5 minutes ago, the IOC slammed Chicago to the mat with a first round elimination from the bid to host the 2016 Olympics.
We lost.
The sputtering, half baked, shoddy journalistic shreiks of "Why?" will come. America is still fighting 2 wars. We've yet to make back all the friends we've lost over the past several years. The speculation will fill at least one news cycle. Maybe more. But then there is this:
We lost. Lost big.
And the reaching for a vision of Chicago, the painting of a picture yet to happen, a future to make us all just a little bit more alive? Not today.
We lost.
In every single ward of the city were meetings on the Olympics and the sweep of opinions was epic. Monumental. Everyone had an opinion and everyone voiced it. Even if that opinion was indifference--it was a strongly voiced indifference. "Chicago" never, ever, ever, thinks one thing.
Even now. In the wind blown cloudy silence of a gray October day; all the partial truths of who pays, who is included or not included, who flies first class and who doesn't, what kind of a dress Oprah wore to the parties; the infinite roiling simmering stew that is this cross roads of our country is quiet for just a moment.
Because we lost.
The homeless woman who passes my house every morning, a house I couldn't afford if I were to buy it today, she pulls her home behind her in a grocery cart, head down, gray hair matching the tone and texture of the day, she looks up for a moment and we nod to each other.
A cement truck rumbles by. Squirrels chatter.
It's quiet right now. We lost. In the first round. And no one can quite believe that.
An el train rumbles by. A Chicagoan watches the train. A Chicagoan knows that there will be all sorts of folks who are glad we lost, all sorts of folks who will be sad. And everything else in between.
All those who shreik and analyze and name call, and find facts to fit the point they want make, all those who wonder: "Did Al Capone cause this? Or maybe it was Oprah's fault? Or Can the President survive all this? Or any other of a million other silly, sad or pathetically un-informed questions---all of them are quiet for a moment in the wind that swirls off the lake and throws our fates to the indifferent stars.
We lost. So we bring out the big guns. Algren.
"It isn't hard to love a town for it's greater and lesser towers, its pleasant parks, or its flashing ballet. Or for its broad and bending boulevards, where the continous headlights follow, one dark driver after the next, one swift car after another, all night, all night and all night. But you never truely love it till you love its alleys too, Where the bright morning faces of old familiar friends now wear the anxious midnight eyes of strangers a long way from home.
A midnight bounded by the bright carnival of the boulevards and the dark girders of the el.
Where once the marshland came to flower.
Where once the deer came down to water."
We lost.
So we go down to the waters. Breathe in the air of that always changing second hand sea. Look to the sky.
And then go back to work.
Because there is still lots to do.



Salon.com
Comments
Sad that it took such a heartbreaking moment to get you an EP.
We were saved I say!
Myriad--I hear you. The disruption is a very real part of it. One of my favorite books is called "The Devil and the White City" and it spoke to that same very real point.
Tom--I agree that we would have a LOT of work to do if it had happened. The points you mnetioned are just a few of many. One of the ones that concerned me personally was a disruption in the migratory patterns of birds--to build a tennis court. But the actually solved that one already. Before we lost.
Mamoore---Thanks! and they are still playing it as I write this.
Billy---I think you got a movie on your hands my friend.
FLW---Yeah, very true on SA. It was also their third attempt.
Great mood to this piece CG. R
I'm really sorry. I know you guys wanted it.
Gail Maria--Thanks for commenting. Like I said, here in Chicago the range of opinion is infinite. But I LOVE that you saw a Robert Frost moment. A friend of mine who edits Poetry Magazine and just contributed a piece on Frost to Greil Marcus's new "Literary History of America" will be impressed. . .for about a second.
John---absolutely---it was NEVER a slam dunk. Slam dunk was pure fantasy. And hell yes we need the jobs. I need a job!
I think it simply boils down to two things:
1. The United States has lost an incredible amount of prestige during the past decade. We are no longer viewed as favorably as we were when the Olympics were awarded to Atlanta (Atlanta? Before Chicago?) We are the ones that started an unnecessary war. We are the ones that, more than any other country, have caused the global economic crisis. Why should we be honored at this time?
