JANUARY 30, 2012 7:25AM

The Myth of Good Hard Work

Rate: 31 Flag

Do good hard work and you will find a job.

It's a myth. Perhaps the most destructive unemployment myth of all. A myth like a snake. Silently slithering through the sewer tunnels that run beneath the crumbling towers of a once grand and proud American Dream.

 Corrosive at it’s core because we want so badly for it to be true. We were brought up to believe that it’s true. There are exceptions where it is true. So the myth eats away at the national soul while it does its damage. Leaving a scorched earth desolation marked only by the plaintive cries of “If good hard work won’t find me a job, what will?”

 

This sewer snake myth goes beyond fanatical right wing talking points used to bludgeon the vulnerable and turns into real portraits of real people’s lives in stories like the one I am reprinting (with the author’s permission for salon to reprint) below.

 

It’s reprinted without editing. It doesn’t need any. The author is one of the most insightful commentators on the web. One of my heroes. Never met the guy. But he’s changed the way I look at the world.

 

No small trick when you’re talking about actually changing minds.

 

He is a devastatingly effective writer with very strong opinions who understandably uses a screen name. If I were him, I would too.

 

So take a look at his story. NOT his resume. His story. Once you start reading, you won't want to stop.

 

See if it doesn’t show that good hard work leading to a job is a myth.

 

And better yet? If you know anyone who might know someone who could turn his brilliance into a job for him---then send me a private message or a way to contact you.

 

I could put you in touch with this guy. 

 

Imagine a world where good hard work does get a person a job.

 

Even if it’s one person at a time.

 

THE WRITER’S STORY

(Note: The blog he refers to is his own. The words that folllow are his. Verbatim.) 

 

“My job?

 

I am currently unemployed and looking for full time work.

 

Over the last 3 years -- since being laid off from a very demanding, multi-disciplinary position (everything from performance management to writing white papers to managing remote facilities) at which I worked for 10 years, and routinely put in 80-100 hrs/week (no overtime when you are in management) -- I have been underemployed, and have worked several part-time or temporary contract gigs for organizations which desperately wanted to bring me on full time but had their budgets slashed as a direct or indirect result of the Great Recession.

 

I have also just about exhausted everything I carefully put aside for a rainy day during those years because I never imagined it would rain so long and so hard.

 

In the past I have been (since leaving puberty behind and in no particular order) a computer programmer and systems analyst, a college professor, corporate trainer, an IT manager, research manager, editor, grant writer, regular writer, senior executive in charge of damn-near-everything from speechwriting to strategic planning to making the PowerPoints look purdy, a policy wonk, performance management guy, project manager, department reorganizer, consultant several times over, a direct social service provider and much more.

 

I have briefed congressional staff on more than one occasion, prepared bosses for public hearings, and addressed foreign delegations.

 

I have been on the radio several times, done public speaking, and sold a few stories here and there.

 

I have made many inquiries about work in the journalism/pundit trade -- in print or in front of a mic and/or camera -- and have never heard back from anyone. I have sent out lots of resumes and inquiries for many other things and, for the most part, have never heard back from anyone. I don't take any of that personally because shouting into an abyss is just how it is in the working world today.

 

On my last gig, I was heavily recruited for a full-time job by both my boss and his boss. I went through an intense, week-long series of interviews and psych, IQ and "cultural fit" exams. After they were done, I was told I had a virtual lock on the job. That I was perfect for it.   My boss was excited.  His boss was excited.  HR was excited because the number of hoops they had to leap through to hire anyone at this place exhausted them and they were always glad when it looked like the end was in sight.  Then, two days before my temporary contract ended, the president of the organization abruptly decided that she wanted to move in a "different direction".  My contract was not extended and I was let go. My boss was in tears. His boss apologized. HR was stunned.  I have not been able to find anything since.

 

I have also written and Photoshopped this blog almost every day for going on seven years -- rain or shine, 80-hour-work-week or unemployed-and-getting-discouraged -- and podcast  every week with Blue Gal (the 112th straight episode will drop tomorrow) which, all combined and despite the incredible kindness and generosity of my readers and our listeners, brings in considerably less than what a single, minimum wage/no benefit job would pay.

 

I am, of course, also an amateur historian, amateur paleontologist, definer of civilization and leader of the civilizing forces...but it turns out those gigs only pay a living wage when you can get casino moguls to write you multi-million-dollar checks :-)” 

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------ 

So good, hard work. But still no job.

He’s a nationally known blogger. Knows all about resumes, and interviews and creating his own job. All that stuff from the “how-to” books that, as it turns out, doesn’t really help much either.

