Editor’s Pick
DECEMBER 7, 2011 12:58PM

Ethical Politics in Chicago?

Rate: 17 Flag

imag1es

Test the actual soil underlying Chicago City Hall.

No one would be surprised if trace elements of ethical lapses were somehow ingrained in the earth.

It’s been that way since the first Indian standing watch one dark night on the shores of the Big Lake watched the first smiling white man jump from the canoe, yell a hearty hello and set the standard price for anything as being ten cents on the dollar.

With a wink and a handshake. It’s always been that way. Because we’ve always been able to pay the cost. Be it in dollars, culture, human suffering, a strange kind of pride or even bottled up rage. We have always paid the cost for turning away from the smoke of the roaring ethical fires.

But now we can’t afford that anymore. The money’s shriveled up. So now it might change.

Yesterday, Mayor Emanuel appointed an Ethics Reform Task Force unlike any ever seen in this city.

A group of four who have made careers based on being ethical.

Their task is to review Chicago's Ethics Ordinance. And then make it work. Make it stronger.

Cindi Canary will chair the Task Force. Cindi Canary is a groundbreaking force in city and state ethical reform. Her former organization is the “Illinois Campaign for Political Reform.” Pore over any tiny or large steps forward in the fight for government accountability in Illinois  and you will find her name.

 

Alderman Will Burns, who along with counterparts like Alderman Ameya Pawar, has been part of the new crop of city leaders. Leaders who focus on  social justice organizations ranging from The Mikva Challenge and the Shriver Center for Poverty Law to The Common Pantry---Chicago's longest operating Food Pantry.

And if there is any concern at all that real political change needs more than sunlight to make it work, Sergio Accosta, the third member of the group, is a former supervising U.S. Attorney specializing in areas like criminal civil rights.

 

Turns out that civil rights violations are still crimes.

 

But it’s the fourth member of the panel that brings the golden soul of the city into the mix of this new effort. Her name is Dawn Clark Netsch. She’s a former State Comptroller, State Senator and gubernatorial candidate. All facts. None of which give substance to the story of why she could be the soul of the new ethics machine.

 

It’s a short story---but its telling.

 

Back when there were only two telephone companies, I opened up the effort to sell the little telephone company, MCI,  into Illinois State Government. I found a partner to help me learn the backstreets, darkened hallways and phone numbers of Springfield, a state political capital that made Chicago look like Andy Griffith’s home town Mayberry.

 

In the rotunda of the state capital, pretty much every door was closed up tight to me and my little telephone company. Most times no one even wanted to talk. And I mean not even talk about the weather. Everyone but Dawn Clark Netsch.

It was a simple thing. She didn’t know me. I never made a deal with her. Never even a formal meeting. But she was accessible. She talked to anybody. Even me. And that simply didn’t happen anywhere else. Not without access. Not without knowing someone who knows someone else.

Flash forward decades. I’m walking my dog in the Old Town neighborhood of Chicago. And she’s walking her dog. She stops. She chats. That regular nodding hello that fellow dog lovers have. She’s still open to the world.

 

And that would be the first key strategy of the new ethics task force.

Be open to the world.

The Mayor tried to do that in his transition. But he failed. You still had to be in the club. The great blogger driftglass’s 2 rules of Chicago politics:

1. There is a club.

2. You’re not in it.

 

Those two rules still own the day.

But what if that could change? What next?

 

Next is a mapping of the problem as a systemic problem. It’s not a problem where catching one rogue rascal with his hand in another’s pocket solves anything. It’s about a system.

 

And third, it’s about performance standards and measures that sound a bit different from the norm.

 

Turns out that notions of confidence, integrity, pride and passion really can be measured in the laboratory of opinion.

 

So the right people are on board. All four of them. Especially my hero, Dawn Clark Netsch.

 

And the right strategy can be put in place:

1. Accessibility and Transparency from those who serve the public.

2. Mapping the system to really grasp the full problem.

3. Performance standards and measures—to drive the real, concrete action that could produce something none of us have ever seen before, something most of us think isn’t even possible.

 

A renewed Chicago. Known for the ethical standards we practice.

This group could make it happen. And if they need any help?

I’m ready now.

Course, I don't really know anybody.

But I'm ready and qualified now.

Do you suppose that matters?

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Chicagoguy - Good luck!!

Are you in the club??

:-) / R
"trace elements of ethical lapses"...love that phrase. I imagine if you tested the soil anywhere politics is practiced in the state of New Jersey, you'd find far more than traces; then again, you'd have to move aside all the bodies.

