Catherine Forsythe

Catherine Forsythe
Bio
know a bit about computer security, dogs, horses, skiing, medicine and making risotto. My nickname in real life/online is "Noggie" - I'm on Twitter, with the @dogreader account.

Editor’s Pick
SEPTEMBER 1, 2010 6:00AM

Over Many Years, Only Four Words Ever Spoken

Rate: 49 Flag
 
It was a regular routine for me. It was school and then a bus to work at a bar - a sports bar. I would work as many shifts as I could. The only major drawback was that the hours were very long. The job, after reconciling the sales and cleaning up, would be finished in the early hours of the morning. The good thing was that the bar paid for taxi rides home, for those who did not have cars. After a long night, most people didn't want to drive. It is physically taxing work, with long distances walked on every shift.

I mentioned this because the job took me to a part of the city that was far more commercial and busy than the usual academic setting. In that part of the city, there are the invisible people. These are the homeless people who live on the streets. Some pan-handle. Some just exist. They are there but most people really don't notice them. These street people become part of the background noise. 

Often, I would try to beat the traffic rush and catch a bus to that part of town early. I would sit outside on the street benches, have some food from my backpack and perhaps study a bit. Sometimes, on those benches, one of the street people would be sitting and intently reading a newspaper. Every page would be read. To this day, I do not know his name.

It is difficult to tell how old he was when I first noticed him. He could have been in his fifties, perhaps sixties. No matter what the season, he would have his long grey coat with him. And there was an ever present canvas knapsack. I never saw him open that knapsack. It was just always with him. The most distinguishing feature was a baseball cap with a large "H" that always covered his long grayish hair. I later learned that the "H" was an early logo for the Houston Astros. Perhaps, at one time, he liked baseball. Maybe it was the only cap that he came across.

Sometimes when I would sit down on the street bench and he would be there, I would say "hi". He would acknowledge me with a small wave. At times, he would share part of my sandwich or some fruit. Just as often, he would shake his head and refuse. He would keep reading the newspaper. 

When he wasn't reading the newspaper, he would be walking those streets and picking up trash that other people had discarded. He walked in a stooped fashion, with his eyes searching for the litter on the streets. All the detritus from people using that area would be cleaned. He would pick it up, put it in a bag and then dump it into a trash bin. That's what he did - his self imposed task.

There were times when I would be walking from the bus and he would appear. There would be a small wave of the hand to acknowledge me and sometimes we would walk together for a block or two. I would talk. He would listen. If there was some empty cup or some discarded wrapper that distracted him, he was gone. 

Once, one of my co-workers at the bar saw this man walking with me. At work, she asked me if I was scared of him. It may have been naïve of me but I never had thought about it. In fact, over the years, the man in the baseball cap and I had set up a system where I would leave a newspaper for him. If, during the shift, someone left some reading material, I would take it out to the back of the building and leave it tucked in behind a down-spout drain. When I looked there in a few days, there would be a stone instead of a paper or whatever reading material that I had left. I would remove the stone. Message received. 

If the reading material was still there, I knew that the man with the baseball cap was gone. He would be back in a few months. 

There was one night in August that I will remember. The bar was really busy. People coming into the bar were commenting that there were police and police cars over the whole area. The sound of sirens confirmed that and the noise continued until quite late. It was the familiar after-midnight quiet when the shift ended and I saw that my usual cab was waiting outside. I left the bar to take the cab home and there was the man in the baseball cap, with two other street people whom I recognized.

That night, he stood straight. Tall. Imposing. He held open the door to the taxi. And then he said the only words that he ever spoke to me: "Catherine, go right home". It was a deep baritone. All I said was "ok". It was not one of my most eloquent moments. I was shocked. I had never heard him speak. Never. I didn't think he even knew my name. 

On the drive home, the driver who had known me for years said that there had been gunfire and SWAT team vehicles rolling through the streets. He said that he would not have been in the area, except to pick up his regular contract fares. This trip would be his last for the night. That was not his usual hours. On a normal night, he would be working until the morning rush was done. This had been far from a normal night. 

In a storybook scenario, the man with the Astros cap would begin to talk to me. Real life, however, differs. The next time that I saw him was again on a walk from the bus stop. He saw me and walked with me for a minute or so. He did not speak when I thanked him for his kindness on that previous evening. He said nothing and was distracted by some discarded litter that he saw. In an instant, he was gone and I was walking alone again. Nothing changed. 

Routines are a form of protection. There is the security of the familiar. I never heard him speak again. Occasionally, he would take part of a sandwich or a piece of fruit - always refusing any banana. When he wasn't keeping the sidewalks clean from litter, he was reading every page of what he could find. 

