, sometimes, is to pack it away.

Or is that simply pure Americanism: the belief that we can pack it away, the stubborn insistence that we can remake ourselves? Sometimes I think I'm fooling myself in thinking that I'm different than that child I was. Sometimes I marvel at the distance between the two mes.

Very thought-provoking, cartouche. If anyone can both re-tailor and then decide, cleanly, to leave it hanging in the closet, you can. (And if I may: I'm soooo glad you're writing again. Always a delight; always thoughtful.)
A turn through the heart and mind of someone who inhabits herself.

My wife is the daughter of two survivors and all of this -- especially the cleanliness, Deb's mother is like that -- rings true.

There are times I lie with Deb as she snores a bit, or watch her cook, or even when we argue, when I am overwhelmed with ache for what I know about her. How she moves and thinks and feels, having grown up with her mother and father and all their oddity and frailty and steel.

It lasts generations. My daughters take no shit from anyone about being Jewish. I mean, they kick ass. And yet express, at odd times, a certain radical fearfulness about the future for Jews, even in the land of the free, that crushes me a bit.

I am davening here, involuntarily. Exceptional post, Patricia.
This story whispered itself in my ear.
Until this line: "I decided to undress myself completely so my skin could finally breathe."
And then, the story sang.
strong,powerful emotions here.
rated
So expansive and powerful. So many costumes are forced upon us. It's only with growing consciousness that we can look at them more closely and see whether they still, if ever, fit well.

Your really digging deep with your material and emerging and changing before us, which is especially rewarding to watch. I think that's one of the benefits of our community here, is to watch our core members evolve and change via their writing. It's really quite miraculous, really. And I truly mean miraculous.