 

But still no job.

 

Bet you know a similar story.

 

And I bet you know the myth that good hard work brings a job.

 

The really tough question is the next one.

 

What’s next?

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I got suckered into that myth too. It's one of America's most favored myths because it's so effective at keeping us in chains. But it only works because of our collective guilt over our devotion to greed. Take that away and the monsters lose their voice.
In this era, it's definitely a myth. I know so many people with good skills who would work their butts off - if someone would give them a decent job instead of screwing them over yet again.
There is the issue of ageism in every job interaction. One feels it as the years go on. There are laws against age discrimination, but the laws cannot be effective in the face of subtle, unsaid things between the hiring folks.

I really believe the "hard work" ethic was something associated with post-war America, when programs and business incentives were in place to provide opportunities for the masses of young people returning from WW II.

This is a really important and heartbreaking piece. Thank you for shedding light on this Roger...
**tossing roses at ya Roger**

You write well about this myth. I have met men who worked all their productive live's away hard at it, whatever it was who now have nothing left. Homeless so called bums who walk the streets daily. Their only 'income' a food stamp card.

Former hard workers. Men and women who wasted backs, hips, knees and elbows working hard at it and who now have nothing but the streets to show for it.

Hard workers.

Former lives gone into memories. Former vets. Former construction works with bent arms from heavy hammers.

Former farm workers with missing teeth from the cow, or horse.
Former wives showing pictures of their grand kids from a ragged purse.

Lives wasted working very hard to make that dream come true for them.

It did not happen. Sad to say.

When that ditch you land is called life and the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow ain't waiting for you,

it's a sad day to see.....
Come ze revoloooshun, ve all haff chobs!! No?
All right. Accepting the premise of this piece, what can be done? "What's next?" as the last line says. After projecting such an image of hopelessness, it's reasonable to suggest you get a gun and many rounds of ammunition and start blowing away the rich bastards.

Sound extreme? Well, voting for Obama didn't help anything. Voting for any of the Republicans will confirm and expand the current disaster. Glenn Beck encourages anger (which you now must pay for to see) and so does Limbaugh and the teabaggers.

Only they encourage that the targets be black people, Hispanics and Islamics. It only takes a little thought to realize that those nonwhite people aren't the cause of this problem. A little redirection of targeting shouldn't be hard to arrange.
And in two minutes, the new idea comes to mind. Mr. Chicago Guy, you can become our targeting expert. You have the anger. You have the frustration. You have the hopelessness. All you currently lack is the will to get strapped and start offering 7.62 millimeter resumes to these employers.

But then, you don't have to tolerate the smell or cordite on your own hands. All you have to do is keep writing, in bold oversized type, and start offering some particulars. Names, addresses, ways to get access to the targets. Start with...oh, I dunno...the Koch Brothers. You might even go regional to find the One Percenters that own communities like feudal lords.

How's about it? Not much money, but plenty of satisfaction for your tortured soul. (By the way, what you said in this post negates what you put in your previous post, your opening paragraph for your unpublished job hunting book.)
Harry--I appreciate that insight. It's important.

bike--It seems as though it is unique to this era. Maybe that's why its so hard to shake.

Gary--Gallup stats back up your point on ageism. And I think this myth have its historical roots right where you put them.

Mission--The physical toll of this myth is huge.

Matt---Hah!

Neutron--You have an aptly named screen name.

Jane---Thanks! I appreciate him letting me use his story. And as regular visitors to this page know---I have a lot of hope.
You're right - it is a myth. The reality is that finding and growing in a job that fits you requires a combination of hard work, lots and lots of luck and good connections.

I'm sorry your friend is having such a tough time finding something; it's definitely harder to be a mid/advanced career person in this market. And it sounds like he is not having any luck being in the right place at the right time at all.
@neutron, maybe you're confused because Roger is a three-dimensional person instead of the cartoon character you seem to be looking for. I doubt you'll find the one you seek in a mirror, either, unless, instead of posting one-dimensional invective on blogs, you were in the men's room at a range somewhere where you were honing martial skill sets.
Not going to write a resume' here, but with 6 years of college, and a career background in the building trades, sales, social work, landscape design, professional musician and more, at 60 I'm out of ideas.
Almost.
I'll have more ideas because I need to have them. I'll work more because I need keep the world at bay.That's what I've learned.

From "Let the Mermaids Flirt with Me" by Mississippi John Hurt:

"I do not work for pleasure, earthly peace I'll see no more.
The only reason I work at all, is drive the world from my door.
When my earthly trials are over, carry my body out in the sea.
Save all the undertaker bills, let the mermaids flirt with me."
Roger - This is heartbreaking - for the writer .........and for my country.

