cindy capitani

cindy capitani
Location
Rutherford, New Jersey,
Birthday
August 11
Bio
wordsmith at a paragraph factory follow me on Twitter @cindycap

Cindy capitani's Links

Salon.com
Editor’s Pick
JULY 16, 2009 5:03PM

Aftermath of a layoff Part 2: Spared again, but now what?

Rate: 13 Flag

This is the 3rd, maybe the 4th -- I’m losing track -- layoff in the past year at my newspaper. The layoff gods have been good to me, and were again once more. I’m happy to say I still have a job, I remain among the employed, still a working journalist. I’m grateful.

Especially given the newest unemployment stats posted that put the country’s average near the 10% mark, the highest in 30 years.

Scarier still, workers laid off early in the downturn will lose their unemployment benefits come September unless there is another extension.

Though there’s never a good time to be unemployed, now seems particularly harsh. The experts haven’t been especially good at gauging this recession and aside from an upswing by Goldman Sachs and JP Morgan Chase, today’s business news was the same as yesterday’s: bad.

The industry where I’ve built my career – newspapers – has always been low-paying and competitive. Today, it’s still those things, but it’s shrinking as it expands. What a paradox journalism has become.

As the appetite for information grows, the ranks of journalists have disappeared. The demand for credibility increases, yet the ability to meet that demand becomes impossible; there are just a few people doing work previously done by many.

Survival becomes the goal, the only one really, and cost-saving measures are implemented at every turn, even when no sense can be made of it. Except that it saved a few bucks. Maybe over time, a job.

In the end, because everyone in this field loves what they’re doing, we work long hours, aim for top quality and kick into high gear when the governor comes to town. Even as the product shrinks and expands and mutates into what’s surely just the start of what’s so far proven to be a most unpredictable future, we carry on, the adrenaline still pumps, just not as often as it used to.

I haven’t heard a single happy layoff story. But I do know some people who found jobs in the same fields they were let go from. And some industries will bounce back as the economy improves over time.

Laid off journalists however, have no place to look, now or in the future. Not in traditional media anyway. It’ll still exist, but the business model as we once knew it is gone, and with it, the traditional newsroom.

New media is largely comprised of unpaid writers, with just a small staff of paid editors and maybe a writer or two. Profit margins are slim at many new media sites, and social media has yet to turn the money corner. Everyone has an opinion how this will shake out but it’s still shaking, the balls still in the air.

What’s a hit, a miss, a fad, a must? It’s hard to know yet if Twitter will go the way of MySpace or become a Google-like success, or if some bloggers will tire of the pastime, the novelty of commenters gone.


Not to discount the importance of bloggers; I blog more than write. Bloggers have improved the news landscape in many ways, and kicked open areas for exploration and discussion that might have otherwise remained buried. Bloggers are part of the new journalism, but they don’t define it, and many, I think, are passing through. Blogging is, largely, a hobby for many.

I also wonder, too, if readers will become fussier, get tired of opinions and begin to demand sources. Right now it’s all new, all fun, there’s so much information all the time, everywhere. I know I can’t stop looking, reading in every direction; I think the web gave me ADD. Once in a while, I pull back from the fray and just read one publication. Just because it’s easier. I picked up Newsweek not long ago and I thought how nice it was to have all this info in one place. Glossy, convenient. I read it lying on the couch. Comfy!

But as traditional newspapers and magazines fight for survival, every still-working journalist is fearful of the next layoff. And if not the next layoff, the future overall. Because even if we hang on for another year or two or three, then what? Will there ever be security?

Probably not. But then, I guess if I wanted security I would not have picked this field to begin with. Hopefully I’ll get to stick around to see how it all shakes out. In the mean time, be sure to follow me on Twitter …



 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
It's interesting to note that it's not just newspaper jobs, but really a large variety of professional or good paying jobs that are going away due to either technological innovation or globalization.

* Computer help desks and even programming are being outsourced to other countries.
* Most auto manufacturing is going to other countries, or at least to non-union states.
* Boeing is doing final assembly on their 787 in their plant in Everett, WA near where I live, but most of the components are made in other countries.
* Even "medical tourism" is on the rise, where by Americans go to other countries to get operations done for less.

Meanwhile, consolidation and bankruptcies in the financial sector mean fewer management jobs there.

Like they say, the only constant is change, but technology drives change so quickly that I wrestle with even trying to think what fields to advise my kids to go into.

Interesting times.
more fine writing... now...how 'bout Boots pt deux?
damn Cindy the stress! congrats for still having a job. Saturn Smith doesn't anymore. you need a back up plan i would say but for now rock on..
"I also wonder, too, if readers will become fussier, get tired of opinions and begin to demand sources."

I'm already there. News print is still the best way to get "real" news as far as I'm concerned. Network and Cable news has become snark fests for the masses with opinion and speculation spun in a blender to fit the political slant of the editors. It's more than a little sad. We need more reporters that do solid research rather than less.
good point fins. even as i wrote that i was thinking there were more industries wiped out i just couldn't think of. it is a brave new world
thanks brian. boots deux? now i have to go look at my old posts!

it would be way more to have no job trig, so for now, i'll just keep doing and see where it all ends up. i read saturn's post but i couldn't figure out what she did. will have to look at old posts.

thanks michael! i only hope more people start to agree with you!
This sounds awful - again. Glad you survived for now. I'm an old school guy who just loves newspapers and always will; however, my two children (18 and 23) have never adopted the habit (well, obsession for me at times). The 24 hour cable stuff and the fluffy local TV news stations seem to have totally blurred everything in terms of what's newsworthy. I'm still a loyal and devoted fan of The News&Observer here in NC.

Hang in there.
Cindy, having met you, I understand why you have survived. You're a damn good writer. You're also able to adjust to a changing world. You have credibility with your readers heres, and also with your employers. thanks for the update.
You make so many interesting and thought-provoking points throughout this post. It does seem quite a paradox that in our society we demand immediately accessible credible news and yet there are fewer, less-qualified people delivering it.

Whenever I open a good magazine or newspaper and take the time to enjoy it with all my senses, I think, "this just can't go away."

For your sake and all our sakes, I sure hope it doesn't.

Continued good luck.
I've been watching a lot of my colleagues get picked off during buyouts and layoffs.
The other thing I worry about is that we will all begin to devalue our already undervalued work for the sake of keeping our jobs.
I think a lot of corporate owners of newspapers take advantage of the fact that many of us truly love our craft, and that our desire to tell a good story and inform the public will often outweigh our desire to be paid for doing that work.
A word to the wise...in the midst of layoffs the key to survival is often "not how well you do your job" but, "how many jobs you do well." Hang in there and spend any spare time you have working on plan B. Being one of the rats throw off a sinking ship is not a good thing.
A newspaper, magazine, or good book is teddy-bear comforting--something I can snuggle up with and sneak away to a quiet corner and enjoy. Computers are cold and impersonal.
Maybe there will be a print come-back, grif. who knows. there's much to be said for analysis.

That's so nice to say OE! Thanks!

Thanks Duane! I've been reading magazines more and more after a long fall-off and I see again why they're great. I think there will always be a place for print. It's just being redefined.

That's the sad thing Bethany, we so love it we'll do it free, on the side, or any which way.

Good point Splasher. It's not just one job any more for sure.