Editor’s Pick
APRIL 20, 2010 3:14PM
The Big Lie: Tea Party Rebranding and Liberal "Infiltrators"
The Right wing media and the Tea Parties are playing chess while the Left and the mainstream media are playing checkers.
While they can be disparaged as being narrow minded ideologues possessed of an authoritarian personality, Conservatives in the U.S.--and the extreme Right wing that has now become the center of the GOP--have long been masters of using emotional and moral appeals to motivate their public. While the Democrats are hamstrung by an issues based approach to politics, Conservatives have mastered the art of creating an alternate world of political facts and reason (enabled by the Right wing media echo chamber) where the reality based community need not tread.
This week the note being struck is that liberal infiltrators (in the guise of "agent provocateurs") are targeting the Tea Parties in order to smear and discredit them. Without any factual substantiation (and ignoring the racist, bigoted, and violent rhetoric that is common at the Tea Party gatherings) the Right has succeeded in reframing the narrative which surrounds the tea baggers. Now, freed from any responsibility for their own actions, the Tea Parties can point to some imagined villain as being responsible for all things disruptive and violent at their protests.
This is a brilliant move because it frees the tea baggers from any measure of responsibility for their deeds. Consider the simple genius at work here: if someone has a racist sign he/she is an infiltrator; if someone spits on a black congressman "they aren't really one of us" (or alternatively John Lewis was not spat upon because there is no "proof" save for eye witness accounts); if someone incites violence "he isn't a tea bagger, it must be a crazy progressive." Not surprisingly, rather than expose this quackery, most in the media are repeating these narratives without critical intervention or comment.
My claim is not that provocation by liberal instigators is an impossibility. No, the rebuttal should be "so what?" With all of the evidence of how central white racial animus and hostility are to the Tea Party movement, what else could the infiltrators possibly do? What other bad behavior--short of bombings, shootings, and other wanton acts of violence--could they possibly provoke the tea baggers into committing?
An appeal to the liberals as infiltrators strategy is also doubly effective because it inverts the political landscape by making the Tea Parties into victims of Jim Crow 2.0 and Barack Obama's America--those liberals whom despise "the patriots" and the good white folk who only want to exercise their first amendment rights against an "oppressive" and "tyrannical" regime that practices "reverse discrimination" and "pays too much attention" to black people's needs.
The Right has upped the ante. Not content with displacing responsibility onto "liberals" and "progressives" for the brigands in their midst, the Tea Parties are now trying to take the moral high ground as the party of diversity and tolerance. To that end, the tea baggers and their Right wing media arm have been circulating a video of a confrontation between a Tea Party member and an alleged white supremacist. Here the tea bagger confronts the white supremacist and condemns him. While doing so, the Tea Party activist is sticking to a clear script: "the Tea Parties are not racist," that "racism has no place with the Tea Parties," and "that the Tea Party does not concern itself with race." In one 2 minute clip, the Tea Party has created a counter-narrative, one with compelling soundbites, that runs explicitly counter to the popular understanding that the tea baggers are racist xenophobes. This is poetry in motion.
It is also a classic false flag operation. In intelligence and military circles these tactics involve the use of subterfuge and trickery (thus the allusion to a ship flying a "false flag") to create a pretext for military intervention or regime change, for framing events in the service of your own agenda, or more simply for making the public believe that "X" is occurring when it is in reality "Y."
In keeping with this strategy, the "white supremacist" in question (and there will be other videos of similar events released soon...you can mark my words) is a Tea Party activist. He is playing the role of the devil in their midst, a cancer to be conveniently exorcised as a way for the Tea Parties to demonstrate their love of diversity and colorblind politics. It is ironic then that the Tea Parties and the Right are sounding an alarm regarding the use of dirty tricks by the Left (Conservatives such as Beck and Limbaugh assert that the Progressives are masters of subterfuge and disruption) where in the United States the truth has been that through programs such as Cointelpro, the forces of elite power and Conservatism have spied on, disrupted, discredited, harassed and even killed members of Left-leaning organizations.
The repackaging of the Tea Parties as tolerant and inclusive political organizations is happening as we speak. It will continue from its own momentum regardless of the facts on the ground. In much the same way that Dr. King has been reimagined by conservatives to be a Republican (notice how Glenn Beck, the Pied Piper for the Tea Parties, is increasingly appropriating both the language and symbolism of The Civil Rights Movement), the tea baggers will be depicted as forces of American virtue and pluralism. As this false flag operation continues to develop, here are a few things to watch for in the upcoming weeks:
- More coverage of the "racial diversity" of the Tea Parties. Expect to see the same talking heads and black and brown apologists trotted out on the major networks;
- The discussion of agent provocateurs will take on the weight of fact as opposed to speculation;
- There will be more videos of white supremacists, nativists, and overt "Birthers" being thrown out of Tea Party rallies;
- Simultaneously, there will be a great deal of attention paid to "incidents" where Palin supporters and tea baggers are assaulted by "anti-Tea Party" forces and "agents of the Obama regime";
- The Right wing media frame will continue to emphasize their long standing narrative that Conservatives and "real Americans" are "victims" of the Left and Progressives;
- Similar to what happened with the ACORN pimp and prostitute scandal (a fraud staged by Breitbart and company), the efforts to "infiltrate" the Tea Parties will be exposed as events planned by the Right;
- Loose lips sink ships: one of the "white supremacist" or other "agent provocateurs" will give up the fact that they are on the payroll of someone semi-connected (for reasons of plausible deniability) to the Right wing media and/or political establishment.