2. Really, as the awarding of the Olympics to China also illustrated, we are living in a time of change, when the Triumvirate of North America-Europe-Japan is being eclipsed by new center of powers, with populations that rival, or far exceed, that of the old centers of power. In that sense, it makes sense to award the games to Brazil, a vibrant, culturally diverse nation. Rio, moreover, perfectly perfectly reflects those attributes, and lies on one of the most beautiful pieces of coastline anywhere. I think it was a good choice.
I am a student in Chicago. I followed a community organization, Housing Bronzeville, that was very concerned about what the effects on the community would be if the Olympics were in Chicago. They really feared that gentrification would happen at a higher rate in their community as a result.
Chicago could not have afforded the Olympics. It's poor, working class, and middle class would have been driven into further economic ruin. The state's fiscal crisis would have deepened as it tried to pay off debt created by hosting the Olympics.
Chicago would have become a militarized zone. It would have been heavily policed and the security would have been like the security in Beijing.
The winners would have been security contractors who would have made huge profits. The losers would have been the people of Chicago.
We would have hosted two weeks of sports for the world, but when it was over, what it would it have been like in 2017, 2018, and so on?
That's a future I didn't want to know. And, I don't want to know it.
If Chicago is to have the Olympics some day, its people need to change the city. Right now, we are not a city fit for hosting the Olympics.
But nothing can top Obama making his acceptance speech in your park while the whole nation wept in joy!
NO POLITICAL MOMENT IN MY LIFE HAS BEEN BETTER!!
You make Chicago get up and get dressed, scrape the stubble off its cheeks, put on a fresh shirt. You do that with your vision of it, with your keen ability to snap together descriptive phrases like Legos.
This was an excellent job and a well-deserved EP, Roger.
Job well done, man.
From my earlier post today
How do you maintain elite white rule in a population that is non white and poor? This was a question that many sought answers to during the last century - Brazil was touted as a success story in racial harmony. Academics were sent in droves to Brazil observe and report on what turned out to be a well promoted myth of racial harmony. In fact urban Brazil was and remains a deeply segregated society. What Americans learned from Brazil was how to do this without legal segregation. We now know how this is done - simply > Internal State Sponsored Terrorism. You might call it "The War on Drugs" or "The War on the Poor" but since 91101, when we were all obligated to learn about terrorism - text book terrorism - some of us discovered that what we were learning was not new to us. Back then, since the early 1980's actually, I had written that Drug War was racist adding this to my 1970s argument that Drug Laws were economically and morally wrong.
During the surge of post 911 terrorism academic interest I came to discover that textbook Internal State Sponsored Terrorism had three observable stages - Intimidation, Forced conversion, and Genocide. My class was surprised when I argued that Drug War fit easily into that box.
But where did "we" learn it? A further study of race in Latin America I undertook a few years later led me to discover some great Academic papers on the subject. It was then that I discovered that the final bit of my three decade hunt for the source of the stupidity behind Drug War. It was Brazil. What do Rio and Chicago have in common? Internal State Sponsored Terrorism - and White "mob" rule.
In this context seeing Rio as the final candidate for the 2016 host of the NEW WORLD ORDER Olympic games makes sense to me. Drug war 20 trillion dollars, hosting O games, 30 billion....keeping urban populations in a total state of chaos...priceless
Coyote---thank you. That's really what this is about.
Steve---you do realize that beach volleyball was slated for Rockford?
Kevin G--I appreciate the energy and thoughtfulness of your reply. And yes---if we had won---we would have had a lot to do. Mostly I appreciate you marking me as a favorite. My trips to page one are rare---so I hope you come back.
Thanks nofrills---yeah---at my house we did. On most days.
Thanks voicegal!
Chuck---I agree. There was nothing more we could have done.
Mary---Yes, the Fox assault pushed me into wanting it more too.
Mike--Cool beans back at you! (Which reminds me that there is an awful lot of coffee in Brazil)
Stacey--thanks for being there no matter what page I'm on.
http://open.salon.com/blog/cartouche/2009/10/02/sights_and_sounds_unseen
HEY EVERYONE! GO READ CARTOUCHE! She is what you might call a guiding spirit of this community.
(Bill S taught me how to do that. Yesterday)
Snowden---WOW! Somebody is quoting their own post on my little page.
SM---Thank you.