Let's see what happens in the Windy City and if anything good blows our way.
toritto---I am so NOT in the club!

Nikki--My parents down the road from you would agree. Beneath those Pine Barren Roads. . . .YIKES!
Lordy, we can hope, but should we? Isn't it possible this is just a feel-good publicity stunt to help keep any more Chicago mud from splashing on Obama during his campaign? Lordy, I hope not.
Ethics in politics must start with Ethics at home and in schools which will translate to the demand for ethical standards in public office. Figure out how to make that happen and I'll support you for World Grand Champion and Global Dictator.
When I was in Chicago, the first Mayor Daley said he wanted to be buried in St. Brigid's parish so he could remain politically active after his death. (rim shot)

Proposed first question for the ethics committee: How did Rahm make $18 million as an investment banker in two years after leaving the White House when he'd never been a banker before, no finance training, a ballet major in college. Curious--damn curious.

r
Now I want to know how Dawn Clark Netsch survived.

As for your ready & qualified & whether it matters - that's the question, isn't it? The answer will tell us if anything's changed. I know we can count on you to keep an eye out & report back.
I'd like to see you get involved, CG. I've never known what to make of Chicago/Illinois politics. My first immersion was reading the official report on the Chicago Police Riots during the '68 DNC ... and I must admit to confusion ever since. How --why -- in hell do people put up with it?

On a related (if somewhat sunnier note), I see from CBS news -- via Fark.com -- that Rod Blagojevich got 14 years for corruption, becoming the second Illinois governor in a row -- and the fourth in the last four decades -- to get prison time.
Chicagoguy wrote: "No one would be surprised if trace elements of ethical lapses were somehow ingrained in the earth."

Truer words were never spoken, as this 1903 editorial cartoon by famed Chicago cartoonist John T. McCutcheon so aptly demonstrates: http://home.comcast.net/~russ.maheras/McCutcheon-1903-Chicago-Alderman-72dpi.jpg

Keep in mind this cartoon was published 108 years ago (five years BEFORE the last time the Cubs won a World Series).
So you won't be able to bribe your way out of a moving violation anymore? In Chicago? Are you kidding me?
Matt--As you know, ANYTHING is possible!

Doug--you mentioned schools. And starting at home. The Mikva Challenge (mentioned in the piece) focuses on just that. So the tie to schools is there. . .

Con ---Hah! (Try the veal. . .)

You bring up an interesting issue. My take on that (just opinion) is that the Mayor's success on Wall Street was based not on finance or banking---it was based on selling. Selling would have been the key skill set for most people doing what he was doing. And there is no one better at that than him. I can tell you that all of it was earned on commission--not salary. Which, having had to live that way myself, ain't easy. He was a ballet dancer---that's true, but in my house that's a plus as my wife is --like the Mayor--a former ballet dancer.

NC--By being a good person. Weird huh? And you can count on me reporting back as to what comes of this.

B--That is the real question. Why do we put up with it. There is no one answer. And the full answer is systemic. I'd love to get the chance to answer it! As for Springfield. Yep. Gov Kerner, Walker, Ryan and Blag0---and those are just the ones who got caught.

Russ---ANY post that evokes John T McCutcheon is a success. I hope people google what you pasted in there. That man was a treasure. MANY Thanks!
i'm still enough of an idealist to hope that you're right, that it's possible. and i think rahm is making a difference, even if it's small steps and slowly. look where he had to start, for pete's sake, where rod blowhard/blowdry/pay-me left off. good piece, roger. keep trying.
@con: NYT - Dec 2008 “In Banking, Emanuel Made Money and Connections”

emanuel worked in M&A, brought in clients and did deals, relying on others (because he could) for number-crunching, made most of his money in bonuses for business he generated. he's an exceptionally smart guy, worked 12-hr days, and the company he worked for made a ton of money off the work he did. nothing mysterious or nefarious going on here.
Will wonders never cease? Dawn Clark Netsch may be the only political figure in Illinois whose integrity is unassailable. And she and her cohorts know well that a commission can only be as strong and effective as the extent to which it is funded and staffed -- and given wide berth to exercise its authority.
Candace--I thought it was important for something like this to be communicated today---the day of the Blago sentencing. Leaving that sad story out of this was a very conscious choice.

You bring up a very relevant point about the Mayor's work ethic. Living across the street from where his security detail is housed and being his neighbor, I can tell you that his work hours are incredible. He still does those 12 plus hour days. Makes me tired!