Salon.com
Comments
This is a serious movement in need of infiltration to expose the grave danger they represent?
We'll see this bunch over and over again ad nauseum this summer, with non stop talk show blather.
Your predictions all sound on point to me.
Anyway, I'm so glad you wrote this and did it with such care. You're providing in analysis what I only touched upon with satire in Free PR Tips For Tea Partiers.
Cheers.
It's clear to me that racism and Tea Party go together, in spite of protests to the contrary, because that's the line of attack that feels obvious to these so-called liberal infiltrators. Whether those infiltrators are real or not is beside the point. If they are mischievous liberals or double-triple psyching conservatives, it's clear that these troublemakers know to pretend to be racists. And that speaks volumes about the for-real racism implicit in the group.
I've said time and time again that this movement represents the radicalization of the right the same way the Weathermen represented the radicalization of the left in the 60s and 70s. And this ideological "purification" will end with the same results, only this time for the right.
And when a massacre occurs at a gun-toting demonstration, I suppose it will be the fault of those pesky leftist infiltrators.
Observation- Far Lefties "infiltrate" the Right and, for example, sing political satire songs a Capella, and on-key. Right Wingers, after a few chapters of Saul, park their butts on a chair, wait, then scream, hyper-ventilate, and spit themselves.
Truth, from Mr. Glaude, Jr.,
"April 21st marks the seventh anniversary of Nina Simone's death. Hers was a voice that challenged us in so many ways. I have always loved her ironic use of the show tune to call attention to the murders of Medgar Evers in Mississippi and the four little children in Birmingham, Alabama.
'Alabama's gotten me so upset
Tennessee made me lose my rest
And everybody knows about Mississippi Goddamn'
Mississippi and its violence function in the song as common sense; its horrors are known and its failures are deeply felt. And as Nina calls attention to the contradictions and the hypocrisy, as she demands equality for herself and black people, Mississippi stands in for America as such. Her words rest alongside the actions of those young people who dared fifty years ago this month to organize the Student Non-Violent Coordinating Committee (SNCC) and later in April of 1964 found the Mississippi Freedom Democratic Party to challenge the brutality of American racism."
AUWE
As for #7, a poster here last week debunked some of them, by doing what the MSM are too lazy to do - following the links and the money.
They sure do Whip It, Whip it Good (frenzy, that is).
I ain't holding my breath till this one's over.
{sigh}
BTW, how about the AP? Will you believe them that you are wrong? I didn't think so, but here it is anyway just in case somebody who reads this might care and consider you a left wing (what ever).
By VALERIE BAUMAN, Associated Press Writer Valerie Bauman, Associated Press Writer – Mon Apr 12, 6:30 pm ET
ALBANY, N.Y. – Opponents of the fiscally conservative tea party movement say they plan to infiltrate and dismantle the political group by trying to make its members appear to be racist, homophobic and moronic.
Jason Levin, creator of http://www.crashtheteaparty.org, said Monday the group has 65 leaders in major cities across the country who are trying to recruit members to infiltrate tea party events for April 15 — tax filing day, when tea party groups across the country are planning to gather and protest high taxes.
@Also--you are right. This is a great story to be recycled over and over again by the 24 hour new machine. It is tough because this needs to be covered because of the danger present, but we don't want to give them too much attention.
@Drew--The Right wing echo chamber is working as designed. It is creating drones that do the bidding of the corporateocracy.
@Lainey--Agreed. There is real racism here. The sad part of the tea party story is how they really are part of a long continuum where the working and middle class white American is manipulated by elites through the use of racial resentment.
@Jill--Spot on.
@Old Lefty--Great parallel on the fringe radicalization of the Right. Folks forget that history. My worry is that if we look at the public opinion data these folks are the new center of the GOP.
@Sheila--Thanks for the mention of Zorn's piece. That would be a good combo, you should go for it.
@Oahu--Great Nina mention. I was also thinking of the Dylan song on the Birchers. I am going to do a post here or on my main site linking the Tea Parties to the Birchers, White Citizen's Councils, Liberty Leagues, the Know-Nothings, etc. This is nothing new. It is the real ugly ugly side of the Perot movement and Reagan Democrats mated with white ethnic backlash from the 1960s and 70s.