Sally--talk about the perfect comment. . . .!
Stellaa-- Thank you. Comments from you are hard earned. You have no idea how much I appreciate that.
Kathy---you're right about that speech.
However, for Chicago to be kicked out in the first round does smack of something political. I had a feeling it was always going to be Rio, but it would have been nice if Chicago didn't get last-place.
Doesn't really matter... the world's going to be toast on 21 December 2012, anyway... :)
I will never get the Olympics thing.
We both live in Chicago. So, I will check back here for updates on what's happening in Chicago from your perspective.
I have no idea what you typically write on your blog but if it's about what's happening locally, I am sure I will enjoy it whether it deals with news or simply sports, entertainment, and other things.
Congrats on the cover page. I've made it their many times and it's a great place to be.
A beautiful piece Roger, one Nelson would have read, and smiled at....
I'm actually happy for Rio. I hope it will bring some world attention to South America.
aim---me either
gary---"Glorious Failure" is perfect---and thanks for the call out on my main man!
Jim---"What if" sums up the whole thing.
Mistercomedy---Thank you!
Carolina---yeah the last place thing was a stunner. Did not see that coming. So much for the whole "fix is in theory"
owl--see you next time, when my unexpected moment of noteriety.
is over
Kevin--you remind me of a younger version of myself. Poor guy!
Perhaps at least this way you won't have an incident like the bombing in Atlanta in 1996.
And security during the games in our increasingly dangerous world is for the Brazilians to worry about, not the Chicago Police Department.
No song is going to be sung at the opening ceremonies by one Chicago child while being lip-synched by a cuter child.
(Okay, I'm working on trying to find the silver lining, here.)
Great writing, even when about disappointment.
Rated
And it is still, "My kind of town!"
Melissa-"No song is going to be sung at the opening ceremonies by one Chicago child while being lip-synched by a cuter child." My favorite line of the day
wildmarjorman (what a great screen name!) thank you.
ginsing---yes---a huge headache
voicegal---that was in 1892!
Skanktamonius---interestingly enough---the Special Olympics was invented here by Anne Burke, now a judge, who worked at the park District at the time
Mary ann---the Palmer House was just renovated---haven't seen it yet
I promise you that the Olympics in Brazil will be an event that no one will ever forget because it will become more than a national event, I predict it will encompass the pride and energy of the entire South American continent and be a great big assist in propelling the populace into the global populism. The more minds and energy we can bring together, in sport, in intellect and science, and the arts and humanism, the greater the chance we have in solving the complex problems confronting us all as human beings in the centuries to come.
I was born at Loretto hospital in Columbus Pk in 1939.
I lived/loved in Chicago many years.
Even though I've lived in other parts of the US, whenever I see a pic of anything "Chicago", I get "that feeling".
In my travels(bumming/slumming?), I haunted almost every neighborhood of the city.
I have those memories that can only be formed by being there.
I can still "feel" the Bobs and smell the midway of Riverview.
I can still hear the screech of the subway wheels as the train goes around a curve.
I can still smell the dampness of the subway.
I can still remember going to the "Tip Top Tap" at the top of the Allerton hotel with Fran.
Ahh, she was gorgeous.
I wonder where she is now.
I also remember W Madison St~~"skid row" before they tore much of it down.
They did the same thing with something which was a wonderful part of my Chicago~~Halsted and Maxwell~~the market.
All that said, I don't care about Chicago not getting the "spectacle" of the Olympics.
The Olympic games are actually the political maneuverings PRIOR to the athletic events and, I actually believe that Chicago is better off without them.
What we won't now see are all the whitewashed views of the city WITHOUT the REAL city.
Oh, well.
There are STILL the Hawks and Bears.
I now live in north central WI, a beautiful, clean, woodsy smelling place.
That old saying is true for me though~~you can take the boy out of~~~~.
XJS-- You certainly have some serious Chicago "cred" (as they say now. The Alllerton, Riverview etc (Riverview is now a police station as you might know) I believe Fran is no longer with us. . .sorry!
Amy---Just a temporary front page visitor. I think squirrel must be on vacation or something.
