Cartouche's Blog

Writing My Way Out of Something

cartouche

cartouche
Location
Someplace, somewhere else, USA
Birthday
February 09
Title
nonconfromist (on Twitter)
Company
Mind My Own Business
Bio
Artist, former newspaper columnist and restaurant critic. Author of "In Pursuit of Excellence" (the first cookbook of Two Star Michelin Chef Josiah Citrin). In my spare minute I can be found blogging here, on Huffington Post and other places that don't pay. And writing for some that do. You are NOT in Kansas anymore, Toto. Neither am I.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
JANUARY 31, 2011 6:18AM

The Greatest Generation that Never Was

Rate: 66 Flag

Last Friday, I went to grab a late lunch. I specifically picked a restaurant with TV sets, so I could watch the unfolding events in Cairo.  I know this sounds counterintuitive for someone who admits to rarely watching TV, but since last week, my inner Rottweiler has grabbed onto the bone that is Egypt and is not about to get distracted by anything else. For some “big picture” reason I can’t quite define or explain, I’m riveted by what is happening there, as if it is a crystal ball of sorts, revealing to us all our collective near-future.  My gaze is fixed. 

I can’t let that bone go. 

What amazed me at first in the fairly crowded restaurant (an upscale sports bar) was that most people seemed to be detached from, if not completely disinterested in (or completely unaware of) the significance of this historic event.  It may as well have not been taking place at all.  The lingering, pervasive sense of isolated entitlement and detached idea that Americans are somehow different or better than the rest of the world continues to make me bristle.  It confounds me. 

It occurred to me that if Jay Leno were to walk in and do one of his “Jaywalking” segments, the sheer ignorance (or stupidity) of people would be proven once again when it comes to matters of current events, especially when they occur outside our country.  I find nothing about this remotely funny or laughable at all.  It makes me cry.

I asked to be seated in a (relatively) quiet booth with a TV that was tuned into the news with the volume on.  I watched and listened to it as I opened my laptop, surfed the net and followed updates on Twitter. Within moments, the White House press briefing began.  For what seemed like too long, I listened to Robert Gibbs offer absolutely no information that wasn’t already old news.  He awkwardly failed to commit himself or President Obama to any concrete positions or statements that could come back to haunt him (or the administration) and bite them on the proverbial ass as I am about to do now. 

In short, like the premise of “Seinfeld”, Friday’s press briefing was about nothing.

At once, the Egyptian uprising has turned me into perhaps a never-to-be-reformed armchair analyst, observer/writer of the human condition and rabid truth-hound, using social media tools to hunt for facts or an angle to the story that may have yet to be considered.  

What I didn’t expect was for my connect-the-dots moment to appear as the news reverted back to (filtered CNN) reporting.  It arrived in the form of a young man.

Within a minute of seeing him sit down in the booth next to me, I was curious to know what made this kid do what nobody else in the restaurant (other than myself) was doing.  With great intensity, he was witnessing the world shift before his eyes as I once did in 1989 when I watched the Berlin Wall fall. 

His profile was handsome.  He had skin that reminded me of deep, rich coffee that had been lightened by cream.  I knew immediately that he was not Caucasian and for a moment, I considered he might possibly be of Middle Eastern heritage.  This piqued my curiosity even more. 

This dog had found a new bone.

I told the young man that I was fascinated by his interest and asked him what prompted him to sit down and watch the news when he could be watching any number of sports events on the flat screen TVs.  His answer took me by complete surprise.

“I’m thinking about enlisting in the military and I wanted to see what I might be in for,” he said.

Gulp.

army

I have no children of my own, but my immediate instinct was to become a Mother Tiger of a different color and save this boy’s life.

“Why?” I asked.

What he told me nearly broke my heart and put such an intimate immediacy on the face of Egypt, war, this world that we now live in and why we need to all be paying closer attention. 

(Paraphrased):

“I’m 23 years-old and have looked for but been unable to find a steady job for three years.  I’ve worked in construction (which I love) off the books, but nobody is building anything around here anymore.  I have my GED but can’t afford college and don’t qualify for financial aid.  I’m good with computers and would love to go to a technical school but I don’t have the money and can’t get work because I don’t have a college education,” he said. My heart sank deeper. 