The following summer was hot, with some record setting high temperatures. I had continue to leave a newspaper or magazine behind the down-spout drain and one week I found that what I had left was still there. It was not unusual. He would be gone for months sometimes. I would resume again when I saw him on the streets.

Weeks passed. When it stretched into months and I hadn't seen him in the area, I began being more vigilant and looked for him on my walks from the bus stop. One day, by chance, I was crossing the street at the lights and a police car was stopped at the red light. I recognized both officers in the unit. They were among the regulars who came into the bar to watch whatever games were being played on the broadcasts. I walked to the side of the car and said 'hello'. I knew both officers by name. I asked if they had seen the man with the Astros hat. Of course, both of them knew whom I meant. They said that they had not seen him for some time but they would check and let me know. I went to work and didn't think about it. 

Hours into the shift, the officers came into the bar and told me. The body of the man with the Astros cap had been found months ago. He had been found about ten blocks away. The officers told me that the summers were a bad time of the year for people on the streets. The heat is far more cruel than the cold. Sometimes there is no escape from the heat and dehydration occurs. It was only speculation. They didn't know. They asked if I wanted them to find out more details. They were more than willing to do so. I said it wasn't necessary - and it really wasn't.

I still walk from that bus stop. The bar shifts are not as frequent. Sometimes I think of the man with the Astros cap. I see the litter on the streets and wonder what I could have done differently. Do I have regrets? Absolutely. I have a few.

Catherine Forsythe  
 
SAN FRANCISCO - JULY 31:  A Starbucks cup is seen discarded on a newspaper rack July 31, 2007 in San Francisco, California. With dairy prices reaching record highs, Starbucks announced that it will raise their coffee drink prices an average of nine cents per beverage. Starbucks last raised prices in October 2006 to recoup rising labor and energy costs.  (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
 
[Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images]

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Very compelling story, Catherine. It sounds like speaking up, he migt have saved your life that night. It also sounds lke you're wondering if you could have done the same for him. Maybe you did. Maybe you couldn't have saved him forever from the elements or forces of nature, but maybe you gave him moments of love and grace and thoughtfulness and respect he might not have had otherwise. That's something.
Enjoyed this story, this look into your life, who you are also. Someone who shares with a homeless man, hides newspapers and sees the humanity in each person no matter their station in life. i know that was not your intent, but I appreciated this facet of the post, I think the most.
It's so strange about death. We all pass by people we don't really associate with like at work or a regular at a coffee place. Then, the person dies and we can't stop thinking about that person.
Best Wishes,
Blittie
Never have regrets Catherine.. Walk your own road..
Great piece and rated with hugs
Spellbinding, Catherine. Absolutely breathtaking story. I was half-expecting you'd say, after the SWAT team episode, that he was an undercover cop on the BUM Squad - you know, like "Dogbreath" on Hill Street Blues. I've known a few fellows like The Man in the Baseball Cap. Your tribute is beautiful.
We find angels everywhere but most often in writing such as yours. r.
You gave him the ultimate gift: recognition and respect. R-
This was a wonderful read, Catherine. Compared to your normally short and factual posts, this opened a window to your soul and shared something tender and telling about who you are. I liked that.
Through your narrative, you have made this invisible man visible. How well you capture the texture of this man's life, and how admirable your kindness and concern for him. In powerful stories we inhabit the characters' lives. Yours is powerful, indeed.
an amazing story. thank you for sharing it.
I echo Cartouche's words! {{{R}}}
I live in Detroit where we do care for the truly homeless and disabled like your friend but our goverment won't. You were a wonderful friend to a person that needed care but couldn't afford it.

Health care is a basic human right. So many countries have learned that and provide it. Isn't it odd that ours relies on your employer to provide it, punishing people like your friend that couldn't afford treatment for his illness?
Wow... it is a humbling experience to know just when the right words have to be said, and even heard. This was a touching post. Thank you for sharing.
Catherine, fantastic post. I agree with what cartouche said. Sometimes words are unnecessary-- you were his friend.
This blows me away! It's such a departure from your usual stuff, Catherine. It's just great.
You walked with him and noticed his interests and treated him like an equal human being, without pity or patronizing. That seems like all you could do, and it was a lot.
What rita said. This was eloquent in its restraint and thoughtfulness.
You each shined here. Wonderful, and sad story. No glitz, just authentic human-glow. (r)
I liked this a lot Catherine -- the ease of an unusual friendship, spanning many years, and very real despite a lack of words between you.
You have a great depth Catherine, to share and recognize what is often ignored and unseen. Well written and thank you for sharing, caring. R
:( damn, this made me cry.
Powerful and riveting. I was there watching the whole thing. Rated
All that knowledge. Makes me wonder what he did with it, who he might have shared it with. Or if it was just for him, his life.
Many thanks.
there are many that are one step away from a baseball cap with the large letter *H*. I will remember this story... the man who spoke to you only four words.
I, too, liked reading this, as something more personal than your more journalistic blogs.