:-( / r
in the past, people would blame "gods wrath" at their sins for crop failures or decimation of their flocks by disease

then came the scientific approach, and people began to understand that even bad things happening to good people might not have an immediate, apparent cause, actual research can uncover solutions

now we've come full circle, where people again believe that mysterious forces outside their control are conspiring against them, and that hard work isn't worth it because it doesn't 100% guarantee success.

good luck with your belief structure.
That seems to be implied by every last politician these days. Somehow being in financial trouble is the fault of no one or nothing besides the laziness of the person who suffers this. Through thick and thin I can tell you that I have never lost a job from being a poor worker or lazy. Without fail it was my politics and my mouth that always got me in trouble.
How are they supposed to drive wages low enough to make us competitive with China & India if they go around giving everyone jobs? I ask you.
I don't understand what's happening in this country. Sharing to FB.
Wow, who can pick out the two OUTRIGHT LIES in baltimore aureole's comment?

The first one is where he claims that someone is saying that hard work isn't worth it. That's a lie.

The second one is where he claims that people are asking for some kind of 100% guarantee. Nope, that's not what anyone is asking for. Another lie.

Sorry, to hijack the comment thread, Chicago Guy, but this is the kind of thing that really pisses me off.

Great post. Rated.
A job? Simple. Nepotism seems to work as well as anything I know. Who needs experience when you can hire your idiot brother-in-law and lose money by the wheelbarrow full. Maybe hire your nephew for that management job that is opening up soon, well, as soon as he gets his driver's license.
Laura--exactly. If you leave out the connections, right place at right time, and luck---the hard work and quality work just doesn't cut it.

also---Right ON! YOU put your finger on something that DOES help.


torrito--I think what's heartbreaking is when people can't see the scope of the problem or take the "blame the victim" game. Or even "blame the world view" game. I would expect that this sory would draw some fire--which in my mind means that the truth hit home.

And the truth ain't always fun. But pretending is worse. How can you solve a problem when you don't know what it is?




Baltimore---Cool! The comment I was expecting from someone! Although I wish I was a better writer. Because somehow you read that the message was (as you put it) "hard work isn't worth it because it doesn't guarantee 100% success."

And that's not the message at all. Not even close. You also read that "mysterious forces" were in play. And for the life of me, I could not find the part where I said or implied. Sorry the writing was not clear. So let me try again: The message here is that hard, good work no longer gets you a job.

It sounds simple. But its not. It is one of America's most favorite myths. So when it's questioned---it naturally would make some folks angry. Which is too bad. Because we all have a lot of work to do to right the ship. And it would be nice if we could do it together without looking for blame or judgement or stomping on the vulnerable.

And the questioning (debunking) or popular myths like this one might be a place to start.

Bob--You make an important point. So much is IMPLIED or said in code. So when somebody says something directly like "Hard good work doesn't get you what it used to get you" the reaction is "Huh? what does THAT mean? What's he REALLY saying?
And when the answer is "Nothing other than what he said.". . .
That's when the suspicion really starts to fester and grow!"
nerd---beats me. How?

ccdarling--me neither. But maybe we have a leg up on all those folks who believe they HAVE all the answers!
Scanner---YES YES AND YES! THAT is what I see---in a million different ways. the guy who wrote the story you see here has a saying I repeat all the time:

"There are two rules:

1. there is a club
2. you're not in it."
Jeanette--NO problem. Seriously. NO problem! We got to get pissed off if myths like this one are to be dug out of the American soul.
It is this same myth that still drives the misguided rank and file in the Republican Party. How long will they cling to the myth?

Lezlie
I'm not sure I agree that this is a "myth." (Not challenging you - just thinking "aloud") To me, a myth is something that was never true but has a human truth in it. I think that during the not-so-long ago good times, there were plenty of jobs, even a surfeit of jobs when headhunters would come 'a calling and people moved up or increased their salaries by frequently switching jobs. I think there just aren't jobs which seems different to me than your premise that hard work can't get you a job. There just aren't jobs to be gotten whether through hard work, nepotism, networking, bribery, or empty political promises. I think the question we need to ask isn't what's next? But what is the next big problem or problem(s) in the world that we can create industries to solve...then we will see jobs. The problem is that takes time that too many people don't have....and I don't hear any of the current candidates talking about how we can unite to solve problems....definitely a thought provoking read!
driftglass has such talent. That David Brooks morphing into the Queen has made me spit coffee. Thanks for another worthy bookmark. These days, my good hard work heats the house. Mountain living can get tough sometimes, but never as rough as life on Mt. Resume.
I lost faith in the American Dream years ago. Which is only fair, since it lost faith in me years before then.
Just happened to be passing thru and thought you could use another rate. Oh, and so long as I'm here I'd like to note that we birds of a feather don't always stick together. I'm thinking of the common aureole at the moment, but there are others I would hesitate to share a roost with even were the Apocalypse right around the corner. bukbukbukbuk
"1. There is a club"
"2. You're not in it"
to which I would add:
"3. And given the kind of people who are in it, you probably wouldn't want to be anyway ... Except for money, which they have more of ... Because you're not in the club."