He went on to explain that he felt as if his life was worthless and that there was no hope for a job or the future and that he may as well join the military so he can “do something”, get paid and eventually be able to go to college.

I asked him when he planned on enlisting and he said within the next three weeks. 

I listened to all this as revolt played out on the screen in front of us, half a world away.

My head was spinning and, as I sometimes do, I felt compelled to offer some perspective and advice as if I had birthed this boy myself.

The first thing I told him was obvious.  He’s young and therefore thinks he’s invincible and immortal and that nothing bad will ever happen to him.   I informed him that the military loves nothing more than to round up young kids with that kind of attitude and use them as pawns to do their dirty work so a few people behind the scenes can benefit and make sickening stockpiles of money that we he will never see.  I also warned him that regardless of the promises the military might make about his (or anyone else’s) future, the future is guaranteed to no one. 

I got his interest.

Then I went on to tell him that our country has a very poor record of taking care of our veterans.  I asked him to imagine himself returning from combat with a missing limb and PTSD, hearing anguished screams or bombs in his head for the rest of his life and trying to learn to walk with a prosthetic leg.  I told him in no uncertain terms that I did not wish this on him or anyone else, but the ugly truth about war is that but for the lucky few who come out of it without seeing combat, it’s not as pretty a picture as they paint in the recruiting stations and shiny brochures.

I made him promise me he would go to a VA hospital and visit with soldiers.  I implored him to ask some of the people who are all but forgotten and being barely treated by our “system” if they had to do it over, whether they would make the same decision to enlist again.

And then I begged this young boy to give me 30 days to find him a job so he wouldn’t have to make a choice of enlisting because the reality of life in America today has put this fully loaded gun against his head. 

I’m sending out e-mails and this story to friends (including the CEO of the restaurant where we met) and doing everything possible to help change the direction of (and potentially save) this young man’s life.  (His girlfriend works at the restaurant, which is why he was there; he had come to pick her up from her shift.  Believe me, I asked if he was so poor, what he was doing there.)  Somebody needs to give this young man a job.

Joe DiMartino has no criminal record (when I asked him, he replied with authority, “Absolutely not.”).  He has a clean driving record.  He’s obviously strong, willing and like many others, frustrated and able.  But a 50 year-old jobless man faces different obligations and frustrations than a 23 year-old.  The older (wiser) person may have a better grasp of implications for choices that are made; a younger version often sees no other way out and makes rash decisions.  The military kind of likes it that way.

26 year-old Mohammed Bouazizi may one day be the poster child of the revolution that is now taking place in Egypt.  For the uninformed, he was the man who, after having his fruit cart taken away by the Tunisian government, set himself on fire in protest.  He died three weeks later, without knowing that ten days after his death, President Zine El Abedine Ben Ali finally fled the police state he had controlled for 23 years. 

mohhamed 

Mohammed started the fire of change people could believe in and the flames have spread quickly throughout the Middle East.   Egypt’s rage rages on.

Here in America, we don’t seem to have the courage to do what the people of Tunisia and Egypt have done.  We don’t pay close enough attention to the internal strife of our own citizens.  And then we allow young kids like Joe DiMartino in a fit of frustration, with seemingly no other option, to enlist in the military and risk dying on foreign soil because the insecurity of our homeland is quietly killing us.  And nobody is listening.

Our world is on high alert and Egypt is the reminder of the week.

I can’t help but wonder what color Homeland Security chief Janet Napolitano’s face is right now after announcing just a few days ago that the ridiculous color-code threat level alert will be retired.  We should all be seeing red, but not from embarrassment as much as anger.  We are living in dangerous times.

Every young man and woman who is forced to die at the hand of an oppressive regime or because of war is one of our own children.

mohammed2 

The world is watching us as we contribute to this insanity by feeding the war machine, while we go to sports bars to watch football or sit at home and flip channels, entertaining ourselves with "Reality TV" and choosing to ignore the truth.

We are a show about nothing.