Ablonde--Beautiful statement on Rio. Of course I might have to go there to be sure (I wish!) Loosing to Rio took about 30 seconds to get over---it was being last that sucked! That said, the Rio teams presentation of a world map showing all locations of all Olympics with SA being dark was a terrific visual display of your excellent point.
William---well put! I don't think St Louis ever forgave the amending the flow of the river. And any comment that brings Vonnegut to the table ---"So it goes" ---could not be more welcome. Thank you.
Forget the Olympics. Put on your own spectacle.
Remember The Columbian Exposition in 1893? Put on a new one.
Put on a show you don't have to bid on, something like no one's ever seen before, that will draw lots of attention, crowds, and money, in that order.
So if you don't find your comment here---I'll attempt to explain. I don't want to close comments (yet) ---but this is really not the post to use to pick a fit. About ANYTHING. So I'm just doing the best I can to avoid that.
This piece was not about the politics. It was about a moment, now over, when I place I love felt a sense of loss. That's all.
I suppose I could ignore some of the ill will written here. But somehow that could imply acceptance. And what's on the list below, I find unacceptable. So if your comment is gone, or if you want to write about one of these things below---please be kind enough to do it somewhere else. I'm sure there is a FOX news station pretty near to wherever you are. Tell them. Personally? I choose not to accept.
1. Racism. However it's disguised or presented.
2. Bashing or lecturing the people of Chicago. If I wanted advice,
I would have asked. You do not see it asked for in the piece.
3. Relating this relatively SMALL issue to the slughter of 6 million
Jews.
4. Allowing this piece to serve as a target for the hard working
people employed by the government of Chicago.
5. Allowing this piece to insult the Chicago Police Department
6. Setting up a tired old liberal/conservative wars.
I'm sure this will provoke more venom. But if you choose to attack---please read the piece first and ask yourself---is it really worth it?
Roger
Edit---Yes---it's the road up to the event that is really the important part.
It's not all about U.S. -- er, us, folks. We need to wake up and grow up and stop thinking that we are the center of the universe!
But the depth to which people enjoy the political shrieking t is remarkable.
I'm ready for the olympics to leave the news cycle
Today? It's the last day of baseball and neither the Cubs nor Sox did real well this year---which is a bummer---I wonder if anybody will find the political meetings in that?
If somebody wants to talk "outrage" lecture or moralize lets talk about health care, or kids not being safe in schools. . .
Rio was the pick for a while now. Chi-town didn't have a chance, not even with Oprah selling her superior celebrity with Obama as arm candy. Too little too late.
You didn't lose. There was never a competition in which to participate. You may have been spared some unknown nightmare, who knows?
Bummer. I know.
I love the Olympic Games and curse the tepid and inept American news coverage every 2 years. I think they're one of the pillars of achievement of the modern age and so long as they continue in some form it means that whatever else may be going wrong our civilization is still intact, is not yet doomed.
But the idea that Chicago lost -- not in a limited way like at a Cubs game or a political scandal -- but -LOST- lost, lost in an -existential- sense, is beyond me.
This piece asks its readers to extend the frustration of a failed Olympic bid into universality, to feel that they too are Losing, in a transcendent way. It asks us to mourn the entire city's loss. It asks us to see the loss of an entire nation. It asks us to weep as we would for the destruction of some priceless treasure or the squandering of some heartachingly unrealized potential.
In short it asks too much. It overreaches.
The US has bid to host the games nearly every time they've been held. Most of the time we are passed over in favor of other cities. This heartbreaking tragedy of stupendous sorrow is repeated pretty much every 24 months.
Sorry it didn't work for you! I was pretty much over the loss last Friday about 5 minutes after I wrote it. Yesterday's news.
And I honest to God wasn't trying to make ANYBODY weep!
What I was trying to do is capture the sweep of the city's feeling at just the moment of loss. That's all. To get aawy from finger pointing, politics and tired cliches as well as gross generalizations.
IF there is anything transcendent in the Olympic process it is in improving a place to make it worthy of a world wide event. Something that would be good for Chicago or Rio or really anywhere. That's all.
But once done--we all now have, as the piece says "lots of work" to do.
And if somebody had said, OK here's your choice, a Chicago Olympics or real health care for the country? I'd pick health care.
Like I said---a lot of work to do. There's no crying in track and field!
Thanks again---Roger