Given the quality of the morons I've seen "in the club" over the years in various venues (and that's substantiated by the ultimate consequences of the way they were able to behave and get away with it) one is left with little alternative but to create your own club, or if you can stomach it, slither your way into theirs.

These things have always been a part of human existence, but as systems devolve, their structures just become more apparent and undeniable. No, Baltimore, the issue isn't that hard work makes no sense, it's that it makes no sense when you do it in a such a dynamic, where you'll always be the club's expendable hired help.

CEO's fly to exotic locales to play golf and call it a 70 hour work- week (that's written off) while being paid hundreds of times more than people who actually work 70 hours a week and couldn't afford the Green Fees. But hey, it's all an even playing field... It's just that some people play the sand traps and others are used to fill them in.

R
Nikki--I just read the piece by Heather Michon and you are so right. This is cut from the same cloth. That and anyone smart enough to Live in Charlottesville--one of the greatest cities in the country--I'm automatically going to like!

L--Yep. Same myth. And it is pretty well ingrained. So the clinging will be fierce!

JG-- Like you've never challenged me! :) . . (Of course I loved that)
.Another way to describe a myth---not far from what you said--is as "something that explains the human condition." Could be true, not true, human true or no one knows.

If you take that ---one of the Merriam definitions--as a starting point--then saying "Hard good work can get you a job" rings true. It's a piece of the collective thought that is used to explain the way things are. It's also not true.

Also true is the fact that there aren't jobs.

Where I ended is "What's next?" You answered
that--the key is to find a need. From the need will come the work. Looks like we end up in the same place. No surprise on that.

STIM---That's about the size of it.

Julie---You've been there. You know.

CM--You are one great bird!
Stacey---You know the Man---so you know why I wrote this. And I had the same reaction to David Brooks and The Queen!

Samasian--That is incredibly well said. Thank you for that.
One of the most insidious myths of all. Like the one that says a college education will get you a job. Thank you for sharing his story with us. Rated.
What's next? Eat the rich? Revolution? Torches and Pitchforks? Farming?

I'm still working out the answer for myself. Let me get back to you on that.

Hard work will get you employed? If that's all it took, I'd be sitting pretty in my mansion along the river's edge, or in the mountains, sipping fine beers and the occasional port while I practiced my horticultural ambitions under a large geodesic dome.

I've been working hard since I can remember. There were days I couldn't get more than three or four hours of sleep (even if I were inclined to laze about longer than six hours in a sleeping period) and I literally worked myself into pneumonia twice. And then got hammered on my performance review for being gone from work too long!

Rat bastards.

There may not be anything as a free lunch, but I was distinctly under the impression that hard work and loyalty to the job was supposed to net you more than a knife in the back or a kick in the face.

--r--
swimming against the current myself.
Great post - thought provoking. May I mention one thing that I think is different about people who are struggling to find work today? Many are mentally over invested in their past, and have a difficult time moving away from the skill set they feel comfortable using, or that "defines" them.

The friends I have that have been "lucky" enough to find work or create their own work in this economy have had to let go of what they identify as appropriate work. One had to relocate to the middle of nowhere. He spent a year doing something different and getting back on his feet. Since then he has moved again (at least he is back to civilization), and is doing something different yet again. I remember my father doing the same thing. It was the seventies...

r./
Erica---that myth of college getting you a job is a good point and very much related. And isn't interesting that the for profit college lobby is fighting federal corruption probes of its members?

dunn---If we ever get this myth turned around, I say the party is in your geodesic dome. I hope I get an invitation!


onislandtime (Can I just say that might be my favorite screen name ever?) You make a really good point about investment in the past. Both the guy who's story I reprinted here and I have been in workforce development and adult education. And I'm guessing he would agree that your point has always been important. Not just now.