Let’s start thinking about saving lives of kids like Joe DiMartino before the channel gets changed on us and he becomes one more member of the greatest generation that never was. 

I’ve got 27 days to make good on my promise.

Images:  usarmy, africaresource.com, anorak.co.uk

* * * * * * * * *  

Latest updates from Cairo:

10:00 am EST:  The death toll has now reached 138, according to Reuters.

7:30 am EST:  A number of Al Jazeera reporters have been arrested by the military. (They have been subsequently released, but without their cameras.)  Danish (oil) shipping company MAERSK is suspending activities in Egypt.

6:00 am EST:  A “Mega Protest” has been called for Tuesday, asking 1 million people to join in the demonstration demanding that President Hosni Mubarak step down.  Film legend Omar Sharif has joined in the call.  Police, who have been absent since Friday, have slowly begun to return to duty.  Crowds continued to gather in Tahrir Square overnight on Sunday, despite a 3 pm – 8 am curfew.  In the last six days, millions of dollars have been transferred to other countries by investors and markets have been suspended.  Basic food supplies are dwindling as people stock up, with no signs of replenishment.  

Sources:  Al Jazeera English, Reuters

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I like and admire you for so many reasons. This is an example of one of them:
"My head was spinning and, as I sometimes do, I felt compelled to offer some perspective and advice as if I had birthed this boy myself."
I believe your heart is always in the right place. ~r
I think...I hope you know how this makes me feel. Thank you, Cartouche for taking the time to listen and seeking to lend a helping hand. What would happen if each of us reached out to just one lost soul?
I have heard similar stories here in the streets from the young.
I hope you find this young man a job. One young man is too much to waste. You got a good heart Cartouche'.
Your outrage only amplifies the unfailing excellence of your writing, cartouche. You are a force to be reckoned with, and I am right there with you. I, too, feel as if I'm watching a crystal ball on CNN. Good luck on your quest for a job for Joe.

Lezlie
I hope your "inner Rottweiler" is never domesticated.
You are a piece of work, Patricia. I've been following the Egyptian revolution right here, on OS. My wife has the TV on with no sound so she can keep an eye on the screen as she works around the house. But I hadn't been slapped to the full implications of Egypt until just now. You've put it all together for me. Not that anything you said is new, but you've put it in the right order. Thanks. And good luck finding Joe a Job. I have a hunch you will.
This was deeply insightful on so many levels.
Thank you for making such valid points and good luck on finding Joe a job.
You have a good heart and brilliant mind.
“I’m 23 years-old and have looked for but been unable to find a steady job for three years. I’ve worked in construction (which I love) off the books, but nobody is building anything around here anymore. I have my GED but can’t afford college and don’t qualify for financial aid. I’m good with computers and would love to go to a technical school but I don’t have the money and can’t get work because I don’t have a college education.”

That describes how the military is stocked in third world countries. I don't care if America dies anymore. She's already dead.
As I may have mentioned before, you should have a talk show. I see a kind of Ed Schulz fervor when you take up a cause.
Thank you so much for writing this, and more so for trying to help this young man. I wish I had something to suggest, and I will ask around to people I know who might be able to help. Bravo for starting your own revolution!
I know what you mean about the obliviousness of so many to the Egypt uprising. Even here at OS, aside from yours, old new lefty and Stellaa had worthy posts while everything else was business as usual.

Good luck with your job search. That's an extraordinarily thoughtful initiative.
You are a force of nature, cartouche, and I mean that in the best possible way. Best wishes on the job hunt . . . and may Egypt achieve equitable peace.
You put a face on the young men who see military service as their only way to survive. I really hope someone will hire him soon...You are doing him a tremendous solid with your efforts on his behalf.
The world needs more people like you.
I finished reading this, my heart in thumping, you are one wonderful person....the gest in this dull winter of discontent.
Here's hoping this young man gets a job and is saved from the cannon fodder machinery.

I think the U.S. has this isolationism because it's, well, isolated. European countries rub shoulders with each other, and ditto the Arab world. For neighbors, the U.S. has Mexico (a bunch of despised poor people) and Canada (boring, boring and ignorable), so has a strange ignorant view of itself...and a nutty notion of going off and intruding into the affairs of countries far away of which they know nothing.