@Gee Bee--So it begins. We have to keep the MSM's feet to the fire the best we can.
@Connie--There are lots of McVeigh's out there. We have already seen sporadic violence. My thought is will Beck and company own what they are ginning up when their is an inevitable incident of domestic terrorism.
@Catnlion--You quoted: By VALERIE BAUMAN, Associated Press Writer Valerie Bauman, Associated Press Writer – Mon Apr 12, 6:30 pm ET
ALBANY, N.Y. – Opponents of the fiscally conservative tea party movement say they plan to infiltrate and dismantle the political group by trying to make its members appear to be racist, homophobic and moronic.
You get my point right? How can the infiltrators make them look anything more than what they have proven themselves to be already? The tea parties are racist, homophobic, and moronic. Thus, my thesis that they are actively repackaging themselves. Moreover, I am suspicious of the person you mentioned, for all we know he could be on the payroll of the tea partiers enablers...
The yield is bottom-line a least common denominator of conflation, confusion, and misplaced and misdirected rage.
The original, maybe even righteous, wrath, that was the roux in this bouillabaisse provides the ardor this otherwise cold-blooded exercise in political chicanery would obviously lack.
I attended a Tea Party the other day to try to co-opt their message and to see first hand what they were all about. While the vast majority of them are fringe racists, there are some who are just frustrated and scared, looking for an outlet and the only available option right now is the racist Tea Parties.
I posted a video on my page of a racist woman saying that Obama doesn't represent her because she isn't from the ghetto. Unfortunately, now the TPers can claim she is an infiltrator. She isn't, Anchorage is a small place in terms of population, and she is definitely the real deal.
Glenn Ford had a good post the other day on BAR regarding the racist nature of the TPers. I also just read Michelle Alexander's book 'The New Jim Crow, Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness' that was very eye opening to me with regard to how pervasive racism is even though it is just under the surface and not obvious, making it more dangerous. The Tea Partiers with their thinly veiled coded language illustrate this.
None of the signs have been this blatant though some have depicted Pres. Obama in witch doctor garb and used a peculiar amount of references to Africa, a place where the president never lived. Some signs are in coded language readily apparent to all who lived through the last portion of the 20th century.
Some quotes have come from the podiums, some from the crowds. Some have been the things said to pollsters.
But it's there, make no mistake about it.
It's good to see a couple of commentators expose its errors.
All the apparent evil demonstrated by the Tea Baggers is really just a liberal plot foisted on them by those nasty vicious left wingers who are the real source of the guys with guns, misspelled signs, racist rhetoric et al.
Tea Baggers are the salt of the earth nice guys who would never misbehave in any fashion. Yeah, that's the story.
Have you seen the video posted here:
http://www.salon.com/news/politics/war_room/2010/04/16/tea_party_rapper_polatik_video/index.html
The right wing rapper Polatik raps: "It's not a race thing but you hear that often".
As if to confirm this rather defensive and strained assertion, his video includes close-ups of all non-white people who have ever attended a Tea Party rally.
Without round-the-clock promotion from Fox News, the "movement" has already peaked.
The "teabagger" reference was deliberate on the part of the original organizers. There were signs saying "teabag them before they teabag us". They later changed their name to "Tea Partiers" after they realized that their opponents are much better at using lewd slurs than they are. At least some of them were aware it was making them a laughing stock.
Salon's own Walt Glenn Greenwald wrote in January that Barack Obama's new head of office of information and regulatory affairs, Cass Sunstein, had championed creating fake websites and using outside 501(C)(3) interest groups to act as alleged indepentent champions of government policy and to "cognitively infiltrate" opposition websites. All this is in a paper that he, Sunstein, wrote back in 2008!
So all this is the play book of the right. Just because it's one of President Obama's right hand men who wrote about what to do years ago, the right just thought it up. At this rate there is going to be a shortage of Kool-Aid. Better stock up now.
For those of you who don't know, Rage is a group that advocates communism. Which begs the question as to why a so-called Tea Party member would EVER be at such a concert...
Also, to prove that the guy was an "infiltrator", he posts that the shirt and hat the supposed racist is wearing can be ordered online and goes on to show the EXACT hat and shirt! Coincidence? I don't think so....
This guy is a fraud.
Sometimes they are soliders just back from the war with PTSD points of view, sometimes they are lefty ideolouges with "Che Dreams," sometimes they are ideolouges from the right trying to spoil credibility, and sometimes they are cops looking for a political bust.
Whoever they are, its the responsibility of the group to stay non-violent and on topic. There are no "he made me do it" excuses allowed.
I don't see why the Tea-Parties think "he made me do it" would work as an excuse just for them, at least why they think it will work with independants and moderate middle types.
Also, there all ready has been an act of domestic terroism, a man flew a plane into the IRS building in Austin Texas, and the right wind expressed sympathy for the terrorist.
Looking forward to reading your other posts.