It's amazing how our lives can be touched like that, how a bond can be formed with so few words. I'm sure he appreciated your kindness, and the fact that you treated him as a human being.
Thank you for each and every one of your comments - truly. The Open Salon technical issues today have caused me the well known log-in problem, so I am late in responding. As many of you know, my Open Salon submissions generally are more factual. I am trying to add more 'first person' writing to this space. First person writing is not something that I do with any great ease. I have asked, in a previous posting, that people ask me some questions if they wish. I will try to answer. The response to that request has been surprisingly overwhelming - and I will start answering those questions this week.

The topic of this present post is something which I know there is not a definitive answer. I do think about it - often. Your comments give perspective. I remember reading a quote from Plato, when I was in high school. It has been used in some submissions here on Open Salon. The quote is "Be kind, for everyone you meet is fighting a hard battle". How true that is. Thanks again for your kindness...
i'm late to the party (i actually WORKED today for a change) but this is good. rated not only for clarity and heart but for the great tags, which i love around OS, a kind of sneaky poetry:

"purpose, wanderings, connections, street people"
Excellent piece! This really struck a chord for me. I had a homeless friend in San Francisco who lived in an old station wagon. He was so affable that he became rotund from all the food people working in nearby buildings brought each day. He was also given money to buy gas for his "mobile home." He was an avid reader and his car was piled to the roof with paperback books, also carted by his fans in their brief cases. Suddenly, he disappeared.
Months later I asked one of the other "residents" of the streets in the area if he knew what had happened to Mario. "Oh, they found him dead by the side of the freeway about a month ago." I cried. He had been beaten to death.

Lezlie
I just loved this glimpse of you for some reason. I know you as a "newsworthy" writer. This story is incredibly touching. thank you~r
This was riveting, Catherine. I got goosebumps when he spoke to you, and hoped for the same fairytale you hoped for. Clearly there was a real connection made, just not the kind we are able to classify or understand using any notions of regular social interaction.
Thank you. An amazing story of human connection.
Catherine, I think one of the reasons this post resonated with so many is not only because you don't often write personal narrative, but that for some, they might feel like they don't know you well and now you're finally speaking, like your friend now gone. There's an interesting parallel. It's a very human piece, a great story for you to share.
What a gripping story. You tell it well and it tells about you too.
I've had friends like this starting in my twenties in Berkeley. I always will. Thanks for reminding me that the friendship itself is the reward. I'm sorry he died.
Catherine, complelling, touching, and so eye opening, a truly wonderful piece of writing opening the deep, caring beatufiul side of whom I've always known you are. I never doublted for an instant from the first few words we shared what kind of a person you truly are, I am proud to count you amoung my few friends. I would love to read more of this from you
wschanz wrote (9:07am, 11-1-10): " I live in Detroit where we do care for the truly homeless and disabled like your friend but our goverment won't. You were a wonderful friend to a person that needed care but couldn't afford it.

Health care is a basic human right. So many countries have learned that and provide it. Isn't it odd that ours relies on your employer to provide it, punishing people like your friend that couldn't afford treatment for his illness?

That's a lot of assumptions, there, my friend. Roughly a third of the "street people" are the sort of mentally ill who were turned out of the old state mental hospitals in the late 1970's. That was a liberal project which thoughtlessly reacted to the existing system's real abuses and shortcomings by blowing said system up, without first securing a viable and superior replacement for it. The lesson that should have been learned is that politics only works for the common weal when it relies on a sustained consensus. One such existed; your side withdrew from it without first obtaining another. Whining about how the other fellow won't see things the way that you do is a mug's game. Only children imagine that it'll get them anywhere they want to go.

As for the other two-third's of the "street people," I'd hazard a guess that the vast majority are winos or drug addicts. Perhaps you and I could agree that the best thing to (begin to) do about the latter would be to end the "Drug War," but the electorate is still overwhelmingly in favor of it, so let's not kid ourselves. Failing that, few sane people will long expose themselves to the savage violence that proceeds therefrom. (In that regard, it isn't just white, suburban attitudes that could use some adjusting. Drug use, especially exclusive of ganja, is regarded widely among blacks as a white, establishment plot; drug legalization, as an extension of that plot.)