Helen--there MIGHT be somebody besides Professor Netsch on that list---but if there is, no names come to mind!
John B---This is why we need to bring Millard Fillmore back! (For anyone wanting in on that comment---google John's name and Millard Fillmore and you'll fine a book you need to buy right now!)
We need more ethics in Chicago politics like they need more rain in Texas. Blago was sentenced to 14 years in prison today, and he chose to live in Chicago instead of in the governor's mansion in Springfield; he would have been better off downstate and away from Daley, uh, daily temptations. I'm glad to know that there isn't any reason to have buyer's remorse with Rahm and his ethics task force; I'm positive that I voted for Dawn in 1994 instead of the previous governor who also went to prison for corruption.
Paul Haider, Chicago
I've never been in a club and wouldn't join one that would have me.
"Hey, have ya heard, the Mayor of Chicago appointed an ethics panel?" sounds like the beginning of a joke. Then some fella asks, "Oh yeah? Who's on it?" "Three hookers and a barkeep," the answer comes back. And the follow-up question: "And who are they investigating?" And the reply: "Nobody. They just thought it would be festive."

rate
I want to be a believer.
Paul--Yep. A contrast to the Blago story.

Also---You and Woody Allen. . .or Freud. . .or me

Dr. Lee--Yes. Lots of potential jokes!

Mimetalker---Me too. And it ain't easy, is it?
Good government in Chicago moves more slowly than a glacier. However, move it does. When I was a pup back in the good ol' days, Hizzoner, Richard J. Daley was God. Daley was an improvement over the Kelly machine, which was an improvement over Big Bill Thompson. Fast forward a few decades, and Richard Nixon had Operation Greylord that cleaned out some Chicago judges. Then Harold Washington really shook things up. Then decades more of Little Dicky Daley, and now Mayor Rahm. I'll bet dollars to doughnuts that city and county goverment is cleaner now than maybe it's ever been.

But everything is relative. Chicago might have the reputation, but Louisiana, West Virginia, and Rhode Island probably set the gold standard.
OLN--All true. And I would not take that bet cause you're right. The reputation and the reality are worlds apart. Flat out corruption has been weeded out through the ages. Yesterday a governor went to jail for 14 years because of crimes he TRIED to commit. He was never really successful at pulling them off. A failed and yet punished criminal is just kind of sad.

What remains are ethical issues. And the mapping of ethical gaps have mostly to do with access. And blocking access (whether its intentional or not intentional) costs money, impacts real life and hinders quality delivery of everything. Keeps people from connecting to work. Slows down or eliminates social service.

Not because someone is breaking a law. (Most times) But because there is a club and you are not in it. Ethics is the problem--not corruption.

Usually.
Baltimore--You're right. That is Canary's former organization. which is what it now says---isn't blogging great?

What's different about this situation than the typical "fox in charge of the hen house" is that these four people are actual reformers. Even the Alderman.

In principle, it's a lot like Pat Quinn, a career "outsider" becoming governor.

The key test will be to see whether they "get" accessibility aand transparency. Putting the bank statement on line. Setting up web sites for people to chime in. Bringing in qualified support resources, not just ones who are successful.

We'll see. . . .
I read your comment @ 1:17PM.
I remember a great book ref crime.

John McPhee's THE PINR BARRENS

I may reread. It's about Moonshine.
etc.,
Politicians and speculator City Slicks.

WE need those old gravel roads again.
The book informs about backstabbing.
A term "Pine Barrens" was where to go.

Farmers, loggers, moonshiner, and the:
white collar crime wheeler & dealers go.
The book tells of those "goof hearts"`
`
Who could read Thugs - Not many books.
Read people's inner nature. That's reading.
Thanks. I have a habit of barfing at the news.
Reading blogs is one way to become briefed.
apology. . .

typo
not
PINR
but`
`
PINE BARRENS.
`
I need to practice
exquisite senryu
one word haiku
1
E
i
o
and rail `al`il`
`
silent heehaw!
Art! An honor to have you stop by. McPhee is a hero to anybody who writes. And if that wasn't his first book, it was a very early one. I loved it!
Speaking of ethics...I saw a show last night that listed Ghandhi's seven social sins... you probably know them but I'm not sure I had seen them before. They seem apropo...

Wealth without Work
Pleasure without Conscience
Science without Humanity
Knowledge without Character
Politics without Principle
Commerce without Morality
Worship without Sacrifice

As a society, I think maybe we're batting 1000....

And what to you mean you don't know "anybody"???? What are we...mincemeat???
JG--Those 7 sins are worth a piece on their own! And OK---I know no one in power!