And now the U.S. is eating its young...and the eaten are meek and cooperative...

I've been watching Al Jazeera live-streaming on my computer for the last few days, and it's gonna be a permanent tab. It's really a window on the world. When its not focussed on Egypt, it has items about other places in the world never heard about on U.S. media...and the weather forecasts are a gas - Africa, South America, India. The blizzards of the U.S. are off the radar...

Anyway, good on you. Keep us informed about this young man... You may well have saved a life.
You are doing what one person can do, help another person. As a woman of capable force, there's no doubt that you will help this man in some way.

My sense is that a national sense of impotence settled on us during the Bush years. We came out of it briefly during early Obama, full of hope, but quickly settled back into the view that nothing we do matters. One of the electrifying aspects of the Egyptian uprising is that it puts the lie to that. Here are angry people demanding what is humane and right, standing together as a forceful entity. It's a fantasy of the Bush years fulfilled.
An extremely important post. It should wake up more than a few people. I will be sending good intentions that you find that young man a job. -R-
What Lea said and what Owl said. You ARE the force of change...and I hope your effort for this one young person can be spread to thousands more. Maybe if each of tried on behalf of one person - used our age, our experiences and our connections - we could all promote change.
(One thing - you should really question him about financial aid. Many people don't think they qualify, but they do. And college can be paid for through grants - especially community college. I'm a bit of an expert on college and financial aid, due to returning as an oldster.)
You made me cry. Yes, we are a show about nothing. If only the middle class here would begin to demonstrate...
Wonderful post, Cartouche. I used to suggest similar things to my sixth graders (during the Iraq War), or rather let them discuss such things and reach similar conclusions. I fear we have become a nation of morons, and even trying, we can only get the news on alternate websites (this one, OpEdNews, CommonDreams, RawStory, Alternet, Yes!, etc.)

I fear I have been a bit harsh in my own criticism of young folks stuck in the position of the fellow you talked too (I do understand their harsh circumstances, but I also understand this http://www.warresisters.org/pages/piechart.htm all too well).

You can see for yourself how favorably my ideas are received,
http://open.salon.com/blog/daniel_geery/2010/11/11/christian_viewpoint_thou_shalt_not_kill, even though this is the advice I would have given my father before he got a Purple Heart in WWII, had I been his father.

If I were in a position to hire your young friend, I surely would. Stay on it, keep networking, keep all doors of possibility open. And do let us know the results.
This is an excellent post. I feel the same way you do about the lack of engagement and the isolation from world events or the suffering and struggles of others pervasive in our country. I only wish I knew of somewhere - or knew someone who could give this young man a job. It may sound "flattering" but I'm quite sincere - the world needs more people like you.
r
I have what might be called an insider's take on our military and I agree with you....of course the military depends upon the enrollment of the less fortunate and the disinfranchised to fill its ranks. That is nothing new and has been a fact of life ever since Armies have been formed.
I agree with you that it would be a shame if this young man....or any young man or woman joined the military only to become just another piece of "damaged goods" because of their service.

My question is....What do we do? Do we disband our armies and navies because they are only the tool of an oppressor. as so many believe? Where would we be without them?
Maybe we sould make it so that everyone has to serve and not just the poor and those who have no other options. Maybe if the rich man's sons and daughters have to serve, those same rich men might think twice about getting us into some of the conflicts we have.
Hell, to be truthful, I believe that the armies should be staffed by old men over fifty. Many of us already have the military knowledge and God knows, we would be missed a lot less than our youger generation. Yeah, waste all us old guys, god knows many of us were wasted in our youth so why not just let us go out the same way.
Seriously, as much as we hate how our military is used and I am one of those, we need a military. This is a very thoughtful and interesting entry and I really believe it deserves to be on the front page.
This boy could be a whole lot of my students attending college on the G.I. Bill. It's not that they don't get what could happen to them--believe me, they do. They've all seen friends and family and neighbors fight with the V.A. It's that the alternative isn't any better.