But it's also fixable. One tool I've personally used and coached literally thousands of folks thru is the Clifton Strengthsfinder, found in the book "Strengthsfinder 2.0" by Tom Rath. It is available everywhere. What it does is give you the unique language to describe your own unique set of talents. How you are hardwired. Armed with that, a person can focus on what they do well---instead of, as you pointed out, what they used to do.
I will check out Strengthsfinder 2.0. Sounds intriguing.
And you know, it's not a whole lot different when you've all but given up on finding something which requires that you exercise the skills you've spent a career developing and instead hope only for something that will let you get by for a few years so you can finally pull the plug.
This is poignant and painful and yet all too real.
onislandtime--feel free to PM me if you do the Strengths assessment and have any questions. It's on-line. (There is a pass code when you by the book---don't even read the book till you take the assessment. It takes like 20 minutes) I can tell you that it changes peoples lives.

neutron--Sorry, had to delete your comment because i saw it as a personal attack on another contributor---and life is to short for that. I've been on OS since the beginning and I don't think I've ever done that before. As to the other peace on job search, I encourage you to read the whole piece. At the end of the piece, there are 5 principles on how to think differently about finding work. So it is the exact opposite of hopelessness---its about a way to make things better for yourself.

Would be happy to answer any point you have, and if you want to PM me that's fine. As you can see---I take the time to answer everyone.

Opposing views are fine. But personal attacks get deleted.

Especially when they are attacks on a friend of mine.


Walter---You're right ---its not all that different than that. But I think the hope is that in recognizing it---maybe onc can get over it.
Roger, this post reminds me of what I learned from watching The Simpsons and listening to George Carlin. I thought of an episode in which the Simpsons encounter a Mary Poppins-like nanny named Sherry Bobbins, and she sings "Do A Half-Assed Job: It's the American Way" when teaching Bart and Lisa how to quickly clean their bedrooms. Americans will do a half-assed job at work as a passive-aggressive way to express their dissatisfaction. Also, it was George Carlin who said, "They call it the 'American Dream' because you've got to be asleep to believe it. There is a big club, and you ain't in it! By the way, it is the same club that they beat you over the head with when telling you want to think and what to believe."
Paul Haider, Chicago
When I worked construction, the one thing I could never get used to was getting thrown out with the rest of the trash at the end of the job. Still, that sort of experience hardens you, and helps you realize the truth about the myth that hard work equals success. You may recall that not long ago I visited that myth with a post of my own:

Arbeit Macht Frei
.
One more -- I'm currently working on my August concert called The Life and Hard Times of the Blues. John Henry makes an appearance in it, and here's how I deal with that incarnation of the Great American Myth:

John Henry Blues

The say John Henry whipped that steam drill
I say that story is a lie
How do they dare to call it winnin’
When he lied down his hammer and he died?
Lawd, lawd, lied down his hammer and died

Now if you’re a workin’ man
In this godforsaken land
I got some real bad news
They’ll work you half-to-death
And throw-out what is left
And leave you with the John Henry blues

They say all men are treated equal
I say that story is a lie
How do they dare to call it equal
When the rich man robs the poor man blind?
Lawd, lawd, rich man robs the poor man blind

Now if you’re a workin’ man
In this godforsaken land
I got some real bad news
They’ll work you half-to-death
And throw-out what is left
And leave you with the John Henry blues
Paul--Have seen that Simpson and it is hilarious. You make a great point about the passive aggressive behavior of people who have jobs. Buying into the myth that hard good work will get you a job is VERY close to buying into the myth that hard work will allow you to KEEP your job.

TC--Just went back and read "Arbeit Macht Frei" and it was even better the second time. "Meeting Ayn Rand in the libertarian jungles of hell" (paraphrasing you there) is the kind of great image that regularly comes from the gentleman I'm writing about here and you.

In this piece, I'm playing the role of the reporter. Just framing the point. The real star of this is the unemployed guy. So yeah--you and me are on the same wave length. But you and this guy lead the pack in political/social commentary. If we were the Beatles, you two would be John and Paul, and I'd be Ringo!

. . . . .keeping the beat to John Henry. That is perfect. I do want to give anybody else a chance to comment, so I won't close comments---even though I doubt I'll see anymore of them---but I'll tell you that if this piece was a movie, I'd roll the credits to the sound of you singing John Henry.

And call it a good days work.
One of your best ever, Roger. I can't really add to the comment string (you and your readers pretty much said it all) -- except to say that it was disconcerting to read to the end of the piece and see a popup ad for Walmart. That in itself was a "comment" on the state of work in this country.