(I do love my G.I. Bill students. They actually STUDY, and turn work in on time, and come to office hours, and are in general dedicated students. The Army'll do that to you.)
Cart, great piece! You focus right on the heart of the issue. When I was young, the Draft was pretty straight forward ... you had a number and if it came up, you were gone - either the military or Canada. Today, in this era of the so called voluntary military, young men and women are "drafted" by seduction. {{{R}}}
Talk about putting your money where your mouth is cartouche. I have no doubt the universe will answer you with a job for this kid; good attracts good. I won't weigh in on what's going on in Egypt but I agree with Torman - we do need a military even though it has its flaws, admittedly big ones. I like his theory about creating a military of older guys instead of youth. They'd probably be mad enough about things they'd seen with age to be even more badass than the younger guys. I might even consider joining. So gratifying to know there's people like you out there. Please let us know what you inner Rottweiler comes up with for that guy.
You, unlike most people I meet, understand that while one cannot change the world, one can make it better by whomever one touches. We all have this potential and if most of us exercised it the revolution would be worldwide and truly beautiful.

American exceptionalism: We are only exceptional, anymore, in our arrogance and apathy, our self-absorption and magical thinking. I am grateful whenever I find someone who actually lives fully in the present moment and is unafraid of touching what part of the world comes near. r.
Amazing post. Only you would do something like this. Truly admirable. It's nice to imagine that, if enough people like you, followed suit and were successful, military ranks would be sorely depleted. One problem with that -- knowing out nation's insatiable love of war, they'd probably reinstitute the draft.
Cartouche, you are an example of why we need to stop with the mindless yapping about Americans as ignorant and narcissistic when it comes to the rest of the world. You are a shining example of our capacity for and intent to do good works for others.

Every day, I read something here and elsewhere that shows just how well traveled and interested Americans are, that is when they have the resources or opportunity to travel.

I wish that you were on CNN right now.

zumapick
Too much to say and no words can do the job for me. You are on the money with your analysis. I truly believe that the only reason we do not draft our young people is so we can keep the minimum wage down to a level where poor people are forced to "volunteer" for military service and removing the pernicious figuring to keep wealthy children out of harms way.
That about which you have so eloquently written here is so much more important that the ty[ical drivel which we see all around us, OS included.
Your allusion to a "Greatest Generation" and the decsription of the young man with whom you spoke is of a 18O0 difference from the reasons for our Greatest Generation and why they join today.
The motivations and pride of the Greatest Generation are gone from most of those who inhabit our country today.
Not only is the Greatest Generation dying off, so are those of us who are old enough to truly give a damn about our America.
I was born in 1939 and knew them.
"We are a show about nothing."

precisely.
a great piece of writing--I admire your passion.
You're a wonderful person, Cartouche...xox
So glad you not only came out on this, but stepped up to do something about it. Lately, my ears burn when I hear someone in the media offering kudos to 'all those brave men and women in the military protecting our country', or 'fighting for our freedom' when it's been many years since the US military was deployed to protect our country.

To continue to pretend the military is a choice made out of 'American pride' or because it's an 'honor to serve', when in many, many cases it's a desperate solution to other problems, is a travesty. The suggestion about a VA visit was inspired. We have homeless vets living on the streets, in their cars, and in shelters b/c they can't find work. Tom Brokaw and 60 Minutes have done pieces on this recently. Michelle Obama spoke just this week (on Oprah) about the problems of military families, that they are barely holding it together with little to no support from the military or the community. She and Jill Biden are starting an awareness campaign to address some of these issues. Biden was responsible for getting behind Delaware's Boots On the Ground program. The website listed for info is www.serve.gov, so I guess we'll see where this goes with such a high profile group speaking out. You, on the other hand, are a walking, talking example of what can be done by every one of us, if we just pay attention. Excellent.
I don't think that meeting are random and occur by chance.

Via con Dios, Cartouche.
You deserve the praise coming your way today.
At 23, my life was also going nowhere fast. I damn near signed up with the Navy. The recruiter gave me a few brochures. One of the brochures highlighted the power of the missiles on board a vessel. I didn't want to shoot missiles at anyone. That was the end of my naval career.

Worldwide, the military is a common means of escaping poverty or times of little employment.
cartouche, what about those of us who do watch, who do care, who do reach out in our communities? What do we do about Egypt? What do we do here? About the homeless guy I just bought two sandwiches for? About the homeless boys I've let sleep at my house (my oldest son finds them, makes sure they're not trouble, then he brings them here, to our house.) ? Tried to find jobs for? Tried to talk sanity to, but they've already given up?
I struggle with despair, yet know I can only do so much...one at a time, one at a time.
What else can I do? I know there is more....
Thanks for speaking up.
This is a compelling story. You nailed it. That young man will never forget you.
This is a wonderful essay that brings a bit of light to darkness. One candle at a time, nurtured in its burning, can start a fire of hope. I have no doubt of your sincerity, and your commitment to this task. My wish is that you are successful and he is fulfilled with new opportunity. My hope is that everyone who reads this is open to the same opportunity to help someone else. As for our in attention to the world and continually numbing by the almighty corporate interests in this country, our future does not look so bright. We have been quiet, and pacified for too long. There is something coming, not just in Egypt, but in many places and possibly and most dangerously here. Yes, here.
My nephew Brian will be entering the US Army when he finishes college. We really don't like thinking about it, but it's one of those things that creeps into your mind at 3am. Too many what-ifs.
What a passionate response. Your love shines through.
I hope that you can keep this one from going and that he can keep another and another and another.
rated with love
Superior post -- I am awed by your passion, your writing and your sense of duty to other human beings. That last is a hard quality to find in this country anymore. But I think real action is between individuals not large groups... groups are daunting and the fact is as you so quietly pointed out, "nobody is listening." They are not listening to the information, to the cries of those in need and the winds of the future.

Your bravery is inspiring: to be so motivated by the event and the young man you met is amazing. As a writer you are doing exactly what writers can do -- to reach others who need to be inspired to take similar actions.

Thanks for being a lone, clear and meaningful voice.
thank you for this, my friend
Brilliantly and eloquently written. Good luck with helping that young men, and bless you.
You are an amazing person, Patricia. You bring tears to my eyes the way you so clearly see how all of us here on earth are connected. The Egyptians, the people of Arab nations are not the "other", "those crazy fundamentalists from those 'crazy countries'", as my mother likes to call Arab countries. They are our brothers and sisters who have suffered from decades of oppression under dictatorial "presidents-for-life" backed by the corrupt leaders of Western nations. We should care about our brothers and sisters in the Middle East because we are all connected; we are one. What happens to them happens to us, and vice versa.

Good for you for thinking globally and acting locally!!! ~RRRRR+. I wish you the best in finding that young man a job. What a beautiful heart you have.
Thank you Cartouche, for actually taking action and for writing this post.
Chee-SUS, Cartouche, you are, like, the Anti-recruiter of Doom! How is anyone supposed to make their quota with you around?

So, I am listening to NPR this morning and they are interviewing a young Egyptian man who is essentially saying the same thing this young man said to you: he is going into the military because he has no prospects anywhere else. And, if I may venture, that is one of the reasons Egypt and Tunisia boiled over: jobs--if we could somehow say it with the capital "J" that somehow includes human dignity.

We are so lost today as a world culture in not understanding that work is the most civilizing experience on the planet. Granted all of us have wanted (and did) take that job and shove it, and I want to argue for a big tent when it comes to meaningful work, but we literally have hundreds of millions of young men and women on the planet for which society essentially has no use.

That we in the U.S. are now beginning to share that trait with what used to be called the Third World is maybe a chink in our hubristic and entitled armor, but underlying it all, amongst those who are not on the gravy train, what I perceive is heartbreak.

As you did.

What shines through in this piece is the quality that always shines through in your work--your deep empathy for whatever surrounds you. I don't know if you make good on your pledge, but perhaps you should consider that your little intervention may already have been a step in transforming a life.

All I can say is wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. You rock it for us all.
What a heartfelt plea -- for all of us to pay attention, and to reach out. Our young people, even those with a bit of safety net, are falling through in large numbers. I see them in the faces of my twenty-four-year-old son's friends. With no hope of a career-type job (no health insurance, no pension, no benefits...their bodies are machines that will cease to matter once the parts cease to work), they shuffle and suffer and fret and become desperate. I've seen it happen.

I hope Joe finds an alternative path. If he does, he'll owe at least part of it to you. I've had many "other mothers" in my life, women who never gave birth but committed themselves to nurturing the people around them and I benefited from their love. I only wish everyone would experience that -- the knowledge that someone cares.
The realities of life and death in today's world distilled to their very essence with eloquence and passion. You never cease to amaze me. We need so many more of you, like you, in our sad, messy world.
Cartouche, your passion inspires! I too am hyper focused on the events unfolding in Egypt. I'm an Air Force vet myself from the first Gulf War era (no hardships, I had a cushy hospital job in Texas). After only one four-year tour, I made my exit as I knew a military life was not for me. Today, I make it a point to tell any potential recruits who cross my path not to enlist. We need to start shrinking our military and growing the collective size of our brains. I know it sounds polyannish, but I believe if we do it right, we can educate ourselve out of the need for a war machine.

Here's hoping you can find work for Joe. That's what I call hands-on taking care of business!
I like this post on a number of levels, not the least of which is your interest in a news story that I think has huge implications for the world's future. Good luck finding the kid a job... be aware that if you do, there'll be another kid, and another, and another... (not to mention the 50 yr.old men. (Something is really slowing this site down. Is it the moving ad above the comment box?)
"We are a show about nothing." And we also have...Skins, to prove it. Not a real representation of the youth of our nation but...closer than I like to admit, as a former educator who saw kids actually do those things...and brag about it...all the time...

I also had lots of kids like your young man in the restaurant, who joined up aimlessly, desperately...and in some cases, died for it.

I would talk to my high school boys much as you did to that one. They would hear me on one level...but not on the basic, "I need a job to help me survive" one. And my heart would sink...

You've done something wonderful and important here. Thank you...
I so hope you can find this young man a job. It is so difficult to fully comprehend what joining the military truly entails until there's no turning back. Good luck. R for caring and writing with such compassion and purpose.
a touching take on our hard times!
Interesting post. I, in fact, did serve in the military. I deployed to Afghanistan and Iraq. Joining the military was the greatest decision I have ever made. You seem to subscribe to the liberal rule of 3 when it comes to stereotyping our military. Here are the three military archetypes that most liberals choose from:

a) Country bumpkin simpleton 'duped' into military service by a money grubbing higher power of some sort (most likely white and/or male)
b) Sociopathic pyscho seeking a societal approved institution through which to channel his homicidal tendencies
c) "Down and out'r" with nowhere to turn but Uncle Sam for a way out of destitution

I actually was raised upper-middle class by educated parents and as far as I know have no homicidal tendencies. I joined the military because the gates need to be guarded, and I felt obligated to lend a hand.

I have a simple question for you, if your argument was taken to its logical conclusion, there would be NO military. What then?
You are very presumptive. You speak of caring about this young man as "if I birthed him." Who are you to know what emotions mothers of sons experience, upon being told their son wants to enlist, when you never had a child of your own?

I know a number of men who look back upon their decision to join the military as one of the best decisions of their lives. Some of these men lost friends to war, but still they believe in the greatness of their chosen career. How do you know this young man wouldnt have felt the same?

If you want to be supportive why not find one of countless support groups for military families, and help out in some meaningful way? If you did, you would encounter real mothers, with strong minds and hearts, who are proud of their sons' courage and service. And, yes, you would read about the sons who died or are grievously injured, but you wont find much bitterness there. You will find honorable people who realize that our country needs a military and somebody has to be the person who steps forward to do the job.
What a wonderful writer you are -- and what an even more wonderful person you are. I wish I could help you in your quest for a job for this young man, but unfortunately, your story hit too close to home, for I have a 22 yr-old faced with the same dilemma -- a bright, sensitive, caring young man facing a future in this country that may be more like the future faced by young men in the Mideast than his father wants to admit.